JadedWriter wrote:
I think my complaint is the softness and randomness of the whole thing for me. I basically want things sharp and to not worry about the output, which the lens doesn't do for me,
The design of this lens was specifically Mandler style for the look it rendered, and unfortunately that means it also exhibits focus shift with aperture and distance. This shift is most notable from wide open to about f4 or 4.5 and can only be AF fine tuned out reliably on a DSLR body at a chosen aperture AND subject distance in that range. (I used f1.8 and 6 feet as it gave me a decent central working performance point, but it still was only about 70% successful.) As such, I am in the camp it can't overcome that particular aperture/focus/distance shortfall *until you dedicate it to a mirrorless body*. Once you embrace it on mirrorless, it's in an entirely different league and IMHO, a total game changer. (FWIW, similar situation with the 105/1.4, though the issue isn't as pronounced as on the 58. And again, using the 105 on a mirrorless body is frankly Nirvana...)