fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2014So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO

  
 
macrobild
Offline
Details
p.4 #1So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
thats not more noise, d800 together with for example Camera Raw and Adobe standard is twisting the lower levels as the shadow at the wall due not holding the black point properly, one thing which is better in d810, remove all colors and you can se it is a different s-curve /contrast curve regarding the shadow at the wall
Aug 20, 2014 at 04:32 PM
shutterbug guy
Offline
Details
p.4 #2So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
macrobild wrote:
ggreene wrote
macrobild wroteAnd you where looking at the same file size as Canons and higher iso?. Sorry no way the 1dmk4 looks better at high iso than d800, because it is a physical impossibility and you are looking at that case at noise reduction and not resolution and details. You are spreading myths like many others about d800-810 high iso reproduction and that is a reason why Im doing this little comparison which clearly shows the results from 25600ISO and between two of my cameras Canon 6D and Nikon d810
Don't know about the D810 but the D800 was not as good as my 1DX even when downsized at high ISO (6400+). A fellow sports shooter and I shot some indoor basketball in a low light gym and I thought my RAW and JPEG's looked cleaner. We synced settings and shot from the same sideline position.

Is the D810 that much better then the D800? From reading the Nikon forum many people liked the high ISO of the D800 over the D810 in one thread.
the raw d810 is cleaner due they have got rid of the visual read noise in lower levels which can be seen in d800 and high iso, Im talking about 25600iso
None of Nikons cameras has a thin CFA as Canon which are better suited for 2800K light, Nikons CFA is steeper and optimized for day light,therefore the higher color depth scores in DXO tests, the D810 results against 6D in a 2800K light and 25600iso is therefore incredible good .


So does that mean that Nikon has fixed their orange skin tones, non-functioning focus points, oil splashing shutters or thermal sensor spotting?

Aug 20, 2014 at 04:52 PM
Sneakyracer
Offline
Details
p.4 #3So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
jcolwell wrote:
macrobild wrotenew and new, the new is that d810 is even cleaner than d800 in the shadows, and much better than the Canon 6D sensor (who has less Canon banding of them all ) and even with 2 stop of less light falling in to the sensor the d810 are still better than the 6D regarding shadow noise and resolution in low levels , that may be news to some
My 6D is so bad that I bought a second one to make it feel better.

P.S. I don't need to buy a second 1DX, because my 1DIV sucks so bad that it makes the 1DX look good.



The 6D, 5D3 and the 1Dx are excellent cameras. Yes, the D810 has undoubtedly a better or more capable sensor. It does not mean the Canon's are bad or that one cannot produce amazing images using the Canon's. A lot of people here have proven that. Heck, I used my first DSLR, a Fuji S2pro to make some of my favourite images. I recently looked at raw files in my archive from that fuji and they are still good. I actually really like the color from that ccd. And yet compared to the latest and greatest that camera is a relic.

None of this makes a lot of people's observation's in regards to comparison's between the latest Nikon and Canon sensors any less valid. A lot of them are spot on.

For lot of the frequent posters in this Forum these discussions are beating a dead horse but newcomers appreciate the info.
Aug 20, 2014 at 05:07 PM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.4 #4So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
macrobild wrote:
new and new, the new is that d810 is even cleaner than d800 in the shadows, and much better than the Canon 6D sensor (who has less Canon banding of them all ) and even with 2 stop of less light falling in to the sensor the d810 are still better than the 6D regarding shadow noise and resolution in low levels , that may be news to some

jcolwell wrote:
My 6D is so bad that I bought a second one to make it feel better.

P.S. I don't need to buy a second 1DX, because my 1DIV sucks so bad that it makes the 1DX look good.



Sneakyracer wrote:
The 6D, 5D3 and the 1Dx are excellent cameras. Yes, the D810 has undoubtedly a better or more capable sensor. It does not mean the Canon's are bad or that one cannot produce amazing images using the Canon's. A lot of people here have proven that. Heck, I used my first DSLR, a Fuji S2pro to make some of my favourite images. I recently looked at raw files in my archive from that fuji and they are still good. I actually really like the color from that ccd. And yet compared to the latest and greatest that camera is
...Show more →

I agree. I also agree that the current Sony A7R / Nikon D800/D810 sensor has usefully more pixels and usefully more DR than the current Canon FF cameras. I've often said that, too. I just get exasperated by the endless repetition of these claims, made in the spirit of "why would anybody stick with Canon? They must be morons.". It pi**es me off to no end. Even though I'm a likely A7R adopter, if Canon doesn't soon produce a true competitor in terms of high MPx and improved DR. Of course, that doesn't mean that I will be selling any of my Canon stuff. Ninety percent of the equipment capability that I need to accomplish what I want to do in photography is provided by my existing Canon and Fujifilm (and Sony) cameras. It would be nice to scratch that 10% itch, but I'm trying to be patient.

Apparently, I can be more patient about waiting for new products to appear, than I can for tolerating the constant stream of biased and repetitive drivel that seems to fill almost every thread on this forum, even in threads that nominally have nothing to do with the topic; until some bright light brings it up. Fortunately, the Alt forum often has more intelligent dialogue on these matters.

I don't expect that many newcomers appreciate the dark and nasty mood in which these topics are often discussed, nor do they appreciate the poor manners that are becoming commonplace.

That's my 5 cents; there's no pennies in Canada, any more.
Aug 20, 2014 at 05:34 PM
StillFingerz
Offline
Details
p.4 #5So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
Bravo Jim, said by many before, I hope some actually listen, thanks for speaking up
Aug 20, 2014 at 05:57 PM
Sneakyracer
Offline
Details
p.4 #6So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
Regarding the 1Dx and 5D3 performance at high iso. I routinely use iso 3200 and 6400 when I am photographing on set and I find the files really superb to work on in post. That was never the case with previous generation Canon's. These high iso files have more dynamic range, better color, sharpness and the noise is MUCH less blotchy. (I asume the 6D is similar in that regard). I really push my gear to the limit. Always have. I get paid to make and deliver quality images regardless of conditions (which vary greatly in my work). No excuses. Trust me, if the Canon's could not deliver the goods I would have sold them years ago. They don't give them to me for free and I don't get paid to endorse any product and really have no issues "switching" or using other manufacturer's products.

Given how good today's top en DSLRs are there is really no substitute for doing one's own testing to determine which one is best for one's purposes before committing thousands of dollar's in a system. With several quality online photo gear rental services available it is quite easy to do and totally worth it. That would be my main advice to anyone in the market.

The DXO ratings are not completely out of touch with reality and the data is pretty good but one has to really read between the lines to make solid conclusions and like I said, its no substitute for doing some testing of your own.

And regarding the tone of some of the discussions in this and other forums regarding the subject (Nikon vs Canon) yes, some are a bit nasty. No need for that. It's always best to keep it classy.
Aug 20, 2014 at 06:16 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.4 #7So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
jcolwell wrote:
I agree. I also agree that the current Sony A7R / Nikon D800/D810 sensor has usefully more pixels and usefully more DR than the current Canon FF cameras. I've often said that, too. I just get exasperated by the endless repetition of these claims, made in the spirit of "why would anybody stick with Canon? They must be morons.". It pi**es me off to no end. Even though I'm a likely A7R adopter, if Canon doesn't soon produce a true competitor in terms of high MPx and improved DR. Of course, that doesn't mean that I will be selling
...Show more →

Well said. :-)
Aug 20, 2014 at 06:55 PM
wordfool
Offline
Details
p.4 #8So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
Can this thread just die already... it keeps dragging me in, like watching a slow train wreck!
Aug 20, 2014 at 07:12 PM
Pixel Perfect
Offline
Details
p.4 #9So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
pipspeak wrote:
Can this thread just die already... it keeps dragging me in, like watching a slow train wreck!


It's almost as much fun as watching the Kardashian's
Aug 20, 2014 at 07:29 PM
Sneakyracer
Offline
Details
p.4 #10So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
It's done, I'm sure another similar thread will pop up within a week.
Aug 20, 2014 at 07:35 PM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.4 #11So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
whumber wrote:
Here's the area where it's super noticeable, I downsampled the D800E image to match the 1DX's resolution.


That's closer then the comparison I did with a fellow sports shooter in a low light gym. We were boosting shutter a bit though at the expense of exposure to stop motion. That is suppose to be where the Exmor sensor has the advantage but not at high ISO's and the DXO graph shows that the 1DX sensor has the DR edge at the high end.

Funny how DXO says the D800 is the better low light sports sensor overall.
Aug 21, 2014 at 05:10 AM
macrobild
Offline
Details
p.4 #12So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
shutterbug guy wrote:
macrobild wrote
ggreene wrote
macrobild wroteAnd you where looking at the same file size as Canons and higher iso?. Sorry no way the 1dmk4 looks better at high iso than d800, because it is a physical impossibility and you are looking at that case at noise reduction and not resolution and details. You are spreading myths like many others about d800-810 high iso reproduction and that is a reason why Im doing this little comparison which clearly shows the results from 25600ISO and between two of my cameras Canon 6D and Nikon d810
Don't know about the D810 but the D800 was not as good as my 1DX even when downsized at high ISO (6400+). A fellow sports shooter and I shot some indoor basketball in a low light gym and I thought my RAW and JPEG's looked cleaner. We synced settings and shot from the same sideline position.

Is the D810 that much better then the D800? From reading the Nikon forum many people liked the high ISO of the D800 over the D810 in one thread.
the raw d810 is cleaner due they have got rid of the visual read noise in lower levels which can be seen in d800 and high iso, Im talking about 25600iso
None of Nikons cameras has a thin CFA as Canon which are better suited for 2800K light, Nikons CFA is steeper and optimized for day light,therefore the higher color depth scores in DXO tests, the D810 results against 6D in a 2800K light and 25600iso is therefore incredible good .
So does that mean that Nikon has fixed their orange skin tones, non-functioning focus points, oil splashing shutters or thermal sensor spotting?



orange skin tones ? if you get that it, is a question of your chosen profiles, color space etc etc , don't spread myths around you, it only shows ignorance

splashing oil seems to be popular subject , also 1dx got it , as reported.
thermal sensors, well the problem with the sensor seems to be solved now with a upgrade of firmware , not mention Canon problem with leaking light and the problem solved with tape.

If you are trying to discuss with bad arguments I can answer with all the Canon flaws during the years . not particularly fruitful discussion-or what do you think?


Edited on Aug 21, 2014 at 08:03 PM · View previous versions
Aug 21, 2014 at 07:56 PM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.4 #13So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
....

macrobild wrote:
...what do you think?


I think it's time to go out and take photos. Regardless of the positive and negative aspects of the photo gears that we 'discuss', they're all made for the same purpose; taking photos. What are you waiting for?

Show me why "yours" is better.
Aug 21, 2014 at 08:03 PM
macrobild
Offline
Details
p.4 #14So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
jcolwell wrote:
macrobild wrotenew and new, the new is that d810 is even cleaner than d800 in the shadows, and much better than the Canon 6D sensor (who has less Canon banding of them all ) and even with 2 stop of less light falling in to the sensor the d810 are still better than the 6D regarding shadow noise and resolution in low levels , that may be news to some
jcolwell wroteMy 6D is so bad that I bought a second one to make it feel better.

P.S. I don't need to buy a second 1DX, because my 1DIV sucks so bad that it makes the 1DX look good.

Sneakyracer wroteThe 6D, 5D3 and the 1Dx are excellent cameras. Yes, the D810 has undoubtedly a better or more capable sensor. It does not mean the Canon's are bad or that one cannot produce amazing images using the Canon's. A lot of people here have proven that. Heck, I used my first DSLR, a Fuji S2pro to make some of my favourite images. I recently looked at raw files in my archive from that fuji and they are still good. I actually really like the color from that ccd. And yet compared to the latest and greatest that camera is a relic.

None of this makes a lot of people's observation's in regards to comparison's between the latest Nikon and Canon sensors any less valid. A lot of them are spot on.

For lot of the frequent posters in this Forum these discussions are beating a dead horse but newcomers appreciate the info.
I agree. I also agree that the current Sony A7R / Nikon D800/D810 sensor has usefully more pixels and usefully more DR than the current Canon FF cameras. I've often said that, too. I just get exasperated by the endless repetition of these claims, made in the spirit of "why would anybody stick with Canon? They must be morons.". It pi**es me off to no end. Even though I'm a likely A7R adopter, if Canon doesn't soon produce a true competitor in terms of high MPx and improved DR. Of course, that doesn't mean that I will be selling any
...Show more →

morons or not, Im still waiting for a high resolution Canon camera with great DR to use with all my Canon lenses.
Heard about it? I will be the first to buy one

Aug 21, 2014 at 08:07 PM
macrobild
Offline
Details
p.4 #15So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
jcolwell wrote:
....

macrobild wrote...what do you think?
I think it's time to go out and take photos. Regardless of the positive and negative aspects of the photo gears that we 'discuss', they're all made for the same purpose; taking photos. What are you waiting for?

Show me why "yours" is better.



Are we not talking about preconditions ? . Just like when you are testing your lenses, one is better than another ? And you keep the best ones.
Different cameras is with me every day and the results is presented in pictures also every day, for fun or work.

Edited on Aug 21, 2014 at 08:21 PM · View previous versions
Aug 21, 2014 at 08:15 PM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.4 #16So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
macrobild wrote:
morons or not, Im still waiting for a high resolution Canon camera with great DR to use with all my Canon lenses.
Heard about it? I will be the first to buy one


Me too. I just don't like getting my nose rubbed in it.

As the ancient ones said, "what goes around, comes around".
Aug 21, 2014 at 08:17 PM
macrobild
Offline
Details
p.4 #17So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
well send me a PM when things are starting to move around in Canonland
Aug 21, 2014 at 08:20 PM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.4 #18So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
macrobild wrote:
Are we not talking about preconditions ? . Just like when you are testing your lenses, one is better than another ? And you keep the best ones.


Yes, I keep the best ones. I keep a lot of not-best ones, too.

macrobild wrote:
The camera is with me every day and the results is presented in pictures every day, for fun or work


Me too. That's why I said, "show me".
Aug 21, 2014 at 08:21 PM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.4 #19So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
macrobild wrote:
well send me a PM when things are starting to move around in Canonland


Will do.
Aug 21, 2014 at 08:22 PM
macrobild
Offline
Details
p.4 #20So Nikon D800 is better than 1D X at high ISO
Regarding pictures , google at my name is the easiest way, you get several 1000 hits, or welcome in to my FB page now when I'm about to retire after 30years. You will find pictures/videos i try to take from the air, and also about my new life with a 1 year old Riesenschnauzer dog.


Edited on Aug 21, 2014 at 08:31 PM · View previous versions
Aug 21, 2014 at 08:26 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister