p.3 #1Canon 1dx vs Nikon d810 for portraits in non scientific environment ;)
justruss wrote:
At the same time: I find some of the responses in this thread fairly rude. Piling on the OP, and posting things like "Stupidest. Test. Ever." doesn't help this community foster a friendly environment (for new or veteran members), and help others interested in conducting tests get an idea of how to conduct such a test in a more useful manner. Hell, it might prevent people from conducting tests at all-- if mistakes are only to be responded to with mirthful mockery instead of constructive criticism or discussion.
But that's what the anonymity of the 'net does, it enable people to feel big and important as they know they have little chance of actually having the crap beaten out of them the way they would if they said these things face to face.
I see the OP's test as very flawed but the methodology of the test has become the issue as there isn't really that much between the cameras in image quality
p.3 #2Canon 1dx vs Nikon d810 for portraits in non scientific environment ;)
dhphoto wrote: justruss wroteAt the same time: I find some of the responses in this thread fairly rude. Piling on the OP, and posting things like "Stupidest. Test. Ever." doesn't help this community foster a friendly environment (for new or veteran members), and help others interested in conducting tests get an idea of how to conduct such a test in a more useful manner. Hell, it might prevent people from conducting tests at all-- if mistakes are only to be responded to with mirthful mockery instead of constructive criticism or discussion.But that's what the anonymity of the 'net does, it enable people to feel big and important as they know they have little chance of actually having the crap beaten out of them the way they would if they said these things face to face.
I see the OP's test as very flawed but the methodology of the test has become the issue as there isn't really that much between the cameras in image quality
I totally agree that everything is unfortunately turning into an argument or an insult exchange, however, the OP's attitude doesn't help at all. Usually when someone posts a test they would be willing to answer questions, try something different, take recommendations, be unbiased, etc...However, the OP posted these two images, labelled his thread as D1X vs. D810 and has closed the door to any suggestions, requests or recommendations from members who are really interested in the results. It's a combination of confirmation bias & cherry picking and that's my objection at least, in fact I checked the OPs website and I love his wedding photography, I was just hoping for more objectivity.
p.3 #5Canon 1dx vs Nikon d810 for portraits in non scientific environment ;)
Trevorma wrote:
Molson...... I think I diagnosed the issue with your D800 in your comparison.... You will get better results if you remove the lens cap
No need... with that Sony sensor, you can pull enough detail out of the blacks to actually see through the lens cap!
p.3 #7Canon 1dx vs Nikon d810 for portraits in non scientific environment ;)
I for one don't mind this test. It proably shows the Nikon lens was slightly front-focused but overall they both have about the same amount of detail in it. The portrait photography was always one of the "less demanding" types of photography however. You could easily blow up the 1Dx photo to much larger prints than 24x36" with this kind of sharpness. The Nikon colors are plain ugly and have a green cast. The Canon colors have a bit more purple tones (I'm judging this on a terrible laptop monitor) but it's nowhere as distracting as the green tones in Nikon.
As others pointed out, Nikon would be better in landscape photography. But I'm sure 1Dx wouldn't be bad either, because my 1D Mark IV used-mostly-for-landscapes gives me plenty details for 24x36" prints. It just needs proper on site capture, PP and sharpening, which many seem to neglect and/or doing improperly.
p.3 #8Canon 1dx vs Nikon d810 for portraits in non scientific environment ;)
The great thing about feeling that the 1DX is good enough for any possible application is that owners won't need to upgrade to the next Canon any more than they are interested in looking into the D810!
p.3 #9Canon 1dx vs Nikon d810 for portraits in non scientific environment ;)
bernardl wrote:
The great thing about feeling that the 1DX is good enough for any possible application is that owners won't need to upgrade to the next Canon any more than they are interested in looking into the D810!
Anyone that thinks that the 1DX is not good enough for any possible application is misguided. It may not be optimized for all applications but given the current state of DSLR's they all are amazingly versatile pieces of equipment. The same can be said of the D810.
If there is something you can't do with either one, then the fault lies with the user not the gear.
p.3 #10Canon 1dx vs Nikon d810 for portraits in non scientific environment ;)
ggreene wrote: bernardl wroteThe great thing about feeling that the 1DX is good enough for any possible application is that owners won't need to upgrade to the next Canon any more than they are interested in looking into the D810! Anyone that thinks that the 1DX is not good enough for any possible application is misguided. It may not be optimized for all applications but given the current state of DSLR's they all are amazingly versatile pieces of equipment. The same can be said of the D810.
If there is something you can't do with either one, then the fault lies with the user not the gear.
p.3 #12Canon 1dx vs Nikon d810 for portraits in non scientific environment ;)
Thorsten wrote: isaacimage wroteHello dear friends
I'm shooting people mostly and was very interested in this comparison,
So for those who is also interested here we goThank you for sharing this! And I would not worry about the negative comments. It looks some folks will require a thesis project to be done before any comparison can be posted, and even then would probably find issues. I do those quick and dirty comparisons like yours all the time to get an initial feeling how certain combos work.
p.3 #13Canon 1dx vs Nikon d810 for portraits in non scientific environment ;)
dehowie wrote:
Mmm i forgot we shoot portrait work from tripods using Sigma lenses.
Better leave the 85L and G in the cabinet.
Wtf would you test two cameras with a third party lens and all of the AF issues that can cause?
You test with the brand lens they will use in the real world.
This allows both systems the best chance to show what they can do in the "real" world.