fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
dgdg
Offline
Details
p.49 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
If you are bracketing Gene, staying with a Canon body makes sense to me. You have great compatibility with any other Canon mount lens. The 5DS would be great if you can swing the price.
However, for the extra resolution at a good price point, I think the A7R v1 used is your best bet with the ts-e lenses. Generally you can do it all in one shot by pushing the shadows to taste which is very handy.
(I have an A7R v1 and use it with the ts-e lenses for landscape and also rented the 5DS for a trip so I am familiar with these choices.)
Be warned - another poster demonstrated mild flare from bright interior point light sources using the A7R and 17mm ts-e. You'll need to make sure your eos-sony adapter is fully flocked. The most recent metabones IV model T comes pre flocked and they do a good job on it. Or you can save ~$100 on a used metabones III but wind up breaking even spending the time to flock it just right.
Sep 24, 2015 at 12:25 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.49 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
ggreene wrote:
I don't think anyone here in the Canon forum wants less DR but the examples posted by some of washed out blacks and color shifts leave us wondering what all the fuss is about. If I'm going to fight for more DR from Canon I want it to be effective DR not DR for the sake of DR on a benchmark test.


Did you mean something like this?

To be fair, I've not seen the A7R II comps in this regard ... BUT, the overall principle approach being used with the Sony sensors of when / where you do your compression / expansion likely isn't going to be radically different as their mechanism of approach for achieving the "increased DR" ... comes with a cost @ "There's no such thing as a 'free lunch'."

Before Mttran posted up the corollary to this, I was looking much harder at the Sony sensors. But, after seeing this, it struck me that for all the Sony sensor exclamation and Canon sensor bashing ... ummm, Canon is doing something really, really right that gets lost amongst all the Nay saying that abounds. For me, when Canon does improve their DR, I certainly hope it comes without the cost to achieve it that we see here in the Sony approach.

For those shooting base ISO ... the difference of approach might mean something more to them. But for the vast number of folks that shoot beyond base ISO, the Canon approach likely serves a much broader market. As a heavy shooter of base ISO with my "one trick pony" SLR/C ... I have a fondness for what that can do for you. But, shooting base ISO "one trick pony" doesn't serve all my purposes. Granted, the Sony is a bit more than a "one trick pony" of the SLR/C ... but, imo just because Sony has one "special pony trick" with DR (that comes at a cost) ... it isn't cause for trying to turn all the other thoroughbreds, quarter-horses and mustangs into geldings ... especially when the end of the race turns out like this.






Sep 24, 2015 at 06:09 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.49 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
hmm, I don't play with words like some of you do. I often evaluate camera IQ performance from its actual data. A closer look at the pixel-level will show noise creeping into shadows that wouldn't be there in a sensor with better DR performance. Sure canon sensor has some bandage patches but its famous low iso shadow noise still bother me in real life application. These were what I have seen back then in my canon bodies and the same as what I have seen now in canon new bodies. So, why so many nonsense posts from the previous page ? As the consumer, should he not allow to talk about it ? c'mon guys, you know canon can offer better than this from last 7 years of their sensor improvement.

http://www.dpreview.com/previews/canon-eos-5ds-sr/samples/5DS-TulipSunrise-FullSize.jpg
http://c2.staticflickr.com/6/5489/18825544126_78c36e8f7d_o.jpg
http://c1.staticflickr.com/1/485/18326444060_0a5f459599_o.jpg
http://c2.staticflickr.com/6/5444/18851805515_edf273807a_o.jpg
Sep 25, 2015 at 08:10 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.49 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Since we are into the game of reposting old examples without context and comparison, here is a little inspection on the A7rII pixels:

https://horshack.smugmug.com/photos/i-2GFSwnL/0/O/i-2GFSwnL.jpg

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1380305/0#13142521

Sep 25, 2015 at 09:27 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.49 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
The best respond to trolls, especially serial trolls, is to not respond to them at all. ;-)

Some believe that trolls are less interested in the actual subject of their posts and certainly little interested at all in shedding light on issues or having a respectful discussion. Rather, one theory says that they simply crave attention in any form, even if the attention is, objectively speaking, negative. And one way to get attention, as sad as it might seem, is to act poorly and to insult others.

(We have probably all succumbed to this temptation at times, and we probably regret it. Acting out this way on rare occasions is probably a normal human thing. It is when the behavior becomes obsessive, compulsive, and repetitive that it crosses a line and becomes a bigger problem.)

For a person with a personal life in which they might feel ignored or frustrated or that no one is listening, acting poorly to provoke angry responses may bring the (sad) satisfaction of at least getting _some_ attention. Unfortunately, when that is the goal, no amount to reasoning or logic or counter-argument by the rest of us will help, since the sensible response from a person with that unfortunate "troll-ish" perspective is simply to provide more inflammatory responses in order to get that perverse gratification of more argument. This is especially true when the process plays out in a public arena such as a photography forum.

(There are those who see past the proximate argument, in this case about cameras, and see that the other person is perhaps hurting — and these folks sometimes want to help. To these wonderful people I say contact the troll individually and offline and express your concern and see where it goes, but don't do it here. The dynamics of that relationship simply won't work given the place from which the troll's initiative derives.)

The most effective (and often the hardest) response is no response at all. The troll offers up insults? Ignore it. The troll offers up bizarre and obsessive counter arguments? Do not respond. No response means no gratification of the desire to anger others.

To respond is only to encourage the behavior to continue. And, as is plain to see, to respond is to become embroiled in an eternal argument that no one ever "wins." You will never convince that person to change their tune and they won't convince you.

Let it go.

Dan

Edited on Sep 25, 2015 at 09:45 AM · View previous versions
Sep 25, 2015 at 09:31 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.49 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
Since we are into the game of reposting old examples without context and comparison, here is a little inspection on the A7rII pixels:

https://horshack.smugmug.com/photos/i-2GFSwnL/0/O/i-2GFSwnL.jpg

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1380305/0#13142521



Long exposure is how everyone shoot these days, Anders? No, some of us use camera to take picture of their garden and some won't have this problem, like this one in wide DR: http://c2.staticflickr.com/8/7589/16848729598_13f7150e91_o.jpg
Sep 25, 2015 at 09:39 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.49 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mttran wrote:
alundeb wroteSince we are into the game of reposting old examples without context and comparison, here is a little inspection on the A7rII pixels:

https://horshack.smugmug.com/photos/i-2GFSwnL/0/O/i-2GFSwnL.jpg

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1380305/0#13142521
Long exposure is how everyone shoot these days, Anders? No, some of us use camera to take picture of their garden and some won't have this problem, like this one in wide DR: http://c2.staticflickr.com/8/7589/16848729598_13f7150e91_o.jpg


Like a similar beautiful picture from the 5DS can be shown. Point is, not everyone pushes 3 - 5 stops after the exposure just like not everyone shoots long exposures. You blow this out of proportions.
Sep 25, 2015 at 09:54 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.49 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
mttran wrote
alundeb wroteSince we are into the game of reposting old examples without context and comparison, here is a little inspection on the A7rII pixels:

https://horshack.smugmug.com/photos/i-2GFSwnL/0/O/i-2GFSwnL.jpg

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1380305/0#13142521
Long exposure is how everyone shoot these days, Anders? No, some of us use camera to take picture of their garden and some won't have this problem, like this one in wide DR: http://c2.staticflickr.com/8/7589/16848729598_13f7150e91_o.jpg
Like a similar beautiful picture from the 5DS can be shown. Point is, not everyone pushes 3 - 5 stops after the exposure just like not everyone shoots long exposures. You blow this out of proportions.


Then we are going back to the same argument again and again whenever a camera faces its wide DR scenes challenge. Why not just give us a better DR sensor? what wrong with this request that some of posters here react to that so badly. Should we all want it?
Sep 25, 2015 at 10:12 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.49 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mttran wrote:
alundeb wrote
mttran wrote
alundeb wroteSince we are into the game of reposting old examples without context and comparison, here is a little inspection on the A7rII pixels:

https://horshack.smugmug.com/photos/i-2GFSwnL/0/O/i-2GFSwnL.jpg

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1380305/0#13142521
Long exposure is how everyone shoot these days, Anders? No, some of us use camera to take picture of their garden and some won't have this problem, like this one in wide DR: http://c2.staticflickr.com/8/7589/16848729598_13f7150e91_o.jpg
Like a similar beautiful picture from the 5DS can be shown. Point is, not everyone pushes 3 - 5 stops after the exposure just like not everyone shoots long exposures. You blow this out of proportions.
Then we are going back to the same argument again and again whenever a camera faces its wide DR scenes challenge. Why not just give us a better DR ?


Lik I tried to explain to you on the previous pages, there is nobody here that can give us better DR. Canon does not read here, and they don't need to in order to know about the state of things. We want better DR just as much as you, but your repetitions is not going to help, it is just annoying because everybody knows all this painfully well.
Sep 25, 2015 at 10:20 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.49 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
mttran wrote
alundeb wrote
mttran wrote
alundeb wroteSince we are into the game of reposting old examples without context and comparison, here is a little inspection on the A7rII pixels:

https://horshack.smugmug.com/photos/i-2GFSwnL/0/O/i-2GFSwnL.jpg

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1380305/0#13142521
Long exposure is how everyone shoot these days, Anders? No, some of us use camera to take picture of their garden and some won't have this problem, like this one in wide DR: http://c2.staticflickr.com/8/7589/16848729598_13f7150e91_o.jpg
Like a similar beautiful picture from the 5DS can be shown. Point is, not everyone pushes 3 - 5 stops after the exposure just like not everyone shoots long exposures. You blow this out of proportions.
Then we are going back to the same argument again and again whenever a camera faces its wide DR scenes challenge. Why not just give us a better DR ?
Lik I tried to explain to you on the previous pages, there is nobody here that can give us better DR. Canon does not read here, and they don't need to in order to know about the state of things. We want better DR just as much as you, but your repetitions is not going to help, it is just annoying because everybody knows all this painfully well.


Anders, remember the old low iso shadows banding threads. It's the same failure communication that happen here.
Sep 25, 2015 at 10:24 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.49 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Michael Tapes DR comparison between Nikon D810, Canon 5DSR, Canon 1DX and Sony A7RII



I like the comparison but this test fails to normalize the images for a 1:1 comparison. Per-pixel noise is not a relevant measure imo.
For example, when comparing Shadow DR between the 1DX vs 5DSR, he should resize the 5DSR to 18MP (resolution adjusted) and THEN compare it at 1:1. I'm sure the 1DX would lose all the advantage he demonstrated.
Sep 25, 2015 at 10:26 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.49 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
The best respond to trolls, especially serial trolls, is to not respond to them at all. ;-)

Some believe that trolls are less interested in the actual subject of their posts and certainly little interested at all in shedding light on issues or having a respectful discussion. Rather, one theory says that they simply crave attention in any form, even if the attention is, objectively speaking, negative. And one way to get attention, as sad as it might seem, is to act poorly and to insult others.

(We have probably all succumbed to this temptation at times, and we probably regret
...Show more →

I hear what you are saying, Dan. It is just that Michael is like an old friend to me, we used to stand together in another time, when I also was not communicating well with you and we were arguing about the low ISO banding. The reason I disagreed so hard with you was not that I thought you were foolish, but I respected you so much that I found your opinion important, and important to see what was up to. Now time has passed and I have learned and things have developed. I enjoy reading your posts, and it seems that you like some of mine as well. I am just som much hoping that other relations can also develop in a positive way. But maybe these discussions is not the place for it to happen.

Thanks,

Anders
Sep 25, 2015 at 10:37 AM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.49 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mttran wrote:
"hmm, I don't play with words like some of you do."


Au contraire, Michael. You do yourself a disservice. Most of your wordplay is nearly coherent.

Sep 25, 2015 at 10:41 AM
mogul
Online
Details
p.49 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Fred, why not resize everything down to the ancient beginnings of digital photography (like DXO normalizing to 8 mpix)? The truth of the matter is that if the shot was 50mpix and is going to be seen at such resolution, then that is what should be tested. Crops at 100% and/or resizing are not a fair way to gauge image quality. The IQ of the 1Dx doesn't compare to the 5Dsr except for iso differences.
Sep 25, 2015 at 10:42 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.49 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
Fred, why not resize everything down to the ancient beginnings of digital photography (like DXO normalizing to 8 mpix)? The truth of the matter is that if the shot was 50mpix and is going to be seen at such resolution, then that is what should be tested. Crops at 100% and/or resizing are not a fair way to gauge image quality. The IQ of the 1Dx doesn't compare to the 5Dsr except for iso differences.


DXO normalizes to 8MP because it compares a big range of sensors and for certain tests like SNR and DR is actually a good idea.
I know it seems unfavorable but we are not comparing "resolution" here. In the example I pointed out (1DX vs 5DSR), the 5DSR should actually come out on top regarding SNR and DR and that is not what Michael described because the crops were not normalized.

To a lesser degree, the same goes to the A7RII vs D810 DR comparison. Once you downsample the 42MP file to 36MP, the 1:1 comparison may change slightly.
Sep 25, 2015 at 11:01 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.49 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I think there is value in both measurements. While it's nice to see the down sampling for its potential, seems to me people buying a 5DsR are going to be interested to see the IQ at its native resolution.
Sep 25, 2015 at 12:23 PM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.49 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteThe best respond to trolls, especially serial trolls, is to not respond to them at all. ;-)

Some believe that trolls are less interested in the actual subject of their posts and certainly little interested at all in shedding light on issues or having a respectful discussion. Rather, one theory says that they simply crave attention in any form, even if the attention is, objectively speaking, negative. And one way to get attention, as sad as it might seem, is to act poorly and to insult others.

(We have probably all succumbed to this temptation at times, and we probably regret it. Acting out this way on rare occasions is probably a normal human thing. It is when the behavior becomes obsessive, compulsive, and repetitive that it crosses a line and becomes a bigger problem.)

For a person with a personal life in which they might feel ignored or frustrated or that no one is listening, acting poorly to provoke angry responses may bring the (sad) satisfaction of at least getting _some_ attention. Unfortunately, when that is the goal, no amount to reasoning or logic or counter-argument by the rest of us will help, since the sensible response from a person with that unfortunate "troll-ish" perspective is simply to provide more inflammatory responses in order to get that perverse gratification of more argument. This is especially true when the process plays out in a public arena such as a photography forum.

(There are those who see past the proximate argument, in this case about cameras, and see that the other person is perhaps hurting — and these folks sometimes want to help. To these wonderful people I say contact the troll individually and offline and express your concern and see where it goes, but don't do it here. The dynamics of that relationship simply won't work given the place from which the troll's initiative derives.)

The most effective (and often the hardest) response is no response at all. The troll offers up insults? Ignore it. The troll offers up bizarre and obsessive counter arguments? Do not respond. No response means no gratification of the desire to anger others.

To respond is only to encourage the behavior to continue. And, as is plain to see, to respond is to become embroiled in an eternal argument that no one ever "wins." You will never convince that person to change their tune and they won't convince you.

Let it go.

Dan
I hear what you are saying, Dan. It is just that Michael is like an old friend to me, we used to stand together in another time, when I also was not communicating well with you and we were arguing about the low ISO banding. The reason I disagreed so hard with you was not that I thought you were foolish, but I respected you so much that I found your opinion important, and important to see what was up to. Now time has passed and I have learned and things have developed. I enjoy reading your posts, and it
...Show more →

Anders, I always have the same thought as yours. I stick with data since I disagree with some here the way they choose words to discuss the issues. If I remember correctly, this is the only page I respond to most your posts, nothing against you my friend and I believe we have a failure of communication on this subject just like we did with others in the old days

Btw, I like canon and I can't wait to see them to release the A7Riii (BSI, RS) copy. Yes, MILC not DSLR. I have been saying this for many moons now.
Sep 25, 2015 at 12:29 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.49 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
The truth of the matter is that if the shot was 50mpix and is going to be seen at such resolution, then that is what should be tested. Crops at 100% and/or resizing are not a fair way to gauge image quality. The IQ of the 1Dx doesn't compare to the 5Dsr except for iso differences.


Actually, ...

... very few 5DS/R images are going to spend much, if any, time being viewed at 50 Mpix.

Most of them, and most of the time, will be viewed at pocket computer (smart phone) sizes or medium sized web images (say 1200 x 800 pix). Some will spend some time at large tablet size (less than 8 x 12 inch) or 8x12 print size, which is less than 8 Mpix at 300 pixels per inch. Realistically this is plenty for most magazines even full page.

A very select few will spend some time at gallery sizes (11 x 17 inches and on up), to be observed by an equally select viewership in homes and galleries.

So really, both kinds of measures are valid: resized to 8 Mpix and compared at full resolution. But the full resolution comparisons should remind readers that when comparisons come out equal or about equal, you are getting a lot extra with the 5DS/R.
Sep 25, 2015 at 01:12 PM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.49 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Monito wrote:
So really, both kinds of measures are valid: resized to 8 Mpix and compared at full resolution.


Agreed. If I get a 5DS, it'll probably be for my next huge-print project (e.g. 53 ft x 9.5 ft). In this case, full resolution comparisons between something like my current 6D and the 5DS would be the most relevant, for me.

On an aside, I wouldn't use the higher pixel count to enable me to take fewer photos, rather I'd use it to retain better detail at the finished size. For example, last time I did this, I used a fourteen-image pano taken with 6D + CZ 50/2 ZE as the background. If I do a similar project with a 5DS, I'd take the same fourteen-image pano with the same lens, and use the same magnification to produce the final image, and so provide a lot more detail (magnification is based on sensor size, not pixel count).
Sep 25, 2015 at 02:15 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.49 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
ggreene wrote:
I think there is value in both measurements. While it's nice to see the down sampling for its potential, seems to me people buying a 5DsR are going to be interested to see the IQ at its native resolution.


+1 @ value of each. Heavy croppers want to see it one way, full frame printers want to see it the other. Yet, other folks may want to see it somewhere in between. Judging one way for the utilization of the different way ... gee, folks are going to take exception to that know matter which camp we present to / from whenever it is a mismatch to our utility.

Personally, I think that show me the straight output is the first order of business. RAW data first, application / utilization second ... noting that the latter is what dictates the meaningfulness of the former to a given individual. I really don't need someone jacking me around telling me how I'm supposed to be interpreting what I see based on the way they intend to use it, when it isn't necessarily how I'll use it ... that's for me to decide for me, just like it is for them to decide for themselves.

Just because someone else wants to use ISO 100 and push it multiple stops, doesn't mean it is how I should do it ... that's my call whether I shoot ISO 1600 or ISO 100 + push. I simply see that it comes with a cost and I find it folly to not acknowledge that cost, when it occurs. For some, that is a very willing cost for them. For others, not so much. Sure, there may even be times that I adopt such a strategy / cost. But, for now ... not so much. If I'm printing to a finished size of 16x20 from a FF or modest compositional crop, that is a far different matter from printing to 60+ inches or cropping away 80% of the image first. The end application is kind of a key component aspect as to which evaluation approach better represents how the tool will facilitate creation of the end product.




Edited on Sep 25, 2015 at 04:52 PM · View previous versions
Sep 25, 2015 at 03:16 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister