fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.36 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
I will let go and just disagree for now, but I really look forward to your comment the day Canon implements dual ISO readout and leapfrogs Exmor RS generation 6 low ISO DR with another stop, using the same old sensor technology from 2008.


I am with you with the humor . Unfortunately I would have never thought when I bought my Canon 5D MkII in 2009 that this was the high point of Canon's FF sensor development for many years to come afterwards. Meanwhile it is quite a possibility that Canon might stick to the 2008 technology with continuous tweaks but at some point might give up on FF since they might be overrun by competitors in the FF market. I doubt the 5Ds(R) will be a big seller for Canon since it simply came too late and is too expensive, and many people already switched to Nikon or added with Sony. This is unfortunate because IMO the 5DsR is the best camera which Canon released with its available technology (no matter if good or bad) since the 5D MkII.
Sep 01, 2015 at 06:24 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.36 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Just some objective data on how the two latest Canon and Sony high res FF sensor generations have developed:

http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/CSNR_zps8h8zs0za.png
http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/SSNR_zpsrgvoig9b.png

http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/CDR_zpsmgbns9ni.png
http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/SDR_zpsprrrezjc.png

Canon has increased the SNR all over with more than Sony.

Canon has increased both high ISO and low ISO DR, while Sony has increased high ISO DR but decreased low ISO DR.

This is Sony with two new groundbreaking generations, and Canon using the same sensor technology. Arguments that the Canon results are due to signal processing algorithms are totally without substance.
Sep 01, 2015 at 06:25 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.36 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
Earlier quoteretrofocus wrote 5 pages ago::
You forget here that the sensor in the A7R II is a totally different one than in the A7R even its resolution increase between 36 and 42 MP is not a lot. Canon's FF sensor technology remains pretty stagnant since the 5D MkII was released, no big changes here other than some improvement in high ISO (no hardware change but done with software algorithms). Even the 5Ds(R) finally has a great resolution, it relies on 7D MkII sensor technology simply doubling its resolution.

In fact the 5Ds(R) sensor easily could have been released 3 years ago. There is nothing groundbreaking new in its technology. Sony's technology is very different here, each generation so far showed a big advancement in sensor technology.
It is between the lines here.
Not sure how this is connected to "He makes it sound like that is a Canon game alone, and other manufacturers give customers what they want." Otherwise I fully hold up to my opinion expressed in my former post cited above. Maybe you imply that in between the lines I am saying that people rather look out for new sensor technology plus other options provided in alternative high MP FF cameras. If you mean this, then I fully agree, I am convinced that this is the case.
In my view, your bias comes through in the way you write. You say the canon sensor is simply doubled, whereas the Sony sensor is clearly brand new and not merely a larger version from an existing sensor. The BSI exmor R was first available over 2 years ago in a 20MP rx100. Both the Canon and Sony are FF versions of an existing sensor, yet you paint it as one making huge steps and the other just doing something that they should've done 3 years ago. The 7Dii sensor wasn't available 3 years ago, so still not sure how you know that Canon could've easily released a FF version at that time. What is your reasoning for Sony releasing such a flawed initial a7r?
Because the 7D MkII is not groundbreaking new technology either. It improved (again) in high ISO, same old game. Main improvement in this camera was - again - AF. There is no technical reason why Canon could not have used this technology to release a high MP FF body much earlier as competitive reply to the D800(E).


You have no idea what your talking about. You can't possibly know what Canon was able to release 3,5,8 years ago. Again, what was groundbreaking about the a7rII sensor, it was just a bigger version of the sensor they release in 2013 and using the same technology as one release in 2009...6 years ago. Why are you using 6yr old technology (well, not you, since you don't want all the software/peripheral junk in the A7rII).
Sep 01, 2015 at 06:25 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.36 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
Earlier quoteretrofocus wrote 5 pages ago::
You forget here that the sensor in the A7R II is a totally different one than in the A7R even its resolution increase between 36 and 42 MP is not a lot. Canon's FF sensor technology remains pretty stagnant since the 5D MkII was released, no big changes here other than some improvement in high ISO (no hardware change but done with software algorithms). Even the 5Ds(R) finally has a great resolution, it relies on 7D MkII sensor technology simply doubling its resolution.

In fact the 5Ds(R) sensor easily could have been released 3 years ago. There is nothing groundbreaking new in its technology. Sony's technology is very different here, each generation so far showed a big advancement in sensor technology.
It is between the lines here.
Not sure how this is connected to "He makes it sound like that is a Canon game alone, and other manufacturers give customers what they want." Otherwise I fully hold up to my opinion expressed in my former post cited above. Maybe you imply that in between the lines I am saying that people rather look out for new sensor technology plus other options provided in alternative high MP FF cameras. If you mean this, then I fully agree, I am convinced that this is the case.
In my view, your bias comes through in the way you write. You say the canon sensor is simply doubled, whereas the Sony sensor is clearly brand new and not merely a larger version from an existing sensor. The BSI exmor R was first available over 2 years ago in a 20MP rx100. Both the Canon and Sony are FF versions of an existing sensor, yet you paint it as one making huge steps and the other just doing something that they should've done 3 years ago. The 7Dii sensor wasn't available 3 years ago, so still not sure how you know that Canon could've easily released a FF version at that time. What is your reasoning for Sony releasing such a flawed initial a7r?
Because the 7D MkII is not groundbreaking new technology either. It improved (again) in high ISO, same old game. Main improvement in this camera was - again - AF. There is no technical reason why Canon could not have used this technology to release a high MP FF body much earlier as competitive reply to the D800(E).
You have no idea what your talking about. You can't possibly know what Canon was able to release 3,5,8 years ago. Again, what was groundbreaking about the a7rII sensor, it was just a bigger version of the sensor they release in 2013 and using the same technology as one release in 2009...6 years ago. Why are you using 6yr old technology (well, not you, since you don't want all the software/peripheral junk in the A7rII).


Certainly we know that Canon wasn't able to develop a new FF sensor technology with less than the 2008 developed 0.5 micrometer process generation sensors - and they still aren't. If you look at the specs, you will see that the sensor used in the A7R and in the A7R II are very differnet types of sensors even they might both rely on the same 0.18 micrometer process generation. Certainly Sony currently keeps a much faster pace in cranking sensors out than Canon does, this is without doubt.

You never answered my question with your personal involvement in digital FF sensor camera technology.
Sep 01, 2015 at 06:46 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.36 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
Certainly we know that Sony wasn't able to develop a new FF sensor technology with less than the 2012 developed 0.18 micrometer process generation sensors - and they still aren't. If you look at the specs, you will see that the sensor used in the 5DII and in the 5DS are very different types of sensors even they might both rely on the same 0.5 micrometer process generation. Certainly Canon currently keeps a much faster pace in cranking sensors out than Sony does, this is without doubt.



Hmm...
Sep 01, 2015 at 06:52 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.36 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
Just some objective data on how the two latest Canon and Sony high res FF sensor generations have developed:

http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/CSNR_zps8h8zs0za.png
http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/SSNR_zpsrgvoig9b.png

http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/CDR_zpsmgbns9ni.png
http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/SDR_zpsprrrezjc.png

Canon has increased the SNR all over with more than Sony.

Canon has increased both high ISO and low ISO DR, while Sony has increased high ISO DR but decreased low ISO DR.

This is Sony with two new groundbreaking generations, and Canon using the same sensor technology. Arguments that the Canon results are due to signal processing algorithms are totally without substance.


I agree with your point that the A7R II shows no improvement in low ISO over the A7R - one reason why I am personally hesitant to upgrade. Clearly Sony wants to move more into the high ISO shooter territory (unfortunate for me but might make sense from a business perspective for Sony). We continue to disagree with the overall perspective of sensor development comparing Canon and Sony where I believe that Sony is miles ahead of Canon in this regard - just looking at the process generation difference makes this clear (and Sony might already be smaller than 0.18 micrometer in its current backlit sensor generation, but I didn't find any information about this online).
Sep 01, 2015 at 06:54 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.36 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wroteIt is between the lines here.
Not sure how this is connected to "He makes it sound like that is a Canon game alone, and other manufacturers give customers what they want." Otherwise I fully hold up to my opinion expressed in my former post cited above. Maybe you imply that in between the lines I am saying that people rather look out for new sensor technology plus other options provided in alternative high MP FF cameras. If you mean this, then I fully agree, I am convinced that this is the case.
In my view, your bias comes through in the way you write. You say the canon sensor is simply doubled, whereas the Sony sensor is clearly brand new and not merely a larger version from an existing sensor. The BSI exmor R was first available over 2 years ago in a 20MP rx100. Both the Canon and Sony are FF versions of an existing sensor, yet you paint it as one making huge steps and the other just doing something that they should've done 3 years ago. The 7Dii sensor wasn't available 3 years ago, so still not sure how you know that Canon could've easily released a FF version at that time. What is your reasoning for Sony releasing such a flawed initial a7r?
Because the 7D MkII is not groundbreaking new technology either. It improved (again) in high ISO, same old game. Main improvement in this camera was - again - AF. There is no technical reason why Canon could not have used this technology to release a high MP FF body much earlier as competitive reply to the D800(E).
You have no idea what your talking about. You can't possibly know what Canon was able to release 3,5,8 years ago. Again, what was groundbreaking about the a7rII sensor, it was just a bigger version of the sensor they release in 2013 and using the same technology as one release in 2009...6 years ago. Why are you using 6yr old technology (well, not you, since you don't want all the software/peripheral junk in the A7rII).
Certainly we know that Canon wasn't able to develop a new FF sensor technology with less than the 2008 developed 0.5 micrometer process generation sensors - and they still aren't. If you look at the specs, you will see that the sensor used in the A7R and in the A7R II are very differnet types of sensors even they might both rely on the same 0.18 micrometer process generation. Certainly Sony currently keeps a much faster pace in cranking sensors out than Canon does, this is without doubt.


I'm still waiting for your explanation of how a 0.5 vs 0.18 process is relevant (not Wikipedia, but you basic and easy to understand explanation)

Fact is that Sony had the exmor R sensor years ago. They had a BSI sensor over 6 years ago. The rest of us understand why it takes time to release these in different variations, but you seem to judge canon while ignoring all others. You just make up crap about what canon could've done, yet you don't have the faintest concept of product development or sensor technology(quoting a sensor spec repeatedly is not an understanding of sensor technology).
Sep 01, 2015 at 07:14 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.36 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote

Certainly we know that Canon wasn't able to develop a new FF sensor technology with less than the 2008 developed 0.5 micrometer process generation sensors - and they still aren't. If you look at the specs, you will see that the sensor used in the A7R and in the A7R II are very differnet types of sensors even they might both rely on the same 0.18 micrometer process generation. Certainly Sony currently keeps a much faster pace in cranking sensors out than Canon does, this is without doubt.

alundeb wrote:

Certainly we know that Sony wasn't able to develop a new FF sensor technology with less than the 2011 developed 0.18 micrometer process generation sensors - and they still aren't. If you look at the specs, you will see that the sensor used in the 5DIII and in the 5DS are very different types of sensors even they might both rely on the same 0.5 micrometer process generation. Certainly Canon currently keeps a much faster pace in cranking sensors out than Sony does, this is without doubt.

Hmm....
Sep 01, 2015 at 07:35 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.36 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I still think you have to hand it to Sony for improving the high ISO of the A7RII, especially at that pixel density. It will be interesting to see what Nikon does with it as that is probably the only chance we'll have to see a decent body around that sensor.
Sep 01, 2015 at 07:48 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.36 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Whether Sony had the latest sensor tech 10 years ago or not...we really won't ever know. What I know is that Sony is pushing the sensor and camera market which is good news for everyone around. If things continued as a two horse race, Nikon and Canon, we would have seen progress at a snails pace as both companies are slow methodical moving.
Sep 01, 2015 at 08:08 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.36 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wroteNot sure how this is connected to "He makes it sound like that is a Canon game alone, and other manufacturers give customers what they want." Otherwise I fully hold up to my opinion expressed in my former post cited above. Maybe you imply that in between the lines I am saying that people rather look out for new sensor technology plus other options provided in alternative high MP FF cameras. If you mean this, then I fully agree, I am convinced that this is the case.
In my view, your bias comes through in the way you write. You say the canon sensor is simply doubled, whereas the Sony sensor is clearly brand new and not merely a larger version from an existing sensor. The BSI exmor R was first available over 2 years ago in a 20MP rx100. Both the Canon and Sony are FF versions of an existing sensor, yet you paint it as one making huge steps and the other just doing something that they should've done 3 years ago. The 7Dii sensor wasn't available 3 years ago, so still not sure how you know that Canon could've easily released a FF version at that time. What is your reasoning for Sony releasing such a flawed initial a7r?
Because the 7D MkII is not groundbreaking new technology either. It improved (again) in high ISO, same old game. Main improvement in this camera was - again - AF. There is no technical reason why Canon could not have used this technology to release a high MP FF body much earlier as competitive reply to the D800(E).
You have no idea what your talking about. You can't possibly know what Canon was able to release 3,5,8 years ago. Again, what was groundbreaking about the a7rII sensor, it was just a bigger version of the sensor they release in 2013 and using the same technology as one release in 2009...6 years ago. Why are you using 6yr old technology (well, not you, since you don't want all the software/peripheral junk in the A7rII).
Certainly we know that Canon wasn't able to develop a new FF sensor technology with less than the 2008 developed 0.5 micrometer process generation sensors - and they still aren't. If you look at the specs, you will see that the sensor used in the A7R and in the A7R II are very differnet types of sensors even they might both rely on the same 0.18 micrometer process generation. Certainly Sony currently keeps a much faster pace in cranking sensors out than Canon does, this is without doubt.
I'm still waiting for your explanation of how a 0.5 vs 0.18 process is relevant (not Wikipedia, but you basic and easy to understand explanation)

Fact is that Sony had the exmor R sensor years ago. They had a BSI sensor over 6 years ago. The rest of us understand why it takes time to release these in different variations, but you seem to judge canon while ignoring all others. You just make up crap about what canon could've done, yet you don't have the faintest concept of product development or sensor technology(quoting a sensor spec repeatedly is not an understanding
...Show more →

To say it in simple words is that smaller process generation allows smaller pixel size needed to allow better resolution on a hardware basis. For example using 0.18 µm generation process technology produces 4.75 µm pitch pixels whereas Canon sticks with 0.5 µm generation leading to 6-8 µm pitch pixels up to nearly twice this size.

You forget that the Exmor R generation years ago is not the same as the current Exmor RS generation which addresses some of the R's llimitations by further increasing pixel sensitivity.

Coming back to your personal involevement with FF technology in cameras.....zero.
Sep 01, 2015 at 08:19 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.36 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
News Flash: This Isn't the "Smallest Pixel Size" event at the camera olympics, or is it the "Newest Incremental Manufacturing Improvement of 2014" Award.

Now back to our regularly scheduled program...
Sep 01, 2015 at 08:49 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.36 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
News Flash: This Isn't the "Smallest Pixel Size" event at the camera olympics, or is it the "Newest Incremental Manufacturing Improvement of 2014" Award.

Now back to our regularly scheduled program...


Yes, but it is a discussion about the two new cameras in a gear forum where their sensors are of utmost interest.

Talk about Canon forum becoming polluted.
Sep 01, 2015 at 09:00 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.36 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
News Flash: This Isn't the "Smallest Pixel Size" event at the camera olympics, or is it the "Newest Incremental Manufacturing Improvement of 2014" Award.

Now back to our regularly scheduled program...


I don't think it exceeds your intellectual capability, but we are discussing technology here. And believe it or not, it makes a difference how a sensor is built. To give an easy comparison for you to better grasp it, it is like film in the old days (and I don't mean this negative at all!) - depending on the applied emulsion recipe you got different results in contrast/noise/color etc. Also you see differences in the digital technology how sensors are made and built. And BTW, those differences might look small in number but can lead to a big impact in the final image.

Edited on Sep 01, 2015 at 09:10 AM · View previous versions
Sep 01, 2015 at 09:07 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.36 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
ggreene wrote:
I still think you have to hand it to Sony for improving the high ISO of the A7RII, especially at that pixel density. It will be interesting to see what Nikon does with it as that is probably the only chance we'll have to see a decent body around that sensor.


+1 @ body around sensor = Nikon, not Sony. Sony's only current FF body is the A99 with it's SLT approach to a non-moving mirror via translucence ... which eats ~ 1/2 (i.e. one stop reduction @ measured ISO from rated ISO) the light passing through the lens by diverting it to the viewfinder.

Although, it seems that Sony could wrap an A99 II body around it. Given the split / share of light through the SLT, it could really benefit the most of any camera, since it is already crippled by a 1 stop loss of light going to the sensor. Of course, if they were to go away from the SLT to mirrorless in that body, then you'd get a double dose of goodness with the full available light reaching the sensor and the improved sensor.

To my way of thinking, if Sony wants to play with the big boys, the have to make a big boy camera. It's not like they don't have the pieces of the puzzle to do so. I mean, they shook things up with the A900 (moving mirror @ DSLR) and then went into SLT (non-moving mirror @ translucence) and now E-mount for mirrorless.

Take that mirrorless technology and BSI sensor and drop it into a real body and you'll have something that is "ahead of the pack", rather than the hyperfocus on the "small & light". BUT, it makes me wonder if they are concerned that a FF mirrorless with EVF won't be well received. Bring on the A99 II (SLT or mirrorless) with the BSI sensor, and while an SLT would be a "decrease" in spec, it would still be on par with the big boys and a gain over it's existing spec.

Which, BTW, the spec on the A mount camera's for Sony are still on the "light" side for being a full bodied FF camera. They aren't built like a 1 Series, but they aren't as heavy as a 1 Series either ... very Goldilocks for a lot of folks, I'd think. Just need to do something about that SLT approach eating 1/2 the light.

Why they haven't already done so ... that's the one that has me scratching my head @ lagging where they coulda / woulda / shoulda. Imo, as long as they keep their mirrorless and latest sensor out of a FF A mount body ... there are telling the world they aren't serious about making a big boy camera anymore. We'll see what the A9, A99 II, etc. bring ... but the pieces are there (and have been) for Sony. For Sony, the message seems to very LOUD & CLEAR be, our flagship is the E-Mount, not the A mount.

Edited on Sep 01, 2015 at 09:19 AM · View previous versions
Sep 01, 2015 at 09:09 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.36 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
For better or for worse Sony a-mount system appears to be dead on the vine.

Edited on Sep 01, 2015 at 09:23 AM · View previous versions
Sep 01, 2015 at 09:19 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.36 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
darbo wrote:
For better or for worse I think the Sony a-mount system is dead on the vine.


Which is entirely a matter of choice by Sony if they ALLOW it to die out. The introduction of f/2.8 zoom into the E-mount could signal the beginning of the end for the A mount. We'll see what they do / don't do with the A99 successor.

If I were confident that the A mount were going to prosper forward ... ... but, while I might be hopeful, I'm not confident. Sony moved away from FF to mirrorless (and has pocketed well from it), I just don't think they'll make much of a move to invest the A mount, despite their indication of continued support for the A mount.

For me ... still shooting the SLR/C ... I'd be okay with a "dead" camera in the form of the A99 II if that's all the farther they took the A mount. I truly do not NEED the latest technilogical advancement marvel for my photography. I just want a body that works like it should, and I don't want to give away 1/2 my light from the sensor in it's current SLT approach. As such, that puts Nikon in the realm of the viable approach to a Sony sensor in a full bodied FF body (barring what a larger A9 might be like).

Sony E mount ... deficient in handling / long glass performance
Sony A mount ... deficient in getting all the light to the sensor

Darned if you do, danged if you don't.

They're SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO close ... yet, so far.



Edited on Sep 01, 2015 at 09:35 AM · View previous versions
Sep 01, 2015 at 09:22 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.36 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
It is intriguing to watch it unfold.
Sep 01, 2015 at 09:24 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.36 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
And believe it or not, it makes a difference how a sensor is built. To give an easy comparison for you to better grasp it, it is like film in the old days (and I don't mean this negative at all!) - depending on the applied emulsion recipe you got different results in contrast/noise/color etc. Also you see differences in the digital technology how sensors are made and built. And BTW, those differences might look small in number but can lead to a big impact in the final image.


Let's have a look at the 2008 vintage Canon 5DSR 0.5 um sensor compared to the latest and greatest Sony Exmor R 0.18 um sensor then. Outstanding, right?

http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/dprcomp1_zpsi25nw2og.png
http://i306.photobucket.com/albums/nn242/Overflate/dprcomp2_zpsd7mbcxbw.png
Sep 01, 2015 at 09:32 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.36 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
^ Is there a reason the e-shutter was used for the comparison? Does it make a difference? Just curious.
Sep 01, 2015 at 10:08 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister