fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2014Critique - REICHMAN

  
 
TRReichman
Offline

p.1 #1Critique - REICHMAN
I'm not big on pushing my work in front of other photographers for a number of reasons. But based on certain discussions that have been going on I'm somewhat curious to hear what people will say.

www.reichmanphotography.com

You can check out my blog if you want current work. I will say (no excuses) that because of personal reasons (my wife and I had our first child) the last several weddings weren't actually "our" weddings (my wife and mine) but were instead shot by our associate. Those weddings should be labelled. They don't represent the type of event we normally do as well, nor do they completely comply with the rules we set down for our work (we're still training). So if you're going to judge on the blog go back a ways.

But I'm curious...

- trr
Aug 28, 2014 at 07:51 PM
morby
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Critique - REICHMAN
Hey Todd! If it says "Reichman by Ashleigh" is that your associate? It looks like the last 3 weddings were hers?

Edited on Aug 29, 2014 at 07:37 AM · View previous versions
Aug 28, 2014 at 09:06 PM
dhp_sf
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Critique - REICHMAN
The thing that strikes me about your work is how ridiculously consistent it is. Admittedly, it is hard to give your work a critique because of what I know of you through FM and how I feel like you have things down to a science based on your target clientele and everything.

It all feels very genuine and honest. There's something deceptively simple about it. Or maybe it is simple. I don't know, but to me, this feels like the kind of work that the couple and their families would never look back and say "what was he thinking?" And there's never any question about what is going on or where people are in the photographs.

Personally, I feel like the blog goes on forever and it would be hard for me to look through many weddings, but I'm sure you have a reason to do it the way you do.
Aug 28, 2014 at 09:22 PM
DannyBostwick
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Critique - REICHMAN
Yeah, I view your work in the same camp as Duy's. Any negative critique I could would give would really be just nitpicking for the sake of nitpicking. There's no real trends or bad habits. I suppose that my only real critique is that they are all really safe shots. I don't feel you take a lot of chances and try new things, however I have a slight understanding of your brand and client base, and I don't think that "chances and new things" fit what you do for your clients. You don't brand yourself off "epic", so I guess now wouldn't be the time to change things when your making plenty of money and enjoying what you do. No weird fireworks or visual trickery, just good, honest, truthful photography. Good stuff.
Aug 29, 2014 at 05:57 AM
morby
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Critique - REICHMAN
Like many others here, I've followed you for a while and you've had a huge impact on my business. However, I rarely look at your images, so this was new for me.

Your photography is really consistent from start to finish. I can tell that you've been shooting for a while, because every wedding is different, yet you get the same results over and over again. Your formals are always posed really well and your lighting is consistent.

For critique...

1. You seem to play it safe each wedding. You know what you need to get and you get it. That's not a bad thing (I do the same thing), but that could cause complacency and missed shots. I say missed shots, because every wedding has unique moments, lighting and scenes that might get overlooked because they don't fit into what you normally look for and shoot. Try getting what you need to get, then stepping back and seeing if there is anything different that you don't normally see.

2. Some photos seem to miss focus. Soft photos are inevitable throughout the day, but unless it's an amazing moment, or intentional, they shouldn't be blogged IMO.

3. To be completely honest, your photography is solid, but it doesn't stand out among the sea of other photographers out there. I know that branding goes way beyond our photographs, but as a casual viewer, I wouldn't know the difference between you and someone charging much less. In your podcasts you've said that you don't go epic anymore, which is fine, but what else about your photography makes you stand out in a crowd? I think you can stay away from epic and still create photographs that cause someone to say you're different. I'd love to look at a blog post and say, "this is whatTodd Reichman is about".

4. I think you over blog a little bit. The great photographs get lost when they are mixed in with too many good photographs. Photographs are a part of your brand, so which ones support your brand the most? My guess would be well done formals, high end venues, moments that show the type of wedding, etc.

5. I'm announcing my first associate in September, so I've been thinking a lot about how to go about it. This is a personal preference, but I think that you should do a better job at differentiating your associate's photos from your own. If you don't feel that she is "there" yet, it has the potential to weaken your brand. When someone goes to view your website, they might not realize that they are viewing your associates photos, and think less of your brand than you want them to. For me, I'm creating a separate website for my associate so that he has his own galleries, blog, pricing, etc. It will be linked from my site, but I don't want people to get confused on which photographer they are viewing.

I hope that helps! You've helped my business more than you can imagine, so I hope I returned the favor in a small way.
Aug 29, 2014 at 07:37 AM
D. Diggler
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Critique - REICHMAN
TRReichman wrote:
based on certain discussions that have been going on I'm somewhat curious to hear what people will say


I'm surprised that you got involved in this game.

Aug 29, 2014 at 08:12 AM
TRReichman
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Critique - REICHMAN
Hey Mike - what's the protocol on responses? The last thing you want to do is sound defensive in a critique, but I think that some of the reasons that I do things people have pointed out might be helpful.

So for those of you that have pointed out "going beyond the safe shot" how would you recommend doing that? What does that look like? Or is there a process that makes that happen? How do you know when you have done it?

- trr
Aug 29, 2014 at 08:22 AM
morby
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Critique - REICHMAN
I don't think there is any protocol. A reasoning would be helpful in allowing us to understand why you do the things you do.

For me, going beyond the safe shot means seeing if there is something further that can be done with what I'm given. I always get the safe shots first, then look for something that might make the photograph stronger. A safe shot has a good composition, it's well lit and technically solid. It should document the scene and be done really well. Going beyond that I would look for different angles, posing, focal lengths, lighting. If I always go for the creative and different first, but it doesn't work, I might miss the moment, which is what they've hired me to capture.

TRReichman wrote:
Hey Mike - what's the protocol on responses? The last thing you want to do is sound defensive in a critique, but I think that some of the reasons that I do things people have pointed out might be helpful.

So for those of you that have pointed out "going beyond the safe shot" how would you recommend doing that? What does that look like? Or is there a process that makes that happen? How do you know when you have done it?

- trr

Aug 29, 2014 at 08:38 AM
TRReichman
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Critique - REICHMAN
morby wrote:
For me, going beyond the safe shot means seeing if there is something further that can be done with what I'm given. I always get the safe shots first, then look for something that might make the photograph stronger. A safe shot has a good composition, it's well lit and technically solid. It should document the scene and be done really well. Going beyond that I would look for different angles, posing, focal lengths, lighting. If I always go for the creative and different first, but it doesn't work, I might miss the moment, which is what they've hired me
...Show more →

CAn you show any examples?

- trr
Aug 29, 2014 at 08:45 AM
morby
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Critique - REICHMAN
Eventually. I'm outside rebuilding my firepit today taking FM breaks

TRReichman wrote:
morby wroteFor me, going beyond the safe shot means seeing if there is something further that can be done with what I'm given. I always get the safe shots first, then look for something that might make the photograph stronger. A safe shot has a good composition, it's well lit and technically solid. It should document the scene and be done really well. Going beyond that I would look for different angles, posing, focal lengths, lighting. If I always go for the creative and different first, but it doesn't work, I might miss the moment, which is what they've hired me to capture.
CAn you show any examples?

- trr

Aug 29, 2014 at 08:49 AM
jmraso
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Critique - REICHMAN


morby wrote:
FM breaks



Love it !!! 😊😊😊
Aug 29, 2014 at 08:51 AM
morby
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Critique - REICHMAN
Here is a quick example. Maybe not the best, but it gets the point across. While she was getting her makeup done I did a basic side lit photo. Then I changed my angle, focal length and did a silhouette. If I only delivered the silhouette I don't think I would have done my job...

http://morbyphotography.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/Cait-and-Evan-039.jpg

http://morbyphotography.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/Cait-and-Evan-045.jpg

morby wrote:
Eventually. I'm outside rebuilding my firepit today taking FM breaks

TRReichman wrote
morby wroteFor me, going beyond the safe shot means seeing if there is something further that can be done with what I'm given. I always get the safe shots first, then look for something that might make the photograph stronger. A safe shot has a good composition, it's well lit and technically solid. It should document the scene and be done really well. Going beyond that I would look for different angles, posing, focal lengths, lighting. If I always go for the creative and different first, but it doesn't work, I might miss the moment, which is what they've hired me to capture.
CAn you show any examples?

- trr

Aug 29, 2014 at 08:55 AM
DannyBostwick
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Critique - REICHMAN
This is sort of a separate conversation from what mikes talking about, but how often to you find yourself saying, "that looks like shit", "this just isn't working", "Ah-ha! There it is!!", those are the frantic of thoughts of someone trying new things. I would guess, and maybe I am way off base, (I am probably way off base), that isn't your thought process. I would guess, and again, I am probably way off base, that your thought process is, "I have 60 minutes to do family portraits, bridal party, and b&g portraits before this high end wedding planner starts beating me with a club, I better get this right the first time" I know at your price point and brand, that you facilitate some things that we all may not know about, a lot of which has little to do with photos, and a lot to do with scheduling and client accommodation.

That's what I feel is the "safe shot", and "safe" has such a negative connotation to it, I feel efficient and consistent is the right word. From what I understand at ~7-10K price points, leaving anything up to "artistic interpretation" may not be a good and sustainable business decision. That may work for me at 3-4K weddings, but not someone paying 10k. Just a thought process, I'm probably a rambling idiot who is totally wrong and subtly insulting you, I promise I am not doing it on purpose.
Aug 29, 2014 at 09:19 AM
morby
Offline
Details
p.1 #14Critique - REICHMAN
I think we are saying basically the same thing. Consitent, efficient, safe shots (whatever you'd call it) are undervalued in our industry. Creativity is praised, consistency is boring. It's like buying a phone that has ton of amazing features, but keeps dropping calls or the battery dies within an hour. The features can be awesome, but if it doesn't do the basics well, it's not a good product.

Same goes with photography. Creativity and pushing the limits can serve to strengthen a brand and set it apart, but if we don't handle the basics, we will most likely disappoint a lot of clients.

Sorry if we are getting too off topic!

DannyBostwick wrote:
This is sort of a separate conversation from what mikes talking about, but how often to you find yourself saying, "that looks like shit", "this just isn't working", "Ah-ha! There it is!!", those are the frantic of thoughts of someone trying new things. I would guess, and maybe I am way off base, (I am probably way off base), that isn't your thought process. I would guess, and again, I am probably way off base, that your thought process is, "I have 60 minutes to do family portraits, bridal party, and b&g portraits before this high end wedding planner starts
...Show more →
Aug 29, 2014 at 09:48 AM
Ian Ivey
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Critique - REICHMAN
Meh. The wedding stuff is okay, but we need to see more photos of babies on the blog.

[cough]
Aug 29, 2014 at 09:59 AM
Brian Virts
Offline
Details
p.1 #16Critique - REICHMAN
I'm sure you shoot and make tons more than me, so this is just FWIW. The port is cool, very b&w PJ, I thought you were a color guy? The blog posts are way too long for me, I got lost and bailed. It's just too much information at a time, one and half weddings and I was out, not engaged or wanting more, like when I hear a good piece of music. Tone was good, it seems like you shoot a lot of f4+, which is cool. I would have just liked to see some (more)dramatic lower aperture shots. Overall, very high-end look to the site, incredibly consistent and professional.
Aug 29, 2014 at 12:36 PM
J Knight
Offline
Details
p.1 #17Critique - REICHMAN
I don't have a comment on your work (not checked it out yet) but I wanted to say congratulations to you and your wife. I hope all is going well. Boy or Girl ?

I am also curious, how did your clients deal with you stepping back from work for a bit?

Happy families to you both and thanks for all the podcasts you did. :-)
Aug 29, 2014 at 03:04 PM
TRReichman
Offline
Details
p.1 #18Critique - REICHMAN
DannyBostwick wrote:
This is sort of a separate conversation from what mikes talking about, but how often to you find yourself saying, "that looks like shit", "this just isn't working", "Ah-ha! There it is!!", those are the frantic of thoughts of someone trying new things. I would guess, and maybe I am way off base, (I am probably way off base), that isn't your thought process. I would guess, and again, I am probably way off base, that your thought process is, "I have 60 minutes to do family portraits, bridal party, and b&g portraits before this high end wedding planner starts
...Show more →

To be honest, you're right - I don't find myself in a "this isn't working" scenario at weddings. That isn't because I'm so awesome, just because I tend to focus on getting better at the "safe" images and improving what I'm already good at rather than worrying about doing something else. For instance, in the scenario that Mike presented above, you could say that the "safe" shot was in the can and worry about the silhouette. But I think that safe shot could be done much better. I'd rather have a cleaner shot with no tilt, and without the frame bisecting her head. I'd rather not have the artist's hand covering her face. If the artist is important, I'd rather wait for a moment where their relationship is more evident. If the artist isn't important, I'd rather clip them in a more logical point of the body instead of a medial bisect. I'd rather find an image that gives more context to what is happening in the room.

The silhouette in this example, is featuring a photographic technique instead of featuring people. It draws attention to the photographic process instead of the content. I think that these days photographers dismiss the "safe" stuff too quickly.

DannyBostwick wrote:
That's what I feel is the "safe shot", and "safe" has such a negative connotation to it, I feel efficient and consistent is the right word. From what I understand at ~7-10K price points, leaving anything up to "artistic interpretation" may not be a good and sustainable business decision. That may work for me at 3-4K weddings, but not someone paying 10k. Just a thought process, I'm probably a rambling idiot who is totally wrong and subtly insulting you, I promise I am not doing it on purpose.


I'm in a position to get asked for advice from a lot of people that have angry clients. Almost everything that I've seen that leads to angry clients is weak "safe" shots. Photographers tend to say "look at all this great creative stuff I got" and the client says, "where is all the safe stuff you missed or phoned in?" That just seems to be magnified at the higher price points.

Don't worry, you won't insult me BTW. I take what I do seriously, but I don't take it personally.

- trr
Aug 29, 2014 at 04:57 PM
TRReichman
Offline
Details
p.1 #19Critique - REICHMAN
Brian Virts wrote:
I'm sure you shoot and make tons more than me, so this is just FWIW. The port is cool, very b&w PJ, I thought you were a color guy? The blog posts are way too long for me, I got lost and bailed. It's just too much information at a time, one and half weddings and I was out, not engaged or wanting more, like when I hear a good piece of music. Tone was good, it seems like you shoot a lot of f4+, which is cool. I would have just liked to see some (more)dramatic lower aperture
...Show more →

For the first 5 years of my career I shot everything between f1.2-2.0. It was a crutch. In my opinion super-shallow DOF is for featuring a single subject. It is great for a portrait of one person because the technique forces the audience's attention on the subject. The problem for me is that I only take 2 total portraits of single people on the wedding day. I'll probably do one single portrait of the groom by himself, and maybe 1-3 portraits of the bride alone. Beyond that, every photo needs to be about the relationship between 2 people. If a photo is about 2 people, I believe that more than one of their eyelashes needs to be in focus.

A big criteria for us is "what is this photo about?" If the photo is about how clever we are, or our ability to execute a photographic technique, we don't feature it, and probably won't include it or even shoot it. That's just our criteria. We work to make the photos about how people demonstrably feel about each other.

I can totally understand why photographers want drama, but my clients aren't interested in having my idea of drama painted on them (I'm not really interested in creating drama on them either). I'm finding this interesting because it is highlighting the difference between what attracts a photographer and what resonates with a client.

Also, a word on the long blog posts. I totally get why they don't work for photographers, there isn't much interesting in there for you. But I've found that there is a certain list of content that needs to be included for every wedding. Also, the relative amounts of what we show lets the market know what we believe is important. By not featuring a bunch of bride and groom drama shots and a bunch of ceremony or procedural images instead (for example) we're telling the market what we think matters. It is very calculated, but it probably should be boring to you guys.

- trr
Aug 29, 2014 at 05:06 PM
TRReichman
Offline
Details
p.1 #20Critique - REICHMAN
morby wrote:
3. To be completely honest, your photography is solid, but it doesn't stand out among the sea of other photographers out there. I know that branding goes way beyond our photographs, but as a casual viewer, I wouldn't know the difference between you and someone charging much less. In your podcasts you've said that you don't go epic anymore, which is fine, but what else about your photography makes you stand out in a crowd? I think you can stay away from epic and still create photographs that cause someone to say you're different. I'd love to look at a
...Show more →

Just so everyone knows, I'm hoping that my responses don't come off as defensive at all. I'm just trying to explain the thought process behind the things that may not work for you. I'm still interested in what people think - (more on that in a second).

This comment from Mike stood out to me. I totally get the impulse for the photography to be the thing that sets you apart from the sea of photographers. To be honest though, I'm not interested in creating a TR signature image. I'm more concerned with featuring my clients. For me it isn't about the technique at all, and I'm not interested in being "different" on a photo-technique basis. I don't think that clients can see that. I want things to be elegant, sophisticated, mature and discreet. That means the photography itself can't really stand out. And the blog posts are long because instead of trying to have signature shots, I'm trying to brand the community I work in. You guys won't know them, but a number of the people featured are important in their communities. I'm trying to brand who I work with less than what I'm doing with the camera.

The trouble that I'm having, and the reason that I posted this is that I'm not sure what direction to try and grow in on a photographic level that would be in alignment with what my clients want. Still looking for advice or insight on that.

- trr
Aug 29, 2014 at 05:19 PM
FM ForumsPeople, Portraits & WeddingsJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister