fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)

  
 
Ben Horne
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Since 2009, I've shot the majority of my portfolio shots on Velvia 50 which has about 4 to 5 stops of dynamic range. If you can't take a good photo with 11 stops of latitude, maybe it's time to pursue a different past time. :-D
Mar 23, 2015 at 09:20 AM
dhphoto
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Ben Horne wrote:
Since 2009, I've shot the majority of my portfolio shots on Velvia 50 which has about 4 to 5 stops of dynamic range. If you can't take a good photo with 11 stops of latitude, maybe it's time to pursue a different past time. :-D


Don't say that you'll get them really stirred up

(Even though you are of course quite correct)
Mar 23, 2015 at 09:24 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Ben Horne wrote:
Since 2009, I've shot the majority of my portfolio shots on Velvia 50 which has about 4 to 5 stops of dynamic range. If you can't take a good photo with 11 stops of latitude, maybe it's time to pursue a different past time. :-D


According to this test, Velvia is capable of recording about 10 stops of scene dynamic range (what we are talking about here).

http://www.clarkvision.com/articles/film.vs.digital.summary1.html/
Mar 23, 2015 at 09:30 AM
jimmy462
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
alundeb wrote:
A histogram of the read noise values would quickly answer that. Is it possible for youy to provide that without too much effort? Thank you!


Hi alundeb,etal,

Were I to use a camera with this many pixels, Read Noise would not my first concern. However, File Size as a function of ISO Noise would be the first thing "I looked at".

Soo, using the images at IR that employed NR0 (zero) we get the following, er, datum ...

E5DSRhSLI00100NR0.CR2 - 66.84MB
E5DSRhSLI00200NR0.CR2 - 67.89MB (+1.05 MB above ISO 100)
E5DSRhSLI00400NR0.CR2 - 69.23MB (+2.39 MB)
E5DSRhSLI00800NR0.CR2 - 71.12MB (+4.28 MB)
E5DSRhSLI01600NR0.CR2 - 74.24 MB (+7.40 MB)
E5DSRhSLI03200NR0.CR2 - 78.23MB (+11.39 MB)
E5DSRhSLI06400NR0.CR2 - 82.91MB (+16.07 MB)
E5DSRhSLI12800NR0.CR2 - 89.74MB (+22.90 MB)

Simple math tells us that for every 100 pretty landscape pictures taken at ISO 1600 the user could (should?) expect to have to provide storage for 7.4MB x 100 = 740MB worth of additional noise data on their drives. 1000 images = 7.4GB. 10,000 images = 74GB.

Also, there is the time factor with PPing out (massaging) 7.4MB worth of noise for every ISO 1600 image. Depending on a user's fastidiousness in dealing with tweaking both chrominance and luminance noise away to their tastes, one could be expending anywheres from a minute or so per image, or more. Computer processor speeds and RAM and drive speeds (and user fortitude) need be up to the task, as well.

Some, present in this thread, have suggested these are niche cameras, to which, I concur. An under-ISO 1600 (read: "daylight-only", or "bring along your lights!"), high-resolution camera will certainly please the landscape (up to a point), portrait and advertising shooters (have I left anyone out?!). However, this one's not for me.

And, out of respect for some of our, um, more sensitive readers, I'll spare everyone present another one of my litanies about wanting a high-ISO, low-light shooter with gobs of DR and 4K video!

Oop,
Jimmy G

Mar 23, 2015 at 09:34 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Hi Jimmy!

I don't take many landscape images at ISO 1600, but if I were to store 10000 images with extra noise, those 74 GB of storage would cost me about the same as a cup of coffee.

Take care!

Anders
Mar 23, 2015 at 09:48 AM
zlatko
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
snapsy wrote:
zlatko wrote
chez wrote
zlatko wrote
retrofocus wroteCanon police early in action . Trying to rule out every sort of criticism or cons. No surprises here.
Constant repetition of alleged DR deficiencies. What else is new? It would be the same as posting frequent reminders on Sony / Nikon forums of the various lenses their systems lack. Or droning on about their ergonomic deficiencies. How would they receive that information?
Firstly, many people that shoot with a Sony also own and shoot with Canon so I ( we) have interest in what and where Canon is heading. And yes the lack of DR is brought up time and again as there has been very little progress on this front by Canon and with each new camera released there is anticipation a new sensor technology will be released.

The only reason you are getting upset by all this talk about Canon's DR is because you are taking it personally. The work done in this post was to measure the DR improvements for Canon's latest cameras. I think most here would like to know how much if any improvements have occurred.

I don't see any pointing fingers or putting sticks into people's eyes...just good solid information on the latest Sensor. Now if these tests showed a great improvement in DR, would we even be having this discussion?
Then no one will mind if I go on Sony / Nikon forums every day and post "good solid information" about the lenses their systems lack, or their lack of radio flashes, or their ergonomic deficiencies ... along with hints that they can solve these problems by switching to Canon.
Which forum should someone go to when they want advice on how the Canon system compares to Nikon's or Sony's?


We get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?
Mar 23, 2015 at 10:00 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
ben egbert wrote:
Just downloaded a CR2 from the web site. Photoshop will not open it. Breeze browser does but when I converted it, the result was a black frame. Still, I can view the raw in Breeze.

But this sort of shot does not tell me what I need to know. I need a shot or a set of bracketed shots taken of a scene that exceeds the DR of not only this camera but all cameras. For example an into the sun sunset. I want to see what happens when you lift shadows on a shot that has the highlights controlled.


Back in early February right after the announcement, Canon made some full size out-of-camera jpg files available online. (Links are in my post — see below.)

The jpg files can't give us the complete picture of sensor performance — for that we'd like to see raw files. But they can give us some useful information. For example, they give us some idea of how the resolution of the 50MP sensor might look in large prints, they can reveal certain kinds of image distortion if they are present, the effect of the lack of AA filtering, and so forth.

I downloaded one of those files from the "R" model — an aerial photograph of a dense urban environment — and took it through a light post-processing workflow (mostly some generic sharpening and a small curve adjustment) and resized the images for 30" x 45" prints. I printed a letter size section of the image, choosing an area of the image that might be susceptible to aliasing/moire, since that was one of the two issues I was most interested in. I've written a bit more about the results at the link (http://www.gdanmitchell.com/2015/02/06/new-canon-5ds-r-dslr-a-printing-test), but I was very pleased to not see moire/aliasing in places where I might have expected it to occur, and the detail in the sample from the 30" x 45" print was very good. As you can read at the link I also tried a much larger conversion.

I'm sure the DR-focused people will recognize — as I do, too — that an in-camera jpg doesn't reveal much about DR, and it is hard to know what it tells us about noise in the initial capture. (On the latter point, however, the very sharp print from the image shows no visible noise at all, and the results in a very large print matter most to me.)

Dan

By the way, while I have not tried it yet, it used to be possible to convert almost any raw file to DNG using the Adobe DNG converter program. Anyone tried that yet?
Mar 23, 2015 at 10:02 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Beni wrote:
In the studio I often use the Nikon MC-30A release in my teeth for when I have my hands full, it's such a big button that it's far easier in general to use than any other release from my canon or sony cameras. In the mouth I press the button with my tounge. Bit yeuch perhaps to some but when you're shooting product or repro and have both hands full, it's very very useful.


A switch is a switch. Adapt it to a foot switch.
Mar 23, 2015 at 10:15 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote:
A camera is more than a sensor. ;-)


Yup. Much more.
Mar 23, 2015 at 10:18 AM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote:
snapsy wrote
zlatko wrote
chez wrote
zlatko wrote
retrofocus wroteCanon police early in action . Trying to rule out every sort of criticism or cons. No surprises here.
Constant repetition of alleged DR deficiencies. What else is new? It would be the same as posting frequent reminders on Sony / Nikon forums of the various lenses their systems lack. Or droning on about their ergonomic deficiencies. How would they receive that information?
Firstly, many people that shoot with a Sony also own and shoot with Canon so I ( we) have interest in what and where Canon is heading. And yes the lack of DR is brought up time and again as there has been very little progress on this front by Canon and with each new camera released there is anticipation a new sensor technology will be released.

The only reason you are getting upset by all this talk about Canon's DR is because you are taking it personally. The work done in this post was to measure the DR improvements for Canon's latest cameras. I think most here would like to know how much if any improvements have occurred.

I don't see any pointing fingers or putting sticks into people's eyes...just good solid information on the latest Sensor. Now if these tests showed a great improvement in DR, would we even be having this discussion?
Then no one will mind if I go on Sony / Nikon forums every day and post "good solid information" about the lenses their systems lack, or their lack of radio flashes, or their ergonomic deficiencies ... along with hints that they can solve these problems by switching to Canon.
Which forum should someone go to when they want advice on how the Canon system compares to Nikon's or Sony's?
We get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?


If you go onto the Sony forums you'll almost never read about DR. Instead what's often discussed is the lack of lens choices, poor ergonomics, artifacts from Sony's compression algorithm, etc. If you go onto the Canon forums you'll almost never read about lack of lens choices, poor ergonomics, or compression artifacts. In other words, you'll get objective reality about shortcomings in each respective forum. Only when the threads cross and both systems are discussed do you start seeing people reject, distort, or marginalize this reality. Which again brings up my question - where can both systems to be discussed and compared objectively?
Mar 23, 2015 at 10:20 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
zlatko wrote:
We get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?


What happens is that the insecure guy who predicted Canon's demise posts about how great Sony DR is (for his work) and complains about "Canon police". He does this to shore up his self-esteem about his switch to a Sony body.

Then the well-meaning but almost as single-minded guy who actually makes and posts good photographs chips in to make sure that everybody knows how happy he is too.

Are there any Canon or Nikon posters making as many similarly redundant unnecessary posts in the Sony forum?
Mar 23, 2015 at 10:25 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
snapsy wrote:
zlatko wrote
snapsy wrote
zlatko wrote
chez wrote
zlatko wroteConstant repetition of alleged DR deficiencies. What else is new? It would be the same as posting frequent reminders on Sony / Nikon forums of the various lenses their systems lack. Or droning on about their ergonomic deficiencies. How would they receive that information?
Firstly, many people that shoot with a Sony also own and shoot with Canon so I ( we) have interest in what and where Canon is heading. And yes the lack of DR is brought up time and again as there has been very little progress on this front by Canon and with each new camera released there is anticipation a new sensor technology will be released.

The only reason you are getting upset by all this talk about Canon's DR is because you are taking it personally. The work done in this post was to measure the DR improvements for Canon's latest cameras. I think most here would like to know how much if any improvements have occurred.

I don't see any pointing fingers or putting sticks into people's eyes...just good solid information on the latest Sensor. Now if these tests showed a great improvement in DR, would we even be having this discussion?
Then no one will mind if I go on Sony / Nikon forums every day and post "good solid information" about the lenses their systems lack, or their lack of radio flashes, or their ergonomic deficiencies ... along with hints that they can solve these problems by switching to Canon.
Which forum should someone go to when they want advice on how the Canon system compares to Nikon's or Sony's?
We get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?
If you go onto the Sony forums you'll almost never read about DR. Instead what's often discussed is the lack of lens choices, poor ergonomics, artifacts from Sony's compression algorithm, etc. If you go onto the Canon forums you'll almost never read about lack of lens choices, poor ergonomics, or compression artifacts. In other words, you'll get objective reality about shortcomings in each respective forum. Only when the threads cross and both systems are discussed do you start seeing people reject, distort, or marginalize this reality. Which again brings up my question - where can both systems to be discussed
...Show more →

In order to compare anything objectively in photography forums you have to wade through a lot of hyperbole and stuff that might be more about the writer's strongly subjective point of view than about objective fact. You can get some sense from reading a range of posts on a subject in a forum and by getting to know what each of the posters typically shares. Over time you may be able to identify some whose opinions might be more or less trustworthy, and you'll eventually figure out that some always sing the same song, never leaving out a verse!

I can't think of any single source of information that provides purely objective information. In the end you'll need to consult a range of them — and here I'm not limiting my point to just photography forums. This is also true of review sites, the opinions of excellent photographers, and more.

Fortunately, if you hang out with actual photographers much you will be reassured to find that these gear wars don't amount to much in the real photography world — they are largely a phenomenon of forums.

Good luck,

Dan
Mar 23, 2015 at 10:26 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Ok, which one from canon to replace my recently re-purchased 1ds2 ($500) with 11 stops of DR. There is none so what is the point
Mar 23, 2015 at 10:32 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
x wrote:
Velvia 50 which has about 4 to 5 stops of dynamic range. If you can't take a good photo with 11 stops of latitude, maybe it's time to pursue a different past time. :-D


Latitude and dynamic range are not the same thing. Lattitude is much less than dynamic range.

Latitude is how much an exposure can be varied. Perhaps it is meant that Velvia has 4 to 5 stops latitude since it has more dynamic range than that.

alundeb wrote:
According to this test, Velvia is capable of recording about 10 stops of scene dynamic range (what we are talking about here).

http://www.clarkvision.com/articles/film.vs.digital.summary1.html/


Mar 23, 2015 at 10:34 AM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote:
Fortunately, if you hang out with actual photographers much you will be reassured to find that these gear wars don't amount to much in the real photography world — they are largely a phenomenon of forums.


Have you ever seen someone on the landscape forum complain that there is too much focus on the art of a good image and not enough discussion about gear? Why should the inverse be different on this gear forum? Do you not consider yourself an "actual" photographer because of your participation on this thread? Do you consider others on this thread to not be photographers by their participation here?
Mar 23, 2015 at 10:42 AM
dhphoto
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
mttran wrote:
Ok, which one from canon to replace my recently re-purchased 1ds2 ($500) with 11 stops of DR. There is none so what is the point


Of all the Canon dslr's I've owned (which is most of them) my 1Ds3 has the best sensor under 800 ISO
Mar 23, 2015 at 10:43 AM
StillFingerz
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Beni wrote:
StillFingerz wrote
chez wrote
StillFingerz wrote
cgarcia wrote
memoria wroteWhich software do you use when editing the 5Ds RAW files?
dcraw with the options"-D -4 -j -t 0 -v"

On this way, we have access to the full raw data capture (14-bit pixel values stored in 16 bit integers). This includes the image borders covered to not capture light (useful to measure the sensor read noise).

The decoding is wrong (a 17792x2960 image). The left half seems to have good data, though.Usually dcraw is able to decode future sensor images (except for fine color adjustments) but this is not the case for the 5DS. We'll have to wait a bit.

The vertical masked area ends stored in two places in this weird geometry:

x=0, y=64, width=160, height=2896
x=4448, y=64, width=160, height=2896

To calculate stats I use a small custom made C++ application I started a few months ago. I'll publish it for free one of these days if I finally end it (currently requires manually editing the coordinates).
Since your calcs, the software and the design unknowns of a 'new' sensor and it's RAW files that are pre-production are only in limbo; could change at any moment, like when production RAWs are available, how can you declare 'zero' change in DR, you can't.

That said the math and software 'Dcraw' seem an interesting concept/methodology for evaluating sensors, yet it's nowhere conclusive, so all you've done is report inconclusive data with a methodology that has reportedly work before on 'production' targets, doing so on a non-production target sample...

This smells of sensationalism, guessing if there will be a double yoke before cracking the egg kind if thing. Much like what the media does with their 'story telling' disguised as 'news', often causing damage before the 'real' truth is revealed. In this case, I'll hazard a wild arse guess that 'ZERO' doesn't equal 'Zero' when the final numbers are derived, and thus your 'headline' was a false statement; until proven correct, with zero doubt.

On another note, as a C++ coder myself; began in the mid-90s, I'd be most interested in your application and it's implementation...I'm always looking to learn a new trick or two, or three...no joking

Cheers,
Jerry
Jerry, until we have a release camera, we will never know the actual performance...but given the data we have today, this information is very valid. Sure the sensor performanc can and will most likey change...but given what we have today, this is very relevant data.

Love to see the exact analysis done on a production version.

By the way...I would think the sensor is very close to production version if it has been released by Canon for pre-release testing.
Mostly agree Chez, I'm not thinking we'll see anymore DR magic in this new mega 35mm sensor design than perhaps the 'cleaner' shadows found in the 6D or the 7D2's, my gut feels Canon isn't to concerned with the DR race with these models. These are very niche bodies, not unlike the 7D/7D2 were/are, serving a smaller group of photographers.

Note also, other than their MP count, which might help me from a cropability standpoint; caused at times by my disability related reach issues, I'm not seeing a buy here. And even though I'm grabbing a 6D for current FF purposes, my eyes are wide open and are following Sony closely.

As mentioned before I'm kind of tied to Canon because only their wired remotes are of a size/design that can be used between my teeth; a big mouth on forums perhaps but physically not, to allow me to hand-hold and shoot. All Sony has to do is make their remote a bit thinner and change the button position, and add a touch screen, and I'd be 'able' to avail myself of their extras, including wider DR. Even in gardens; covered or not, there can be deep shadows filled with much flora that otherwise go unseen.

So I forego the wider DR for now and stay with ergonomics that work with my speshul needs, those that have allowed me the privilege to shoot for near thirty-seven years seated. Hand-holding is one of those last freedoms I'm unwilling to give up. Compromise is a must with a high level spinal injury on so many levels; subject mater just one, and tripods/wheelchairs play not well together

Cheers,
Jerry
In the studio I often use the Nikon MC-30A release in my teeth for when I have my hands full, it's such a big button that it's far easier in general to use than any other release from my canon or sony cameras. In the mouth I press the button with my tounge. Bit yeuch perhaps to some but when you're shooting product or repro and have both hands full, it's very very useful.


Thank you, Beni, that looks workable, even smaller the my current remote. Does it allow for a half press for AF then full press for tripping the shutter? Another option is a good thang, now to research Nikon glass

Cheers,
Jerry
Mar 23, 2015 at 10:53 AM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Thanks for taking the time to do this cagarcia. Soon enough we will have multiple review sources to confirm, but your work so far is in line with what Canon told us the day the 5DS/R was released. Then again, 'actual' photographers apparently don't care about DR or appreciate state of the art camera gear, so I'll have to return to the drawing board to see what it is I am after shooting hundreds of thousands of images
Mar 23, 2015 at 11:04 AM
zlatko
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
snapsy wrote:
zlatko wrote
snapsy wrote
zlatko wrote
chez wrote
zlatko wroteConstant repetition of alleged DR deficiencies. What else is new? It would be the same as posting frequent reminders on Sony / Nikon forums of the various lenses their systems lack. Or droning on about their ergonomic deficiencies. How would they receive that information?
Firstly, many people that shoot with a Sony also own and shoot with Canon so I ( we) have interest in what and where Canon is heading. And yes the lack of DR is brought up time and again as there has been very little progress on this front by Canon and with each new camera released there is anticipation a new sensor technology will be released.

The only reason you are getting upset by all this talk about Canon's DR is because you are taking it personally. The work done in this post was to measure the DR improvements for Canon's latest cameras. I think most here would like to know how much if any improvements have occurred.

I don't see any pointing fingers or putting sticks into people's eyes...just good solid information on the latest Sensor. Now if these tests showed a great improvement in DR, would we even be having this discussion?
Then no one will mind if I go on Sony / Nikon forums every day and post "good solid information" about the lenses their systems lack, or their lack of radio flashes, or their ergonomic deficiencies ... along with hints that they can solve these problems by switching to Canon.
Which forum should someone go to when they want advice on how the Canon system compares to Nikon's or Sony's?
We get this "advice" a lot. And it is *always* about DR, the *one* thing in which Sony / Nikon have some limited advantage. In this post it comes with all sorts of disclaimers about Dcraw, something I never use. As I said, Nikon / Sony forums should not mind if someone gives them frequent "advice" about the advantages of the Canon system, perhaps with lessons about the fine points of ergonomics. Perhaps Sony forums would appreciate a daily post or two advising about the advantages of optical viewfinders?
If you go onto the Sony forums you'll almost never read about DR. Instead what's often discussed is the lack of lens choices, poor ergonomics, artifacts from Sony's compression algorithm, etc. If you go onto the Canon forums you'll almost never read about lack of lens choices, poor ergonomics, or compression artifacts. In other words, you'll get objective reality about shortcomings in each respective forum. Only when the threads cross and both systems are discussed do you start seeing people reject, distort, or marginalize this reality. Which again brings up my question - where can both systems to be discussed
...Show more →

If only we had discussions in which both systems were compared objectively. We don't. We have daily criticisms of Canon's DR ... "yet another boring Canon sensor with, again, the same boring 11 f-stop DR" says the OP. But it's only boring if the photographer is boring and can't make a decent photo with 11-stop DR. For some photographers, that is no doubt true. For others, it's not true at all — and the 5DS is quite exciting, sensor and all.

Which Sony / Nikon forum should I go on to expound about the virtues of Canon's flicker reduction system for shooting in fluorescent light, or about Canon's dual pixel AF for video? Surely they'll appreciate objective advice about these exciting technologies, along with daily reminders about how "boring" their systems are?
Mar 23, 2015 at 11:05 AM
Beni
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
StillFingerz wrote:
Beni wrote
StillFingerz wrote
chez wrote
StillFingerz wrote
cgarcia wrotedcraw with the options"-D -4 -j -t 0 -v"

On this way, we have access to the full raw data capture (14-bit pixel values stored in 16 bit integers). This includes the image borders covered to not capture light (useful to measure the sensor read noise).

The decoding is wrong (a 17792x2960 image). The left half seems to have good data, though.Usually dcraw is able to decode future sensor images (except for fine color adjustments) but this is not the case for the 5DS. We'll have to wait a bit.

The vertical masked area ends stored in two places in this weird geometry:

x=0, y=64, width=160, height=2896
x=4448, y=64, width=160, height=2896

To calculate stats I use a small custom made C++ application I started a few months ago. I'll publish it for free one of these days if I finally end it (currently requires manually editing the coordinates).
Since your calcs, the software and the design unknowns of a 'new' sensor and it's RAW files that are pre-production are only in limbo; could change at any moment, like when production RAWs are available, how can you declare 'zero' change in DR, you can't.

That said the math and software 'Dcraw' seem an interesting concept/methodology for evaluating sensors, yet it's nowhere conclusive, so all you've done is report inconclusive data with a methodology that has reportedly work before on 'production' targets, doing so on a non-production target sample...

This smells of sensationalism, guessing if there will be a double yoke before cracking the egg kind if thing. Much like what the media does with their 'story telling' disguised as 'news', often causing damage before the 'real' truth is revealed. In this case, I'll hazard a wild arse guess that 'ZERO' doesn't equal 'Zero' when the final numbers are derived, and thus your 'headline' was a false statement; until proven correct, with zero doubt.

On another note, as a C++ coder myself; began in the mid-90s, I'd be most interested in your application and it's implementation...I'm always looking to learn a new trick or two, or three...no joking

Cheers,
Jerry
Jerry, until we have a release camera, we will never know the actual performance...but given the data we have today, this information is very valid. Sure the sensor performanc can and will most likey change...but given what we have today, this is very relevant data.

Love to see the exact analysis done on a production version.

By the way...I would think the sensor is very close to production version if it has been released by Canon for pre-release testing.
Mostly agree Chez, I'm not thinking we'll see anymore DR magic in this new mega 35mm sensor design than perhaps the 'cleaner' shadows found in the 6D or the 7D2's, my gut feels Canon isn't to concerned with the DR race with these models. These are very niche bodies, not unlike the 7D/7D2 were/are, serving a smaller group of photographers.

Note also, other than their MP count, which might help me from a cropability standpoint; caused at times by my disability related reach issues, I'm not seeing a buy here. And even though I'm grabbing a 6D for current FF purposes, my eyes are wide open and are following Sony closely.

As mentioned before I'm kind of tied to Canon because only their wired remotes are of a size/design that can be used between my teeth; a big mouth on forums perhaps but physically not, to allow me to hand-hold and shoot. All Sony has to do is make their remote a bit thinner and change the button position, and add a touch screen, and I'd be 'able' to avail myself of their extras, including wider DR. Even in gardens; covered or not, there can be deep shadows filled with much flora that otherwise go unseen.

So I forego the wider DR for now and stay with ergonomics that work with my speshul needs, those that have allowed me the privilege to shoot for near thirty-seven years seated. Hand-holding is one of those last freedoms I'm unwilling to give up. Compromise is a must with a high level spinal injury on so many levels; subject mater just one, and tripods/wheelchairs play not well together

Cheers,
Jerry
In the studio I often use the Nikon MC-30A release in my teeth for when I have my hands full, it's such a big button that it's far easier in general to use than any other release from my canon or sony cameras. In the mouth I press the button with my tounge. Bit yeuch perhaps to some but when you're shooting product or repro and have both hands full, it's very very useful.
Thank you, Beni, that looks workable, even smaller the my current remote. Does it allow for a half press for AF then full press for tripping the shutter? Another option is a good thang, now to research Nikon glass

Cheers,
Jerry


Sure. It's the best remote I've ever had the pleasure to use. Wish other companies would make one with a huge button like that.
Mar 23, 2015 at 11:08 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister