fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.20 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
technic wrote:
The question is how solid an 'investment' in EF lenses is for the long run, with this new Sony I'm less sure about that.


That is a very good question. I would consider an investment in Sony FE lenses far more risky in the long run. They cannot be used on any other platform.
Jun 18, 2015 at 06:16 AM
Mike V
Offline
Details
p.20 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Hopefully this strong competition is going to force Canon into releasing a camera with some more modern sensor tech.

Although unless people stop buying the bodies, I guess they will keep rehashing the same old stuff.
Jun 18, 2015 at 06:19 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.20 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
technic wroteSo the next body is going to be a Nikon or a Sony - tough decision because both require a big 'investment' in time, because of different ergonomics, software etc. I have worked in imaging product development for many years and would prefer to upgrade to a familiar, reliable camera. But if the incentive is big enough I'm willing to take a chance :-)
It is best to go for the camera that has the features you want. Regarding closed systems, a Nikon DSLR is even more closed than Canon. ...

Since I already have the A7r to bridge the features the 5DS R is lacking, I will wait a bit to get the A7r II. If I was in your shoes, I would get the A7r II now, because only you can in the end decide if the AF is good enough for your use.


The D750 meets all my important requirements and I think I can adjust to the different ergonomics, software etc. The only real problem is lenses, and starting to invest in another closed system.

I considered A7(r) but it would be at best a temporary solution for me; this A7RII looks like it could be a complete solution. But yes, AF speed and accuracy is a big question so I will wait for reliable reports and if it looks good, try it with my Canon lenses. I don't have local shops who would sell this camera (for a good price) and return policy in Europe means I have to return it within a week if I don't like it, which doesn't offer sufficient time for real testing.


Edited on Jun 18, 2015 at 06:29 AM · View previous versions
Jun 18, 2015 at 06:22 AM
Stoffer
Offline
Details
p.20 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
Sony use a combination of PDAF and CDAF in the A7r II. CDAF is used for precision focus after initial PDAF lock. With EF lenses and adapters, the CDAF is disabled. One would expect the accuracy to be less in that case.


Ahh, that could be an important point regarding accuracy. Maybe that could change in the future via a new firmware to the metabones adapter? Or could you just choose CDAF instead of PDAF in the camera if accuracy is much more important than speed?
Jun 18, 2015 at 06:25 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.20 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
technic wroteThe question is how solid an 'investment' in EF lenses is for the long run, with this new Sony I'm less sure about that.
That is a very good question. I would consider an investment in Sony FE lenses far more risky in the long run. They cannot be used on any other platform.


Good point. I don't plan buying many Sony FE lenses, not many attractive lenses there for me anyway. But I would probably buy a few small primes (e.g. the Zeiss Batis) or a good standard zoom to realize the full AF performance in a relatively small/light system.
Jun 18, 2015 at 06:28 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.20 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Stoffer wrote:
alundeb wroteSony use a combination of PDAF and CDAF in the A7r II. CDAF is used for precision focus after initial PDAF lock. With EF lenses and adapters, the CDAF is disabled. One would expect the accuracy to be less in that case.
Ahh, that could be an important point regarding accuracy. Maybe that could change in the future via a new firmware to the metabones adapter? Or could you just choose CDAF instead of PDAF in the camera if accuracy is much more important than speed?


It would be possible to change that in firmware, the problem is the slow communiaction speed in the EF protocole specifiaction. This is what makes CDAF very slow with EF lenses in the first place. They are simply not designed for the fast update rate required by a trial-and-error approach that CDAF is. With CDAF only, we basically have the A7r AF as it is. It works much faster with native Sony FE lenses than with Canon EF lenses.

Jun 18, 2015 at 06:30 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.20 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Mike V wrote:
Hopefully this strong competition is going to force Canon into releasing a camera with some more modern sensor tech.

Although unless people stop buying the bodies, I guess they will keep rehashing the same old stuff.


Given that Canon outsells Sony 4 to 1, they probably don't have much incentive to change.
Jun 18, 2015 at 06:31 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.20 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Stoffer wrote:
alundeb wroteSony use a combination of PDAF and CDAF in the A7r II. CDAF is used for precision focus after initial PDAF lock. With EF lenses and adapters, the CDAF is disabled. One would expect the accuracy to be less in that case.
Ahh, that could be an important point regarding accuracy. Maybe that could change in the future via a new firmware to the metabones adapter? Or could you just choose CDAF instead of PDAF in the camera if accuracy is much more important than speed?


I don't think we have reliable information about this (just some translated statements, and sometimes the devil is in the details). I would guess it is a software/firmware limitation that could be avoided when one can accept lower speed. I guess we will hear more about this subject in the next two months. Another question is if A7RII AF accuracy is a real problem with adapted Canon lenses, maybe for the less exotic (very bright, very short/long focal length) lenses it isn't a significant problem.
Jun 18, 2015 at 06:34 AM
howard
Offline
Details
p.20 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
Mike V wroteHopefully this strong competition is going to force Canon into releasing a camera with some more modern sensor tech.

Although unless people stop buying the bodies, I guess they will keep rehashing the same old stuff.
Given that Canon outsells Sony 4 to 1, they probably don't have much incentive to change.


It is this kind of complacency that led Canon to where it is now (nothing against you, just an observation).
Jun 18, 2015 at 06:42 AM
J_ph
Offline
Details
p.20 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
technic wrote:
The question is how solid an 'investment' in EF lenses is for the long run, with this new Sony I'm less sure about that.


Sony is clearly being aggressive and innovative with their new cameras as you would expect with any company that has newly entered a market and wants to gain a significant position. Not to pick on any manufacturer but Sony is similar to many other companies that have been successful in markets and then dropped them when they are no longer part of the long haul plan, for example the PC market (Vaio computers were great), and now rumors about the Mobile market too. Canon on the on the other hand is at it's core, an imaging and optics company.

Guessing the long run, will always be guessing. But I started with Canon gear, switched a couple times, happily back with Canon... and staying put.

Edited on Jun 18, 2015 at 07:50 AM · View previous versions
Jun 18, 2015 at 07:04 AM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.20 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
technic wrote:
The question is how solid an 'investment' in EF lenses is for the long run, with this new Sony I'm less sure about that.


I have a lot of money invested in EF and TS-E lenses, but it's not "an investment" which I expect will give me a decent monetary return when I decide to sell them. The expense for the investment is paid off by what I do with the lenses while I own them, not when I sell them.
Jun 18, 2015 at 07:14 AM
J_ph
Offline
Details
p.20 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
> The expense for the investment is paid off by what I do with the lenses while I own them, not when I sell them.

indeed, well said.
Jun 18, 2015 at 07:28 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.20 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Sony is clearly being aggressive and innovative with their new cameras as you would expect with any company that has newly entered a market and wants to gain a significant position. Not to pick on any manufacturer but Sony is similar to many other companies that have been successful in markets and then dropped them them when they are no longer part of the long haul plan, for example the PC market (Vaio computers were great), and now rumors about the Mobile market too. Canon on the on the other hand is at it's core, an imaging and optics company.

Guessing
...Show more →

That's an interesting meta-observation concerning the differences between how a new (in the context of new to a particular market) company operates relative to a company that is already established in the market.

The successes often get our attention, perhaps for several reasons. The ideal is a company that has a disruptive product that is also very good and very timely. One current example (some might argue, but someone will always argue when it comes to this subject) is Tesla. There have been and continue to be tons of doubters, but they certainly have made headway with a product that challenges an entire industry. (Though it also fits in — the current vehicle competes in a market segment that, gas engines aside, is already rather successful.)

But for every Tesla there are dozens of other companies that look like the next hot new thing, that seem like they might produce that disruptive product that will change everything... but they get bought out for the patents, or some other company sweeps in and preempts them, or the product turns out to be less world-changing and compelling than it first seemed.

When it comes to Sony as a camera company or two mirrorless cameras as a breed, who really knows? I tend to think that mirrorless cameras and their successors are likely to become more and more powerful and much more prevalent, though I think it will be a long time before they supplant DSLRs for many purposes. (I'm certainly not anti-mirrorless. I have one and sing its praises frequently.)

One thing we see in the Sony versus Canon debate is a replaying of the familiar story of the entrenched and successful manufacturer versus the upstart company with the disruptive product. (Though do keep in mind the irony of regarding Sony as the upstart outsider!) Companies in either of those positions have to play to different strengths and they have to operate differently.

The value that the upstart brings is not its record of being right, its long term reliability — the value it offers is something quite different: it is going to do something that the big companies won't do (partly because if it did what they do it would never succeed), it is going to offer something new and different (and "different" must be relative to something already known). That is how virtually all new companies portray themselves.

The value that the established firm brings is different. It can tell people to look at its record of producing good and reliable and compelling products. It will offer reliability and value. It may offer innovation (what company doesn't use that word?) but the innovations will be presented as the result of a long and intensive development and testing process — not of rushing a cool thing to market.

I write this not to favor either approach. In fact, both are part of how the market will work. As a consumer (or as a member of the class called consumers) think about how and why each of us responds differently. For some (and I've been in this category at times) the excitement of the new, the possibility of being part of something innovative, the hope/belief that a transformation is taking place are enough to induce us to get on the bandwagon. For others (and I've been in this category, too) the new may not seem to be as compelling as it is thought to be by some, the existing thing works well and is reliable and productive, and the promises of radical transformation are not convincing.

All of that aside, the "battle" between the scrappy upstart and the established firm is not a new story, and it has been played out in much the same way many times before.
Jun 18, 2015 at 07:30 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.20 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jcolwell wrote:
technic wroteThe question is how solid an 'investment' in EF lenses is for the long run, with this new Sony I'm less sure about that.
I have a lot of money invested in EF and TS-E lenses, but it's not "an investment" which I expect will give me a decent monetary return when I decide to sell them. The expense for the investment is paid off by what I do with the lenses while I own them, not when I sell them.


I used quotation marks to indicate that; I'm not expecting financial returns in any way.

Point is, I spend a lot of money on lenses and if I can't get the right body from Canon the returns (in the form of pleasure taking pictures and/or viewing the results) are unsatisfactory. Trading lenses is painful in my country (no good market like e.g. on Ebay) and if you keep them just in case Canon comes out with a much better body in a few years you have to wonder how the value of those DSLR lenses will hold up, now that mirrorless is becoming more mature. I'm not talking just about A7RII, maybe Nikon and Canon will be forced to introduce serious mirrorless bodies as well and introduce new lenses to go with them.
Jun 18, 2015 at 07:39 AM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.20 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
technic wrote:
I used quotation marks to indicate that; I'm not expecting financial returns in any way.

Point is, I spend a lot of money on lenses and if I can't get the right body from Canon the returns (in the form of pleasure taking pictures and/or viewing the results) are unsatisfactory. Trading lenses is painful in my country..


Fair enough.

Trading lenses is easier in Canada, but it's always tough to switch systems. If I decide to get an A7R II, it won't be to swicth away from Canon, it'll supplement my Canon gears. In the same way that my Fujifilm X-E2 and X100S do.

Jun 18, 2015 at 07:48 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.20 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
The value that the upstart brings is not its record of being right, its long term reliability — the value it offers is something quite different: it is going to do something that the big companies won't do (partly because if it did what they do it would never succeed), it is going to offer something new and different (and "different" must be relative to something already known). That is how virtually all new companies portray themselves.

The value that the established firm brings is different. It can tell people to look at its record of producing good and reliable
...Show more →

Agree. I worked in development for many years and know both sides of the story. Something similar applies for the users: a photography pro in an established market, with a large client base and excellent reputation is usually not going to take risks and primarily needs a familiar, reliable product.
People who take pictures just for fun may like experimenting with a new camera, or pushing the boundaries of what can be done. The same goes for 'pros' who are just starting or trying to break into a new market, or people working in specialized fields like scientific photography and video.
Jun 18, 2015 at 07:51 AM
vpPhoto
Offline
Details
Jun 18, 2015 at 07:54 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.20 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jcolwell wrote:
it'll supplement my Canon gears.


And your "little" alt lens collection.

Jun 18, 2015 at 07:57 AM
dgdg
Offline
Details
p.20 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
Sony use a combination of PDAF and CDAF in the A7r II. CDAF is used for precision focus after initial PDAF lock. With EF lenses and adapters, the CDAF is disabled. One would expect the accuracy to be less in that case.


Interesting info and good to know.
Would this type of AF accuracy be improved or affected by AFMA? I am expecting not, but it it is I'd surely want to take advantage of it.

Jun 18, 2015 at 07:57 AM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.20 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jcolwell wrote:
it'll supplement my Canon gears.

RustyBug wrote:
And your "little" alt lens collection.


Yes, many of them are quite small.
Jun 18, 2015 at 08:00 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister