Todd wrote:
Hey Bastian,
Cool sample shots. How would you rate the sharpness of the lens as seen on your computer at 100%? I read where you said it was not the sharpest lens, which is surprising.... Since Nikon made this lens (supposedly a super sharp lens) at f/1.4. Do you have other lenses like the sigma 35mm f/1.4 that are sharper wide open compared to the 58mm? What camera (mp) are you using? I wonder if the 58mm holds up to the D800e's resolving power. And.....did you have to fine tune the focus?
Todd
Hi Todd,
Well I'll do my best to come up with a sharpness scale to answer your question. My 3 "sharpest" lenses are the 200 f2 VRII, Sigma 35 and the 85 1.4G. So on a scale of 1-10 (10 being the sharpest lens, for me)
200 f2 = 10
Sigma 35 = 8
84 1.4G = 7.5
58 1.4G = 6
Mind you that I am putting it against my 3 sharpest lenses. I could also include the 45 TS, 70-200 VRII, and even the 14-24 as having a similar score to the 58 or even lower. Maybe I just had a bad copy but I was never thrilled with my 70-200 VRII (I loved the VRI)
It seems to me in my first real day of shooting that this lens requires you to take a step back to see the magic at 1.4 come to fruition. Just an initial observation of course, but I have heard similar from other reviewers.
I am shooting with a D4 and I did not have to adjust at all with either D4 body which to be honest I was very surprised by. My Sigma I had to do a +20 prior to having the dock. I am going to use a friends D800 to do some more tests with the lens pretty soon so I will get a better sense on how it holds up.
EDIT: And I thought of this after, when I take a few steps back with the Sigma I would drops its rating to right around a 6 yet I would bump the 58 up to an 8. Just an afterthought. Cheers!