snapsy wrote:
snapsy wrote
curious80 wrote
snapsy wrote
curious80 wrote
snapsy wrote
Gamma conversion from raw to a color space can be non-linear and thus is not inhibited by bit depth. But independent of bit depth the A7s sensor is only capable of 13EV even though the implied linear limit would be 14EV for 14-bits (irrespective of Sony's tonal compression). But raw image files don't store gamma converted data, they store the linear data, and with that you are limited to 14EV of maximum DR with 14-bits. And that too only if your A/D is up to the task. A 14-bit A/D doesn't produce actual 14-bit worth of data.
Note that cameras like D810 which have over 14 stops of DR on DxoMark have that DR when down-sampled to 8MP, which effectively gives you more bits per downsampled pixel. At pixel level D810 has 13.67EV of DR as per DxoMark (which admittedly is still very high for a 14-bit sample).
A7s is at a disadvantage here because it is natively only 12MP and each of its fat pixels gets only 14-bits to represent it. SLOG2 provides a non-linear mapping of the type that you are talking about allowing storing more stops of DR to be stores in 14-bits. But the gamma conversion is non-linear during demosaicing, the same technique performed for slog2 that you ascribed to its ability to exceed the native bit range for DR. You are missing the point that once the linear data has been sampled by a 14-bit A/D and stored in the RAW file as 14-bits then any additional data that was captured by the sensor in the 15th or 16-bit has already been thrown away. There is nothing you can do to reclaim that. The only way you can save any extra information captured by the sensor is if the non-linear mapping is done in the sensor itself before it is sampled by the A/D. Which I believe is what modes like SLOG2 do. That's true, Sony may be doing non-linear encoding of the sensor values at the ADC for slog2. However that doesn't really increase captured DR when the underlying pixels and their charge capture+transfer mechanism is still principally linear. It simply applies a tone curve earlier in the process (against the raw data) so that the encoded ADC values can later be gamma-interpreted to a > 2^14 of tonal space. I'm not seeing how that's fundamentally different than simply re-interpreting non-slog2 raw data in the same fashion after the fact. Perhaps I'm overlooking something though.
Btw I'm less inclined to believe the A7s's true sensor-level DR is 15.3EV that can only be unleased via slog2 when you consider that slog2 is only available on the A7s at ISO 3200, which has 1/5 the FWC (and thus DR) than ISO 100. Thinking it through more, an ADC-based slog2 would be fundamentally different vs simply reinterpreting non-slog2 raw data if the native DR capability of the sensor is greater than the underlying ADC bit depth + ADC noise. But I don't see the A7s's FWC and charge-transfer noise supporting 15.3EV and its on-chip parallel ADC adding an entire 1EV of noise. Also, considering that the A7s has only 13EV of DR at ISO 100 (post-ADC) I don't see how it can how slog2 can achieve 15.3EV of sensor-level DR when it operates at ISO 3200 for slog2.
Well I don't really know too much about the performance of today's ADCs. When I dealt with ADCs, 13 effective bits out of a 14-bit ADC was really as good as you could expect and the 13.67 EV DR that D810 pulls out of a 14-bit ADC would have been the more surprising part.
I am not saying that A7s sensor does have 15.3 EV of DR. Maybe you are right and it doesn't. All I am saying is that IF it does indeed have 15.3EV of DR then it could not be captured in a 14-bit RAW file and will require something like SLOG2 to be able to capture that.
Also I suspect you can't really interpret the ISO's the same way as a linear RAW file when you are dealing with modes like SLOG2. I am 99% sure that in the ISO3200 SLOG2 mode A7s uses its FWC and not 1/5 FWC.