phibes wrote: Orestis.Ch wroteWhere are the raws posted??not really "posted", but available in imaging-resource. Just replace the .jpg with .CR2 in the image url
Thank you! i've just downloaded them.. any ideas on any raw-converter that can handle them??
chez wrote: EB-1 wroteCanon and Nikon have a wide range of lenses. The others have not so much.
EBHI beg to differ. The A7R takes all my existing Canon mount lenses as well as a boat load of others.
C'mon Chez, you know what was meant: Sony and Pentax have a very limited selection of native lenses, and the Sony does not offer full compatibility and speed with other brands' automated features, especially AF speed/accuracy.
The Sony cameras are acknowledged to take great pictures, but function in a limited and jerry-rigged fashion, not without some problems with internal reflection from aftermarket parts/adapters.
Glad you like yours and can still use your Canon lenses.
I am optimistic. The real proof will be 5Ds R images shot by actual buyers of production cameras, of course. I had been trending toward FX Nikons, and cropped-frame Canons, but the 11-24L has turned my attention back to 5D-series bodies, so it is good to see progress by Canon. (I learned to shoot with both Canon and Nikon at the same time, and have a mentor from each "camp," so have been doomed to suffer from two strains of G.A.S.)
Edited to add: I want, of course, to see sample images shot with Canon lenses, with production Canon 5Ds R cameras. (I think the I.R. images were shot with a Sigma lens?) I can be patient, as cropped-frame bodies suit my actual needs, and I cannot commit funds to major purchases until I know whether my wife will have to retire early for medical reasons, and I have a better idea of when I will be retiring. (My exit "window" is opening in July, but 2016 to as late as 2018 will have financial advantages, if my aging body and mind can handle the stresses.)
EB-1 wrote:
Is there any change to the delivery date or is it still late June
No change has been announced. That date is somewhat fuzzy and different than what some have heard in other countries. We'll see.
johnvanr wrote:
I'm still at the point of trying to figure out why I would need that many megapixels, no matter how well they render.
If you don't need them, there is no reason to get this camera. Continue using what you use now, or consider a different camera with a different feature set.
chez wrote:
Looking at these results I see zero reasons to move away from the A7R to the new Canon's. This is just one test so awaiting to see others. Maybe will rent the Canon when it's available to do my own tests.
Now that Pentax is smoking hot...just wish it would take my Canon mount lens.
Too early to say, but the best test will be a direct 1:1 comparison between A7R (or its successor with higher MP sensor if available) and the new 5Ds series cameras including scenes where DR plays a role by using the same lens on both cameras. Then we will know what's going on. This said, it is never wrong to keep expectations low.
For me the test will be against the 5d3, the best camera I have ever owned, and one that would probably be good enough. But this may be my last hurrah so I want to go out in style.
I may never really need 50mp, even though I print a few dozen large prints each year, but at 16x24, 22mp is pretty good. But I will enjoy viewing them and no doubt will print the best larger.
Gunzorro wrote: chez wroteEB-1 wroteCanon and Nikon have a wide range of lenses. The others have not so much.
EBHI beg to differ. The A7R takes all my existing Canon mount lenses as well as a boat load of others.C'mon Chez, you know what was meant: Sony and Pentax have a very limited selection of native lenses, and the Sony does not offer full compatibility and speed with other brands' automated features, especially AF speed/accuracy.
The Sony cameras are acknowledged to take great pictures, but function in a limited and jerry-rigged fashion, not without some problems with internal reflection from aftermarket parts/adapters.
Glad you like yours and can still use your Canon lenses.
Funny thing is most of my lenses for my Canon cameras are not made by Canon.
As far as Jerry-rigged goes, I am part way through my New Mexico trip and have been using my A7R with the Sony 16-35 lens and it's been an easy carry around setup for the entire day. I can truly say I am not finding any of your mentioned Jerry-rigged features in my daily use of the camera.
mttran wrote: Sarsfield wrotemttran, not to be a smarta$$ but what are those little samples/comparisons supposed to show? They all look like crap to me.Look like 2 to 3 DR stops differences between 5Dsr and current models
retrofocus wrote: chez wroteLooking at these results I see zero reasons to move away from the A7R to the new Canon's. This is just one test so awaiting to see others. Maybe will rent the Canon when it's available to do my own tests.
Now that Pentax is smoking hot...just wish it would take my Canon mount lens.Too early to say, but the best test will be a direct 1:1 comparison between A7R (or its successor with higher MP sensor if available) and the new 5Ds series cameras including scenes where DR plays a role by using the same lens on both cameras. Then we will know what's going on. This said, it is never wrong to keep expectations low.
True, but there has to be a marked increase in image quality before I make any move from what I use today. The size of the A7R cannot be dismissed...I thoroughly enjoy using it. The cost factor with Canon not doubt being more expensive also needs to be taken into account.
sb in ak wrote:
Could you tell the difference between the A7R, D810, 5DSR, and 645Z in a blind test, provided files are all normalized to 50MP?
dhphoto wrote:
I don't think that is the question you should ask.
None of this is about looking at 100% crops, it's about actual finished results, either in print or litho, i.e. what these cameras are actually used for and the answer is almost always no, except at very large sizes
chez wrote:
I see two reasons to ger these high Rez cameras, print large or crop heavy. If you don't do either, I don't see the need.
If the frame is full 50 MP is nice, but it also helps if the subject is far out and cropping is needed. With less MP the IQ after cropping would be unacceptable.
Looking good. I have already talked to my dealer in Canada and he is shipping me the first R he gets. Wonder if he will get stock as quickly as the big boys.
I get back home in 2 to 3 weeks and then I'm pretty sure I will pre-order a 5Ds at the local branch of Henry's. With the exchange rate, it saves about US$ 430 over B&H price. But please order from B&H so I can get mine sooner.
chez wrote: Gunzorro wrotechez wroteEB-1 wroteCanon and Nikon have a wide range of lenses. The others have not so much.
EBHI beg to differ. The A7R takes all my existing Canon mount lenses as well as a boat load of others.C'mon Chez, you know what was meant: Sony and Pentax have a very limited selection of native lenses, and the Sony does not offer full compatibility and speed with other brands' automated features, especially AF speed/accuracy.
The Sony cameras are acknowledged to take great pictures, but function in a limited and jerry-rigged fashion, not without some problems with internal reflection from aftermarket parts/adapters.
Glad you like yours and can still use your Canon lenses.Funny thing is most of my lenses for my Canon cameras are not made by Canon.
As far as Jerry-rigged goes, I am part way through my New Mexico trip and have been using my A7R with the Sony 16-35 lens and it's been an easy carry around setup for the entire day. I can truly say I am not finding any of your mentioned Jerry-rigged features in my daily use of the camera.
Well, now you are talking about using a native Sony lens (of course I'd expect it to be trouble free and easy to use!), in comparison to your earlier comments about using Canon and other lenses with adapters to work with the a7R! You have to pick a set of parameters and stick with them in the debate, or at least acknowledge the varied approaches and assets/limitations.
Again, I'm happy that you are happy with your Sony set-up.
gdanmitchell wrote: sb in ak wrotegdanmitchell wroteA 50MP MF (even mini MF) body is always going to be capable of higher system resolution than a 50MP FF body, even with lenses of equal optical quality as measured in the usual lp/mm fashion.
Why doesn't everyone just use digital MF then? We all probably recognize at least some of the reasons why it isn't for everyone despite its demonstrably higher IQ potential:
1. Price
2. When both formats are excellent, sometimes being more excellent won't make a difference that is visible.
3. The larger format also requires larger lenses for the same coverage, producing a very large and heavy system. If you use a lens or two and they aren't too long this may not be an issue. If you rely on long lenses or use a larger number of lenses, it may be.
4. Although strides have been made recently, there certain subjects and kinds of shooting for which MF is not really suitable: wildlife, sports, etc. (I'm not saying it isn't possible, just not ideal for most people.)
MF is great for some people and some kinds of photography, but not for all.
Regarding the comparisons among the FF options (here including the 36MP Sony/Nikon sensor cameras and the 50MP Canon bodies, but also the Olympus option in the article), the image quality differences are likely quickly get into the "how many angels on the head of a pin" territory. I know that some are going to disagree, but the differences between the photographs produced on these cameras are likely to be pretty small — so small that they probably won't be visible in most cases and so small that other functional/operational differences may seem more important to a lot of folks.
DanOh yeah, totally agree; I was just pointing out the differences that I saw. Though the overall takeaway message for me is that any of these cameras can really give great results. Though people may sway either way if they are into certain niches and have the capital. The law of diminishing returns is as present as ever.By the way, I'm very intrigued by the 645z and I haven't ruled out getting one for my photography. It seems like a really fine camera and a great value for a camera that does what it does. The question marks for me involve the relative functional advantages of the smaller system (which can produce really fine results) versus the somewhat better IQ potential of the 645z in very large prints.
For some time I have considered MF digital —in fact I gave some though the 645d predecessor of the 645z. At one point I had a conversation with a friend who at that time was using only the Mamiya 645 body with the full size MF 80MP Phase One back, in which I mentioned my interest. Keeping in mind that he is a person who used to shoot only LF film and then downsized to MF digital, I was a bit surprised (until I thought about it) when he pointed out that despite the IQ potential of the larger system there would be things that I regularly do in my photography that I really couldn't do with MF, and that these functional issues might make the MF systems less useful to me than I imagined.
He was, of course, correct. Some of my photography could be done nicely with the MF system, but some of it literally could not be done — some of the wildlife photography for example, or some of the photography that I do in the backcountry while traveling on foot. A major issue would be, for me at least, the fact that I often use longer focal lengths.
(Interestingly, he started using the D800e and then the D810 for some of his work during the past two years, and on a recent two-week Antarctica trip, where he photographed and instructed, he took only the D810 system.)
I handled a 645Z at CES this year. Was very impressed with the ergonomics. Was even more impressed with the passion of the Ricoh sales staff. They let me take a bunch of photos with a display model using my own SD card. Look how noisy this ISO 100 image is:
But wait...that image was shot underexposed by 7EV and pushed in LR...so it's equivalent to an ISO 12,800 exposure! Here's that same image without the PP exposure adjustment:
EB-1 wrote:
I can't make any determination from this data. Are there any raw files of test charts available?
EBH
I can't get much useful out of these jpg images either. People worry too much about beta software and too little about the jpg processing. We can't tell anything about the image quality before we get a decent raw converter with support for these files.