fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.41 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Shield wrote
chez wrote
Shield wrote
chez wrote
Gunzorro wroteAs used prices continue to plummet, I'm strongly considering (eventually) buying a used a7R to use with Alt lenses, and maybe a few select Canon EF and Nikon AIS and AFD lenses too. But this would be a sideline for me, something to upgrade from my foray into M43. It would be purely personal and oriented to Alt and travel/outings. It couldn't replace my Canon or Nikon DSLRs and lenses.

About time I unshackle myself from my last 120/220 system: the Pentax 67II and all its lenses. I'm pretty sure I'll never have a need to shoot that again.

So, yes, Chez, multiple systems (tools) are the word. Hard to escape the whirlpool if you have a curious mind or like technical comparisons while staying on top of your craft. You are right, there is no perfect system. It's just that some are considered more universally useful than others (see market share and sales, as well as public use).
Ah, yes...market share and sales...the herd. Toyota leads in sales...but rather than driving a boring sedan, some people reach out to the corvettes of the world. Leading hamburger joint McDonalds rolls in the bucks, I'd rather get a good burger and beer at the local brewpub.

Market share implies they cater to the general herd...niche products like micro brew beer cater to the ones that want more than the norm.
I don't know if I necessarily agree here - there is no Corvette in Sony's lineup for sports shooting. There is no "local pub burger" Sony body for shooting in harsh environments. Until Sony releases a pro level body and/or one that can actually AF and track in all lighting conditions (and no EVF blackout during bursts) then the boring Toyotas/Hondas (Canon/Nikon) are the ONLY game in town. I'd like to see Sony setup a true professional services support system as well. You're not talking about a regular Corvette, but a niche 63 Split window coupe with no air conditioning.

Sony doesn't even have a real mini-van for soccer mom's. Aka the 24-70 / 70-200 2.8. ZERO native 2.8 zooms in FE mount. No, overpriced F/4 lenses do not count, sorry.
There is also no good light street camera in the Canon lineup.

What I meant by not following the herd is the breakaway designs and features Sony is coming up with compared to Canon. Yes, the 1Dx is king in the sports arena...but it's design has been around for 15 years...boring as that is. It gets a little more horsepower with each release, but its looks and functionality etc... are stale. That's OK...the herd likes true and tried things.

I see the Sony, being mirrorless full frame with a great EVF, IBIS and a leading sensor all breakaway technologies...sort of like a Tesla Model X...breaking the mold of old.
It can't be a "herd" mentality for people shooting sports - there simply aren't any options from Sony. I'm glad you brought up the Tesla - now that's a good analogy. I can't hop in
any Tesla model and drive my family from Ohio to Florida on vacation without having major hassles always stopping to recharge. Just like I cannot find any Sony mirrorless bodies / lenses to shoot sports with anywhere near as well as Canon. Yes, it *can* be done - pre-focusing and anticipating the action. Will I walk away with as many keepers with an adapter + awkward ergonomics, poor battery life and EVF blackout, or my 12FPS rugged 1000+ shot OVF body with an native 300 2.8 / 70-200 2.8 lens?
Just like I *could* stop in Tennessee - let my car recharge for 4 hours while my kids are beating each other up and my wife is annoyed. Why go through that hassle just to brag about owning a Tesla?

All I'm saying is to use this "I don't follow the herd" statement suggests one has viable/better options elsewhere. I simply do not shooting action. Landscape? Absolutely. But if I need a mini-van to haul the kids around and your car company doesn't make one - it doesn't mean we're sheep - we're simply using the best tools available for the job.
I agree, you are correct in the sports arena...but the huge vast majority of people purchasing a Canon do so just because it is popular...they follow the herd. They see it advertised, being used to shoot amazing landscape photos...so they buy it. They see it advertised as rows of big white glass at sporting events...so they buy it. People love to go with the popular...the herd mentality at its finest.


Think you can stop with your typical arrogant, BS posts here
Sep 02, 2015 at 09:11 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.41 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
chez wrote
jctriguy wrote
Shield wrote
chez wrote
Gunzorro wroteAs used prices continue to plummet, I'm strongly considering (eventually) buying a used a7R to use with Alt lenses, and maybe a few select Canon EF and Nikon AIS and AFD lenses too. But this would be a sideline for me, something to upgrade from my foray into M43. It would be purely personal and oriented to Alt and travel/outings. It couldn't replace my Canon or Nikon DSLRs and lenses.

About time I unshackle myself from my last 120/220 system: the Pentax 67II and all its lenses. I'm pretty sure I'll never have a need to shoot that again.

So, yes, Chez, multiple systems (tools) are the word. Hard to escape the whirlpool if you have a curious mind or like technical comparisons while staying on top of your craft. You are right, there is no perfect system. It's just that some are considered more universally useful than others (see market share and sales, as well as public use).
Ah, yes...market share and sales...the herd. Toyota leads in sales...but rather than driving a boring sedan, some people reach out to the corvettes of the world. Leading hamburger joint McDonalds rolls in the bucks, I'd rather get a good burger and beer at the local brewpub.

Market share implies they cater to the general herd...niche products like micro brew beer cater to the ones that want more than the norm.
I don't know if I necessarily agree here - there is no Corvette in Sony's lineup for sports shooting. There is no "local pub burger" Sony body for shooting in harsh environments. Until Sony releases a pro level body and/or one that can actually AF and track in all lighting conditions (and no EVF blackout during bursts) then the boring Toyotas/Hondas (Canon/Nikon) are the ONLY game in town. I'd like to see Sony setup a true professional services support system as well. You're not talking about a regular Corvette, but a niche 63 Split window coupe with no air conditioning.

Sony doesn't even have a real mini-van for soccer mom's. Aka the 24-70 / 70-200 2.8. ZERO native 2.8 zooms in FE mount. No, overpriced F/4 lenses do not count, sorry.
+1

I also find it unfortunate that some feel the need to label things as the 'herd', or 'boring'. I guess that is another way to feel superior. Just think, some might actually choose a Toyota even though they could easily buy a corvette.
JC...that's a very common term to use when talking about the general masses..look it up.

Yes, people still will by a Toyota even though they can afford a corvette...that is exactly what I'm talking about...going with the herd is comfortable for many. That's OK...you don't need to get your shorts into a knot about it...afterall, you are in the majority and there is safety in numbers.
Who said anything about making choices to feel comfortable in a group? Can you read, or do you just make it up and make assumptions.

People can choose of their own free will, with the benefit of using their brain. If someone chooses to buy a Toyota, it doesn't mean they are doing it to be comfortable, it likely means they liked the features and price. Your comments suggest that you don't get it. You somehow think people who choose mirrorless are making bold moves away from the masses. What a crock of shit.



I'm not talking specifics about choosing or liking a Toyota...I drive a Honda.. I'm talking about general herd mentality where the comfort of inclusion plays a big part. If its good for so many people...it must be good. It plays in everyday life...Starbucks lined up 20 deep, Apple lineups on new release dates, popular music...the beat goes on.
Sep 02, 2015 at 09:13 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.41 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
chez wrote
Shield wrote
chez wrote
Shield wrote
chez wroteAh, yes...market share and sales...the herd. Toyota leads in sales...but rather than driving a boring sedan, some people reach out to the corvettes of the world. Leading hamburger joint McDonalds rolls in the bucks, I'd rather get a good burger and beer at the local brewpub.

Market share implies they cater to the general herd...niche products like micro brew beer cater to the ones that want more than the norm.
I don't know if I necessarily agree here - there is no Corvette in Sony's lineup for sports shooting. There is no "local pub burger" Sony body for shooting in harsh environments. Until Sony releases a pro level body and/or one that can actually AF and track in all lighting conditions (and no EVF blackout during bursts) then the boring Toyotas/Hondas (Canon/Nikon) are the ONLY game in town. I'd like to see Sony setup a true professional services support system as well. You're not talking about a regular Corvette, but a niche 63 Split window coupe with no air conditioning.

Sony doesn't even have a real mini-van for soccer mom's. Aka the 24-70 / 70-200 2.8. ZERO native 2.8 zooms in FE mount. No, overpriced F/4 lenses do not count, sorry.
There is also no good light street camera in the Canon lineup.

What I meant by not following the herd is the breakaway designs and features Sony is coming up with compared to Canon. Yes, the 1Dx is king in the sports arena...but it's design has been around for 15 years...boring as that is. It gets a little more horsepower with each release, but its looks and functionality etc... are stale. That's OK...the herd likes true and tried things.

I see the Sony, being mirrorless full frame with a great EVF, IBIS and a leading sensor all breakaway technologies...sort of like a Tesla Model X...breaking the mold of old.
It can't be a "herd" mentality for people shooting sports - there simply aren't any options from Sony. I'm glad you brought up the Tesla - now that's a good analogy. I can't hop in
any Tesla model and drive my family from Ohio to Florida on vacation without having major hassles always stopping to recharge. Just like I cannot find any Sony mirrorless bodies / lenses to shoot sports with anywhere near as well as Canon. Yes, it *can* be done - pre-focusing and anticipating the action. Will I walk away with as many keepers with an adapter + awkward ergonomics, poor battery life and EVF blackout, or my 12FPS rugged 1000+ shot OVF body with an native 300 2.8 / 70-200 2.8 lens?
Just like I *could* stop in Tennessee - let my car recharge for 4 hours while my kids are beating each other up and my wife is annoyed. Why go through that hassle just to brag about owning a Tesla?

All I'm saying is to use this "I don't follow the herd" statement suggests one has viable/better options elsewhere. I simply do not shooting action. Landscape? Absolutely. But if I need a mini-van to haul the kids around and your car company doesn't make one - it doesn't mean we're sheep - we're simply using the best tools available for the job.
I agree, you are correct in the sports arena...but the huge vast majority of people purchasing a Canon do so just because it is popular...they follow the herd. They see it advertised, being used to shoot amazing landscape photos...so they buy it. They see it advertised as rows of big white glass at sporting events...so they buy it. People love to go with the popular...the herd mentality at its finest.
Think you can stop with your typical arrogant, BS posts here


OK...tell me what is BS about the post. It is advertising at its best. Please elaborate on your post.
Sep 02, 2015 at 09:15 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.41 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
About "herd following" — 

Sometimes herds are small, and they are followed by folks who may not realize the irony of imagining that following their own herd makes them better than people who follow a different herd. "I'm not a herd-follower because the herd I follow is a smaller and different herd than the herd that the people I call herd-followers follow. If they weren't herd followers they would stop following that other herd and follow my herd." ;-)

In some matters, what some call "herd following" is simple a choice by many intelligent people to use a thing that is useful and good. The fact that others do some thing is irrelevant to the value of the thing. A choice to do something or use something that others do or use is not the same as mindless herd-following, any more than a choice to do something different is always evidence that one is brilliant or exceptional. (Why follow the herd and travel overseas by airline when real individuals construct their own boats and sail?! ;-)

In photography, some define themselves by the equipment they use. Photography is full of people who have doubts about the value of their work and about whether they are serious or talented enough. (To some extent this is normal, and everyone should have at least a few such doubts!) There are many ways to buttress oneself against this natural human response, and I won't list all of them. However, in photography several are quite common. One is to claim that one has the "best" gear or to ensure that one looks like a "pro" by carrying such gear, or to use the possession of such gear as a symbol of competence and authority. Another is to try to separate oneself from, ahem, "the herd" by looking for individuality though choices about equipment. ("My photography is special because I coat my own wet plates!" "My photography is special because I only use primes!") There is nothing wrong with using equipment that is different from what most people use, but some who go this route turn into petulant and annoying "true believers" who impugn the judgment and work quality of those who don't go along. (Ironically, if everyone did succumb to their arguments, what they do would soon become what defines the new herd...)

Finally, when it comes to separating oneself from the herd in ways that matter — that show the value of a photographer's individual personality and world view and competence through the product of their work — the choice of equipment they use seems like just about the least meaningful mode of establishing individuality that I can imagine. (Can you imagine a painter claiming, "I'm special because I use different brushes then everyone else!" or a roofer claiming superiority because "I use hand-made wood-fire forged Etruscan hammer heads and hand-crafted nails."?)

When it comes to who you are and the quality of the work that expresses that person, it is what your photographs say that matters. In that regard setting yourself apart from "the herd" seems to be a meaningful measure among a larger group of measures. But attempting to "be an individual" by choosing to use tools from one Big International Mega Corporation instead of tools from some other Big International Mega Corporation seems completely irrelevant.

YMMV,

Dan,

who has owned and relied on a wide range of vehicles (including some non-herd vehicles) over a period of decades, but who today owns not one, but TWO Toyotas — a Prius with 135,000 miles on it and a 4Runner Trail. Both do a damned good job of getting me to the places I want to and need to go to in order to do the things that matter to me. Go figure.

Edited on Sep 02, 2015 at 08:42 PM · View previous versions
Sep 02, 2015 at 09:15 AM
Shield
Offline
Details
p.41 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Look Chez, Sony is not without their merits. Competition is good for everyone, and perhaps this will force Canon to develop better dynamic ranged sensors.
I love the silent shooting modes, the higher framerate videos and the portable size. If I shot stationary objects / landscapes I'd be shooting an a7r II (well, if I can work around not allowing it to shoot in 12 bit raw - you know, don't expose longer than 30 seconds or have any one of 20 settings that will trigger 12 bit .
If AMD didn't exist we'd be getting Intel chips from 2008 probably about now. So I'm a huge fan of Samsung, Fuji, Panasonic doing their thing. I like Nikon as well. I just find it strange how everyone loves the GH4 but it's sensor is far worse for dynamic range than the Canon bodies.

People love to bash Microsoft because they're on top. You can be different and shoot Sony - just like millions of others do...

Edited on Sep 02, 2015 at 11:47 AM · View previous versions
Sep 02, 2015 at 09:19 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.41 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Shield wrote:
Also you state the 1d body design has been around for 15 years. Perhaps it's just a brilliant design? Long battery life, built in grip for portrait shooting, rugged and durable. Boring? Perhaps. It's a tool for a job, not a lifestyle statement piece for me.


I wonder what you'd get if you asked Sony to build you a hammer?

"No, it can't pound nails unless you download the nail pounding app from Playstation, and it needs 5 hours of charging between nails, but look how small it is... and it has NFC to communicate with the nail each time you strike it! And if you don't like that it is for left-handed carpenters only, just wait six months and we'll discontinue it and replace it with a more expensive right-handed version that drives screws instead!

Sep 02, 2015 at 09:19 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.41 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Canon shooters are provably not a herd. They can't even go together and delete all of their unwanted replies in this thread:

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1384686
Sep 02, 2015 at 09:24 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.41 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
I wonder what you'd get if you asked Sony to build you a hammer?

"No, it can't pound nails unless you download the nail pounding app from Playstation, and it needs 5 hours of charging between nails, but look how small it is... and it has NFC to communicate with the nail each time you strike it! And if you don't like that it is for left-handed carpenters only, just wait six months and we'll discontinue it and replace it with a more expensive right-handed version that drives screws instead!


The Hammer Forum http://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2012/03/hammerforum-com would know. (thanks to LensRentals.com)
Sep 02, 2015 at 09:25 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.41 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
jctriguy wrote
chez wrote
Shield wrote
chez wrote
Shield wroteI don't know if I necessarily agree here - there is no Corvette in Sony's lineup for sports shooting. There is no "local pub burger" Sony body for shooting in harsh environments. Until Sony releases a pro level body and/or one that can actually AF and track in all lighting conditions (and no EVF blackout during bursts) then the boring Toyotas/Hondas (Canon/Nikon) are the ONLY game in town. I'd like to see Sony setup a true professional services support system as well. You're not talking about a regular Corvette, but a niche 63 Split window coupe with no air conditioning.

Sony doesn't even have a real mini-van for soccer mom's. Aka the 24-70 / 70-200 2.8. ZERO native 2.8 zooms in FE mount. No, overpriced F/4 lenses do not count, sorry.
There is also no good light street camera in the Canon lineup.

What I meant by not following the herd is the breakaway designs and features Sony is coming up with compared to Canon. Yes, the 1Dx is king in the sports arena...but it's design has been around for 15 years...boring as that is. It gets a little more horsepower with each release, but its looks and functionality etc... are stale. That's OK...the herd likes true and tried things.

I see the Sony, being mirrorless full frame with a great EVF, IBIS and a leading sensor all breakaway technologies...sort of like a Tesla Model X...breaking the mold of old.
It can't be a "herd" mentality for people shooting sports - there simply aren't any options from Sony. I'm glad you brought up the Tesla - now that's a good analogy. I can't hop in
any Tesla model and drive my family from Ohio to Florida on vacation without having major hassles always stopping to recharge. Just like I cannot find any Sony mirrorless bodies / lenses to shoot sports with anywhere near as well as Canon. Yes, it *can* be done - pre-focusing and anticipating the action. Will I walk away with as many keepers with an adapter + awkward ergonomics, poor battery life and EVF blackout, or my 12FPS rugged 1000+ shot OVF body with an native 300 2.8 / 70-200 2.8 lens?
Just like I *could* stop in Tennessee - let my car recharge for 4 hours while my kids are beating each other up and my wife is annoyed. Why go through that hassle just to brag about owning a Tesla?

All I'm saying is to use this "I don't follow the herd" statement suggests one has viable/better options elsewhere. I simply do not shooting action. Landscape? Absolutely. But if I need a mini-van to haul the kids around and your car company doesn't make one - it doesn't mean we're sheep - we're simply using the best tools available for the job.
I agree, you are correct in the sports arena...but the huge vast majority of people purchasing a Canon do so just because it is popular...they follow the herd. They see it advertised, being used to shoot amazing landscape photos...so they buy it. They see it advertised as rows of big white glass at sporting events...so they buy it. People love to go with the popular...the herd mentality at its finest.
Think you can stop with your typical arrogant, BS posts here
OK...tell me what is BS about the post. It is advertising at its best. Please elaborate on your post.


I think Dan's post explains things well. Try reading it carefully, maybe even two or three times until it sinks in.

You place herd followers as mindless and see yourself as outside the herd making a bold break from the pack. That is arrogant and bullshit.
Sep 02, 2015 at 09:26 AM
Shield
Offline
Details
p.41 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
chez wrote
molson wrote
chez wrote
molson wrote
gdanmitchell wroteIf a tree falls in the forest and Sony is there to photograph it, it is still Canon's fault that the Sony photo is out of focus? ;-)
If a tree falls in the forest and your Sony has been vacationing in Mexico... sorry, sitting in a bin somewhere at Sony's service facility for nearly two months waiting for a minor repair to be done, there will be a reliable Canon on hand to photograph it... but the fanboys won't care because the Sony could have done an awesome job, with boatloads of dynamic range, if it ever got repaired and returned to its owner...
I had to deal with Sony service once. Sent the camera in under warranty, came back fixed in about 1 week. No issues. The same was true with my Fuji X100, simple and no issues.
Seven weeks and counting to repair the defective rear LCD of my A7R, which had started to peel off, and still no indication of when they will complete the "expedited" repair...
I guess there is good and bad everywhere. I've read enough reports of people having to send in their 7d2 numerous times to get the AF fixed. Surely Canon service should be experts by now fixing the floud of 7d2 cameras being sent in.
Hard to fix user error...

However, whenever I've had to send something to Canon, they have performed the necessary service or repair and gotten the equipment back to me within 48 hours (or less) - including the shipping time from Alberta to Ontario and back.

I asked Sony Canada last year if they planned to offer pro service,and they stated that they would not be offering anything like CPS or NPS, because, and I quote: "Sony does not make any professional camera equipment". I'm glad at least one person in that company is in touch with reality...


Check out this review of the only "high end" lens Sony makes - the 300 2.8 SSM II:
http://www.dpreview.com/products/sony/lenses/sony_300_2p8/user-reviews

I realize this is Dpreview and all, but this guy said he had real trouble getting this serviced.
Would a working pro who earns his bread and butter shooting with high end glass ever find this solution acceptable?

Sony has gone from a Corvette to a Lotus in the service dept.
Sep 02, 2015 at 09:30 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.41 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Shield wrote:
Would a working pro who earns his bread and butter shooting with high end glass ever find this solution acceptable?



It depends on how much sponsorship support Sony is giving him to use their gear, I suppose...
Sep 02, 2015 at 09:35 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.41 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
Canon shooters are provably not a herd. They can't even go together and delete all of their unwanted replies in this thread:

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1384686


If only we had a "tongue-in-cheek" emoticon, we wouldn't have all this confusion...
Sep 02, 2015 at 09:36 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.41 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Chez ... you are truly insulting your fellow FM'ers by associating them to herd mentality.

There are some of the finest, sharpest, experienced minds around. To suggest that they are incapable of making their decisions based on anything other than "follow the herd" mentaliity is about the most ludicrous, disrespectful of other members thing you've (politely) said.

The degree of faulty logic in your efforts for presentation are so twisted, that it has become unworthy of the effort to try and reveal the errors contained therein. Either, you are intent on utilizing such fauty logic to the nth degree, at all costs to further your agenda ... that, or you are not cognizant of the difference between logic and faulty logic.

I think many of us have probably "herd" enough.
Sep 02, 2015 at 11:10 AM
mogul
Online
Details
p.41 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
Chez ... you are truly insulting your fellow FM'ers by associating them to herd mentality.

There are some of the finest, sharpest, experienced minds around. To suggest that they are incapable of making their decisions based on anything other than "follow the herd" mentaliity is about the most ludicrous, disrespectful of other members thing you've (politely) said.

The degree of faulty logic in your efforts for presentation are so twisted, that it has become unworthy of the effort to try and reveal the errors contained therein. Either, you are intent on utilizing such fauty logic to the nth degree, at all costs
...Show more →

Chez "the Canon Baiter" should know better than going against the flock.
Sep 02, 2015 at 11:24 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.41 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
Chez ... you are truly insulting your fellow FM'ers by associating them to herd mentality.

There are some of the finest, sharpest, experienced minds around. To suggest that they are incapable of making their decisions based on anything other than "follow the herd" mentaliity is about the most ludicrous, disrespectful of other members thing you've (politely) said.

The degree of faulty logic in your efforts for presentation are so twisted, that it has become unworthy of the effort to try and reveal the errors contained therein. Either, you are intent on utilizing such fauty logic to the nth degree, at all costs
...Show more →

I didn't point out any member here specifically...its just a known human phenomena regarding herd mentality and people wanting to purchase, use and be seen with the popular items. The FM boards in general have very unique photographers and I'm sure many choose their equipment carefully ensuring it meets their needs.

But my original response was to the statement that Canon has the most market share and I suggested the herd mentality exists that fuels most market leaders. This is a known fact.
Sep 02, 2015 at 11:31 AM
Shield
Offline
Details
p.41 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Shield wroteAlso...in rethinking your Corvette reference earlier - the 1dx/D4s are the real Corvettes.
Only in the sports arena...for my 2 month SE Asia travel...they would be the chevettes of the world.


Methinks you have it inverted Chez. Only in the light / travel / landscape world is Sony mirrorless superior - the Canon/Nikons rule everything else.
We'll have to agree to disagree. Keep in mind I have a Samsung NX1 and had the a7r/a7s for a while, so you're not talking to a Canon fanboi. I shot the GH2 for quite a while too, but always have come back to Canon for the glass / system / support / reliability / functionality.


Sep 02, 2015 at 11:41 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.41 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
I think many of us have probably "herd" enough.


Sep 02, 2015 at 11:42 AM
Shield
Offline
Details
p.41 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Shield wrote
chez wrote
Shield wrote
chez wrote
Gunzorro wroteAs used prices continue to plummet, I'm strongly considering (eventually) buying a used a7R to use with Alt lenses, and maybe a few select Canon EF and Nikon AIS and AFD lenses too. But this would be a sideline for me, something to upgrade from my foray into M43. It would be purely personal and oriented to Alt and travel/outings. It couldn't replace my Canon or Nikon DSLRs and lenses.

About time I unshackle myself from my last 120/220 system: the Pentax 67II and all its lenses. I'm pretty sure I'll never have a need to shoot that again.

So, yes, Chez, multiple systems (tools) are the word. Hard to escape the whirlpool if you have a curious mind or like technical comparisons while staying on top of your craft. You are right, there is no perfect system. It's just that some are considered more universally useful than others (see market share and sales, as well as public use).
Ah, yes...market share and sales...the herd. Toyota leads in sales...but rather than driving a boring sedan, some people reach out to the corvettes of the world. Leading hamburger joint McDonalds rolls in the bucks, I'd rather get a good burger and beer at the local brewpub.

Market share implies they cater to the general herd...niche products like micro brew beer cater to the ones that want more than the norm.
I don't know if I necessarily agree here - there is no Corvette in Sony's lineup for sports shooting. There is no "local pub burger" Sony body for shooting in harsh environments. Until Sony releases a pro level body and/or one that can actually AF and track in all lighting conditions (and no EVF blackout during bursts) then the boring Toyotas/Hondas (Canon/Nikon) are the ONLY game in town. I'd like to see Sony setup a true professional services support system as well. You're not talking about a regular Corvette, but a niche 63 Split window coupe with no air conditioning.

Sony doesn't even have a real mini-van for soccer mom's. Aka the 24-70 / 70-200 2.8. ZERO native 2.8 zooms in FE mount. No, overpriced F/4 lenses do not count, sorry.
There is also no good light street camera in the Canon lineup.

What I meant by not following the herd is the breakaway designs and features Sony is coming up with compared to Canon. Yes, the 1Dx is king in the sports arena...but it's design has been around for 15 years...boring as that is. It gets a little more horsepower with each release, but its looks and functionality etc... are stale. That's OK...the herd likes true and tried things.

I see the Sony, being mirrorless full frame with a great EVF, IBIS and a leading sensor all breakaway technologies...sort of like a Tesla Model X...breaking the mold of old.
It can't be a "herd" mentality for people shooting sports - there simply aren't any options from Sony. I'm glad you brought up the Tesla - now that's a good analogy. I can't hop in
any Tesla model and drive my family from Ohio to Florida on vacation without having major hassles always stopping to recharge. Just like I cannot find any Sony mirrorless bodies / lenses to shoot sports with anywhere near as well as Canon. Yes, it *can* be done - pre-focusing and anticipating the action. Will I walk away with as many keepers with an adapter + awkward ergonomics, poor battery life and EVF blackout, or my 12FPS rugged 1000+ shot OVF body with an native 300 2.8 / 70-200 2.8 lens?
Just like I *could* stop in Tennessee - let my car recharge for 4 hours while my kids are beating each other up and my wife is annoyed. Why go through that hassle just to brag about owning a Tesla?

All I'm saying is to use this "I don't follow the herd" statement suggests one has viable/better options elsewhere. I simply do not shooting action. Landscape? Absolutely. But if I need a mini-van to haul the kids around and your car company doesn't make one - it doesn't mean we're sheep - we're simply using the best tools available for the job.
I agree, you are correct in the sports arena...but the huge vast majority of people purchasing a Canon do so just because it is popular...they follow the herd. They see it advertised, being used to shoot amazing landscape photos...so they buy it. They see it advertised as rows of big white glass at sporting events...so they buy it. People love to go with the popular...the herd mentality at its finest.



Maybe in 2009 Chez, but not in 2015. Many beginneres these days pick up Fuji/Samsung/Sony/Panasonic/Olympus smaller bodies these days. I think you're still stuck in 6 years ago when your 5d2 was all the rage. I live about 8 miles north of Midwest Photo Exchange - they have most of the shelf space and customers (novice to mid-range) folks oogling smaller mirrorless bodies.
Sep 02, 2015 at 11:45 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.41 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
you are truly insulting your fellow FM'ers...(


Indeed, and it is perplexing
Sep 02, 2015 at 11:49 AM
Shield
Offline
Details
p.41 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
Chez ... you are truly insulting your fellow FM'ers by associating them to herd mentality.

There are some of the finest, sharpest, experienced minds around. To suggest that they are incapable of making their decisions based on anything other than "follow the herd" mentaliity is about the most ludicrous, disrespectful of other members thing you've (politely) said.

The degree of faulty logic in your efforts for presentation are so twisted, that it has become unworthy of the effort to try and reveal the errors contained therein. Either, you are intent on utilizing such fauty logic to the nth degree, at all costs
...Show more →

I would submit Chez, while walking a tight rope here, is actually referring to Joe Average consumer camera buyer, not the good folks on the FM forum. Not that some of his analogies aren't silly and for someone so pro-Sony one could question why he spends so much time in this particular forum, but still. I don't think he's insulting the FM'ers.

Sep 02, 2015 at 11:50 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister