fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
chez
Offline
Details
p.46 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII


RustyBug wrote:
chez wroteRusty...not all Canon shooters are sheep, just some...and I don't need to point out who you are. You know for yourself.😮
Yup, I still shoot an SLR/C ... I reckon that means you think I'm the leader of the followers.
Yup, I know for myself, and I think for myself. Thank you very much.

Thanks for illustrating the use of ad hominem.


Better leader of the followers than follower of the leader.✌️
Sep 03, 2015 at 05:09 PM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.46 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I think if some of the folks who are arguing so vehemently step back and read Chez's comments from the last few pages without looking at who wrote them-- you might be surprised at how even handed he's been on the whole. It's really a lot of some things are good, some are bad, each system has its strengths and weaknesses. That much is very accurate. And also, I'd note Chez has said he doesn't feel compelled to upgrade from his A7R to the mk2... so he's not exactly the fanboy he's being painted as.

I do think it's interesting that for the first time it seems Canon users-- including those who seem very level headed here-- are almost threatened by Sony and its proponents. Honestly, I don't get why: for one thing, the Canon still reigns supreme in its niches; for another, it's just a tool, and it's not worth getting too defensive about other brand's fanboys.

Let me add my own datapoint, as a Fuji XE-1, Canon 5D2, Sony A7rII owner: Each of these systems has its advantages and disadvantages. The Sony feels oddly awkward at times, with reviewing images near glacial, battery life poor (notably light draining while off; perhaps it's the internal battery charging in early ownership), menus confusing, and colors different. Lens choices are filling out, but nowhere near as versatile w/ native AF as Canon (this will eventually change I think).

On the plus side, the Sony, with a small lens (28mm f/2, for me) is small. Given its increased weight and size comparison images I'd seen... I'm shocked by how small the thing is. That's a big part of my reason for adding the system. It's got the resolution, something I felt at times lacking in my Fuji, and to a lesser extent my 5D2 (thought it wasn't ever a problem). It's got DR (yes, we know). And at least the native lenses I've tried have some real winners in terms of speed and accuracy (but mostly not price, and give me a native 35mm f/2).

On the whole, I'd still give the hat tip to Canon for pleasure in shooting, ability to be an extension of my hand, native AF lens choice, battery life. The Sony is a small, superb IQ, young system, with all the trappings of such.

Honestly, an editor could drop me off with either system and I could do 99% of my assignments to a level that the top magazines for photojournalism in the country would be more than satisfied with the image quality (my job as photographer... less assured ). Hell, it would work with the Fuji too. So use what makes you happy, your life easier, or whatever. Right now I want the option of something a little smaller with compromises I can accept, with a nice resolution bump from what I had been using. If Canon had made the 5Dsr in Sony A7rII size... this would be far more difficult for me. From where I sit neither is the do-it-all, perfect camera. At this point the quality is so good that it's more personal preference than anything else.

Side note: I really don't think Sony, or Canon (for that matter), fanboys are unique. When Fuji X was the hot new thing, many people claimed Fuji fans were a particular breed of rabid and pushy fanboy. The same was said in Nikon circles about Canon fanboys circa FF/5D. Just discount the most rabid (positive or negative) 5-10% of personalities (there are partisans in all things) and comments, and you'll get mostly solid, lower-bias, views on whatever is being discussed.

Sep 03, 2015 at 05:28 PM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.46 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
justruss wrote:
...The same was said in Nikon circles about Canon fanboys circa FF/5D. Just discount the most rabid (positive or negative) 5-10% of personalities (there are partisans in all things) and comments, and you'll get mostly solid, lower-bias, views on whatever is being discussed.


You should try being a Pats fan.

Go Pats!

Sep 03, 2015 at 05:32 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.46 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
justruss wrote:
Each of these systems has its advantages and disadvantages. The Sony feels oddly awkward at times, with reviewing images near glacial, battery life poor (notably light draining while off; perhaps it's the internal battery charging in early ownership), menus confusing, and colors different. Lens choices are filling out, but nowhere near as versatile w/ native AF as Canon (this will eventually change I think).

On the plus side, the Sony, with a small lens (28mm f/2, for me) is small. Given its increased weight and size comparison images I'd seen... I'm shocked by how small the thing is. That's a
...Show more →

I would tend to think that most objective oriented folks would accept this as being a reasonable assessment.

Sep 03, 2015 at 07:32 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.46 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
justruss wrote:
I do think it's interesting that for the first time it seems Canon users-- including those who seem very level headed here-- are almost threatened by Sony and its proponents. wasn't ever a problem).


And why would they feel threatened by Sony, Nikon, Fuji, or anyone else?

I think it is more a case of being bored by someone's repetitive ranting and raving.
Sep 03, 2015 at 07:41 PM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.46 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Imagemaster wrote:
justruss wroteI do think it's interesting that for the first time it seems Canon users-- including those who seem very level headed here-- are almost threatened by Sony and its proponents. wasn't ever a problem).
And why would they feel threatened by Sony, Nikon, Fuji, or anyone else?

I think it is more a case of being bored by someone's repetitive ranting and raving.


+1 I just wish Sony users were more content with their gear. Seems they should be happy and have no need to affirm their superior, breakaway technology. Why some Sony users are so insecure is truly baffling.
Sep 03, 2015 at 08:41 PM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.46 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
Imagemaster wrote
justruss wroteI do think it's interesting that for the first time it seems Canon users-- including those who seem very level headed here-- are almost threatened by Sony and its proponents. wasn't ever a problem).
And why would they feel threatened by Sony, Nikon, Fuji, or anyone else?

I think it is more a case of being bored by someone's repetitive ranting and raving.
+1 I just wish Sony users were more content with their gear. Seems they should be happy and have no need to affirm their superior, breakaway technology. Why some Sony users are so insecure is truly baffling.


It cuts both ways. But this is my point: It's not only or even especially "Sony users" who are fanboys and fail to see the perspective of "Canon users". Factionists often fail to see their factionalism-- but are very drawn to seeing the other guy's factionalism!

I put those groups in quotes because it supposes a purity that, at least on here, isn't all that common among the so-called factionalists. I, for one, own Fuji, Sony, Canon cameras-- and I'm delighted by each in my own way. Hilariously (to me), when Ming Thein wrote his review of the A7rII-- Canon fanboys were up in arms that he kept the Sony and not the Canon, and Sony fanboys were up in arms that he thought the Sony was soulless and seemed to miss the bit about him keeping the Sony.

I'm quite confident that both Sony and Canon users (our make-believe factions) are content with their gear... proposing otherwise is a bit of the 'ol "methinks she doth protest too much" from where I sit. I mean, let the majority content enjoy their contentedness, and suggest alternatives (but don't try to persuade) to those that really aren't content (likely an exceedingly small group, and not those who you probably label as such).

I mean, we can all bring the temperature down, but the divisive language and posturing on BOTH sides turns this from a real, useful, actionable discussion about differences-- into a religious battle that has zero value to anyone.
Sep 03, 2015 at 11:18 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.46 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
justruss wrote:
I think if some of the folks who are arguing so vehemently step back and read Chez's comments from the last few pages without looking at who wrote them-- you might be surprised at how even handed he's been on the whole. It's really a lot of some things are good, some are bad, each system has its strengths and weaknesses. That much is very accurate. And also, I'd note Chez has said he doesn't feel compelled to upgrade from his A7R to the mk2... so he's not exactly the fanboy he's being painted as.

I do think it's interesting
...Show more →

There is some good info to be had even within this discussion, and the quality of some of the arguments and points being made deserve some scrutiny. On the block right now is the notion that DSLR PDAF is supposed to be unreliable and in need of user calibration. This point has been made only by people who have Canon experience ending with the 5DII and the 7D. Canon AF has made a quantum leap forward with the 1D-X, 5DIII and 5DS AF systems, with the 5DS apparently being the most accurate. The 7D II AF is also excellent, but an unknown percentage of users get inconsistent or bad results. We don't know exactly what the problem is, but it does not translate to the FF cameras.

And you don't see many Canon users jumping into the A7rII discussions and saying "I heard the A7r has shutter shock issues. Are we seeing a recall? I hope this is not the norm for Sony...."
Sep 03, 2015 at 11:30 PM
panicatnabisco
Offline
Details
p.46 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I don't think you will find anyone here that will deny Sony's sensor superiority but holy hell does it turn people into rabid fanboys that need to interject off topic discussion in canon threads since the year the D800 was released.

Yes, we're fed up with it. No, I don't care about Sony discussion in a Canon forum. Even when given their own subform, a few people elect to keep their eye on the Canon forum and jump on every chance to spewer their hot garbage on anyone discussing canon specs in a positive light.

We already have people trying to talk about photoshop in this subforum. This is ridiculous.
Sep 04, 2015 at 12:19 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.46 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
rattlebonez wrote:
Who is winning the mud slinging contest ?

I still vote Canon 5DS


None of these cameras are good for photographing mud slinging contests. I would stick to a waterproof action camera

Ooops, did I say "stick to"....
Sep 04, 2015 at 12:25 AM
Jon Tainton
Offline
Details
p.46 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Word

panicatnabisco wrote:
I don't think you will find anyone here that will deny Sony's sensor superiority but holy hell does it turn people into rabid fanboys that need to interject off topic discussion in canon threads since the year the D800 was released.

Yes, we're fed up with it. No, I don't care about Sony discussion in a Canon forum. Even when given their own subform, a few people elect to keep their eye on the Canon forum and jump on every chance to spewer their hot garbage on anyone discussing canon specs in a positive light.

We already have people trying
...Show more →

Sep 04, 2015 at 01:12 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.46 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
justruss wroteI think if some of the folks who are arguing so vehemently step back and read Chez's comments from the last few pages without looking at who wrote them-- you might be surprised at how even handed he's been on the whole. It's really a lot of some things are good, some are bad, each system has its strengths and weaknesses. That much is very accurate. And also, I'd note Chez has said he doesn't feel compelled to upgrade from his A7R to the mk2... so he's not exactly the fanboy he's being painted as.

I do think it's interesting that for the first time it seems Canon users-- including those who seem very level headed here-- are almost threatened by Sony and its proponents. Honestly, I don't get why: for one thing, the Canon still reigns supreme in its niches; for another, it's just a tool, and it's not worth getting too defensive about other brand's fanboys.

Let me add my own datapoint, as a Fuji XE-1, Canon 5D2, Sony A7rII owner: Each of these systems has its advantages and disadvantages. The Sony feels oddly awkward at times, with reviewing images near glacial, battery life poor (notably light draining while off; perhaps it's the internal battery charging in early ownership), menus confusing, and colors different. Lens choices are filling out, but nowhere near as versatile w/ native AF as Canon (this will eventually change I think).

On the plus side, the Sony, with a small lens (28mm f/2, for me) is small. Given its increased weight and size comparison images I'd seen... I'm shocked by how small the thing is. That's a big part of my reason for adding the system. It's got the resolution, something I felt at times lacking in my Fuji, and to a lesser extent my 5D2 (thought it wasn't ever a problem). It's got DR (yes, we know). And at least the native lenses I've tried have some real winners in terms of speed and accuracy (but mostly not price, and give me a native 35mm f/2).

On the whole, I'd still give the hat tip to Canon for pleasure in shooting, ability to be an extension of my hand, native AF lens choice, battery life. The Sony is a small, superb IQ, young system, with all the trappings of such.

Honestly, an editor could drop me off with either system and I could do 99% of my assignments to a level that the top magazines for photojournalism in the country would be more than satisfied with the image quality (my job as photographer... less assured ). Hell, it would work with the Fuji too. So use what makes you happy, your life easier, or whatever. Right now I want the option of something a little smaller with compromises I can accept, with a nice resolution bump from what I had been using. If Canon had made the 5Dsr in Sony A7rII size... this would be far more difficult for me. From where I sit neither is the do-it-all, perfect camera. At this point the quality is so good that it's more personal preference than anything else.

Side note: I really don't think Sony, or Canon (for that matter), fanboys are unique. When Fuji X was the hot new thing, many people claimed Fuji fans were a particular breed of rabid and pushy fanboy. The same was said in Nikon circles about Canon fanboys circa FF/5D. Just discount the most rabid (positive or negative) 5-10% of personalities (there are partisans in all things) and comments, and you'll get mostly solid, lower-bias, views on whatever is being discussed.
There is some good info to be had even within this discussion, and the quality of some of the arguments and points being made deserve some scrutiny. On the block right now is the notion that DSLR PDAF is supposed to be unreliable and in need of user calibration. This point has been made only by people who have Canon experience ending with the 5DII and the 7D. Canon AF has made a quantum leap forward with the 1D-X, 5DIII and 5DS AF systems, with the 5DS apparently being the most accurate. The 7D II AF is also excellent, but
...Show more →

I totally agree with everything, but the last lines. There are plenty of so-called Canon users in the Sony discussions bringing exactly these sorts of things up (and the others as they relate to the mk2). The fanboyism isn't exclusive or unique in any single brand. That's my point.

---------------------------------------------

panicatnabisco wrote:
I don't think you will find anyone here that will deny Sony's sensor superiority but holy hell does it turn people into rabid fanboys that need to interject off topic discussion in canon threads since the year the D800 was released.

Yes, we're fed up with it. No, I don't care about Sony discussion in a Canon forum. Even when given their own subform, a few people elect to keep their eye on the Canon forum and jump on every chance to spewer their hot garbage on anyone discussing canon specs in a positive light.

We already have people trying
...Show more →

Well, as may others have noted: i) this is a thread specifically about Canon and Sony, so discussion of Sony is to be expected, and ii) as has been pointed out, many of us shoot both (and more) systems.

The truth is that anyone who is ONLY interested in Canon AND gets annoyed at hearing about Sony-- probably shouldn't read/discuss threads specifically started to discuss both brands (and vice versa). There is a constructive reason for such threads as people from both so-called camps have recently purchased the other camp's newest tool (for plenty of good reasons).

Both the initial fanboyism and the response to the initial episode are telling in their own ways I'd suggest; those small groups of members that make up the extremes of any seemingly opposition groups tend to have more in common with one another than the moderates, while each, ironically, considers itself the voice of moderate reason.
Sep 04, 2015 at 03:37 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.46 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
justruss wrote:
Well, as may others have noted: i) this is a thread specifically about Canon and Sony, so discussion of Sony is to be expected, and ii) as has been pointed out, many of us shoot both (and more) systems.

The truth is that anyone who is ONLY interested in Canon AND gets annoyed at hearing about Sony-- probably shouldn't read/discuss threads specifically started to discuss both brands (and vice versa). There is a constructive reason for such threads as people from both so-called camps have recently purchased the other camp's newest tool (for plenty of good reasons).

Both the initial
...Show more →

Well said. I consider myself rather extreme in some directions in a multidimensional world. I don't mind repetition of what benefits can be offered by the competition, but I do argue against those who think they know what a 5DS R is because they have a 5DII.
Sep 04, 2015 at 06:00 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.46 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
justruss wrote:
Hilariously (to me), when Ming Thein wrote his review of the A7rII-- Canon fanboys were up in arms that he kept the Sony and not the Canon, and Sony fanboys were up in arms that he thought the Sony was soulless and seemed to miss the bit about him keeping the Sony.


A sign of a good reviewer is when everyone finds something to bitch about it.
Sep 04, 2015 at 06:38 AM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.46 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jcolwell wrote:
justruss wrote...The same was said in Nikon circles about Canon fanboys circa FF/5D. Just discount the most rabid (positive or negative) 5-10% of personalities (there are partisans in all things) and comments, and you'll get mostly solid, lower-bias, views on whatever is being discussed.
You should try being a Pats fan.

Go Pats!



Cheaters...
Sep 04, 2015 at 06:38 AM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.46 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Jealous !
Sep 04, 2015 at 06:43 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.46 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jcolwell wrote:
Jealous !


I'm thinking if Tom Brady is a Canon user that his favorite lens might be the 100-400mkI since it moves lots of air in and out as you zoom.
Sep 04, 2015 at 07:10 AM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.46 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jcolwell wrote:
Jealous !


Not really... I don't follow American-rules rugby.
Sep 04, 2015 at 07:27 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.46 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jcolwell wrote:
justruss wrote...The same was said in Nikon circles about Canon fanboys circa FF/5D. Just discount the most rabid (positive or negative) 5-10% of personalities (there are partisans in all things) and comments, and you'll get mostly solid, lower-bias, views on whatever is being discussed.
You should try being a Pats fan.

Go Pats!



Am from MA.
Sep 04, 2015 at 09:13 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.46 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
justruss wroteWell, as may others have noted: i) this is a thread specifically about Canon and Sony, so discussion of Sony is to be expected, and ii) as has been pointed out, many of us shoot both (and more) systems.

The truth is that anyone who is ONLY interested in Canon AND gets annoyed at hearing about Sony-- probably shouldn't read/discuss threads specifically started to discuss both brands (and vice versa). There is a constructive reason for such threads as people from both so-called camps have recently purchased the other camp's newest tool (for plenty of good reasons).

Both the initial fanboyism and the response to the initial episode are telling in their own ways I'd suggest; those small groups of members that make up the extremes of any seemingly opposition groups tend to have more in common with one another than the moderates, while each, ironically, considers itself the voice of moderate reason.
Well said. I consider myself rather extreme in some directions in a multidimensional world. I don't mind repetition of what benefits can be offered by the competition, but I do argue against those who think they know what a 5DS R is because they have a 5DII.


Clearly the AF is better in the 5D series following the 5D MkII
Sep 04, 2015 at 10:29 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister