fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
Jon Tainton
Offline
Details
p.38 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
retrofocus wroteAnd believe it or not, it makes a difference how a sensor is built. To give an easy comparison for you to better grasp it, it is like film in the old days (and I don't mean this negative at all!) - depending on the applied emulsion recipe you got different results in contrast/noise/color etc. Also you see differences in the digital technology how sensors are made and built. And BTW, those differences might look small in number but can lead to a big impact in the final image.
Let's have a look at the 2008 vintage Canon 5DSR 0.5 um sensor compared to the latest and greatest Sony Exmor R 0.18 um sensor then. Outstanding, right?

http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/dprcomp1_zpsi25nw2og.png
http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/dprcomp2_zpsd7mbcxbw.png


Anders, I think the image comparison is deserving of a forum thread all on its own

Suggested title 'Emperor's new clothes'
Sep 01, 2015 at 01:59 PM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.38 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wroteYou have no idea what your talking about. You can't possibly know what Canon was able to release 3,5,8 years ago. Again, what was groundbreaking about the a7rII sensor, it was just a bigger version of the sensor they release in 2013 and using the same technology as one release in 2009...6 years ago. Why are you using 6yr old technology (well, not you, since you don't want all the software/peripheral junk in the A7rII).
Certainly we know that Canon wasn't able to develop a new FF sensor technology with less than the 2008 developed 0.5 micrometer process generation sensors - and they still aren't. If you look at the specs, you will see that the sensor used in the A7R and in the A7R II are very differnet types of sensors even they might both rely on the same 0.18 micrometer process generation. Certainly Sony currently keeps a much faster pace in cranking sensors out than Canon does, this is without doubt.
I'm still waiting for your explanation of how a 0.5 vs 0.18 process is relevant (not Wikipedia, but you basic and easy to understand explanation)

Fact is that Sony had the exmor R sensor years ago. They had a BSI sensor over 6 years ago. The rest of us understand why it takes time to release these in different variations, but you seem to judge canon while ignoring all others. You just make up crap about what canon could've done, yet you don't have the faintest concept of product development or sensor technology(quoting a sensor spec repeatedly is not an understanding of sensor technology).
To say it in simple words is that smaller process generation allows smaller pixel size needed to allow better resolution on a hardware basis. For example using 0.18 µm generation process technology produces 4.75 µm pitch pixels whereas Canon sticks with 0.5 µm generation leading to 6-8 µm pitch pixels up to nearly twice this size.

You forget that the Exmor R generation years ago is not the same as the current Exmor RS generation which addresses some of the R's llimitations by further increasing pixel sensitivity.
You are incorrect in many ways here.
- Canon has a higher density sensor, how is that possible since they use a larger process spec?
- Why are smaller photo site sizes better?
- The a7rII uses the exmor R, not the RS. It was in fact release in 2008, so Sony is using tech from 2008 in the 'revolutionary' a7rII.

Again, what benefit is there for a smaller manufacturing process size, since the two sensors in question are roughly the same density and therefore it isn't for a higher density sensor as you incorrectly stated.

Also, why are you ok with Sony technology from 2008, but not Canon technology from the same timeframe? What does the age of the technology have to do with its characteristics? For the record, I don't care how old something is as long as it works. I know the Sony has better sensor specs in many areas, but are you buying it because it's newer or because it's better?
Smaller pixels allow better spatial seperation between each of them which reduces unwanted electron tunneling and noise plus increases sharpness. This also allows a better setup of the microlens array. In addition, the pixel wells were improved to further avoid electron tunneling. There are several generations of Exmor R sensors with the first one announced in 2008 - and used in cell phones. The sensor used in the A7R is a far more developed generation from the first original cell phone sensor. You are comparing apples and oranges when stating that Sony used the same sensor technology in the A7
...Show more →

Thanks, I sorta expected you to not really understand the concept. It sounds like you are regurgitating tech specs without a full understanding.

Do you see the bias and irony in your assessment of what is old vs new technology? You say it's apples to oranges for a Sony sensor from 2008 to 2015, yet a canon sensor is identical in your mind. The test data shows that this isn't the case. The user reports (end results in prints) shows that this isn't the case. You are making a wild claim that canon could've released a product years earlier, yet you have absolutely no way of knowing anything about their capability to release such a sensor. You say that Sony couldn't possibly release a sensor, yet you constantly say they are capable of putting out a product at the drop of a hat, often waiting until canon releases to develop their technology.

Talk about apples and oranges.
Sep 01, 2015 at 02:09 PM
StillFingerz
Offline
Details
p.38 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Sep 01, 2015 at 02:29 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.38 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wroteCertainly we know that Canon wasn't able to develop a new FF sensor technology with less than the 2008 developed 0.5 micrometer process generation sensors - and they still aren't. If you look at the specs, you will see that the sensor used in the A7R and in the A7R II are very differnet types of sensors even they might both rely on the same 0.18 micrometer process generation. Certainly Sony currently keeps a much faster pace in cranking sensors out than Canon does, this is without doubt.
I'm still waiting for your explanation of how a 0.5 vs 0.18 process is relevant (not Wikipedia, but you basic and easy to understand explanation)

Fact is that Sony had the exmor R sensor years ago. They had a BSI sensor over 6 years ago. The rest of us understand why it takes time to release these in different variations, but you seem to judge canon while ignoring all others. You just make up crap about what canon could've done, yet you don't have the faintest concept of product development or sensor technology(quoting a sensor spec repeatedly is not an understanding of sensor technology).
To say it in simple words is that smaller process generation allows smaller pixel size needed to allow better resolution on a hardware basis. For example using 0.18 µm generation process technology produces 4.75 µm pitch pixels whereas Canon sticks with 0.5 µm generation leading to 6-8 µm pitch pixels up to nearly twice this size.

You forget that the Exmor R generation years ago is not the same as the current Exmor RS generation which addresses some of the R's llimitations by further increasing pixel sensitivity.
You are incorrect in many ways here.
- Canon has a higher density sensor, how is that possible since they use a larger process spec?
- Why are smaller photo site sizes better?
- The a7rII uses the exmor R, not the RS. It was in fact release in 2008, so Sony is using tech from 2008 in the 'revolutionary' a7rII.

Again, what benefit is there for a smaller manufacturing process size, since the two sensors in question are roughly the same density and therefore it isn't for a higher density sensor as you incorrectly stated.

Also, why are you ok with Sony technology from 2008, but not Canon technology from the same timeframe? What does the age of the technology have to do with its characteristics? For the record, I don't care how old something is as long as it works. I know the Sony has better sensor specs in many areas, but are you buying it because it's newer or because it's better?
Smaller pixels allow better spatial seperation between each of them which reduces unwanted electron tunneling and noise plus increases sharpness. This also allows a better setup of the microlens array. In addition, the pixel wells were improved to further avoid electron tunneling. There are several generations of Exmor R sensors with the first one announced in 2008 - and used in cell phones. The sensor used in the A7R is a far more developed generation from the first original cell phone sensor. You are comparing apples and oranges when stating that Sony used the same sensor technology in the A7 series. It is a different beast to go from a tiny cell phone sensor to a 35 mm full frame sensor.

Canon on the other hand released in 2008 the FF sensor in the 5D MkII and 1Ds camera series. At the time, it was top of the line for FF. Unfortunately - against other members belief here - I don't see a huge progression from this sensor (or the 7D MkII cropped sensor) towards the latest one in the 5Ds(R) series other that Canon finally improved the FF resolution. Software algorithms definitely helped to improve in noise and high ISO, in the 5Ds(R) maybe with a bit of DR improvement, but hardware-wise it is no big change IMO.

I decided to go with this Sony technology last year because I wanted a higher resolution FF camera which Canon did not offer. Additional benefit was much better DR at low ISO. So clearly yes, I benefit a lot from this sensor technology. That it came in a mirrorless body, was an additional benefit for me.

I agree nevertheless with your point to use older technology as long as it works. My IR-converted 5D MkII is still great because I am using it at low ISO and don't need a wide DR for this kind of photos.
Thanks, I sorta expected you to not really understand the concept. It sounds like you are regurgitating tech specs without a full understanding.

Do you see the bias and irony in your assessment of what is old vs new technology? You say it's apples to oranges for a Sony sensor from 2008 to 2015, yet a canon sensor is identical in your mind. The test data shows that this isn't the case. The user reports (end results in prints) shows that this isn't the case. You are making a wild claim that canon could've released a product years earlier, yet you
...Show more →

I guess it is fruitless to respond to anything you ask or write with your behavior. But maybe you are smart enough to get a FF camera on your own and just not be jealous on people who have a few of them
Sep 01, 2015 at 02:49 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.38 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
I don't see the A7r2 being a sports camera. It's a very good landscape, event, travel and street camera, but I would not use it for sports. It is definitely there for the photography niches I mentioned, but not action.

Not so sure Sony even wants to enter the action arena with both Canon and Nikon solidly in place there. If I was managing Sony camera products, action photography would be way down in my list...not a huge market that needs huge investments in both cameras and lenses.


Which simply stated puts Sony into the category of an incomplete / immature platform that can't stand on it's own yet in all genre's.

That's not to say it isn't good business to leave the "Top Tier" off the table, and focus on the bell curve of consumers. That's what Sony does well ... very well ... @ hitting that "break point", but not going beyond it may make for very good business. But it doesn't supplant the Canon & Nikon product lines with a complete platform.

Not much different from Toyota not offering a product line with something to compete with GM's Corvette, nor Ford's Heavy Duty lineup. They've done their homework, and made their decisions where to draw the line at how far they're gonna take things into the marketplace(s).
Sep 01, 2015 at 02:55 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.38 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
chez wroteI don't see the A7r2 being a sports camera. It's a very good landscape, event, travel and street camera, but I would not use it for sports. It is definitely there for the photography niches I mentioned, but not action.

Not so sure Sony even wants to enter the action arena with both Canon and Nikon solidly in place there. If I was managing Sony camera products, action photography would be way down in my list...not a huge market that needs huge investments in both cameras and lenses.
Which simply stated puts Sony into the category of an incomplete / immature platform that can't stand on it's own yet in all genre's.

That's not to say it isn't good business to leave the "Top Tier" off the table, and focus on the bell curve of consumers. That's what Sony does well ... very well ... @ hitting that "break point", but not going beyond it may make for very good business. But it doesn't supplant the Canon & Nikon product lines with a complete platform.

Not much different from Toyota not offering a product line with something to compete
...Show more →

Rusty...which camera system can stand on its own...is complete and not immature? Canon, Nikon...who? In ALL genres.

I can tell you from my viewpoint, there is not one single camera manufacturer that is fully complete in all photography genre's. Loved to see who you think is there as I searched yet ended up with cameras from multiple manufactures.
Sep 01, 2015 at 03:04 PM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.38 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wroteI'm still waiting for your explanation of how a 0.5 vs 0.18 process is relevant (not Wikipedia, but you basic and easy to understand explanation)

Fact is that Sony had the exmor R sensor years ago. They had a BSI sensor over 6 years ago. The rest of us understand why it takes time to release these in different variations, but you seem to judge canon while ignoring all others. You just make up crap about what canon could've done, yet you don't have the faintest concept of product development or sensor technology(quoting a sensor spec repeatedly is not an understanding of sensor technology).
To say it in simple words is that smaller process generation allows smaller pixel size needed to allow better resolution on a hardware basis. For example using 0.18 µm generation process technology produces 4.75 µm pitch pixels whereas Canon sticks with 0.5 µm generation leading to 6-8 µm pitch pixels up to nearly twice this size.

You forget that the Exmor R generation years ago is not the same as the current Exmor RS generation which addresses some of the R's llimitations by further increasing pixel sensitivity.
You are incorrect in many ways here.
- Canon has a higher density sensor, how is that possible since they use a larger process spec?
- Why are smaller photo site sizes better?
- The a7rII uses the exmor R, not the RS. It was in fact release in 2008, so Sony is using tech from 2008 in the 'revolutionary' a7rII.

Again, what benefit is there for a smaller manufacturing process size, since the two sensors in question are roughly the same density and therefore it isn't for a higher density sensor as you incorrectly stated.

Also, why are you ok with Sony technology from 2008, but not Canon technology from the same timeframe? What does the age of the technology have to do with its characteristics? For the record, I don't care how old something is as long as it works. I know the Sony has better sensor specs in many areas, but are you buying it because it's newer or because it's better?
Smaller pixels allow better spatial seperation between each of them which reduces unwanted electron tunneling and noise plus increases sharpness. This also allows a better setup of the microlens array. In addition, the pixel wells were improved to further avoid electron tunneling. There are several generations of Exmor R sensors with the first one announced in 2008 - and used in cell phones. The sensor used in the A7R is a far more developed generation from the first original cell phone sensor. You are comparing apples and oranges when stating that Sony used the same sensor technology in the A7 series. It is a different beast to go from a tiny cell phone sensor to a 35 mm full frame sensor.

Canon on the other hand released in 2008 the FF sensor in the 5D MkII and 1Ds camera series. At the time, it was top of the line for FF. Unfortunately - against other members belief here - I don't see a huge progression from this sensor (or the 7D MkII cropped sensor) towards the latest one in the 5Ds(R) series other that Canon finally improved the FF resolution. Software algorithms definitely helped to improve in noise and high ISO, in the 5Ds(R) maybe with a bit of DR improvement, but hardware-wise it is no big change IMO.

I decided to go with this Sony technology last year because I wanted a higher resolution FF camera which Canon did not offer. Additional benefit was much better DR at low ISO. So clearly yes, I benefit a lot from this sensor technology. That it came in a mirrorless body, was an additional benefit for me.

I agree nevertheless with your point to use older technology as long as it works. My IR-converted 5D MkII is still great because I am using it at low ISO and don't need a wide DR for this kind of photos.
Thanks, I sorta expected you to not really understand the concept. It sounds like you are regurgitating tech specs without a full understanding.

Do you see the bias and irony in your assessment of what is old vs new technology? You say it's apples to oranges for a Sony sensor from 2008 to 2015, yet a canon sensor is identical in your mind. The test data shows that this isn't the case. The user reports (end results in prints) shows that this isn't the case. You are making a wild claim that canon could've released a product years earlier, yet you have absolutely no way of knowing anything about their capability to release such a sensor. You say that Sony couldn't possibly release a sensor, yet you constantly say they are capable of putting out a product at the drop of a hat, often waiting until canon releases to develop their technology.

Talk about apples and oranges.
I guess it is fruitless to respond to anything you ask or write with your behavior. SNIP...random useless insults removed.


You try to pass off baseless opinions as statements of fact. People question your faulty logic and you get all in a huff about it. What do you expect when you say things like a multinational technology company could've released a product 3 years earlier. Combined with you lack of understanding of sensor designs, why should anyone pay attention to what you say? You can't even keep the exmor R and RS version separate. Why would I trust your opinion on the technical improvements of the last 10 years of image sensors?
Sep 01, 2015 at 03:22 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.38 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
I don't see the A7r2 being a sports camera. It's a very good landscape, event, travel and street camera, but I would not use it for sports.


Someone should tell DxO - the A7rII edges out the D810 for the top DxO Mark score only because of its high "sports" score...
Sep 01, 2015 at 03:34 PM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.38 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Not so sure Sony even wants to enter the action arena with both Canon and Nikon solidly in place there. If I was managing Sony camera products, action photography would be way down in my list...not a huge market that needs huge investments in both cameras and lenses.


They already have the processing power to do 11FPS at 24MP. They already have the sensor tech in place. A larger buffer and dual slots are largely commodity components. They just need solid reliable low light AF tracking in a tougher body. As far as lenses go if I'm Sony do I really want to maintain two mounts? 2.8 zooms and telephotos will eventually come to the E-mount anyways as they are wanted by people beyond sports shooters.

There really isn't much to invest in just for an action body. If Sony is in the camera business for the long haul those investments will happen anyways.

Sep 01, 2015 at 03:47 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.38 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
ggreene wrote:
chez wroteNot so sure Sony even wants to enter the action arena with both Canon and Nikon solidly in place there. If I was managing Sony camera products, action photography would be way down in my list...not a huge market that needs huge investments in both cameras and lenses.
They already have the processing power to do 11FPS at 24MP. They already have the sensor tech in place. A larger buffer and dual slots are largely commodity components. They just need solid reliable low light AF tracking in a tougher body. As far as lenses go if I'm Sony do I really want to maintain two mounts? 2.8 zooms and telephotos will eventually come to the E-mount anyways as they are wanted by people beyond sports shooters.

There really isn't much to invest in just for an action body. If Sony is in the camera business for the long haul
...Show more →

Yes, and doing all this will bring them 3rd into the sports market. 3rd in any market is not very sustainable.
Sep 01, 2015 at 04:20 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.38 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Rusty...which camera system can stand on its own...is complete and not immature? Canon, Nikon...who? In ALL genres.


There is a difference between continuous improvement by longstanding venerable industry leaders, and totally bowing out of a segment or two by the new kid on the block (their business, their call) as evidenced (and recommended by you).

The corresponding question is which genre's are Canon and Nikon not even competing / bowing out in? Best I can tell Nikon and Canon have been covering all genre's of photography for far longer than Sony has been a (still) camera company (yes, I know resurrected / rebadged Minolta) in their own accord.
Sep 01, 2015 at 04:48 PM
mogul
Online
Details
p.38 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Nikon and Canon just copied Minolta in the 80's (not that long ago) with auto focus, off site optical flash control etc.
Sep 01, 2015 at 05:03 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.38 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
Why are the Sony pictures so blurry?


If a tree falls in the forest and Sony is there to photograph it, it is still Canon's fault that the Sony photo is out of focus? ;-)
Sep 01, 2015 at 05:10 PM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.38 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
RustyBug wrote
chez wroteI don't see the A7r2 being a sports camera. It's a very good landscape, event, travel and street camera, but I would not use it for sports. It is definitely there for the photography niches I mentioned, but not action.

Not so sure Sony even wants to enter the action arena with both Canon and Nikon solidly in place there. If I was managing Sony camera products, action photography would be way down in my list...not a huge market that needs huge investments in both cameras and lenses.
Which simply stated puts Sony into the category of an incomplete / immature platform that can't stand on it's own yet in all genre's.

That's not to say it isn't good business to leave the "Top Tier" off the table, and focus on the bell curve of consumers. That's what Sony does well ... very well ... @ hitting that "break point", but not going beyond it may make for very good business. But it doesn't supplant the Canon & Nikon product lines with a complete platform.

Not much different from Toyota not offering a product line with something to compete with GM's Corvette, nor Ford's Heavy Duty lineup. They've done their homework, and made their decisions where to draw the line at how far they're gonna take things into the marketplace(s).
Rusty...which camera system can stand on its own...is complete and not immature? Canon, Nikon...who? In ALL genres.

I can tell you from my viewpoint, there is not one single camera manufacturer that is fully complete in all photography genre's. Loved to see who you think is there as I searched yet ended up with cameras from multiple manufactures.


Yes, Canon and Nikon can stand on their own as fully complete and integrated systems. I can't think of another.

And I wouldn't consider the Sony a7R or a7RII to be an event camera, unless it's a very slow and staged event. Where is the range of dedicated flash units, system accessories and multiple bodies and formats for this type of work? Where is the tough, knock-around body? No, I don't see the Sony mirrorless FF as being appropriate for events, sports, PJ, or even most weddings (where are the wide aperture lenses and blazing focus?).

Sony's got its niche, but it is a niche, not a time tested pro system.
Sep 01, 2015 at 05:23 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.38 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Gunzorro wrote:
chez wrote
RustyBug wrote
chez wroteI don't see the A7r2 being a sports camera. It's a very good landscape, event, travel and street camera, but I would not use it for sports. It is definitely there for the photography niches I mentioned, but not action.

Not so sure Sony even wants to enter the action arena with both Canon and Nikon solidly in place there. If I was managing Sony camera products, action photography would be way down in my list...not a huge market that needs huge investments in both cameras and lenses.
Which simply stated puts Sony into the category of an incomplete / immature platform that can't stand on it's own yet in all genre's.

That's not to say it isn't good business to leave the "Top Tier" off the table, and focus on the bell curve of consumers. That's what Sony does well ... very well ... @ hitting that "break point", but not going beyond it may make for very good business. But it doesn't supplant the Canon & Nikon product lines with a complete platform.

Not much different from Toyota not offering a product line with something to compete with GM's Corvette, nor Ford's Heavy Duty lineup. They've done their homework, and made their decisions where to draw the line at how far they're gonna take things into the marketplace(s).
Rusty...which camera system can stand on its own...is complete and not immature? Canon, Nikon...who? In ALL genres.

I can tell you from my viewpoint, there is not one single camera manufacturer that is fully complete in all photography genre's. Loved to see who you think is there as I searched yet ended up with cameras from multiple manufactures.
Yes, Canon and Nikon can stand on their own as fully complete and integrated systems. I can't think of another.

And I wouldn't consider the Sony a7R or a7RII to be an event camera, unless it's a very slow and staged event. Where is the range of dedicated flash units, system accessories and multiple bodies and formats for this type of work? Where is the tough, knock-around body? No, I don't see the Sony mirrorless FF as being appropriate for events, sports, PJ, or even most weddings (where are the wide aperture lenses and blazing focus?).

Sony's got its niche, but
...Show more →

Well, when I was looking for a very compact camera which produces nice images and has a good viewfinder, I could not find one from Canon and picked up a Fuji X100. When I wanted a nice travel outfit that could still produce poster sized prints, I went to the A7R as what Canon had to offer did not meet my needs. When I wanted a camera which could focus my manual lenses...all the Canon cameras sucked...so again the A7R is used.

It's one thing covering all genres...it's another covering them well.

There is a reason why so many people have augmented their Canon or Nikon systems with other cameras...it's because other cameras are better suited for certain types of photography.

So it's back to using a multiple camera system, each camera better suited for a certain type of photography. No one system meets all needs.

Funny how there are people out there shooting events, weddings, sports and wildlife with Sony cameras...so I guess you can say Sony covers all genres as well.
Sep 01, 2015 at 05:33 PM
jcolwell
Online
Details
p.38 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
You know what really bugs me? Unwanted electron tunneling! It make me so
Sep 01, 2015 at 05:37 PM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.38 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Gunzorro wrote
chez wrote
RustyBug wrote
chez wroteI don't see the A7r2 being a sports camera. It's a very good landscape, event, travel and street camera, but I would not use it for sports. It is definitely there for the photography niches I mentioned, but not action.

Not so sure Sony even wants to enter the action arena with both Canon and Nikon solidly in place there. If I was managing Sony camera products, action photography would be way down in my list...not a huge market that needs huge investments in both cameras and lenses.
Which simply stated puts Sony into the category of an incomplete / immature platform that can't stand on it's own yet in all genre's.

That's not to say it isn't good business to leave the "Top Tier" off the table, and focus on the bell curve of consumers. That's what Sony does well ... very well ... @ hitting that "break point", but not going beyond it may make for very good business. But it doesn't supplant the Canon & Nikon product lines with a complete platform.

Not much different from Toyota not offering a product line with something to compete with GM's Corvette, nor Ford's Heavy Duty lineup. They've done their homework, and made their decisions where to draw the line at how far they're gonna take things into the marketplace(s).
Rusty...which camera system can stand on its own...is complete and not immature? Canon, Nikon...who? In ALL genres.

I can tell you from my viewpoint, there is not one single camera manufacturer that is fully complete in all photography genre's. Loved to see who you think is there as I searched yet ended up with cameras from multiple manufactures.
Yes, Canon and Nikon can stand on their own as fully complete and integrated systems. I can't think of another.

And I wouldn't consider the Sony a7R or a7RII to be an event camera, unless it's a very slow and staged event. Where is the range of dedicated flash units, system accessories and multiple bodies and formats for this type of work? Where is the tough, knock-around body? No, I don't see the Sony mirrorless FF as being appropriate for events, sports, PJ, or even most weddings (where are the wide aperture lenses and blazing focus?).

Sony's got its niche, but it is a niche, not a time tested pro system.
Well, when I was looking for a very compact camera which produces nice images and has a good viewfinder, I could not find one from Canon and picked up a Fuji X100. When I wanted a nice travel outfit that could still produce poster sized prints, I went to the A7R as what Canon had to offer did not meet my needs. When I wanted a camera which could focus my manual lenses...all the Canon cameras sucked...so again the A7R is used.

It's one thing covering all genres...it's another covering them well.

There is a reason why so many people have
...Show more →

I'll start looking more closely at the photographers and their use of a7-series cameras for breaking news, pro sports, press conferences, corporate events and weddings! I must have overlooked them, they being so compact and all.

Face it, Chez, you are in a niche yourself with equipment needs that are not mainstream. Nothing wrong with being an "Alt" guy. Just know that you are and quit badgering us run-of-the-mill corporate shills for being happy with our choices.
Sep 01, 2015 at 05:42 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.38 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
It has been interesting to watch the evolution over a few months from the apparent notion that some camera would be something along the lines of the One Camera To Rule Them All to the realization that it fills a nice niche for me.*

The pendulum swings. For a while here it has swung far, far to one extreme position. Now, at least in this thread (and in quite a few Sony forum threads, where the universal amazement is being replaced by realistic assessment of an often worthy tool) it almost seems like the pendulum is in danger of swinging back too far in the other direction.

Perhaps the truth lies somewhere equidistant from both extremes?

Some of us have been consistent for months now in saying that Camera A might be wonderful for some things and that it is a very interesting and compelling product that our friends use to make wonderful photographs, but that we happen to think that Camera B (or C or D) serves our purposes very well, regularly acknowledging that the sensor of Camera A excelled in its dynamic range and (at one time) sensor resolution, and that we find it useful to use more than one kind/brand of camera including both mirrorless and DSLR. And this perspective has been deemed sufficiently heretical by a few to warrant their unrelenting anger and insults and derision. Strange.

Dan

* Edited for clarity and for those who would willfully misconstrue or who might miss the ironically humorous film/literature reference. Obligatory smiley --> ;-)

Edited on Sep 01, 2015 at 09:10 PM · View previous versions
Sep 01, 2015 at 05:46 PM
jcolwell
Online
Details
p.38 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I'm liking both Harry and Jim (chez and Gunzorro). There is no border. It doesn't have to be mutually exclusive.

Although, I'd prefer it if some folks were mutually excluded...

P.S. I didn't mean Dan. Timing is as timing does.

(although, in multi-dimensional space, many points that are equidistant from two extremes, are also extreme.)
Sep 01, 2015 at 05:48 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.38 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
It is interesting to watch the evolution over a few months from the notion that some camera would be One Camera To Rule Them All to it fills a nice niche for me.

The pendulum swings. For a while here it has swung far, far to and extreme one position. Now, at least in this thread (and in quite a few Sony forum threads, where the universal amazement has been replaced with realistic assessment) it almost seems like the pendulum is in danger of swinging back too far in the other direction.

Perhaps the truth lies somewhere equidistant from both extremes?

Dan


Dan, can you show us where anyone stated that there exists "One camera to rule all". Go ahead, take your time and if you can't find it, quit making things up to sensationalize your points.
Sep 01, 2015 at 06:33 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister