fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Imaging Resource has posted 5DS R samples

  
 
phibes
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Imaging Resource has posted 5DS R samples
mttran wrote:
5Dsr - TIFF to JPG converted from IR RAW hi iso samples - look pretty nice grain, no banding found. No N/R conversion. Warning, 14MGbytes each - huge files. Both shots with 24-70Lii at 28/50mmf2.8

ISO3200: http://tinyurl.com/nkxkh5y
ISO6400: http://tinyurl.com/ncc2glx

Too bad I did not have chance to play around with low iso samples before IR remove the RAW.


I may have them downloaded, ... will check once I'm at home....
Mar 26, 2015 at 12:09 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Imaging Resource has posted 5DS R samples
I had the ISO 100 raw file from imaging-resource.com downloaded before they were retracted. With the recently provided support in LR 6, I had a look. Because of the restrictions, I will not share any images, but this is my preliminary assessement of the 5DS R image quality:

Where I come from: I have the Canon 5D II and Sony A7r, and will continue to use the A7r along with the 5DS R.

The standard profile in LR gives a much higher contrast for the 5DS R than the A7r. This makes accurate evaluation of colors and noise difficult.

The files were developed with zero sharpening and zero noise reduction and then evaluated as 16 bits TIFF files in Photoshop CS 5.1. The A7r file was interpolated to the same size as the 5DS R, and sharpened with slight USM (0.3/80) to get the same actuance. This is what I would normally do for large prints; to end up with the same output size and actuance for both cameras.

Color: The colors from the 5DS R look very nice, and not much different from the A7r. As said, accurate evaluation is very difficult because the standard profile gives different contrast and thus apparent saturation.

Detail: There is very little detail in the I-R scene that is on the border of resolution for these cameras. Most of the image looks more similar than different. The interpolated A7R image looks very nice, but with a slight edge to the 5DS R. The few places where there is detail on the border of resolution, the difference is larger than expected. The red fabric swatch is badly aliased in the A7r, but very well resolved in the 5DS R. That place there is like a night and day difference. The finest text in one of the bottles is just artifacts on the A7r, but readable on the 5DS R.

Noise: There are no really deep shadows in the I-R image, so a real evaluation of DR is not possible from these. Overall, noise is very similarly absent, with a slight edge to the A7r. At a 2 stop push, both cameras have some chroma noise in the black coffe mug. The 5DS R has just a little bit more, estimated to about 1/3 ISO stop.

Overall, I prefer the 5DS R file over the A7r file. The differences are really small, except for detail at the border of resolution, where the 5DS R wins hands down. Even before I have seen the same image from the 5DS with AA filter, I am leaning heavliy towards the 5DS R.
Apr 26, 2015 at 02:12 AM
dolina
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Imaging Resource has posted 5DS R samples
alundub like you I also have the 5D2. Could you compare the 5D2 to the 5DSR as they have the same ISO range?
Apr 26, 2015 at 03:12 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Imaging Resource has posted 5DS R samples
The shadow noise from the 5DII is much worse than the 5DS R. This is down do:

- Visible criss-cross banding from the 5D II even at a moderate 2 stop push of the I-R file.

- Much finer noise grain in the 5DS R

- Less sharpening required from the 5DS R because of the cancelling AA filter. Sharpening enhances noise.

Comparing midtone noise is difficult at ISO 100. Detail is really no contest, the 5DS R is far ahead.
Apr 26, 2015 at 03:34 AM
Stoffer
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Imaging Resource has posted 5DS R samples
alundeb wrote:
Noise: There are no really deep shadows in the I-R image, so a real evaluation of DR is not possible from these. Overall, noise is very similarly absent, with a slight edge to the A7r. At a 2 stop push, both cameras have some chroma noise in the black coffe mug. The 5DS R has just a little bit more, estimated to about 1/3 ISO stop.



I was lucky to obtain the 5DS R raw ISO 100 from IR too and just downloaded the ISO 100 raw counterpart from their A7R test to compare.

I agree with what you say over all, but I would definitely say that there is some deep shadows in the shots that can be raised in order to get a feel for the real world practical DR. The big difference between the two cameras is that colors do get more washed out with the Canon once you start to lift the shadows like 2-3 stops and there is also more luminance noise, but the results are certainly not useless in my book.

I know some people are more concerned about raising pitch black shadows with perfects results but I don't tend to run into those situations so things are looking pretty good for me.
Apr 26, 2015 at 05:20 AM
Dpedraza
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Imaging Resource has posted 5DS R samples
johnctharp wrote:
My biggest concern with the non-AA cameras is just how hard moire'/color aliasing is to remove when present, and just how intrusive it can be, particularly with lenses that out-resolve the sensor (as many a Nikon user has found!).

That said, given that most of your subjects tend to be 'organic' Dan, I'd be leaning toward the 'R' model if I were in your shoes too.


The whole moire thing isn't s huge issue. I had both the d800 and d800e and with the e I never had moire issues arise ever. On that same token I did have moire issues with my rx1 though which had an aa filter.
Apr 26, 2015 at 05:35 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Imaging Resource has posted 5DS R samples
Stoffer wrote:
alundeb wroteNoise: There are no really deep shadows in the I-R image, so a real evaluation of DR is not possible from these. Overall, noise is very similarly absent, with a slight edge to the A7r. At a 2 stop push, both cameras have some chroma noise in the black coffe mug. The 5DS R has just a little bit more, estimated to about 1/3 ISO stop.
I was lucky to obtain the 5DS R raw ISO 100 from IR too and just downloaded the ISO 100 raw counterpart from their A7R test to compare.

I agree with what you say over all, but I would definitely say that there is some deep shadows in the shots that can be raised in order to get a feel for the real world practical DR. The big difference between the two cameras is that colors do get more washed out with the Canon once you start to lift the shadows like 2-3 stops and there is also more luminance
...Show more →

Agree, and it is so much better than the 5DII that it is well worth the upgrade and will be fine for the most of my use cases.
Apr 26, 2015 at 05:37 AM
dolina
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Imaging Resource has posted 5DS R samples
Thank you for the feedback alundeb. With the many negative comments on the 5DSR I was starting to wonder if it was just a 5D2 with more than 2x the resolution and better AF system.

alundeb wrote:
The shadow noise from the 5DII is much worse than the 5DS R. This is down do:

- Visible criss-cross banding from the 5D II even at a moderate 2 stop push of the I-R file.

- Much finer noise grain in the 5DS R

- Less sharpening required from the 5DS R because of the cancelling AA filter. Sharpening enhances noise.

Comparing midtone noise is difficult at ISO 100. Detail is really no contest, the 5DS R is far ahead.

==========

Dpedraza wrote:
The whole moire thing isn't s huge issue. I had both the d800 and d800e and with the e I never had moire issues arise ever. On that same token I did have moire issues with my rx1 though which had an aa filter.


What were your subjects with the "E"?
Apr 26, 2015 at 10:44 AM
johnctharp
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Imaging Resource has posted 5DS R samples
Dpedraza wrote:
The whole moire thing isn't s huge issue. I had both the d800 and d800e and with the e I never had moire issues arise ever. On that same token I did have moire issues with my rx1 though which had an aa filter.


It happens in certain situations- you have to have the right subject, and you have to have a lens that can properly resolve it, at the appropriate aperture.

What I can say is that I've seen it in D800E/D810 shots posted here on the forum, typically with the sharpest of lenses, and I'd expect that 5Ds R users are going to have the same issue.
Apr 26, 2015 at 11:03 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Imaging Resource has posted 5DS R samples
alundeb wrote:
I had the ISO 100 raw file from imaging-resource.com downloaded before they were retracted. With the recently provided support in LR 6, I had a look. Because of the restrictions, I will not share any images, but this is my preliminary assessement of the 5DS R image quality:

Where I come from: I have the Canon 5D II and Sony A7r, and will continue to use the A7r along with the 5DS R.

The standard profile in LR gives a much higher contrast for the 5DS R than the A7r. This makes accurate evaluation of colors and noise difficult.

The files were developed
...Show more →

Great to know your assessment in normal DR canon shadow improvement. Still like to see the noise signatures at the wider range of DR cases. Thanks
Apr 26, 2015 at 01:41 PM
Dpedraza
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Imaging Resource has posted 5DS R samples
dolina wrote:
Thank you for the feedback alundeb. With the many negative comments on the 5DSR I was starting to wonder if it was just a 5D2 with more than 2x the resolution and better AF system.

alundeb wroteThe shadow noise from the 5DII is much worse than the 5DS R. This is down do:

- Visible criss-cross banding from the 5D II even at a moderate 2 stop push of the I-R file.

- Much finer noise grain in the 5DS R

- Less sharpening required from the 5DS R because of the cancelling AA filter. Sharpening enhances noise.

Comparing midtone noise is difficult at ISO 100. Detail is really no contest, the 5DS R is far ahead.
==========

Dpedraza wroteThe whole moire thing isn't s huge issue. I had both the d800 and d800e and with the e I never had moire issues arise ever. On that same token I did have moire issues with my rx1 though which had an aa filter.
What were your subjects with the "E"?
my kids a lot with 50art or the 14-24.

Apr 26, 2015 at 02:10 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.5 #12Imaging Resource has posted 5DS R samples
dolina wrote:
alundeb like you I also have the 5D2. Could you compare the 5D2 to the 5DSR as they have the same ISO range?


The limitation on the ISO range to 12800 has caused some anxiety. It is time to calm down, the files don't brake down at ISO 12800. Without equalizing detail exactly, ony downsizing to a common size, ISO 12800 from the 5DS R looks closer to 5DIII ISO 12800 than to 5DIII ISO 25600.

Apr 26, 2015 at 02:17 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Imaging Resource has posted 5DS R samples
Played a little bit with ISO 12800 raw files that I also got. It is still difficult to get exactly the same contrast, but I used Camera Neutral now.

When downsized to a common size just above 8M (3600x2400), the 5DS R file appears sharper than the 5D III file. Sharpening the 5D III file very slightly with USM 0.5 / 50 before downsizing gives equal sharpness.

At ISO 12800, there is no consistent difference in noise between the 5D III and the 5DS R. Small differences both ways depending on where you look.

I expect the myth that the 5DS (R) is not the best choice for low light to live long, supported by flawed comparisons at different resolutions and detail levels. I will make no pause using it for demanding low light applications. Good luck to you all
Apr 27, 2015 at 11:05 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister