Ronny Olsson wrote:
Hi guys .. want some feedback on color and sharpness on my pictures on this and the previous picture .. if you don't want to infect the thread, take it through PM
Has changed to a new monitor (Dell UltraSharp UP3216Q) and my pictures look a bit different in color
so I want to know I'm not completely off
Ronny, above photo is not good example for color, as it's processing is so wild that it's obvious that aim has not been realism but instead something artistic (e.g. the masks are way way way too broad and there is severe color bleeding from sky to mountain tops, edge of mountain against sky is way too dark, mountain shape effects how sky gets darker etc. etc. etc.). I love the artistic approach, but hard to have this as reference for your colors, very much out of your normal photographic style.
What comes colors itself to me they seem OK for artistic appearance, but trying to get so much saturation to sRGB has made weird issues. E.g. top left corner just looks weird (mainly due to artistic "over the edge" processing", but also low gamut sRGB contributes to the issue).
Sharpness is difficult to comment as you use Flickr. The original size in Flickr seems OK, but it has some artifacts from too much processing or JPG compression e.g. the small trees on right side of picture above the red house. The Flickr resized image is OK (trees are so small that you can no longer see the weirdness). Many people have been purchasing too small 4K displays (e.g. 27"), and since then their photos have looked just awful as they no longer see pixels properly, photos seem to come out randomly too sharp or too dull. I would recommend to have another "normal" (what used to be normal) pixel density monitor for checking final result sharpness. I'm using 30" 2560x1600 and 27" 1920x1080 monitors for "proofing" the "sharpness level of web images", the 4K display I have is just way too small observe sharpness (but nice to create 4K size versions of images, which are optimally sharpened for the 4K display and view images in the 4K display, looks so damn nice).
Samuli