fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2014Critique - REICHMAN

  
 
TTLKurtis
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Critique - REICHMAN
TRReichman wrote:
morby wrote3. To be completely honest, your photography is solid, but it doesn't stand out among the sea of other photographers out there. I know that branding goes way beyond our photographs, but as a casual viewer, I wouldn't know the difference between you and someone charging much less. In your podcasts you've said that you don't go epic anymore, which is fine, but what else about your photography makes you stand out in a crowd? I think you can stay away from epic and still create photographs that cause someone to say you're different. I'd love to look at a blog post and say, "this is whatTodd Reichman is about".
Just so everyone knows, I'm hoping that my responses don't come off as defensive at all. I'm just trying to explain the thought process behind the things that may not work for you. I'm still interested in what people think - (more on that in a second).

This comment from Mike stood out to me. I totally get the impulse for the photography to be the thing that sets you apart from the sea of photographers. To be honest though, I'm not interested in creating a TR signature image. I'm more concerned with featuring my clients. For me it isn't about
...Show more →

Well for one thing, you could become Jewish, dumdum.
Aug 29, 2014 at 05:31 PM
DannyBostwick
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Critique - REICHMAN
TRReichman wrote:
DannyBostwick wroteThis is sort of a separate conversation from what mikes talking about, but how often to you find yourself saying, "that looks like shit", "this just isn't working", "Ah-ha! There it is!!", those are the frantic of thoughts of someone trying new things. I would guess, and maybe I am way off base, (I am probably way off base), that isn't your thought process. I would guess, and again, I am probably way off base, that your thought process is, "I have 60 minutes to do family portraits, bridal party, and b&g portraits before this high end wedding planner starts beating me with a club, I better get this right the first time" I know at your price point and brand, that you facilitate some things that we all may not know about, a lot of which has little to do with photos, and a lot to do with scheduling and client accommodation.
To be honest, you're right - I don't find myself in a "this isn't working" scenario at weddings. That isn't because I'm so awesome, just because I tend to focus on getting better at the "safe" images and improving what I'm already good at rather than worrying about doing something else. For instance, in the scenario that Mike presented above, you could say that the "safe" shot was in the can and worry about the silhouette. But I think that safe shot could be done much better. I'd rather have a cleaner shot with no tilt, and without the frame
...Show more →
DannyBostwick wroteThat's what I feel is the "safe shot", and "safe" has such a negative connotation to it, I feel efficient and consistent is the right word. From what I understand at ~7-10K price points, leaving anything up to "artistic interpretation" may not be a good and sustainable business decision. That may work for me at 3-4K weddings, but not someone paying 10k. Just a thought process, I'm probably a rambling idiot who is totally wrong and subtly insulting you, I promise I am not doing it on purpose.


"Take what you already do well, and do it better" That's a novel approach. Thanks for that tid bit. See, your so awesome, I came to your thread to critique and I am the one that got something out of it. I feel like I owe you a beer.
Aug 29, 2014 at 07:25 PM
dhp_sf
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Critique - REICHMAN
First of all, I have mad respect for your way of thinking. And I probably model my approach to photography closer towards your philosophy than what you might think.

As for how to grow on a photographic level, I have some thoughts that you may or may not disagree with, but I guess just to throw it out there:

The main thing for me is your use of flash during reception. It looks like there's quite a lot of fill in all of the photos (which I get since you're featuring people). But I think it does take away from the atmosphere of where they are since we don't get the feel for the ambient. I personally aim to shoot how something feels, but this probably goes against your M.O. since that requires you to interpret the feeling of the place. Maybe there is a way to talk with your clients about the vision and aesthetic that they're excited about in their wedding (alongside the other important stuff, obviously) and start incorporating more shots that reflect the mood.

Honestly if you start doing silhouettes and stuff I think it would look totally out of place in your body of work, but I think you could maybe play around with the reception lighting a bit. There looks like there's more use of directional lighting in your work earlier in the day, and then it gets flatter for the reception. It's certainly not bad (and in fact it I'm sure people are quite happy with it), but I think it may be an area that you could stretch if you wanted to.
Aug 29, 2014 at 08:09 PM
DannyBostwick
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Critique - REICHMAN
dhp_sf wrote:
Honestly if you start doing silhouettes and stuff I think it would look totally out of place in your body of work, but I think you could maybe play around with the reception lighting a bit. There looks like there's more use of directional lighting in your work earlier in the day, and then it gets flatter for the reception. It's certainly not bad (and in fact it I'm sure people are quite happy with it), but I think it may be an area that you could stretch if you wanted to.


Even pull out the PLM umbrella or a big octobox for a really well done portrait. Think Annie Leibowitz. Something easily consistent with brand and not too over the top. It's not trendy, it's just better. Another step to making a basic, timeless portrait, better.
Aug 29, 2014 at 08:45 PM
morby
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Critique - REICHMAN
I'd echo what Duy said. At times your photos have dimension and depth, mostly because of directional lighting, and at other times they fall flat. Bringing more depth to your photos through lighting would enhance your photography, without sacrificing your style or approach.
Aug 29, 2014 at 08:47 PM
morby
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Critique - REICHMAN
TRReichman wrote:
For instance, in the scenario that Mike presented above, you could say that the "safe" shot was in the can and worry about the silhouette. But I think that safe shot could be done much better. I'd rather have a cleaner shot with no tilt, and without the frame bisecting her head. I'd rather not have the artist's hand covering her face. If the artist is important, I'd rather wait for a moment where their relationship is more evident. If the artist isn't important, I'd rather clip them in a more logical point of the body instead of a medial
...Show more →

Good point.
Aug 29, 2014 at 08:47 PM
BSPhotog
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Critique - REICHMAN
TRR,
I am so green at this wedding thing that I don't have any solid advice for you. I just wanted to say that it was a pleasure to read your responses. You have a very clear idea of what you're creating for your clients--and the results speak for themselves. All of photography is a distortion of some kind, but your images do seem to carry a sense of honesty and authority about them. More interesting lighting was brought up as a way to improve, but I think that would certainly affect the overall sense of the images (not necessarily for the worse, but not necessarily better either).

If you're looking for a way to make some changes to your look without changing technique or approach directly, my first thought would be to change up some of your equipment. I don't mean that you need to go out and buy a bunch of new stuff (though that can be fun), but even just deliberately choosing what you get to use for an event (see Lars von Trier's "The Five Obstructions"). You can, and perhaps should, take this input with a grain of salt since I'm coming at it from a very different background. Switching some lenses would just be an example, but not allowing on camera flash would be another example. This does pose somewhat of a risk of deviating from the well executed, safe images--but then again maybe not. It could just an opportunity for you to use your well honed skills to tackle the situations in a way that is different from what you'd normally do.

I'm looking forward to seeing where this thread/discussion goes. Thanks for engaging the conversation.
Aug 29, 2014 at 09:32 PM
bthatton
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Critique - REICHMAN
http://www.reichmanphotography.com/2014/04/03/emily-and-michael-the-st-regis-atlanta-wedding/

I went through and chose a random wedding... but this one is basically what I'm basing my comments on. Haven't looked at your work in a long while so it was fun to take a look.

This is what I really enjoyed and I think newbies should take notice to:

- For this particular client... I can't imagine them actually wanting anything different whatsoever from what you delivered.

- I love how architectural your work is. Lines are straight (horizontally and vertically) in the background when possible. The environment always seems to influence the composition ... and generally it's subtle. It makes it look more polished and professional before considering anything else.

- There is only maybe 5% "modern" wedding photography BS. I am a believer that anything we do at weddings to be "creative" that doesn't exist in any other forms of photography is 100% the same as selective color, jumping shots, fisheye, peeking around corners, etc. It's so refreshing to see tried and true methods of photography executed well. You get a sense of the people, not the photographer.

- Your color is beautiful and consistent.

- Exposure is impressively consistent.

The thing I would say.... while I strive for your consistency I am still a bit haphazard. I feel like that can bring a bit more of a human element to buttoned up weddings. You never break the rules so it feels maybe a little cold even if a moment is touching. I never get the idea that you saw something happening and just barely caught the moment shooting from the hip. It looks like you were prepared, of course it was going to happen, and you got it. If you were hanging out with family, you probably wouldn't have your camera out at every moment to capture every little thing perfectly. You'd see someone doing something that you wanted to remember, whip your smartphone out... and take a shitty picture, almost missing it, of something meaningful.

That's what would make me personally consider hiring someone else over you.

That being said... these people want exactly what you gave them.
Aug 30, 2014 at 07:35 AM
Inku Yo
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Critique - REICHMAN
Clean, classic, no trickery, just photography.
Aug 30, 2014 at 08:16 AM
TRReichman
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Critique - REICHMAN
bthatton wrote:
http://www.reichmanphotography.com/2014/04/03/emily-and-michael-the-st-regis-atlanta-wedding/

I went through and chose a random wedding... but this one is basically what I'm basing my comments on. Haven't looked at your work in a long while so it was fun to take a look.

This is what I really enjoyed and I think newbies should take notice to:...


Thanks Brian, that means a lot. For those that don't know Brian Hatton is my favorite wedding photographer.

bthatton wrote:
The thing I would say.... while I strive for your consistency I am still a bit haphazard. I feel like that can bring a bit more of a human element to buttoned up weddings. You never break the rules so it feels maybe a little cold even if a moment is touching. I never get the idea that you saw something happening and just barely caught the moment shooting from the hip. It looks like you were prepared, of course it was going to happen, and you got it. If you were hanging out with family, you probably wouldn't have
...Show more →

This is something that I wonder about. On a philosophical level, I've sort of rebelled against this idea. I think it has become something of a trend for people to adopt that idea that imperfections make things more "real" or "authentic." I think this had lead to people adopting a more lax attitude towards composition and technical craft. We've basically rejected that idea. Having said that, I'm open to the idea that there is a quality that might be missing in my work, and I'm curious about what process it would take to get there?

- trr
Aug 30, 2014 at 08:59 AM
D. Diggler
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Critique - REICHMAN
TRReichman wrote:
I'm open to the idea that there is a quality that might be missing in my work, and I'm curious about what process it would take to get there?


A prism?
Aug 30, 2014 at 09:28 AM
bthatton
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Critique - REICHMAN
TRReichman wrote:
bthatton wrotehttp://www.reichmanphotography.com/2014/04/03/emily-and-michael-the-st-regis-atlanta-wedding/

I went through and chose a random wedding... but this one is basically what I'm basing my comments on. Haven't looked at your work in a long while so it was fun to take a look.

This is what I really enjoyed and I think newbies should take notice to:...
Thanks Brian, that means a lot. For those that don't know Brian Hatton is my favorite wedding photographer.

bthatton wroteThe thing I would say.... while I strive for your consistency I am still a bit haphazard. I feel like that can bring a bit more of a human element to buttoned up weddings. You never break the rules so it feels maybe a little cold even if a moment is touching. I never get the idea that you saw something happening and just barely caught the moment shooting from the hip. It looks like you were prepared, of course it was going to happen, and you got it. If you were hanging out with family, you probably wouldn't have your camera out at every moment to capture every little thing perfectly. You'd see someone doing something that you wanted to remember, whip your smartphone out... and take a shitty picture, almost missing it, of something meaningful.

That's what would make me personally consider hiring someone else over you.
This is something that I wonder about. On a philosophical level, I've sort of rebelled against this idea. I think it has become something of a trend for people to adopt that idea that imperfections make things more "real" or "authentic." I think this had lead to people adopting a more lax attitude towards composition and technical craft. We've basically rejected that idea. Having said that, I'm open to the idea that there is a quality that might be missing in my work,
...Show more →


You're too kind!

Actually, I went back to your website and looked through the opening slide show which I didn't look at before. Those pictures all have that in the moment feel I was looking for. I'd hire ya based on the first page alone. Take more of those! lol
Aug 30, 2014 at 10:31 AM
Brian Virts
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Critique - REICHMAN
TRReichman wrote:
By not featuring a bunch of bride and groom drama shots and a bunch of ceremony or procedural images instead (for example) we're telling the market what we think matters. It is very calculated, but it probably should be boring to you guys.

- trr


And therein lies the beauty of this industry. We're all saying and resonating different things to the market by our work. We make it what we want it to be and clients either respond to that or not. There is no "right way". Your stuff is well done, and obviously very calculated. Cheers to your new family.
Aug 30, 2014 at 03:09 PM
mineymole
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Critique - REICHMAN
I'd hire you in a second if I was looking for timeless, meaningful, classic, elegant images. Love it all.
Aug 30, 2014 at 08:20 PM
Brian Virts
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Critique - REICHMAN
Yeah, I hope I'm not coming off like the villain here, I'm actually glad I said what I said because of the conversation it evoked. I think for me though, I'd be looking for something different, and that's not saying I don't appreciate his imagery. I totally understand where Todd is in his life, with his humble "in the service of" approach for all his clients, the venue/vendors, I totally get what he's doing. It makes sense to be that solid and safe where he is in life. I rarely look at other photographers work anymore, but I think it's a good exercise to take a peek and understand where others are, but in no way do I ever draw any comparisons.
Aug 31, 2014 at 05:59 AM
TRReichman
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Critique - REICHMAN
I don't think you come off as a villain Brian. I sound like a jerk because I'm basically refuting all the critique.

- trr
Aug 31, 2014 at 06:28 AM
TRReichman
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Critique - REICHMAN
P.S. - I'm shooting a wedding today - what should I try? Assignments welcome.


- trr
Aug 31, 2014 at 07:03 AM
jmraso
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Critique - REICHMAN

TRReichman wrote:
P.S. - I'm shooting a wedding today - what should I try? Assignments welcome.

- trr


main camera in your right hand for the safe shot and a small camera with a wide in your left hand for that different shot, you will be taking the to shots at the same time, I saw a Guy from NY city doings this and tried it, it really works !!
Aug 31, 2014 at 07:28 AM
D. Diggler
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Critique - REICHMAN
jmraso wrote:
main camera in your right hand for the safe shot and a small camera with a wide in your left hand for that different shot, you will be taking the to shots at the same time


How is that presented? You show both shots? Pick yer favorite?

Sep 01, 2014 at 08:37 PM
jmraso
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Critique - REICHMAN
D. Diggler wrote:
jmraso wrotemain camera in your right hand for the safe shot and a small camera with a wide in your left hand for that different shot, you will be taking the to shots at the same time
How is that presented? You show both shots? Pick yer favorite?




Just like different shots !!!

(Go to minute 8)

Sep 02, 2014 at 05:02 AM
FM ForumsPeople, Portraits & WeddingsJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister