retrofocus wrote:
Monito wrote
mttran wrote
I am not talking about sony or other MFG here. Why canon keeps offer something that they've already had from their last and it has been years since we know it. Yes you are.
Your statement is just as wrong and misguided as saying why does Sony keep offering the same (to pick just one example of their palette of offerings) lossy compressed file format they have for years.
The Canon sensor in the 5DS is not the same as any previous sensor they have offered. Ever. Period.
It does not matter that the lens mount is 28 years old or the AF is the same as two years ago or the sensor fab line rule width is the same as 10 years ago. What counts is the total package which is why I bought a 5DS.
I wouldn't care if Canon had an army of 5,000 year old Mesopotamian spider mites inside scratching out the images on clay tablets if they could produce the beautiful images the 5DS makes so quickly.
So just drop it with that tired old bogus line. It doesn't work, it is not true, and it doesn't convince. Canon still uses the old 0.5 micrometer process generation for their FF sensors whereas Sony uses a 0.18 micrometer process which allows the needed pixel layout for this high MP Exmor sensor. So the buit-style of Canon sensors didn't change since quite a long time whereas Sony improved in this area. The A7R II now even has a backlit sensor built in which pushed Sony's innovative advantage even further.
That's nice — 0.5 vs. 0.18 — but those are *just numbers* to me. I don't know what a "micrometer process" is because the manufacture of sensors is not my thing. I know there are people who are experts on such things; without them there would be no digital cameras. But in the pre-digital era, I was not intimately familiar with the machinery of film manufacture, and yet could easily pick a film based on the pictures I needed.
Time after time, job after job, Canon delivers the photos that I need. So for my purposes, Canon sensors are *EXCELLENT*. I'm sure they could be better in some respect, just as every tool and gadget could be better in some respect. Sony's limited advantage is compelling to some, not to others. I merely have to look at the work produced with Canon to know that sensors are superb for much of the work that photographers are doing, including some of the world's best photographers.
And then there are some real Sony disadvantages, which everyone seems to overlook in these sensor discussions.