I played around with a Sigma S today and and compared it to the Nikon 200-500mm. I took 3 shots of a car's tag at 500mm with each lens, on tripod, VR off, chose the sharpest one from each and compared the best from the Sigma to the best from the Nikon. The Nikon is sharper but it's not a precise comparison.
Nikon D3100, 150-600C,1-1600sec, f7.1, ISO800, handheld, camera jpeg, Rawtherapee software for small tweaks like NR. Bird is an asian openbill stork, very far above, maybe 300ft or more, picture is a crop of about 60% of the original frame.
Vinnie_VdB wrote: unni wrote...
Nikon D3100, 150-600C,1-1600sec, f7.1, ISO800, handheld, camera jpeg, Rawtherapee software for small tweaks like NROuch, either something went wrong in resizing or what but that is definitely not a picture that is giving credit to this lens, sorry to say this.
For that large distance, I don't think the lens+D3100 combination can produce anything better. It was taken with Continuous focus mode which is not very responsive in the 3100 body (with super tele). This is more of the limits fully stretched ! The shot is not in perfect focus. I could still get some good shots of BIF with this combination though the keepers were one in five or so. However, possibility of capturing critical moments like gulls catching the fish depends more on luck. For three hours, I was trying out all focus modes/ISO/Speed/Aperture combinations to better understand the limitations of the combination of this lens and D3100. Took some 400 shots in all !