sb in ak wrote:
The Canon looks soft next to the 645z. (Lens?) This was certainly a surprise to me, given the similarity in resolution.
The 645z has a different aspect ratio cutting out the left and right edges and a tighter framing in the image height as well. It is not a fair comparison of image detail across these formats.
If we crop our images to anything from 1:1 to 3:4, we need a 56 MP 3:2 sensor to match a 50 MP 3:4 sensor.
alundeb wrote: sb in ak wroteThe Canon looks soft next to the 645z. (Lens?) This was certainly a surprise to me, given the similarity in resolution.The 645z has a different aspect ratio cutting out the left and right edges and a tighter framing in the image height as well. It is not a fair comparison of image detail across these formats.
If we crop our images to anything from 1:1 to 3:4, we need a 56 MP 3:2 sensor to match a 50 MP 3:4 sensor.
I normally do crop to 4:3, which is one attraction of the 645z! This means that, from my perspective, the 3:2 50MP sensors cut off the top and bottom, actually have about 1/9 fewer photo sites for me, making them roughly 45+ MP sensors. ;-)
Buying into a system is more than incremental differences in the final output. Think about service! The Pentax 645D & Z have a very long way to go in servicing these bodies and anything complicated goes to Japan for a few months.
I'm looking at these on a retina iMac and I can't tell. so, really, who cares. the average joe won't tell the difference in an 11x14 or 16x20 print. I'll gladly take the 645D of the Nikon over ANY of Canon's offerings at this point.
3catsinky wrote:
I'm looking at these on a retina iMac and I can't tell. so, really, who cares. the average joe won't tell the difference in an 11x14 or 16x20 print. I'll gladly take the 645D of the Nikon over ANY of Canon's offerings at this point.
If those are your maximum limits in print sizes I can save you a bundle of cash by selling you my used 5d2. You will see zero difference at the smaller print sizes.
3catsinky wrote:
I'm looking at these on a retina iMac and I can't tell. so, really, who cares. the average joe won't tell the difference in an 11x14 or 16x20 print. I'll gladly take the 645D of the Nikon over ANY of Canon's offerings at this point.
The average joe won't see a difference, whether going to 36MP or 50MP FF or to 50MP or larger MF. You could say the same thing about any camera with special capabilities, couldn't you?
Interesting that you would mention the 645D since it (a pretty nice camera, by the way, if you need its capabilities) has been superseded by the 645z.
All camera choices are compromises that are best made with the particular needs/intentions of the photographer in mind. MF digital can produce truly excellent results, but they also cost a lot more, are larger, operate more slowly, and don't provide as many lens options, particularly at the long end. For some excellent photographers they are exactly the best current compromise. For some other excellent photographers, full frame digital systems are the optimal solution. For yet others it can be a mirrorless camera or a camera with a smaller sensor, or whatever.
The "average joe" or josephine is likely best off making a different set of compromises that favor flexibility, relatively small size, lower cost, and so forth.
alundeb wrote: EB-1 wroteI can't make any determination from this data. Are there any raw files of test charts available?
EBHI can't get much useful out of these jpg images either. People worry too much about beta software and too little about the jpg processing. We can't tell anything about the image quality before we get a decent raw converter with support for these files.
So how long should it take for Adobe (CS6 or CC) or Canon (DPP) to make available an update for being able to read these CR2 files? How long has it been with other new camera releases?
albedo_jdb wrote: alundeb wroteEB-1 wroteI can't make any determination from this data. Are there any raw files of test charts available?
EBHI can't get much useful out of these jpg images either. People worry too much about beta software and too little about the jpg processing. We can't tell anything about the image quality before we get a decent raw converter with support for these files.So how long should it take for Adobe (CS6 or CC) or Canon (DPP) to make available an update for being able to read these CR2 files? How long has it been with other new camera releases?
Has anyone tried using the Adobe DNG converter to convert to DNG raw format?
albedo_jdb wrote: alundeb wroteEB-1 wroteI can't make any determination from this data. Are there any raw files of test charts available?
EBHI can't get much useful out of these jpg images either. People worry too much about beta software and too little about the jpg processing. We can't tell anything about the image quality before we get a decent raw converter with support for these files.So how long should it take for Adobe (CS6 or CC) or Canon (DPP) to make available an update for being able to read these CR2 files? How long has it been with other new camera releases?
Canon DPP file support is usually made available when the cameras start to ship.
alundeb wrote: albedo_jdb wrotealundeb wroteEB-1 wroteI can't make any determination from this data. Are there any raw files of test charts available?
EBHI can't get much useful out of these jpg images either. People worry too much about beta software and too little about the jpg processing. We can't tell anything about the image quality before we get a decent raw converter with support for these files.So how long should it take for Adobe (CS6 or CC) or Canon (DPP) to make available an update for being able to read these CR2 files? How long has it been with other new camera releases?Canon DPP file support is usually made available when the cameras start to ship.
Adobe DNG converter doesn't work yet either.
I can open a CR2 with Breeze Browser, which might just be the embedded JPG. I can look but it won't convert.
alundeb wrote: albedo_jdb wrotealundeb wroteEB-1 wroteI can't make any determination from this data. Are there any raw files of test charts available?
EBHI can't get much useful out of these jpg images either. People worry too much about beta software and too little about the jpg processing. We can't tell anything about the image quality before we get a decent raw converter with support for these files.So how long should it take for Adobe (CS6 or CC) or Canon (DPP) to make available an update for being able to read these CR2 files? How long has it been with other new camera releases?Canon DPP file support is usually made available when the cameras start to ship.
Adobe DNG converter doesn't work yet either.
Thanks for the responses. I have avoided going to Adobe CC from Adobe CS6 just on principle, but is this the scenario that CC is supposed to be invented for, ie getting critically needed updates out more quickly and efficiently? I guess it might be time to bite the monthly bullet.
I find it interesting then that even with all the pro and con comments about the new cameras, nobody anywhere except employees at Canon have ever even seen a raw file opened up. I hope the readers are available before the cameras are shipped!
I hate the idea of subscriptions as well, but the photography package from Adobe (LR and PS) actually isn't a bad deal. Last I looked it amounted to around $120 a year.
Let's see if we can get some indication of the high ISO performance. Some people were frightened by 6400 as the highest normal ISO, and that the image quality would break down beyond that.
One way to minimize the effect of in-camera jpg processing and different levels of detail, is to downsample images from different cameras to a common size significantly smaller than both. I did this with the 5DSR and the 5DII, to 1920x1280 pixels, and then cropped out some small patches.
Here is a comparison of the 5DSR at ISO 12800 with the 5DIII at ISO 25600 and 12800.
Interesting, does that mean Canon is still tweaking things at this point, or was this just a violation of some kind of non-disclosure agreement? I have still not seen any other actual CR2 files anywhere else yet...
5Dsr - TIFF to JPG converted from IR RAW hi iso samples - look pretty nice grain, no banding found. No N/R conversion. Warning, 14MGbytes each - huge files. Both shots with 24-70Lii at 28/50mmf2.8