fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)

  
 
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.21 #1Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote:
Mike Eckstein wroteI've never had anyone look at one of my images and say - that would really look nicer if it had more dynamic range.
Maybe because the one's that were blown because of the lack of DR, either blown highlights or muddy shadows or banding in the shadows, get deleted before others can view them.

I've made plenty great photos with my Canon system...continue to do so, but I use techniques to "tame" the DR in the scene if need be. With a sensor that allows for greater dynamic range, I just need to rely less on these techniques and focus more on compositions and light.

Funny, not one person ever said my photos would look better with a camera capable of shooting 12fps.

Not one person
...Show more →

Chez -- Whether you or Mike, who you are lecturing, you are both showing why good editing practices are needed by a photographer. No one bats 1000. There is always material left on the cutting room floor. The point of a professional is to always get the required shots and use the right tools to assure that is accomplished. No one guarantees that every shutter click will be a winner, or that one out of a series will be the best shot.

You're not really arguing for higher DR. You are arguing for best technique with the best available gear at hand.
Mar 30, 2015 at 07:49 AM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.21 #2Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote:
NCAndy wrote
EB-1 wroteIn landscape images there are occasions when higher DR would be useful, but it's not the deal breaker very often and HDR offers a much higher increase in DR than a sensor bump does. I do also like dark shadows sometimes. In the old days we called that contrast - to delineate certain details.

EBH
Drama. Many of the masters of landscape have blocked shadows or lost detail in the highlights in their images. I think the ability to present detail in every part of the image is often overused. I'm not saying having a more DR capable sensor wouldn't be good, it's just that it can also become case of because I can doesn't mean I should. It can be a fine line to walk, especially when the general public tend to go gaga over crazy HDR type images. I'm not on that bandwagon.
Again..that is fine if YOU are not on the bandwagon...but can you at least understand some other people value more DR in their images. Historically, and in fact most landscape photographers still use techniques to manage the dynamic range in an image from GND filters to exposing multiple images of a scene to later combine these. Many of your so called MASTERS have been using these techniques for years. We now have cameras which reduce the reliance ( note I said reduce not eliminate ) on techniques to work around DR scenes which like I said is only a good
...Show more →

Chez -- I don't know when you will finally realize, most photographers, and especially Canon owners, are not "on the bandwagon" for DR as a cause or metric for producing high quality work.

That's not to say these same people are against the concept or the feature. It's just not their top priority or lack of which brings their production to a crashing halt.

This is not unlike crusaders for smaller format cameras trying to convince DSLR shooters to give up their larger cameras and support their industry lobbying to keep small format cameras in production and moving forward in development. It's just not a resounding argument to the ears of devoted DSLR owners (and in particular, FF users).

I made it clear I was in favor of high MP as my top priority, and now that it is coming, I'm happy. But I'm not rubbing it in anyone's nose. And it may be some time before I can justify purchasing the new camera -- I'm still getting by fine with gear that's a generation or more out of date. It's just a feature, and I've lived for a very long time without it and been able to take pleasing pictures.

I'm getting tired of all this politicking and debating to try to break down the interest in Canon DSLRs, and promote other makers' products on the Canon forum. I don't mind comparisons of brands here, or even mentioning newsworthy items from other makers (like Pentax 645D, Nikon D800 series, etc). Just not a constant whining barrage of why Canon sucks and I should want something else or demand something from Canon.

That's not to say I'm a super-fanatic-boy for Canon -- I say buy and use whatever you like, and don't hold it against me if I own multiple brands and formats. I'm not trying to talk you out of using broad DR, so please return the favor and respect that I don't share your zeal in this matter. Same goes for retro, mttran, and others who constantly harangue on this forum.

I guess that's as clear as I can make it, while still respecting your choices and preferences.
Mar 30, 2015 at 08:09 AM
jimmy462
Offline
Details
p.21 #3Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
gdanmitchell wrote:
<snip>
One other thing to keep in mind. I know that many of you get this, but I wonder if everyone does? There seems to be an idea that if you have greater DR you won't have to adjust in post. That's not it. In fact, if you capture an image (either with a larger DR sensor or a blend) that has a huge dynamic range you are most certainly going to have to do some work in post to diminish that DR in your print, since prints cannot produce the same DR that any of the cameras mentioned here can
...Show more →

Hi Dan, etal,

Methinks some folks present are over-complicating the discussion regarding DR. To direct this conversation back to the OPs subject matter and findings, the point here is that the new 5Ds/R cameras will not be offering shooters any major improvements (i.e. extra stops of DR) than what they're currently accustomed to with Canon's 7D Mark II. To this observer, based on the OP's early tests, it appears to me that the sensors in the new model's 4.14µm square pixels are merely a reapplication of the existing fabrications found in the 7D Mark II's 4.1 µm square pixels. That Canon will be applying any improvements as far as ADC or other components, or in-camera processor programming to help improve output, still remain to be seen and tested. But, again, it appears to this viewer that 5Ds/R are merely repurposed tech from the 7D2 generation.

To your comments...

Of course moving an image to the 5-to-6 stop range of print is going to involve adjustment and compromise to any image of greater DR. Be it an 8-, 10-, 12-, or 14-stop image one will need to squeeze their whites, blacks and mid-tones to work to one's satisfaction on paper, and such. Those challenges will remain unchanged.

But, this is true for viewing on various electronic devices. If one's computer monitor or smart device screen is only an 8-stop display, any image of higher bit-depth, be it 10-, 12-, 14-stop, will get remapped into that smaller colorspace for viewing.

It's a matter of how many EV levels are being re-represented in the more limited output formats. That it were possible for print to display 14-stops as 14-stops, and not 14-stops as 5-stops the need for that squeezing of DR-to-fit would no longer be a necessary step. The same being true for electronic displays, that we had 14-stop monitors that could match, pixel-for-pixel, both the tonality and dynamic range of our sensors then we would no longer need LUTs to translate the greater to the smaller.

And, I think, this is where many folks get confused in reading or discussing DR. 14-stops of EV (or 12- or 10-stops) can be represented in both print and electronic display. The extra stops can be thought of as broadening one's palette...if shooting at 11-stops for a particular scene mean sacrificing (blowing) our highlights and crushing our shadows, where 14-stops would give us a bit more latitude on both ends in that exposure choice, I'd rather have the extra few stops at my disposal. I can always toss them in PP should I wish to modify my look and make it, oh say, more film-like.

One can't throw away what they don't have, anymore than they can conjure up something out of nothing.

And, again, my thanks to the OP for letting us know that Canon will not be bringing me those extra stops to artistically play with in these two yet-to-be-released cameras!

Best, Dan, etal,
Jimmy G
Mar 30, 2015 at 09:15 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.21 #4Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Gunzorro wrote:
chez wrote
NCAndy wrote
EB-1 wroteIn landscape images there are occasions when higher DR would be useful, but it's not the deal breaker very often and HDR offers a much higher increase in DR than a sensor bump does. I do also like dark shadows sometimes. In the old days we called that contrast - to delineate certain details.

EBH
Drama. Many of the masters of landscape have blocked shadows or lost detail in the highlights in their images. I think the ability to present detail in every part of the image is often overused. I'm not saying having a more DR capable sensor wouldn't be good, it's just that it can also become case of because I can doesn't mean I should. It can be a fine line to walk, especially when the general public tend to go gaga over crazy HDR type images. I'm not on that bandwagon.
Again..that is fine if YOU are not on the bandwagon...but can you at least understand some other people value more DR in their images. Historically, and in fact most landscape photographers still use techniques to manage the dynamic range in an image from GND filters to exposing multiple images of a scene to later combine these. Many of your so called MASTERS have been using these techniques for years. We now have cameras which reduce the reliance ( note I said reduce not eliminate ) on techniques to work around DR scenes which like I said is only a good thing. It allows more flexibility and choice...very much like the flexibility of to use high ISO or a flash when taking shots of dim scenes.

Don't forget the MASTERS used flash in the old days to illuminate dim scenes...now we have the option of use high ISO. Aren't options great?
Chez -- I don't know when you will finally realize, most photographers, and especially Canon owners, are not "on the bandwagon" for DR as a cause or metric for producing high quality work.

That's not to say these same people are against the concept or the feature. It's just not their top priority or lack of which brings their production to a crashing halt.

This is not unlike crusaders for smaller format cameras trying to convince DSLR shooters to give up their larger cameras and support their industry lobbying to keep small format cameras in production and moving forward in
...Show more →

I give you credit for one thing many others here didn't do who are so enthusiastic about their Canon brand - you at least tried the competitive sensor and described your experience with it. If you now don't need it or find the D810 sensor less beneficial, this is your personal decision, and I am not opposing this.

I am not sure why you and some others here constantly try to silence those who talk about their experience which might be not in line with yours or what you want to hear. It is a discussion about DR in this thread - if you want to compare Canon's technology with something, you need to discuss also the Nikon/Sony high MP/high DR performance. If there would be a similar sensor from additional brand X in the 35 mm format, we would discuss it also. And as chez pointed out very well, many use e.g. both Canon and Sony/Nikon gear in parallel depending on their needs.

Talking about haranguing - I see others here doing this much more in a repetitive (Dan) or even nasty (Monito, jctriguy) way. What surprises me is this finding and defending of excuses why DR is not needed because it might be a Canon weakness - when the future camera sensor is not even out on the market yet to compare them 1:1. But as Jimmy G pointed out correctly above, it looks like DR will remain an issue in the new Canon FF sensor generation when compared with the competion out there.
Mar 30, 2015 at 10:47 AM
panicatnabisco
Offline
Details
p.21 #5Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
I'd rather have a jack of all trades than a one trick pony, thanks.
Mar 30, 2015 at 11:40 AM
Access
Offline
Details
p.21 #6Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote:
as Jimmy G pointed out correctly above, it looks like DR will remain an issue in the new Canon FF sensor generation when compared with the competion out there.

This is like saying (hypothetically) that the car I drive has an issue b'cos it won't go faster than 110mph while there are some other cars out there that you can get up to 120mph or 130mph. Or that my freezer has an issue b'cos it won't go very far below -10C while the competition goes down to -15C or even -20C. Or that this forum is insufficient b'cos it only has only 1000 posters and 10 posts per minute while dpreview or some other forum has more.

Call it an "issue" for yourself, but for a large majority, sensors became 'good enough' several years ago (2008?). And this is in more ways than just DR -- noise, high ISO, etc.

If it was an issue in reality, we'd be hearing more about it in real life. But in all my experience, the discussion is confined to forums like these.
Mar 30, 2015 at 12:34 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.21 #7Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Access wrote:
retrofocus wroteas Jimmy G pointed out correctly above, it looks like DR will remain an issue in the new Canon FF sensor generation when compared with the competion out there.
Call it an "issue" for yourself, but for a large majority, sensors became 'good enough' several years ago (2008?). And this is in more ways than just DR -- noise, high ISO, etc.

If it was an issue in reality, we'd be hearing more about it in real life. But in all my experience, the discussion is confined to forums like these.


What you are saying is to be okay with the status quo and leave it unchallenged - wrong! Canon was leading the FF sensor area in 2007/8 with the introduction of the 1Ds MkIII and the 5D MkII. And we all know the issues of those sensors - no need to be repetitive here. Since this time, Canon improved one thing a bit in their FF sensors - high ISO capability which was most visible in the 6D. The rest remained fairly the same til now with the 5Ds(R) series. Canon was and is challenged now especially by Sony in this market as we all know. Your reasoning reminds me a lot on posts much earlier on where people also claimed that 8MP of the Rebel XT APS-C sensor is more than sufficient .

And you hear about this in real life - by people who are now buying other brands instead, add or switch. And why not? If I see that another brand can provide me more quality for the same or even lower price, I will go for it.
Mar 30, 2015 at 12:48 PM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.21 #8Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote:
And you hear about this in real life - by people who are now buying other brands instead, add or switch. And why not? If I see that another brand can provide me more quality for the same or even lower price, I will go for it.


That's great but the camera sales for Sony and Nikon are not that great either so from Canon's perspective low ISO DR is not a difference maker that is forcing them to re-access and invest multi-billions on a new sensor fab plant.

We've seen the charts and graphs and ratings ad nauseam. The real crux of the discussion is what is going to get Canon to see low ISO DR as relevant.

Mar 30, 2015 at 01:24 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.21 #9Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Death Valley, here I come. With two cameras — one is Canon and one is not.:-)

Edited on Mar 30, 2015 at 01:47 PM · View previous versions
Mar 30, 2015 at 01:29 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.21 #10Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Gonzorro. Exactly. Good luck. :-)

Dan

Edited on Mar 30, 2015 at 01:46 PM · View previous versions
Mar 30, 2015 at 01:31 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.21 #11Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
ggreene wrote:
retrofocus wroteAnd you hear about this in real life - by people who are now buying other brands instead, add or switch. And why not? If I see that another brand can provide me more quality for the same or even lower price, I will go for it.
That's great but the camera sales for Sony and Nikon are not that great either so from Canon's perspective low ISO DR is not a difference maker that is forcing them to re-access and invest multi-billions on a new sensor fab plant.

We've seen the charts and graphs and ratings ad nauseam. The real crux of the discussion is what is going to get Canon to see low ISO DR as relevant.



Lost sales. Canon's revenue the last few years has been going down. Not a good sign. They are a huge company demanding huge revenues...what is the next big thing for Canon to release to improve on their revenues. Not better sensors? Not a full mirrorless line? Staying with the same sensor and same DSLR setup the answer...only time will tell. We have many aggressive electronic companies after the camera ( including cell phones ) market...more aggressive than we've seen in the non digital era. Something will give....just depends what.
Mar 30, 2015 at 01:40 PM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.21 #12Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Yes retro, I've added a D800e to my bag of tricks, and I'm happy about its results, given the limited amount and quality of lenses I have available for it. I know many Canon owners have added a Nikon or Sony 36MP body to their repertoire also. A few have made a complete shift to these other brands.

But the bulk of this forum (including me) is still Canon-centric. We find Canon acceptable, meeting our needs in most cases, and providing more than adequate IQ (including DR).

What I don't like here, or in the other forums, is when agents for change, or agents for the status quo, are so militant in their approach to convince others that the place becomes a nightmare of nitpicking, instead of a place of news and discussion between colleagues and enthusiasts.

You've heard the collective yawn from Canon corporate, and from the owners on this forum, regarding DR. I'm sorry that doesn't suit you. Compared to Canon's system, Sony, and even Nikon, aren't in as good a position to build a full system around the wonderful sensors they have -- not as well as Canon could IF it put its resources in that mode. I can see why that would rankle some Canon owners to move on or motivate them to whine and proselytize in an attempt to wake the sleeping dragon that Canon must seem to them.

Canon seems to be the strongest financially of all the camera makers for good reason -- they are conservative unless they have an earth-shattering change that is all their own making. That's Canon's MO. They don't like to look anxious, apparently. That's what their execs keep saying.

I've been in this game for the long haul, and over all the different formats of film and digital it's always been Canon that is my mainstay in 35mm size imaging. I will try other things, but Canon essentially provides for my needs. I don't think I'm terribly unique in this regard. It's not laziness, it's not a police-state mentality, it's not pure fanboy-ism that keeps me using Canon products. It's a combination of the best lenses, and quality bodies that can support a whole broad system, and my comfortable familiarity with all controls and menus.

In short, I don't mind being told another brand/system is great and exciting, and shown examples and comparisons that support that contention. I don't mind news about the overall photo climate and upcoming developments. I love discussion and "look what I got from this lens/body/lighting".

What I don't love is being lectured to like I'm an total ignoramus who is stupidly stuck on a brand that is incapable of meeting my needs. It's all a matter of approach and knowing the audience that is being addressed. I think that's what's taken as a insult when satisfied owners are termed "Canon Police" for objecting or claiming lack of compelling need to investigate the 36MP Sony sensor. It sets the discussion rolling in the wrong direction.

I don't think there was any surprise in this thread when the OP opened by confirming the likelihood that there is no evidence of any improvement in low ISO DR over what we've seen in the 7D2, 1DX or 5D3. That's predictable and in character for Canon's approach over the last ten years at least. The big news is the class leading resolution with and without AA filtering. That is big news to most Canon owners, and satisfies and excites almost half of them here that are experienced users.

I am happy with that advance. And I'm looking forward to further advances that will speak to the DR as well as DIGIC computing and image capture advances.

There is an Alt forum (as you know) for renegades, advanced users, and trailblazers. My suggestion is the dissatisfied Canon users band together there and undertake discussion of their interests and future developments, occasionally coming back here with findings and results to interest the seemingly blase Canon owners.

Mar 30, 2015 at 01:41 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.21 #13Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Very well written, Gunzorro. You nailed all the points with a careful even tone but there is no mistaking your points or the main purpose of your post.
Mar 30, 2015 at 01:45 PM
Access
Offline
Details
p.21 #14Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote:
What you are saying is to be okay with the status quo and leave it unchallenged - wrong! Canon was leading the FF sensor area in 2007/8 with the introduction of the 1Ds MkIII and the 5D MkII. And we all know the issues of those sensors - no need to be repetitive here. Since this time, Canon improved one thing a bit in their FF sensors - high ISO

How is this wrong? Perhaps it was Canon that realized it didn't matter anymore (to the far majority of the photographers out there) so they took the money they would have spent on further sensor improvements, and instead spent it on making other improvements that more users actually care about. Wouldn't that be the right decision to make in the intelligent spending of limited development funds?

If you look at something like Canon's highly successful 5D3 model this alone should be proof that people just don't care about the sensor anywhere near as much they used to. The most common complaint about the 5D2 was the poor autofocus, the 5D3 featured a far better autofocus system and only a marginally improved sensor. And it sold well. Do you think a 5D3 with a much improved sensor but the same autofocus system (or only marginally improved autofocus) would have sold as well as the actual 5D3 did? B'cos I think we all know the answer to that.
Mar 30, 2015 at 01:52 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.21 #15Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Gunzorro wrote:
Chez -- Whether you or Mike, who you are lecturing, you are both showing why good editing practices are needed by a photographer. No one bats 1000. There is always material left on the cutting room floor. The point of a professional is to always get the required shots and use the right tools to assure that is accomplished. No one guarantees that every shutter click will be a winner, or that one out of a series will be the best shot.



Over my 40+ years in photography, I've observed that most professionals, who shoot for other people, inevitably have lower standards than the skilled amateurs who shoot primarily for themselves and have the luxury of pursuing perfection. That's not to say either point of view is right, only that you have to recognize this dichotomy when engaging in discussions like this one.

I don't think any Canon landscape shooter would turn down more dynamic range if it was available in their camera of choice, but since it isn't, most have learned to live without it.
Mar 30, 2015 at 02:17 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.21 #16Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
100% crop from lunch today, playing with Canon 100-400 II + Kenko 1.4X

Camera: Vintage 2004 Kodak SLR/C 14MP @ 11.5 EV DR

Point ... more DR would might be nice, but Canon's glass is ... well, Canon's glass, as is Canon's AF system and their IS system. No perfect system, but we all have our preferences and prioritizations toward preferences vs. poison(s). Most folks are simply saying that the DR is not a poison to them ... despite a recognition that more DR would be a welcome thing.

ISO 160 (base), wide open with TC, hand-held (with IS on) @ 560mm, manual focus.
I suspect it would be better with a Canon 1.4X III TC instead of my old Kenko.







Edited on Mar 30, 2015 at 03:11 PM · View previous versions
Mar 30, 2015 at 02:39 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.21 #17Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Access wrote:
retrofocus wroteWhat you are saying is to be okay with the status quo and leave it unchallenged - wrong! Canon was leading the FF sensor area in 2007/8 with the introduction of the 1Ds MkIII and the 5D MkII. And we all know the issues of those sensors - no need to be repetitive here. Since this time, Canon improved one thing a bit in their FF sensors - high ISO
How is this wrong? Perhaps it was Canon that realized it didn't matter anymore (to the far majority of the photographers out there) so they took the money they would have spent on further sensor improvements, and instead spent it on making other improvements that more users actually care about. Wouldn't that be the right decision to make in the intelligent spending of limited development funds?


I agree that Canon decided to vest the money more into camera periphery (AF) and especially for video performance since 2008. I also agree that most money in photography comes from event/wedding shooters - even Sony now seems to move with their latest camera developments into this direction (unfortunately IMO for me personally, but business-wise it might make sense). This doesn't mean that I need to adopt to the "mass" and mainstream - I simply decide for the best option out there which fits best for my preference, no matter which brand it delivers.

If you look at something like Canon's highly successful 5D3 model this alone should be proof that people just don't care about the sensor anywhere near as much they used to. The most common complaint about the 5D2 was the poor autofocus, the 5D3 featured a far better autofocus system and only a marginally improved sensor. And it sold well. Do you think a 5D3 with a much improved sensor but the same autofocus system (or only marginally improved autofocus) would have sold as well as the actual 5D3 did? B'cos I think we all know the answer to that.

I am absolutely convinced that a 5D MkIII with improved sensor similar as offered in the D800(E) at the time would have sold much better - I totally admit that I would have bought such model if offered. I think your reasoning above points towards more limited fps with higher MP FF sensors - sorry, but IMO the 5D series started not as fast shooting performance/best AF cameras. There was a paradigm shift from Canon when the 5D MkIII was introduced - users switched from 1D series cameras to this 5D MkIII model, that's why it still sold well. The 5D MkIII was beneficial for some and disadvantageous or not worthwhile to upgrade for others.

Mar 30, 2015 at 02:46 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.21 #18Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
100% crop from lunch today, playing with Canon 100-400 II + Kenko 1.4X

Camera: Vintage 2004 Kodak SLR/C 14MP @ 11.5 EV DR

Point ... more DR would might be nice, but Canon's glass is ... well, Canon's glass.
Imo, old school ... glass rules.

ISO 160 (base), wide open with TC, hand-held (with IS on) @ 560mm, manual focus.



Just a side note...that glass could also have been used on the A7R resulting in more DR as well as a nice sharp image.
Mar 30, 2015 at 03:02 PM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.21 #19Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote:
Access wrote
retrofocus wroteWhat you are saying is to be okay with the status quo and leave it unchallenged - wrong! Canon was leading the FF sensor area in 2007/8 with the introduction of the 1Ds MkIII and the 5D MkII. And we all know the issues of those sensors - no need to be repetitive here. Since this time, Canon improved one thing a bit in their FF sensors - high ISO
How is this wrong? Perhaps it was Canon that realized it didn't matter anymore (to the far majority of the photographers out there) so they took the money they would have spent on further sensor improvements, and instead spent it on making other improvements that more users actually care about. Wouldn't that be the right decision to make in the intelligent spending of limited development funds?
I agree that Canon decided to vest the money more into camera periphery (AF) and especially for video performance since 2008. I also agree that most money in photography comes from event/wedding shooters - even Sony now seems to move with their latest camera developments into this direction (unfortunately IMO for me personally, but business-wise it might make sense). This doesn't mean that I need to adopt to the "mass" and mainstream - I simply decide for the best option out there which fits best for my preference, no matter which brand it delivers.

Earlier quoteIf you look at something like Canon's highly successful 5D3 model this alone should be proof that people just don't care about the sensor anywhere near as much they used to. The most common complaint about the 5D2 was the poor autofocus, the 5D3 featured a far better autofocus system and only a marginally improved sensor. And it sold well. Do you think a 5D3 with a much improved sensor but the same autofocus system (or only marginally improved autofocus) would have sold as well as the actual 5D3 did? B'cos I think we all know the answer to that.
I am absolutely convinced that
...Show more →

You keep holding onto what the 5D series started as, in your opinion. What does that matter if it fills the needs of a large group of photographers? Is it possible that you aren't the target market for a 5D series camera? Time to accept that things change and move on. Canon appears to have a very good understanding of their core customers. The products they release sell very well relative to the rest of the market. If that doesn't satisfy some users, tough luck. Best to move on and discuss something that meets your needs, in the proper forum of course.
Mar 30, 2015 at 03:04 PM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.21 #20Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote:
RustyBug wrote100% crop from lunch today, playing with Canon 100-400 II + Kenko 1.4X

Camera: Vintage 2004 Kodak SLR/C 14MP @ 11.5 EV DR

Point ... more DR would might be nice, but Canon's glass is ... well, Canon's glass.
Imo, old school ... glass rules.

ISO 160 (base), wide open with TC, hand-held (with IS on) @ 560mm, manual focus.
Just a side note...that glass could also have been used on the A7R resulting in more DR as well as a nice sharp image.


With crap AF...pick the equipment that does the best for the job. Stop trying to convince everyone to get a sony.

Mar 30, 2015 at 03:06 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister