fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)

  
 
artd
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote:
But (or should I write "butt?") y'all will at least have something to moan about with the new camera. The sky is still falling!


Dan, as you replied to someone else's post in this thread, so I would reply to yours here:

No one wrote that. ;-)

No one claimed the sky is falling or the 5DS is a bad camera. You should well know that for some people, dynamic range is an important consideration of overall performance, and that while it may not make a difference for you, it will be a legitimate disappointment to some if Canon has not improved this area going on seven years now.

So, while it's fine that it may not matter to you, I don't think it's necessarily going to make these forum conversations go any better by suggesting that people who are disappointed by the lack of DR improvements are "moaning" or belittle their analysis by applying your traditional epithet of "forumtography."

Mar 23, 2015 at 11:10 AM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote:
snapsy wrote
zlatko wrote
snapsy wrote
zlatko wrote
chez wroteFirstly, many people that shoot with a Sony also own and shoot with Canon so I ( we) have interest in what and where Canon is heading. And yes the lack of DR is brought up time and again as there has been very little progress on this front by Canon and with each new camera released there is anticipation a new sensor technology will be released.

The only reason you are getting upset by all this talk about Canon's DR is because you are taking it personally. The work done in this post was to measure the DR improvements for Canon's latest cameras. I think most here would like to know how much if any improvements have occurred.

I don't see any pointing fingers or putting sticks into people's eyes...just good solid information on the latest Sensor. Now if these tests showed a great improvement in DR, would we even be having this discussion?
Then no one will mind if I go on Sony / Nikon forums every day and post "good solid information" about the lenses their systems lack, or their lack of radio flashes, or their ergonomic deficiencies ... along with hints that they can solve these problems by switching to Canon.
Which forum should someone go to when they want advice on how the Canon system compares to Nikon's or Sony's?
We get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?
If you go onto the Sony forums you'll almost never read about DR. Instead what's often discussed is the lack of lens choices, poor ergonomics, artifacts from Sony's compression algorithm, etc. If you go onto the Canon forums you'll almost never read about lack of lens choices, poor ergonomics, or compression artifacts. In other words, you'll get objective reality about shortcomings in each respective forum. Only when the threads cross and both systems are discussed do you start seeing people reject, distort, or marginalize this reality. Which again brings up my question - where can both systems to be discussed and compared objectively?
If only we had discussions in which both systems were compared objectively. We don't. We have daily criticisms of Canon's DR ... "yet another boring Canon sensor with, again, the same boring 11 f-stop DR" says the OP. But it's only boring if the photographer is boring and can't make a decent photo with 11-stop DR. For some photographers, that is no doubt true. For others, it's not true at all — and the 5DS is quite exciting, sensor and all.

Which Sony / Nikon forum should I go on to expound about the virtues of Canon's flicker reduction system
...Show more →

I think you believe you're arguing against my point but you're actually arguing for it. Neither contingent should be discourage from discussing alternate systems on either board when discussing the relative advantages/disadvantages of both. That's not to say there isn't repetition or abuse - but that also occurs when discussing the brand on its brand-specific forum already. There is thread almost every weak on the Sony forum about compression artifacts or lack of lenses or some complaint about ergonomics - and those threads usually contain references to Canon/Nikon cameras that don't have those issues.
Mar 23, 2015 at 11:11 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote:
If only we had discussions in which both systems were compared objectively. We don't. We have daily criticisms of Canon's DR ... "yet another boring Canon sensor with, again, the same boring 11 f-stop DR" says the OP. But it's only boring if the photographer is boring and can't make a decent photo with 11-stop DR. For some photographers, that is no doubt true. For others, it's not true at all — and the 5DS is quite exciting, sensor and all.



I get a different impression of the discussions going on. Systems are being compared all the time. Different aspects of sensor technology, focus problems and ergonomics altogether. I don't mind threads starting out of a single analysis or a single data point.
Mar 23, 2015 at 11:19 AM
StillFingerz
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Monito wrote:
Beni wroteIn the studio I often use the Nikon MC-30A release in my teeth for when I have my hands full, it's such a big button that it's far easier in general to use than any other release from my canon or sony cameras. In the mouth I press the button with my tounge. Bit yeuch perhaps to some but when you're shooting product or repro and have both hands full, it's very very useful.
A switch is a switch. Adapt it to a foot switch.


Monito, Beni wrote that reply to me, a disabled photographer that just happens to have a paralyzed body with paralysis starting at the neck, so a foot switch would not be doable in my case. Cheers
Mar 23, 2015 at 11:32 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Monito wrote:
zlatko wroteWe get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?
What happens is that the insecure guy who predicted Canon's demise posts about how great Sony DR is (for his work) and complains about "Canon police". He does this to shore up his self-esteem about his switch to a Sony body.

Then the well-meaning but almost as single-minded guy who actually makes and posts good photographs chips in to make sure that everybody knows how happy he is too.

Are there any Canon or Nikon posters making as many similarly redundant unnecessary posts in the Sony forum?


Interesting how defensive you and others in this forum get for every bit of criticism regarding Canon as if it is personal. BTW, I didn't switch to a Sony body, I added it to my still existing Canon gear. I see the benefit of having different gear/brands working side-by-side and get benefits of using all of them. Maybe you should try a Sony A7 series camera yourself - you and most others who are so defensive in regard to Canon gear never even tried the competitive sensor and fully lack the experience and benefit which the other sensor brings (In fact I was suprised myself about this when I first got the A7R since I didn't think that DR was so important earlier either - but comparing it with the 5D MkII was eye-opening).

Edited on Mar 23, 2015 at 11:36 AM · View previous versions
Mar 23, 2015 at 11:36 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote:
snapsy wrote
zlatko wrote
chez wrote
zlatko wrote
retrofocus wroteCanon police early in action . Trying to rule out every sort of criticism or cons. No surprises here.
Constant repetition of alleged DR deficiencies. What else is new? It would be the same as posting frequent reminders on Sony / Nikon forums of the various lenses their systems lack. Or droning on about their ergonomic deficiencies. How would they receive that information?
Firstly, many people that shoot with a Sony also own and shoot with Canon so I ( we) have interest in what and where Canon is heading. And yes the lack of DR is brought up time and again as there has been very little progress on this front by Canon and with each new camera released there is anticipation a new sensor technology will be released.

The only reason you are getting upset by all this talk about Canon's DR is because you are taking it personally. The work done in this post was to measure the DR improvements for Canon's latest cameras. I think most here would like to know how much if any improvements have occurred.

I don't see any pointing fingers or putting sticks into people's eyes...just good solid information on the latest Sensor. Now if these tests showed a great improvement in DR, would we even be having this discussion?
Then no one will mind if I go on Sony / Nikon forums every day and post "good solid information" about the lenses their systems lack, or their lack of radio flashes, or their ergonomic deficiencies ... along with hints that they can solve these problems by switching to Canon.
Which forum should someone go to when they want advice on how the Canon system compares to Nikon's or Sony's?
We get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?


I've been using my electronic viewfinder and I feel it is much better than any optical finder. You get exactly how your image will look using the EFV...no need to chimp anymore. In fact, I have the rear LCD turned off now. With focus peeking and zebra striping...electric view finders will quickly obsolete optical view finders.

Have you actually used a good electric view finder to it's fullest abilities. See to go and comment on the other boards, you should at least be familiar with what you are commenting on or you might just look ignorant there.

At least most people who compare the different sensors here actually have experience with the Canon sensors so they can speak from experience, which in my books is always welcome.
Mar 23, 2015 at 11:36 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
StillFingerz wrote:
Monito, Beni wrote that reply to me, a disabled photographer that just happens to have a paralyzed body with paralysis starting at the neck, so a foot switch would not be doable in my case. Cheers


Sorry. My error in reading. I did not take in the fact that he was addressing you. Your work and knowledge are an inspiration to all of us.
Mar 23, 2015 at 11:44 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
If someone posted analysis based on flawed software from images they admit are inadequate in a couple of ways for testing purposes, in the Sony forum, about an announced camera not yet released, I hope that the clearer-minded people there would point that out. It would not be "defensive" to do so, and it is not defensive when I do so here.
Mar 23, 2015 at 11:50 AM
zlatko
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote:
Monito wrote
zlatko wroteWe get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?
What happens is that the insecure guy who predicted Canon's demise posts about how great Sony DR is (for his work) and complains about "Canon police". He does this to shore up his self-esteem about his switch to a Sony body.

Then the well-meaning but almost as single-minded guy who actually makes and posts good photographs chips in to make sure that everybody knows how happy he is too.

Are there any Canon or Nikon posters making as many similarly redundant unnecessary posts in the Sony forum?
Interesting how defensive you and others in this forum get for every bit of criticism regarding Canon as if it is personal. BTW, I didn't switch to a Sony body, I added it to my still existing Canon gear. I see the benefit of having different gear/brands working side-by-side and get benefits of using all of them. Maybe you should try a Sony A7 series camera yourself - you and most others who are so defensive in regard to Canon gear never even tried the competitive sensor and fully lack the experience and benefit which the other sensor brings (In
...Show more →

I worked side by side with a photographer who shot with two D800's. He was working for me as a 2nd photographer. We shot some of the same scenes at the same time. When I got his files, I was prepared to see this amazing DR that some people have been trumpeting about on Canon forums. I was prepared to have this "eye-opening" experience. Instead, DR made absolutely no difference as I reviewed the photos. They looked no better and no worse than my Canon images (although I prefer Canon color). The photos worked or didn't based on so many other factors. DR was a trivial detail, not even worth noting. So making "system comparisons" based on an analysis of DR is just silly, IMO. DR does not a system make.
Mar 23, 2015 at 12:20 PM
StillFingerz
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote:
zlatko wrote
snapsy wrote
zlatko wrote
chez wrote
zlatko wroteConstant repetition of alleged DR deficiencies. What else is new? It would be the same as posting frequent reminders on Sony / Nikon forums of the various lenses their systems lack. Or droning on about their ergonomic deficiencies. How would they receive that information?
Firstly, many people that shoot with a Sony also own and shoot with Canon so I ( we) have interest in what and where Canon is heading. And yes the lack of DR is brought up time and again as there has been very little progress on this front by Canon and with each new camera released there is anticipation a new sensor technology will be released.

The only reason you are getting upset by all this talk about Canon's DR is because you are taking it personally. The work done in this post was to measure the DR improvements for Canon's latest cameras. I think most here would like to know how much if any improvements have occurred.

I don't see any pointing fingers or putting sticks into people's eyes...just good solid information on the latest Sensor. Now if these tests showed a great improvement in DR, would we even be having this discussion?
Then no one will mind if I go on Sony / Nikon forums every day and post "good solid information" about the lenses their systems lack, or their lack of radio flashes, or their ergonomic deficiencies ... along with hints that they can solve these problems by switching to Canon.
Which forum should someone go to when they want advice on how the Canon system compares to Nikon's or Sony's?
We get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?
I've been using my electronic viewfinder and I feel it is much better than any optical finder. You get exactly how your image will look using the EFV...no need to chimp anymore. In fact, I have the rear LCD turned off now. With focus peeking and zebra striping...electric view finders will quickly obsolete optical view finders.

Have you actually used a good electric view finder to it's fullest abilities. See to go and comment on the other boards, you should at least be familiar with what you are commenting on or you might just look ignorant there.

At least most people
...Show more →

Chez, I'm on-board with the EVF for certain subject matter, most non-action photography, the extra info and exact sensor image are a huge bonus. For action, most moving subjects there is still a good deal of work to be accomplished with mirrorless AF systems but I've no doubt that will change in the next decade; perhaps less.

As mentioned, there are only a few issues that keep me from augmenting my Canon kit with a Sony a7 of some sort. I normally carry two bodies for convenience, what brand of body isn't a disqualifier as long as it can manage my Canon glass.

So SONY, slim up your wired remote, add a touch screen; articulated if possible, to your a7 designs and I'm a buyer that will spread the word that you are a disabled friendly company
Mar 23, 2015 at 12:21 PM
zlatko
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote:
zlatko wrote
snapsy wrote
zlatko wrote
chez wrote
zlatko wroteConstant repetition of alleged DR deficiencies. What else is new? It would be the same as posting frequent reminders on Sony / Nikon forums of the various lenses their systems lack. Or droning on about their ergonomic deficiencies. How would they receive that information?
Firstly, many people that shoot with a Sony also own and shoot with Canon so I ( we) have interest in what and where Canon is heading. And yes the lack of DR is brought up time and again as there has been very little progress on this front by Canon and with each new camera released there is anticipation a new sensor technology will be released.

The only reason you are getting upset by all this talk about Canon's DR is because you are taking it personally. The work done in this post was to measure the DR improvements for Canon's latest cameras. I think most here would like to know how much if any improvements have occurred.

I don't see any pointing fingers or putting sticks into people's eyes...just good solid information on the latest Sensor. Now if these tests showed a great improvement in DR, would we even be having this discussion?
Then no one will mind if I go on Sony / Nikon forums every day and post "good solid information" about the lenses their systems lack, or their lack of radio flashes, or their ergonomic deficiencies ... along with hints that they can solve these problems by switching to Canon.
Which forum should someone go to when they want advice on how the Canon system compares to Nikon's or Sony's?
We get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?
I've been using my electronic viewfinder and I feel it is much better than any optical finder. You get exactly how your image will look using the EFV...no need to chimp anymore. In fact, I have the rear LCD turned off now. With focus peeking and zebra striping...electric view finders will quickly obsolete optical view finders.

Have you actually used a good electric view finder to it's fullest abilities. See to go and comment on the other boards, you should at least be familiar with what you are commenting on or you might just look ignorant there.

At least most people
...Show more →

Yes, I've worked with EVF's on the Olympus E-M1, Fuji X-Pro1, X100S and Fuji X-T1 ... all considered to be "good". Haven't tried the Sony. Is it better?

Let me share my recent experience with the Fuji X-T1 EVF. It has a few characteristics that no reviewer seems to note or mention. When shooting with image preview off and the drive mode to single, the X-T1 EVF always has a sluggish blackout time, as if every shot is taken at 1/30th second, even if the shutter speed is much faster. Annoying. When shooting with image preview OFF and the drive mode to continuous, the X-T1 EVF always shows a brief preview after ever shot — even though image preview is set to OFF. How can that be? Annoying. And not good for capturing key moments. Whether this matters to anyone depends on what photography they do, but that Fuji EVF certainly doesn't obsolete my OVF's.

I'm not saying Sony / Nikon make bad cameras. I'm saying that regular proselytizing about a few select Canon advantages on a Sony / Nikon forum could get a little ... boring.
Mar 23, 2015 at 12:35 PM
Access
Offline
Details
p.5 #12Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote:
If only we had discussions in which both systems were compared objectively. We don't. We have daily criticisms of Canon's DR ... "yet another boring Canon sensor with, again, the same boring 11 f-stop DR" says the OP. But it's only boring if the photographer is boring and can't make a decent photo with 11-stop DR. For some photographers, that is no doubt true. For others, it's not true at all — and the 5DS is quite exciting, sensor and all.

I have to agree with this sentiment. By far, it seems like the focus of this forum -- in terms of actual activity and view, is too often this one issue. I understand it's an important issue for some, but there's a lot of other interesting stuff that goes on (or that the rest of us hope for) that just seems to get glossed over for this one "hot" issue. So many of the truly interesting (IMO), revolutionary, or such technologies that are either out there, or (perhaps) up-and-coming in the next few years. In short, I think of DR discussions like "beating a dead horse", at least until we see actual evidence that Canon cares about DR or that meaningful progress can or actually has been made. Just as a reference point ML seems to care more about DR than Canon since that is where we first saw the dual ISO was realized and developed. The sad thing is the feature is there in hardware -- the hardware was built to do this, it just lacked support in the firmware.

It's the same as if I showed up at a local club meeting and everything was talking about the soap-chewing capacity of their cameras and how disappointed they were that the newest camera got only a superficial increase in the all-important bars per minute performance. While I'd respect that soap-chewing capacity was of great importance to the group, I just wouldn't be able to get much out of it from my own perspective, and I'd also have to admit the group is "not really representative" of photographers as a whole. How would it be useful to anyone except those that really needed a camera with enough soap-chewing capacity to take the kind of photos they wanted to take?
Mar 23, 2015 at 12:37 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Monito wrote:
If someone posted analysis based on flawed software from images they admit are inadequate in a couple of ways for testing purposes, in the Sony forum, about an announced camera not yet released, I hope that the clearer-minded people there would point that out. It would not be "defensive" to do so, and it is not defensive when I do so here.


The read noise and saturation analysis with dcraw is accurate after the black point verification, and not flawed. The low ISO engineering dynamic range of the 5Ds cameras is 11.0 Ev +/- 0.1 EV at the pixel level with 99.9% certainty.
Mar 23, 2015 at 12:57 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.5 #14Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
snapsy wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteFortunately, if you hang out with actual photographers much you will be reassured to find that these gear wars don't amount to much in the real photography world — they are largely a phenomenon of forums.
Have you ever seen someone on the landscape forum complain that there is too much focus on the art of a good image and not enough discussion about gear? Why should the inverse be different on this gear forum? Do you not consider yourself an "actual" photographer because of your participation on this thread? Do you consider others on this thread to not be photographers by their participation here?


I'm not referring to any kind of forum. I'm referring to actual people. :-)
Mar 23, 2015 at 01:08 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.5 #15Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote:
I worked side by side with a photographer who shot with two D800's. He was working for me as a 2nd photographer. We shot some of the same scenes at the same time. When I got his files, I was prepared to see this amazing DR that some people have been trumpeting about on Canon forums. I was prepared to have this "eye-opening" experience. Instead, DR made absolutely no difference as I reviewed the photos. They looked no better and no worse than my Canon images (although I prefer Canon color). The photos worked or didn't based on so many
...Show more →

I work side-by-side with people shooting everything including Sony A6000 and A7r, Nikon D800e and D810, Mamiya 645 with 80MP Phase One Backs, Olympus 4/3s cameras, various Canon cameras, large format film, medium format film, the giant Seitz camera, and more.

A number of us get together regularly to review our print work. All we see are beautiful photographs, and while the question of what gear was used comes up, it isn't because we see that Gear A universally produces better photographs than Gear B. We're interested in what was used, but it is usually fairly irrelevant to how we respond to their work. Among some very fine photographers in this group, there are folks who have great reasons for choosing to use any of this gear, and we all simply recognize that, understand the differences, and move on.

I'm fine with whatever choices anyone wants to make — obviously, since I use more than one brand myself — but the insistence that the gear used by others is substandard or poor or falling behind or whatever else it is gets old after we've heard it ad nauseam. I understand that it is a characteristic of gear forums for some to become downright religious (one right answer, will buttonhole anyone to tell them about the right answer, those who don't believe are ignorant or worse) about gear stuff. So be it.

There are differences between different brands and models of equipment. Different people will feel differently about the importance of those differences. Sometimes Brand A tests better than Brand B on parameter X, and sometimes Brand C tests better than Brand D on parameter Y. It matters. A little bit. Maybe. To you.

But what possible value is there in doing the equivalent of driving your Chevy into a Ford dealership to help those poor ignorant Ford buyers understand that your Chevy is miles better than their Ford (or vice versa)? Repeatedly. Daily. Or when any other topic comes up (tires, the best driving routes, what stations to listen to in the car, the weather, best place to eat in Utah...), driving the topic right back to how great your Chevy is and how often their Fords are?

Not that this will change anyone. ;-)

Carry on...

Dan

Edited on Mar 23, 2015 at 01:56 PM · View previous versions
Mar 23, 2015 at 01:20 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.5 #16Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
alundeb wrote:
The read noise and saturation analysis with dcraw is accurate after the black point verification, and not flawed. The low ISO engineering dynamic range of the 5Ds cameras is 11.0 Ev +/- 0.1 EV at the pixel level with 99.9% certainty.



The OP is using software that as they say decodes the Raw to a wrong sized image with artifacts in it. That is a flawed start. The OP is forced to use it because of a lack of any other way at this premature point in the release process.

The OP also admits that the images are not ideal for testing purposes because of the black point and the size.

Yes, one can handwave and compensate for this and that, but in the end it is not definitive. It is indicative at best.
Mar 23, 2015 at 01:41 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.5 #17Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Monito wrote:
alundeb wroteThe read noise and saturation analysis with dcraw is accurate after the black point verification, and not flawed. The low ISO engineering dynamic range of the 5Ds cameras is 11.0 Ev +/- 0.1 EV at the pixel level with 99.9% certainty.
The OP is using software that as they say decodes the Raw to a wrong sized image with artifacts in it. That is a flawed start. The OP is forced to use it because of a lack of any other way at this premature point in the release process.

The OP also admits that the images are not ideal for testing purposes because of the black point and the size.

Yes, one can handwave and compensate for this and that, but in the end it is not definitive. It is indicative at best.


The analysis does not include decoding. We don't need the whole picture, just patches from the masked area to get the read noise. The point the OP made about the size, was that he couldn't decode the whole image to a visible result. He never said this had any inference on the analysis, and it doesn't. There is a small uncertainty about the full saturation level, but this abounts to < 0.05 Ev

The black point problem has been solved and is acknowledged by the OP and his results are corrected for that. It is no longer an issue.

Your points do not bring valid criticism, and the results stand. I also have them verified from another source using a different software, IRIS, to get the same results.
Mar 23, 2015 at 01:52 PM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.5 #18Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote:
I can't think of any single source of information that provides purely objective information. In the end you'll need to consult a range of them — and here I'm not limiting my point to just photography forums. This is also true of review sites, the opinions of excellent photographers, and more.


So true. You can usually pick up fairly quickly the slant that people want to put on things. In the end, the only truly objective source will be your own experience. No review/fellow photographer/forum will ever top that. They are nice to guide an initial purchase but not necessarily great indicators on what will actually work for YOU.

gdanmitchell wrote:
Fortunately, if you hang out with actual photographers much you will be reassured to find that these gear wars don't amount to much in the real photography world — they are largely a phenomenon of forums.


I've yet to actually talk to a photographer that wants to discuss gear. All the ones I talk to and listen to talk about hotels/motels, travel cost/inconvenience, good places to eat, and aches and pains. I've yet to have one come up to me and say (even on a sunny noon game), I wish I had more low ISO DR.
Mar 23, 2015 at 01:56 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.5 #19Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
ggreene wrote:
I've yet to actually talk to a photographer that wants to discuss gear. All the ones I talk to and listen to talk about hotels/motels, travel cost/inconvenience, good places to eat, and aches and pains. I've yet to have one come up to me and say (even on a sunny noon game), I wish I had more low ISO DR.


In my experience most photographers will be interested in talking about gear — it just isn't the first or main thing, and they usually are pretty bored by folks who make that an obsession.

On the other hand, if you ever want to unimpress working photographers, when you meet them for the first time be sure to ask them what gear they use. Even worse, be sure to tell them why their choice is wrong! ;-)

Dan

Edited on Mar 23, 2015 at 02:16 PM · View previous versions
Mar 23, 2015 at 02:03 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.5 #20Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
ggreene wrote:
In the end, the only truly objective source will be your own experience.


Even though I trust my own experience more than most other sources, I have no illusion about it being anything but subjective.
Mar 23, 2015 at 02:03 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister