Had to climb a mountain to get near this Condor female who was kind enough to wait for me. Glad that it was with a Contemporary (and my old 7D) and not the sport, because of the weight!
trenchmonkey wrote:
+1, must be a "C" thing...the Sportma's been superb.
Ya gets what ya pays for I'm guessin'
Hi Trenchmonkey
You have both lenses. I have two questions:
1. Can the Sigma 150-600 S be handheld, with some practice or conditioning of course?
I am 68 years of age, and I am having no problem handholding this D500 with MBD 17 loaded with batteries and the Nikon 200-500. But I think the Sig is about 2 pounds heavier, is it not?
2. Which is sharper:
200-500 @ 500mm or 150-600 S @ 600 mm. In other words, which it sharper at their greatest lengths.....or are they about the same.
This 200-500 is rented. I AFFT it and it is sharp. But of course not as sharp cranked out to 500 as it is at the closer focal lengths. I am about to buy my own copy of it. I shoot offhand almost exclusively. So, considering that the Sigma is considerably heavier, the Sigma S would have to be considerably sharper at 600 than this Nikon is at 500......for me to change my mind.
scenario wrote:
I have the sport am 82 can hand hold for short period use a rifle sling to stableise it works
_______
By rifle sling do you mean one of those gunstock type attachment like the Bushhawk?
bs kite wrote: trenchmonkey wrote+1, must be a "C" thing...the Sportma's been superb.
Ya gets what ya pays for I'm guessin' Hi Trenchmonkey
You have both lenses. I have two questions:
1. Can the Sigma 150-600 S be handheld, with some practice or conditioning of course?
I am 68 years of age, and I am having no problem handholding this D500 with MBD 17 loaded with batteries and the Nikon 200-500. But I think the Sig is about 2 pounds heavier, is it not?
2. Which is sharper:
200-500 @ 500mm or 150-600 S @ 600 mm. In other words, which it sharper at their greatest lengths.....or are they about the same.
This 200-500 is rented. I AFFT it and it is sharp. But of course not as sharp cranked out to 500 as it is at the closer focal lengths. I am about to buy my own copy of it. I shoot offhand almost exclusively. So, considering that the Sigma is considerably heavier, the Sigma S would have to be considerably sharper at 600 than this Nikon is at 500......for me to change my mind.
I'm thinking the same , 200-500 or 150-600m for the long range . Would really appreciate your opinion Will seeing as you have experience with both lenses .
bs kite wrote: trenchmonkey wrote+1, must be a "C" thing...the Sportma's been superb.
Ya gets what ya pays for I'm guessin' Hi Trenchmonkey
You have both lenses. I have two questions:
1. Can the Sigma 150-600 S be handheld, with some practice or conditioning of course?
I am 68 years of age, and I am having no problem handholding this D500 with MBD 17 loaded with batteries and the Nikon 200-500. But I think the Sig is about 2 pounds heavier, is it not?
2. Which is sharper:
200-500 @ 500mm or 150-600 S @ 600 mm. In other words, which it sharper at their greatest lengths.....or are they about the same.
This 200-500 is rented. I AFFT it and it is sharp. But of course not as sharp cranked out to 500 as it is at the closer focal lengths. I am about to buy my own copy of it. I shoot offhand almost exclusively. So, considering that the Sigma is considerably heavier, the Sigma S would have to be considerably sharper at 600 than this Nikon is at 500......for me to change my mind.
I know you asked Will the questions but hope you don't mind that I chime in. For what it's worth, I had a Sigma Sports and the Nikon 200-500 at the same time, my copy of the Nikon was a bit sharper at 500mm than the Sigma at 600mm so I returned the SIgma. But I missed the extra 50mm at the wide end and the 100mm at the long end, also I missed the push/pull feature of the Sigma, this is very convenient for airshows. I couldn't turn the Nikon from 200 to 500 without stopping and adjust my hand's position to continue.
I tried another copy of the SIgma and have kept it ever since. It's very heavy and I can only hand hold it for a minute or so before I have to put it down to give my left arm a break. I am not a muscle man but not a "girly" dude either. When the Sigma is fully extended to 600mm, you have to extend your arm pretty far out to hold it, I think that's what makes it feel heavy on you arm after a minute so, sort of like extending your arm and holding a dumbbell.
Copy variation plays a role in which one you get is sharper. At the end of the day I think by and large they are pretty close. It really comes down to whether you are willing to accept the Sigma's weight for the bigger range and better built. Just my two cents. The Sigma Sports' lens collar cannot be removed, and the Nikon doesn't give you a place to attach a lens strap. You can use something like a Black Rapid strap but I personally is not a fan of it.
I've had the Sigma 150-600 Sport for about a year. It was a challenge to hand hold for more than a few photos when I got it. A year later I can hand hold much longer though I do rest when I can. I still prefer to shoot from a tripod with it and while I used to prefer hand holding I've come to prefer shooting from the tripod as I can rest, there is no effort to stay on a subject waiting for action and photos are sharper, perticulary for longer exposures.
I had the intention to pass from the Sigma Contemporary to the Sports (150-600), but I've found using the Contemporary for 10 months that 2 kilograms of lens are about the most I can carry around running behind the wildlife.
Still I do not know if it can withstand my heavy usage. Probably after my next big annual trip (this year is Costa Rica) in January I will have to decide. I still have my Canon 400 f5.6L in its box after years of good service.
In my last trip (2 weeks ago) I was able to test the Sigma contemporary against the Canon 100-400 II into the Yungas (a wet jungle in Argentina). The results were like a mixed bag. It didnt loose in all the tests. For the "Rufous-throated Dipper" the Sigma was the clear winner!. Not an easy task into the shadows, with the flash as main light!
Morris: Your characterization of how it becomes easier is exactly right. And Douglas made a good point; i.e. the more extended, the more brutal such a lens initially is on the left arm. Even once you get accustomed to it after a long time, it is still the most you can handle.
Douglas: Please tell me......did you autofocus fine tune both the Nikon and the two Sigma's? Of course I welcome your input And you made some good points. I agree on the push/pull. I shoot a lot at the pond of my boyhood, and it is virtually impossible to BIF wild Wood Ducks here with this 200-500, just because of what you said about the zooming problem with this lens. It is impossible to pull back or extend for any significant change.....without violently disrupting the composition.
You know folks, I shoot a lot of wildlife handheld (mostly local). I rarely shoot off a tripod. This weekend I was shooting my American Goldfinches off the tripod and something rang though clearly and loudly. You already know this and I also knew it but I have been shooting offhand for so long that I needed ro relearn this:
When I set up behind the tripod, the AGF have a much greater tolerance of me. And when I am sitting behind the tripod-mounted lens, they are even more tolerant of me. But, if I am standing and carrying the lens....the second I open the door (and no matter how slowly I try to walk down the steps), they are usually gone before I make it to the bottom step. And if I do make it to the corner of the house (my objective), when they see me raise the lens that is usually enough to make them take flight. It's like duh.
And I have been doing this for 40 years. When I grow up I want to be a nature photographer.
bs kite wrote:
Piovanil: Gorgeous bird! Good work!
Morris: Your characterization of how it becomes easier is exactly right. And Douglas made a good point; i.e. the more extended, the more brutal such a lens initially is on the left arm. Even once you get accustomed to it after a long time, it is still the most you can handle.
Douglas: Please tell me......did you autofocus fine tune both the Nikon and the two Sigma's? Of course I welcome your input And you made some good points. I agree on the push/pull. I shoot a lot at the pond of my boyhood, and it is virtually impossible to BIF wild Wood Ducks here with this 200-500, just because of what you said about the zooming problem with this lens. It is impossible to pull back or extend for any significant change.....without violently disrupting the composition.
You know folks, I shoot a lot of wildlife handheld (mostly local). I rarely shoot off a tripod. This weekend I was shooting my American Goldfinches off the tripod and something rang though clearly and loudly. You already know this and I also knew it but I have been shooting offhand for so long that I needed ro relearn this:
When I set up behind the tripod, the AGF have a much greater tolerance of me. And when I am sitting behind the tripod-mounted lens, they are even more tolerant of me. But, if I am standing and carrying the lens....the second I open the door (and no matter how slowly I try to walk down the steps), they are usually gone before I make it to the bottom step. And if I do make it to the corner of the house (my objective), when they see me raise the lens that is usually enough to make them take flight. It's like duh.
And I have been doing this for 40 years. When I grow up I want to be a nature photographer.
I played around with the AF fine tuning on my D810, didn't see much difference but I am new to the AF fine tuning thing so take it as a grain of salt. From the online reviews I have read extensively, the consensus is that the sharpness between the Nikon and the Sigma is so little that it's not the primary factor for which one to choose. Some say the Nikon is s bit sharper, some say the Sigma is bit sharp, I think it's splitting hair, depending on the copy you get.
I think the weight/range issues are more important in which one to choose.