Amazing shots all. Would any owners of these lenses be kind enough to describe the differences between these two lenses, Sporta and Contemporary. Why and when would someone need the Sports version? Thanks.
digitalshah wrote:
Amazing shots all. Would any owners of these lenses be kind enough to describe the differences between these two lenses, Sporta and Contemporary. Why and when would someone need the Sports version? Thanks.
To summarize. Both lenses are capable of producing fantastic images. Sport version is a more capable lens for some people. It allows you to zoom quickly and produce slightly better images when shot at F6.3. The focus is ever so slightly better as well but it comes at the cost of a significantly heavier lens. Build quality of the sport is fantastic. Contemp is great for those looking for a lighter lens more along the lines of the nikon 80-400mm that they can easily handhold for extended periods and toss in their backpack without have to hire a sherpa.
Contemporary Version:
+ Lightweight
+ Smaller dimensions
+ Very good image quality - only very slightly less sharp than the Sport version
+ Smaller front element = cheaper filters
+ Tripod Collar can be removed decreasing weight & bulk further
+ Lightweight platic lens hood that easily attaches by turning
- Build quality is about the same as Nikon 80-400mm AF-S.
- Autofocus is slightly slower than Sport
- Twist zooming can be awkward if you need to zoom in and out quickly
- Not weather resistant like the sport model
- Cannot be push/pulled for zomming (feels like it will break and very stiff @ 500-600mm)
Sport Version
+ Substantially better build quality @ the cost of higher weight
+ Much larger dimensions
+ About as sharp at F6.3/600mm as the Contemporary version is at F8/600mm
+ Push/Pull zooming allows very easy zooming from 150-600mm
+ Weather resistant
+ Tripod collar has detents at 90 degree intervals
+ Manual focus and zoom are very well damped
+ Indent on front element for easy grip for pushing and pulling
+ Better corner sharpness
- Larger Filters are much more expensive.
- Tripod Collar cannot be removed
- Added bulk and weight is substantial
- Added length when zoomed out can be cumbersome especially for shorter people
- Heavy metal hood that attaches with thumb screw (could be a pro for some)
knower wrote:
I am really interested in comparing the Sigma 120-300 2.8 with the latest Sigma TC2x against the 150-600 sport.
If anybody around Vancouver has a 150-600s we can test the two combos.
I have found the Sigma 120-300 2.8 with the new TC 2x a fantastic combination.
G.
Besides the slight advantage in F-stop (5.6 vs 6.3 @ 600mm) I can't help but think these 2 telezooms from sigma are going to be slightly better. They are both slightly better than my Nikon 300mm F2.8 VRII + 2xIII which I can only assume is slightly better than the Sigma 120-300mm + TC.
Pguts wrote:
Were these with the Sports or Contemporary version of the lens by chance?
As I recall, Corey had both but ended up keeping the Sports. His images and his decision was among the factors that convinced me to stick with Sports as well...
BTW, any of you Sports owners updated the firmware yet? I haven't had a chance yet but I am curious if you guys have observed any noticeable improvement in focus tracking.
cambyses wrote:
BTW, any of you Sports owners updated the firmware yet? I haven't had a chance yet but I am curious if you guys have observed any noticeable improvement in focus tracking.
I did, w/in hours of the release. It's definitely quicker...especially with closer moving targets
at 500/600mm. No tune or dock custom adjustments yet for me, but I'll tweak some before
Bosque season that starts up next month.
Besides the slight advantage in F-stop (5.6 vs 6.3 @ 600mm) I can't help but think these 2 telezooms from sigma are going to be slightly better. They are both slightly better than my Nikon 300mm F2.8 VRII + 2xIII which I can only assume is slightly better than the Sigma 120-300mm + TC.
I might be slightly wrong though
Thanks very much for your answer, knowing it is sharper than the 300 2.8 VRII plus 2xIII makes me think at this lens a bit more.
I would have thought the Sport could be a bit sharper, didn't think the contemporary would be, though.
If anybody else can add to this would be very helpful!
Pguts wrote:
At first I thought that was the duck's guts... looked a bit closer and saw it was a slug or leech or something! Amazing shots Hardcore.
Were these with the Sports or Contemporary version of the lens by chance?
Thanks! These were shot with the sports.
---------------------------------------------
cambyses wrote:
BTW, any of you Sports owners updated the firmware yet? I haven't had a chance yet but I am curious if you guys have observed any noticeable improvement in focus tracking.
Updated the firmware and yes I notice a slight improvement with the tracking.
---------------------------------------------
knower wrote: Earlier quoteBesides the slight advantage in F-stop (5.6 vs 6.3 @ 600mm) I can't help but think these 2 telezooms from sigma are going to be slightly better. They are both slightly better than my Nikon 300mm F2.8 VRII + 2xIII which I can only assume is slightly better than the Sigma 120-300mm + TC.
I might be slightly wrong though Thanks very much for your answer, knowing it is sharper than the 300 2.8 VRII plus 2xIII makes me think at this lens a bit more.
I would have thought the Sport could be a bit sharper, didn't think the contemporary would be, though.
If anybody else can add to this would be very helpful!
Thanks!
G.
Your welcome! Tough decision as the 120-300mm is a great lens!
knower wrote:
I am really interested in comparing the Sigma 120-300 2.8 with the latest Sigma TC2x against the 150-600 sport.
If anybody around Vancouver has a 150-600s we can test the two combos.
I have found the Sigma 120-300 2.8 with the new TC 2x a fantastic combination.
G.
I considered both the 120-300 f2.8 and the 150-600 Sport. These are my thoughts:
- At the short end, f2.8 is great to have
- There is a penalty for using the 2x TC in both sharpness and focus speed, though not that bad
- 800mm is useful and the 150-600 gets you there with autofocus when using a 1.4x TC.
I can deal with the losses form the 120-300 with TC. This left me thinking about which was more important to me, f2.8 at the short end or 800mm at the long end. I went for 800mm as 300mm is not that useful to me even with the nice fast f2.8 I own a 180 f2.8 which I love and use for the delicious OOF backgrounds.
Nice to see so many enjoying their lenses! I don't post on forums much anymore, but thought I would share a couple from a recent shoot. The first photo is a RAW file out of my D800 and Sigma 150-600mm Sport. I was curious as to what the eye looked like with the membrane covering it before deleting it, so in LR, zoomed into 1:1 and then cropped. I think it maintains fairly good detail. I have been pleased with my lens (received it back in Feb. and posted on the 1st page of the thread). Being able to zoom has come in very handy at times. The next two shots are examples of why I am enjoying the zoom ability. I couldn't have gotten much more than the doe's head if I would have been using my 500mm.