p.6 #1Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote: retrofocus wroteMonito wrotezlatko wroteWe get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?What happens is that the insecure guy who predicted Canon's demise posts about how great Sony DR is (for his work) and complains about "Canon police". He does this to shore up his self-esteem about his switch to a Sony body.
Then the well-meaning but almost as single-minded guy who actually makes and posts good photographs chips in to make sure that everybody knows how happy he is too.
Are there any Canon or Nikon posters making as many similarly redundant unnecessary posts in the Sony forum?Interesting how defensive you and others in this forum get for every bit of criticism regarding Canon as if it is personal. BTW, I didn't switch to a Sony body, I added it to my still existing Canon gear. I see the benefit of having different gear/brands working side-by-side and get benefits of using all of them. Maybe you should try a Sony A7 series camera yourself - you and most others who are so defensive in regard to Canon gear never even tried the competitive sensor and fully lack the experience and benefit which the other sensor brings (In fact I was suprised myself about this when I first got the A7R since I didn't think that DR was so important earlier either - but comparing it with the 5D MkII was eye-opening).I worked side by side with a photographer who shot with two D800's. He was working for me as a 2nd photographer. We shot some of the same scenes at the same time. When I got his files, I was prepared to see this amazing DR that some people have been trumpeting about on Canon forums. I was prepared to have this "eye-opening" experience. Instead, DR made absolutely no difference as I reviewed the photos. They looked no better and no worse than my Canon images (although I prefer Canon color). The photos worked or didn't based on so many other factors. DR was a trivial detail, not even worth noting. So making "system comparisons" based on an analysis of DR is just silly, IMO. DR does not a system make....Show more →
Well that's very obvious that the scene photos you were shooting were NOT stretching the dynamic range so either camera would produce the same results. It's only when the dynamic range of a scene exceeds the Canon sensor that you see the real beauty of the Sony sensor. Now if you don't shoot under conditions that stretch the dynamic range of your gear...then you surely don't need the extra abilities offered by the Sony sensor...but just because you might not stretch the limits of your Canon sensors does not mean others don't. Really depends on what you shoot.
It's like me shooting a 6d side by side with my A7R and saying I don't see what the big whoop is about the high ISO image quality of the 6d...when I'm shooting landscapes off a tripod at base ISO.
p.6 #2Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote: ggreene wroteI've yet to actually talk to a photographer that wants to discuss gear. All the ones I talk to and listen to talk about hotels/motels, travel cost/inconvenience, good places to eat, and aches and pains. I've yet to have one come up to me and say (even on a sunny noon game), I wish I had more low ISO DR. In my experience most photographers will be interested in talking about gear — it just isn't the first or main thing, and they usually are pretty bored by folks who make that an obsession.
On the other hand, if you ever want to unimpress working photographers, when you meet them for the first time be sure to ask them what gear they use. Even worse, be sure to tell them why their choice is wrong! ;-)
Dan
This is a curious discussion to have on a gear forum. I'm reminded of a certain Groucho Marx quote
p.6 #3Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
StillFingerz wrote: chez wrotezlatko wrotesnapsy wrotezlatko wrotechez wroteFirstly, many people that shoot with a Sony also own and shoot with Canon so I ( we) have interest in what and where Canon is heading. And yes the lack of DR is brought up time and again as there has been very little progress on this front by Canon and with each new camera released there is anticipation a new sensor technology will be released.
The only reason you are getting upset by all this talk about Canon's DR is because you are taking it personally. The work done in this post was to measure the DR improvements for Canon's latest cameras. I think most here would like to know how much if any improvements have occurred.
I don't see any pointing fingers or putting sticks into people's eyes...just good solid information on the latest Sensor. Now if these tests showed a great improvement in DR, would we even be having this discussion?Then no one will mind if I go on Sony / Nikon forums every day and post "good solid information" about the lenses their systems lack, or their lack of radio flashes, or their ergonomic deficiencies ... along with hints that they can solve these problems by switching to Canon.Which forum should someone go to when they want advice on how the Canon system compares to Nikon's or Sony's?We get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?I've been using my electronic viewfinder and I feel it is much better than any optical finder. You get exactly how your image will look using the EFV...no need to chimp anymore. In fact, I have the rear LCD turned off now. With focus peeking and zebra striping...electric view finders will quickly obsolete optical view finders.
Have you actually used a good electric view finder to it's fullest abilities. See to go and comment on the other boards, you should at least be familiar with what you are commenting on or you might just look ignorant there.
At least most people who compare the different sensors here actually have experience with the Canon sensors so they can speak from experience, which in my books is always welcome.Chez, I'm on-board with the EVF for certain subject matter, most non-action photography, the extra info and exact sensor image are a huge bonus. For action, most moving subjects there is still a good deal of work to be accomplished with mirrorless AF systems but I've no doubt that will change in the next decade; perhaps less.
As mentioned, there are only a few issues that keep me from augmenting my Canon kit with a Sony a7 of some sort. I normally carry two bodies for convenience, what brand of body isn't a disqualifier as long as it can manage my Canon glass.
So SONY, slim up your wired remote, add a touch screen; articulated if possible, to your a7 designs and I'm a buyer that will spread the word that you are a disabled friendly company ...Show more →
Jerry, I'm like you. I travel with a couple of bodies, my A7R and 5d2. I'm in New Mexico right now touring around taking in all the scenery and have mainly used my A7R as it provides better images for me than my 5d2. Being able to use Canon mount glass with both cameras is a huge bonus.
I hope you can find a workable solution for your remotes. I think you would really enjoy using the Sony cameras...I sure have, and the results from the cameras are worth any inconveniences they might have.
p.6 #4Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Well, I may still get one of these because it has the same reach as the 7DII and the wildlife I do doesn't need huge FPS. But this makes it easier to stick with my A7R and adapted lenses. In fact, I may trade out my Canon 16-35 for the Sony version now.
p.6 #5Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
snapsy wrote: gdanmitchell wroteggreene wroteI've yet to actually talk to a photographer that wants to discuss gear. All the ones I talk to and listen to talk about hotels/motels, travel cost/inconvenience, good places to eat, and aches and pains. I've yet to have one come up to me and say (even on a sunny noon game), I wish I had more low ISO DR. In my experience most photographers will be interested in talking about gear — it just isn't the first or main thing, and they usually are pretty bored by folks who make that an obsession.
On the other hand, if you ever want to unimpress working photographers, when you meet them for the first time be sure to ask them what gear they use. Even worse, be sure to tell them why their choice is wrong! ;-)
DanThis is a curious discussion to have on a gear forum. I'm reminded of a certain Groucho Marx quote
And it does seem to me that ways in which serious photographers regard gear discussions and the place of such discussions within photography is directly relevant to gear discussions here, especially when it comes to considering the focus of such discussions.
p.6 #6Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote: zlatko wroteI worked side by side with a photographer who shot with two D800's. He was working for me as a 2nd photographer. We shot some of the same scenes at the same time. When I got his files, I was prepared to see this amazing DR that some people have been trumpeting about on Canon forums. I was prepared to have this "eye-opening" experience. Instead, DR made absolutely no difference as I reviewed the photos. They looked no better and no worse than my Canon images (although I prefer Canon color). The photos worked or didn't based on so many other factors. DR was a trivial detail, not even worth noting. So making "system comparisons" based on an analysis of DR is just silly, IMO. DR does not a system make.I work side-by-side with people shooting everything including Sony A6000 and A7r, Nikon D800e and D810, Mamiya 645 with 80MP Phase One Backs, Olympus 4/3s cameras, various Canon cameras, large format film, medium format film, the giant Seitz camera, and more.
A number of us get together regularly to review our print work. All we see are beautiful photographs, and while the question of what gear was used comes up, it isn't because we see that Gear A universally produces better photographs than Gear B. We're interested in what was used, but it is usually fairly irrelevant to how we respond to their work. Among some very fine photographers in this group, there are folks who have great reasons for choosing to use any of this gear, and we all simply recognize that, understand the differences, and move on.
I'm fine with whatever choices anyone wants to make — obviously, since I use more than one brand myself — but the insistence that the gear used by others is substandard or poor or falling behind or whatever else it is gets old after we've heard it ad nauseam. I understand that it is a characteristic of gear forums for some to become downright religious (one right answer, will buttonhole anyone to tell them about the right answer, those who don't believe are ignorant or worse) about gear stuff. So be it.
There are differences between different brands and models of equipment. Different people will feel differently about the importance of those differences. Sometimes Brand A tests better than Brand B on parameter X, and sometimes Brand C tests better than Brand D on parameter Y. It matters. A little bit. Maybe. To you.
But what possible value is there in doing the equivalent of driving your Chevy into a Ford dealership to help those poor ignorant Ford buyers understand that your Chevy is miles better than their Ford (or vice versa)? Repeatedly. Daily. Or when any other topic comes up (tires, the best driving routes, what stations to listen to in the car, the weather, best place to eat in Utah...), driving the topic right back to how great your Chevy is and how often their Fords are?
The difference Dan is that many of us own both a Ford and Chevy and like to discuss the pro's and cons of each. If I'm discussing the merits or shortcomings of a Canon camera...I'll do that on the Canon forum. Sometimes when discussing these merits and/or shortcomings, they need to be compared against other cameras. Not really a novel concept at all. What is more disturbing is people interjecting their opinions on these conversations by trying to squash the conversation if they don't agree with the discussions. I truly don't understand people that seem to have no interest on the subject having a need to come into the conversation and basically belittle the people trying to converse. Maybe that tells me a lot of the characters of some.
p.6 #7Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Schlotkins wrote:
Well, I may still get one of these because it has the same reach as the 7DII and the wildlife I do doesn't need huge FPS. But this makes it easier to stick with my A7R and adapted lenses. In fact, I may trade out my Canon 16-35 for the Sony version now.
I've been using the A7R with the Sony 16-35 during my New Mexico trip. Real joy to use. I have a wrist strap and that combination can be carried all day without any issues. This I could not do with my other full frame cameras as the weight and in fact bulk was too much.
Don't know the quality of the 16-35....will have to wait until I get home and process the images.
p.6 #8Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote: snapsy wrotegdanmitchell wroteggreene wroteI've yet to actually talk to a photographer that wants to discuss gear. All the ones I talk to and listen to talk about hotels/motels, travel cost/inconvenience, good places to eat, and aches and pains. I've yet to have one come up to me and say (even on a sunny noon game), I wish I had more low ISO DR. In my experience most photographers will be interested in talking about gear — it just isn't the first or main thing, and they usually are pretty bored by folks who make that an obsession.
On the other hand, if you ever want to unimpress working photographers, when you meet them for the first time be sure to ask them what gear they use. Even worse, be sure to tell them why their choice is wrong! ;-)
DanThis is a curious discussion to have on a gear forum. I'm reminded of a certain Groucho Marx quote Funny...
And it does seem to me that ways in which serious photographers regard gear discussions and the place of such discussions within photography is directly relevant to gear discussions here, especially when it comes to considering the focus of such discussions.
Which reminds me of another famous quote ... I'm shocked, shocked to find that gambling is going on in here!
p.6 #9Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote: retrofocus wroteMonito wrotezlatko wroteWe get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?What happens is that the insecure guy who predicted Canon's demise posts about how great Sony DR is (for his work) and complains about "Canon police". He does this to shore up his self-esteem about his switch to a Sony body.
Then the well-meaning but almost as single-minded guy who actually makes and posts good photographs chips in to make sure that everybody knows how happy he is too.
Are there any Canon or Nikon posters making as many similarly redundant unnecessary posts in the Sony forum?Interesting how defensive you and others in this forum get for every bit of criticism regarding Canon as if it is personal. BTW, I didn't switch to a Sony body, I added it to my still existing Canon gear. I see the benefit of having different gear/brands working side-by-side and get benefits of using all of them. Maybe you should try a Sony A7 series camera yourself - you and most others who are so defensive in regard to Canon gear never even tried the competitive sensor and fully lack the experience and benefit which the other sensor brings (In fact I was suprised myself about this when I first got the A7R since I didn't think that DR was so important earlier either - but comparing it with the 5D MkII was eye-opening).I worked side by side with a photographer who shot with two D800's. He was working for me as a 2nd photographer. We shot some of the same scenes at the same time. When I got his files, I was prepared to see this amazing DR that some people have been trumpeting about on Canon forums. I was prepared to have this "eye-opening" experience. Instead, DR made absolutely no difference as I reviewed the photos. They looked no better and no worse than my Canon images (although I prefer Canon color). The photos worked or didn't based on so many other factors. DR was a trivial detail, not even worth noting. So making "system comparisons" based on an analysis of DR is just silly, IMO. DR does not a system make....Show more →
I agree with your first part of your response - it is absolutely valid that you didn't see any of the DR advantages if the scene did not permit. I also agree that there is a color difference between both sensors - it is a personal matter of taste which one is preferred (there is no right or wrong). I like the Sony Exmor colors better, but I sometimes have to desaturate the green channel in some of my photos taken with the A7R a bit, too.
The last two sentences are unfortunately personally biased - if you don't see or need DR, it does not make DR "silly". Your photography style simply doesn't need more or better DR. What is sufficient for you, might not be sufficient to others.
You might feel more the need to have fast AF and fps - things I can live without. For you this might make a system, for me it is mainly the sensor performance and increased DR. Neither opinion is stupid - we simply prefer different camera systems.
Other than this, I am still convinced this whole discussion here wouldn't happen if Canon had a really competitive sensor and not just a 0.5 micrometer process generation based 7D MkII upscaled FF sensor on testosterone (even we don't know yet for sure its specs, see my earlier posts, we need to wait for a 1:1 comparison).
p.6 #10Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote: zlatko wroteI worked side by side with a photographer who shot with two D800's. He was working for me as a 2nd photographer. We shot some of the same scenes at the same time. When I got his files, I was prepared to see this amazing DR that some people have been trumpeting about on Canon forums. I was prepared to have this "eye-opening" experience. Instead, DR made absolutely no difference as I reviewed the photos. They looked no better and no worse than my Canon images (although I prefer Canon color). The photos worked or didn't based on so many other factors. DR was a trivial detail, not even worth noting. So making "system comparisons" based on an analysis of DR is just silly, IMO. DR does not a system make.I work side-by-side with people shooting everything including Sony A6000 and A7r, Nikon D800e and D810, Mamiya 645 with 80MP Phase One Backs, Olympus 4/3s cameras, various Canon cameras, large format film, medium format film, the giant Seitz camera, and more.
A number of us get together regularly to review our print work. All we see are beautiful photographs, and while the question of what gear was used comes up, it isn't because we see that Gear A universally produces better photographs than Gear B. We're interested in what was used, but it is usually fairly irrelevant to how we respond to their work. Among some very fine photographers in this group, there are folks who have great reasons for choosing to use any of this gear, and we all simply recognize that, understand the differences, and move on.
I'm fine with whatever choices anyone wants to make — obviously, since I use more than one brand myself — but the insistence that the gear used by others is substandard or poor or falling behind or whatever else it is gets old after we've heard it ad nauseam. I understand that it is a characteristic of gear forums for some to become downright religious (one right answer, will buttonhole anyone to tell them about the right answer, those who don't believe are ignorant or worse) about gear stuff. So be it.
There are differences between different brands and models of equipment. Different people will feel differently about the importance of those differences. Sometimes Brand A tests better than Brand B on parameter X, and sometimes Brand C tests better than Brand D on parameter Y. It matters. A little bit. Maybe. To you.
But what possible value is there in doing the equivalent of driving your Chevy into a Ford dealership to help those poor ignorant Ford buyers understand that your Chevy is miles better than their Ford (or vice versa)? Repeatedly. Daily. Or when any other topic comes up (tires, the best driving routes, what stations to listen to in the car, the weather, best place to eat in Utah...), driving the topic right back to how great your Chevy is and how often their Fords are?
I agree that nowadays digital cameras are all so good that each of those takes excellent photos. But I disagree that differences between camera systems are always marginal or based only on subjective feelings. That's simply not true. You don't see this if you didn't test yourself a different camera system from another brand. Hell, you might be surprised (positively or negatively). In fact more and more camera systems differ from each other now than just 5 years ago. That's for example why Sony went first the diversification route with the A7/A7R/A7S - each of them is made for a different group of users. Canon does the same now with the 5Ds/5DsR and maybe a 5D MKIV. One reason is that one sensor can't be good for everything - one might give you high resolution with best low ISO performance and DR, another one low resolution but excellent high ISO performance, another one an average resolution, unimproved DR, but high fps. Very different cameras and suited for different styles of shooting or shooting situations.
It is possible that we will see a sensor which has a super high resolution, super wide DR, low/high ISO coverage with image processors workflow fast enough to allow fast fps. But we are not there yet. Until then, sensors will improve, process generations will get smaller, we will see other sensor designs if physical limits are reached. So comparisons between sensors are absolutely valid since it will show the progress a company(ies) made with image improvement.
p.6 #11Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote:
Other than this, I am still convinced this whole discussion here wouldn't happen if Canon had a really competitive sensor and not just a 0.5 micrometer process generation based 7D MkII upscaled FF sensor on testosterone (even we don't know yet for sure its specs, see my earlier posts, we need to wait for a 1:1 comparison).
But have we seen any evidence that Canon actually _cares_ to develop their sensor any farther in this respect? In the same way that Sony is obviously still pursuing?
It has been how long already? Is it not clear that if Canon cares, they would have at least put some effort into it and actually done something by now? Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't believe that this performance point has improved in any substantive way since the 5d2 was released in late year 2008.
My point is just that, if this performance point is fundamentally necessary to your photography, the only reasonable course of action is to abandon Canon, even after having stuck with them for these last several years. And in retrospect, the better choice several years ago would have also been to abandon them (though there is no way one could have known that at that point in the past).
If we're on the topic of gambling, this is akin to the Gambler's Dilemma, the Gambler who has already lost a sum of money at a table and hence feels compelled to stick around and keep playing in the hopes that he can win it all back. But in reality, the odds are still stacked against him, just as much as when he first started playing. He's thinking with his ego, he's rationalizing his choices (that didn't turn out so well), and b'cos he never wants to admit he made the wrong choice, he sticks with the same self-defeating course of action.
Granted in this case we are only dealing with time, not money; but time spent with Canon is time that could be spent with another system that has the performance point that is so valued by some, and with a company that actually _cares_ to improve on such. I this is really important to you, the most reasonable course of action is to switch, and sooner is better than later. Or you can continue to hold onto false hope, but where has that gotten you over the past seven plus years!
p.6 #12Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
I didn't expected this crude debate on this topic... well, at least it seems that is a interesting topic, isn't it?. With the Canon words, we all expected not a huge improvement in DR, but still were expectant about a little tech improvement. The final improvement in DR is next to zero, and that won't change in the final product or with proper converters (the data was a bit difficult to be obtained, but do is correct, otherwise it there would have been math contradictions).
This fact doesn't invalidates the camera: the 5DS may have improved in other interesting parameters like color reproduction, or the shadows noise quality as in recent developments. Good engineering even better (shutter improvements). And it has 50 theoretical MP, in reality maybe half of that, which may seem too much for printing in pocketable sizes, but not for the 7680x4320 monitor or TV we'll have in our desk or wall more sooner than later. We'll definitely see a difference on such monitor between a 20 or a 50 MP sensor (prints are a thing of the past: a waste of paper, room and with limited DR! )
About my words I don't find "boring" as an insult... I think that it is simple what many feel. Yes, 11-stop DR is enough for many situations (for example with good lighting, just from were the best photos come out) but current technology allows better results. If we are conformist, manufacturers will have little incentive to improve, specially those with strengths, as Canon.
For example, how many years has needed Canon to get right the auto-ISO, only properly implemented for first time in the 1DX thanks to a firmware patch?. At first, only small industry players got it right. Nikon and Canon have needed more time and a lot of moaning. Another example: in the past, we checked the focus in the field using image reviews magnifying small thumbnails (while phones manufactured at the same date properly showed the pictures at 100%!). Still, nowadays (about 15 years after the first digital cameras) we don't have a good clue of how a photo is exposed after taking it. Histograms are related to poorly processed jpegs even when shooting RAW (fortunately, in Canon we have firmware hacks like Magic Lantern). Is it so difficult to show a RAW-data-related blinking alert overlayed on the human-readable reference jpeg when the user shoots raw only?. ML guys have managed it!. In fact, if ML doesn't runs in the 5DS (and maybe won't due to its lesser video features) I'll have little incentive to upgrade. I can't live without the ML highlights alert, specially in a gear desperately requiring a right exposure.
Still I think that manufacturers have improved a lot, including the ones with higher sales, and I think that is partly because we moan. Canon publicly acknowledged they patched the 1DX because some pros moaned about the lack of exposure compensation in manual mode with auto ISO (while some conformist forum members previously tried to ridiculize another forum members for asking that, referring them to the dictionary definition of exposure).
About DR we started moaning in the forums, then magazines reporting totally wrong DR measures have improved their analysis and joined us (see dpreview's 7D2 review with dedicated lab reports: about 10% of the rewiew is dedicated to show the 7D2 shortcomings in latitude and real world DR compared to Nikon D7000; even in their interviews with Canon managers they use the opportunity to ask about this subject).
In summary, despite somebody may not like it, we are entitled to analyze the gear (including beta products, which usually only change in firmware features or the jpeg IQ) and we are entitled to request our respective manufacturers of choice the missing features already provided by the competitors, which seems reasonably fair.
p.6 #13Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote: zlatko wroteretrofocus wroteMonito wrotezlatko wroteWe get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?What happens is that the insecure guy who predicted Canon's demise posts about how great Sony DR is (for his work) and complains about "Canon police". He does this to shore up his self-esteem about his switch to a Sony body.
Then the well-meaning but almost as single-minded guy who actually makes and posts good photographs chips in to make sure that everybody knows how happy he is too.
Are there any Canon or Nikon posters making as many similarly redundant unnecessary posts in the Sony forum?Interesting how defensive you and others in this forum get for every bit of criticism regarding Canon as if it is personal. BTW, I didn't switch to a Sony body, I added it to my still existing Canon gear. I see the benefit of having different gear/brands working side-by-side and get benefits of using all of them. Maybe you should try a Sony A7 series camera yourself - you and most others who are so defensive in regard to Canon gear never even tried the competitive sensor and fully lack the experience and benefit which the other sensor brings (In fact I was suprised myself about this when I first got the A7R since I didn't think that DR was so important earlier either - but comparing it with the 5D MkII was eye-opening).I worked side by side with a photographer who shot with two D800's. He was working for me as a 2nd photographer. We shot some of the same scenes at the same time. When I got his files, I was prepared to see this amazing DR that some people have been trumpeting about on Canon forums. I was prepared to have this "eye-opening" experience. Instead, DR made absolutely no difference as I reviewed the photos. They looked no better and no worse than my Canon images (although I prefer Canon color). The photos worked or didn't based on so many other factors. DR was a trivial detail, not even worth noting. So making "system comparisons" based on an analysis of DR is just silly, IMO. DR does not a system make.I agree with your first part of your response - it is absolutely valid that you didn't see any of the DR advantages if the scene did not permit. I also agree that there is a color difference between both sensors - it is a personal matter of taste which one is preferred (there is no right or wrong). I like the Sony Exmor colors better, but I sometimes have to desaturate the green channel in some of my photos taken with the A7R a bit, too.
The last two sentences are unfortunately personally biased - if you don't see or need DR, it does not make DR "silly". Your photography style simply doesn't need more or better DR. What is sufficient for you, might not be sufficient to others.
You might feel more the need to have fast AF and fps - things I can live without. For you this might make a system, for me it is mainly the sensor performance and increased DR. Neither opinion is stupid - we simply prefer different camera systems.
Other than this, I am still convinced this whole discussion here wouldn't happen if Canon had a really competitive sensor and not just a 0.5 micrometer process generation based 7D MkII upscaled FF sensor on testosterone (even we don't know yet for sure its specs, see my earlier posts, we need to wait for a 1:1 comparison). ...Show more →
The scenes photographed were diverse: wedding, white wedding dress, black tuxedo, dark church, bright sun, people walking on bright sunny beach, etc., etc. DR advantages of the famed Nikon with the mighty Sony sensor: none to speak of or even notice. DR is not even a factor as you evaluate the photos. There are too many other things that matter to a photo's success or failure. DR wouldn't even be on the checklist because both Canon and Nikon deliver enough DR.
I didn't write that DR is "silly" or that any opinion is "stupid". I wrote that making ***system comparisons*** based on analysis of DR is silly. That's because a system comparison involves a lot more than just DR at low ISO. DR is one small part of a system. And a little extra low ISO DR is one small part of that small part. You can't reduce a whole system to that small part.
Canon does make a competitive sensor for the vast majority of photography, including photography done by some of the world's best photographers — photographers who could choose any system / any sensor. To judge whether Canon sensors are "really competitive", all you have to do is look at the pictures. When someone talks about some factory-specific detail like a "0.5 micrometer process", I sense a preoccupation with engineering issues. All I have to do is look at pictures to know that Canon sensors are competitive. When I look at pictures, my typical impression is of sensors that do the job splendidly.
p.6 #14Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Access wrote: retrofocus wroteOther than this, I am still convinced this whole discussion here wouldn't happen if Canon had a really competitive sensor and not just a 0.5 micrometer process generation based 7D MkII upscaled FF sensor on testosterone (even we don't know yet for sure its specs, see my earlier posts, we need to wait for a 1:1 comparison).But have we seen any evidence that Canon actually _cares_ to develop their sensor any farther in this respect? In the same way that Sony is obviously still pursuing?
It has been how long already? Is it not clear that if Canon cares, they would have at least put some effort into it and actually done something by now? Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't believe that this performance point has improved in any substantive way since the 5d2 was released in late year 2008.
My point is just that, if this performance point is fundamentally necessary to your photography, the only reasonable course of action is to abandon Canon, even after having stuck with them for these last several years. And in retrospect, the better choice several years ago would have also been to abandon them (though there is no way one could have known that at that point in the past).
If we're on the topic of gambling, this is akin to the Gambler's Dilemma, the Gambler who has already lost a sum of money at a table and hence feels compelled to stick around and keep playing in the hopes that he can win it all back. But in reality, the odds are still stacked against him, just as much as when he first started playing. He's thinking with his ego, he's rationalizing his choices (that didn't turn out so well), and b'cos he never wants to admit he made the wrong choice, he sticks with the same self-defeating course of action.
Granted in this case we are only dealing with time, not money; but time spent with Canon is time that could be spent with another system that has the performance point that is so valued by some. So if it's really that important to oneself, the proper thing to do is to switch, and sooner is better than later. At least, until we see some actual evidence that Canon actually cares about this performance point. I mean, Sony clearly does....Show more →
I agree with you - I have no better answer than you what Canon's real strategy here is. Did they give up to compete with Sony? We don't know. I don't think so, at least Canon recognized the need for higher resolution sensors finally. They did at least something.
I also agree that looking outside of Canon makes fully sense if Canon simply doesn't satisfy my own needs. That's exactly what I did last year - adding the A7R to my gear. And I might sell soime of my more redundant Canon lenses at some point also. Others I will keep because I won't get the performance with any other lens system (TSE, MPE lenses for example). Likely I will move to smaller sized lenses which faciliatete weight&travel - I started building up a nice rangefinder lens collection which I am using currently in parallel to my (D)SLR lenses.
I don't think there is a "wrong" choice made, the market simply changes, and I adopt and choose what fits best to me if I have an option. I am zero brand-addicted - if Fuji will make suddenly a great mirrorless FF camera, I will also look into this option, why not? Same with Canon - if they make a product which fits best my needs, I will look into it.
I think Canon cares, but their focus was different than Sony's focus so far. Now it looks like Sony is focusing on groups which Canon was focusing on , and Canon finally recognizes groups they deserted since 2012.... I think in the end it is all good for the user since prices need to be competitive and several good options are out there in general.
p.6 #15Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote: retrofocus wrotezlatko wroteretrofocus wroteMonito wrotezlatko wroteWe get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?What happens is that the insecure guy who predicted Canon's demise posts about how great Sony DR is (for his work) and complains about "Canon police". He does this to shore up his self-esteem about his switch to a Sony body.
Then the well-meaning but almost as single-minded guy who actually makes and posts good photographs chips in to make sure that everybody knows how happy he is too.
Are there any Canon or Nikon posters making as many similarly redundant unnecessary posts in the Sony forum?Interesting how defensive you and others in this forum get for every bit of criticism regarding Canon as if it is personal. BTW, I didn't switch to a Sony body, I added it to my still existing Canon gear. I see the benefit of having different gear/brands working side-by-side and get benefits of using all of them. Maybe you should try a Sony A7 series camera yourself - you and most others who are so defensive in regard to Canon gear never even tried the competitive sensor and fully lack the experience and benefit which the other sensor brings (In fact I was suprised myself about this when I first got the A7R since I didn't think that DR was so important earlier either - but comparing it with the 5D MkII was eye-opening).I worked side by side with a photographer who shot with two D800's. He was working for me as a 2nd photographer. We shot some of the same scenes at the same time. When I got his files, I was prepared to see this amazing DR that some people have been trumpeting about on Canon forums. I was prepared to have this "eye-opening" experience. Instead, DR made absolutely no difference as I reviewed the photos. They looked no better and no worse than my Canon images (although I prefer Canon color). The photos worked or didn't based on so many other factors. DR was a trivial detail, not even worth noting. So making "system comparisons" based on an analysis of DR is just silly, IMO. DR does not a system make.I agree with your first part of your response - it is absolutely valid that you didn't see any of the DR advantages if the scene did not permit. I also agree that there is a color difference between both sensors - it is a personal matter of taste which one is preferred (there is no right or wrong). I like the Sony Exmor colors better, but I sometimes have to desaturate the green channel in some of my photos taken with the A7R a bit, too.
The last two sentences are unfortunately personally biased - if you don't see or need DR, it does not make DR "silly". Your photography style simply doesn't need more or better DR. What is sufficient for you, might not be sufficient to others.
You might feel more the need to have fast AF and fps - things I can live without. For you this might make a system, for me it is mainly the sensor performance and increased DR. Neither opinion is stupid - we simply prefer different camera systems.
Other than this, I am still convinced this whole discussion here wouldn't happen if Canon had a really competitive sensor and not just a 0.5 micrometer process generation based 7D MkII upscaled FF sensor on testosterone (even we don't know yet for sure its specs, see my earlier posts, we need to wait for a 1:1 comparison).The scenes photographed were diverse: wedding, white wedding dress, black tuxedo, dark church, bright sun, people walking on bright sunny beach, etc., etc. DR advantages of the famed Nikon with the mighty Sony sensor: none to speak of or even notice. DR is not even a factor as you evaluate the photos. There are too many other things that matter to a photo's success or failure. DR wouldn't even be on the checklist because both Canon and Nikon deliver enough DR.
I didn't write that DR is "silly" or that any opinion is "stupid". I wrote that making ***system comparisons*** based on analysis of DR is silly. That's because a system comparison involves a lot more than just DR at low ISO. DR is one small part of a system. And a little extra low ISO DR is one small part of that small part. You can't reduce a whole system to that small part.
Canon does make a competitive sensor for the vast majority of photography, including photography done by some of the world's best photographers — photographers who could choose any system / any sensor. To judge whether Canon sensors are "really competitive", all you have to do is look at the pictures. When someone talks about some factory-specific detail like a "0.5 micrometer process", I sense a preoccupation with engineering issues. All I have to do is look at pictures to know that Canon sensors are competitive. When I look at pictures, my typical impression is of sensors that do the job splendidly....Show more →
Again - what works for you does not mean it works for others. I am still using my 5D MkII cameras, mostly for infrared. But I see the DR difference in the same photos taken with my 5D MKII and my A7R every time! We simply don't agree here. I am still using both systems - because the 5D MkII is still better for flash photography with my speedlites and for some micro photography purposes with the Canon EOS Utility program (the Sony software sucks in this regard!). But the A7R is better in the overall image quality, color reproduction (subjective, I know), and DR. Also smaller and less bulky, adaptable to a variety of lenses which I prefer.
The technical detail regarding the process generation shows simply the physical limitation of a sensor. It is quite an investment for a smaller process-based sensor generation like 0.18 micrometer with Sony sensors. This later makes a big impact.
p.6 #16Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Zlatko, let's take this example, do you think a general "power user" should buy a computer based purely on a photoshop performance benchmark? Surely not, for a general user, it makes little sense, it makes more sense to buy a computer based on a larger set of benchmarks that are more representative of general use.
On the other hand, a working photographer who plans to use a computer for photoshop 90% of the time would be more than in the right to select his computer based purely on such a benchmark, provided the others that mattered were at least somewhat passable.
p.6 #17Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Its pretty obvious that Canon is not competing against Sony's sensor at this point with the DR performance of the 7DII and the upcoming 5Ds/r, so why do we keep bringing this subject up? I don't even think it was possible to beat this horse to the ground, but you DRones are finding ways to interject this tired and old argument into everything canon related so far. I guess it's a slow day in the Sony subforum
p.6 #18Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
cgarcia wrote:
I didn't expected this crude debate on this topic...
Perhaps it's a native language difference but when you start a post with "It seems that the 5DS has yet another boring Canon sensor with, again, the same boring 11 f-stop DR at pixel level on base ISO" about a much-anticipated (and expensive) new camera on a forum visited by Canon users it doesn't do much to frame a healthy technical discussion. I'm all for a good discussion but in the future I think you'll find a more receptive audience if you forgo the colorful commentary.
p.6 #19Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Yes. It is a wonder that anyone can make photographs at all given the horrendous and dire circumstances you describe. ;-)
cgarcia wrote:
I didn't expected this crude debate on this topic... well, at least it seems that is a interesting topic, isn't it?. With the Canon words, we all expected not a huge improvement in DR, but still were expectant about a little tech improvement. The final improvement in DR is next to zero, and that won't change in the final product or with proper converters (the data was a bit difficult to be obtained, but do is correct, otherwise it there would have been math contradictions).
This fact doesn't invalidates the camera: the 5DS may have improved in other interesting parameters like color reproduction, or the shadows noise quality as in recent developments. Good engineering even better (shutter improvements). And it has 50 theoretical MP, in reality maybe half of that, which may seem too much for printing in pocketable sizes, but not for the 7680x4320 monitor or TV we'll have in our desk or wall more sooner than later. We'll definitely see a difference on such monitor between a 20 or a 50 MP sensor (prints are a thing of the past: a waste of paper, room and with limited DR! )
About my words I don't find "boring" as an insult... I think that it is simple what many feel. Yes, 11-stop DR is enough for many situations (for example with good lighting, just from were the best photos come out) but current technology allows better results. If we are conformist, manufacturers will have little incentive to improve, specially those with strengths, as Canon.
For example, how many years has needed Canon to get right the auto-ISO, only properly implemented for first time in the 1DX thanks to a firmware patch?. At first, only small industry players got it right. Nikon and Canon have needed more time and a lot of moaning. Another example: in the past, we checked the focus in the field using image reviews magnifying small thumbnails (while phones manufactured at the same date properly showed the pictures at 100%!). Still, nowadays (about 15 years after the first digital cameras) we don't have a good clue of how a photo is exposed after taking it. Histograms are related to poorly processed jpegs even when shooting RAW (fortunately, in Canon we have firmware hacks like Magic Lantern). Is it so difficult to show a RAW-data-related blinking alert overlayed on the human-readable reference jpeg when the user shoots raw only?. ML guys have managed it!. In fact, if ML doesn't runs in the 5DS (and maybe won't due to its lesser video features) I'll have little incentive to upgrade. I can't live without the ML highlights alert, specially in a gear desperately requiring a right exposure.
Still I think that manufacturers have improved a lot, including the ones with higher sales, and I think that is partly because we moan. Canon publicly acknowledged they patched the 1DX because some pros moaned about the lack of exposure compensation in manual mode with auto ISO (while some conformist forum members previously tried to ridiculize another forum members for asking that, referring them to the dictionary definition of exposure).
About DR we started moaning in the forums, then magazines reporting totally wrong DR measures have improved their analysis and joined us (see dpreview's 7D2 review with dedicated lab reports: about 10% of the rewiew is dedicated to show the 7D2 shortcomings in latitude and real world DR compared to Nikon D7000; even in their interviews with Canon managers they use the opportunity to ask about this subject).
In summary, despite somebody may not like it, we are entitled to analyze the gear (including beta products, which usually only change in firmware features or the jpeg IQ) and we are entitled to request our respective manufacturers of choice the missing features already provided by the competitors, which seems reasonably fair. ...Show more →
p.6 #20Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
panicatnabisco wrote:
Its pretty obvious that Canon is not competing against Sony's sensor at this point with the DR performance of the 7DII and the upcoming 5Ds/r, so why do we keep bringing this subject up? I don't even think it was possible to beat this horse to the ground, but you DRones are finding ways to interject this tired and old argument into everything canon related so far. I guess it's a slow day in the Sony subforum
This is not clear in fact. We have this post of some RAW image analysis which points to a non increase in DR supporting the information from Canon so far. But who knows - maybe Canon does a lat minute tweak (software based maybe, who knows!) to crank out a bit more DR, and maybe also Sony remains stagnant with their current DR. All too early to say. We need to wait for the clear 1:1 comparison between both new sensors or at least with the current Sony 36 MP sensor.
That you feel personally offended about sensor drawbacks with your favorite brand, this is simply your problem.