Jason_Brook wrote:
They don't look $900 good IMO. I agree, they have a sterile look. I'd rather see someone shoot the Sig and 58 together, not necessarily the same image, but at least the same post processing.
The Siggy doesn't look $900 good, but the 58G looks $1600 good?
I'd agree that the 50 Art has a more sterile look to it- the 58G is Nikon's 'answer' to Canon's 50L, and has the character to compete- but I'd argue heavily that the 50 Art is still almost certainly worth the price of entry, especially if the first-party options are too expensive.
The 50 Art also comes off more as a 'utility' lens, and seems like it would fit in more with a PJ-style of shooting, something I do more; if I were looking for a pure portrait lens, I'd pay up for the 58G/50L, of course.