fredmiranda.com Login

The 58mm F/1.4G Thread

  
 
Alexander Ross
Offline
Details
p.346 #1The 58mm F/1.4G Thread


Savages

by Aleksander Ross, on Flickr
Aug 29, 2022 at 12:39 AM
akul
Offline
Details
p.346 #2The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
58/1.4G was the only F lens I took to the trip this summer. All other lenses were S lenses. 58/1.4 held its own.






  NIKON Z 6    Nikon AF-S Nikkor 58 mm 1.4G lens    58mm    f/10.0    1/250s    100 ISO    +1.0 EV  

Sep 27, 2022 at 05:01 AM
GiovanniAprea
Offline
Details
p.346 #3The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
The 58, to me, as an amateur, works/worked well on both the D850 and the Z6II through the FTZII, have no complains, anzi, I love it!

The few shots I published with the 58 here https://flic.kr/s/aHsmWjeTSE
Sep 27, 2022 at 05:47 AM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.346 #4The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
I honestly think the lens is fine for street and posed portraits. Chaos photojournalism events is an entirely different story though.
GiovanniAprea wrote:
The 58, to me, as an amateur, works/worked well on both the D850 and the Z6II through the FTZII, have no complains, anzi, I love it!

The few shots I published with the 58 here https://flic.kr/s/aHsmWjeTSE


Sep 27, 2022 at 08:07 AM
GiovanniAprea
Offline
Details
p.346 #5The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
JadedWriter wrote:
I honestly think the lens is fine for street and posed portraits. Chaos photojournalism events is an entirely different story though.
GiovanniAprea wroteThe 58, to me, as an amateur, works/worked well on both the D850 and the Z6II through the FTZII, have no complains, anzi, I love it!

The few shots I published with the 58 here https://flic.kr/s/aHsmWjeTSE


If you refer to AF speed I can't really tell, either on the D8xx and the Z6II I can't tell it missed the focus and if it did it was my failure not the lens nor the camera; by the way it's not supposed to be a speed demon nor I guess the intention of the guy who designed it to be such so, probably, for a street use, which I am not fond of, where speed is crucial, not the right lens.

Sep 27, 2022 at 09:02 AM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.346 #6The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
I think my complaint is the softness and randomness of the whole thing for me. If I'm shooting just to shoot I care less, if I'm shooting under work pressure it's completely different set of priorities for me. I basically want things sharp and to not worry about the output, which the lens doesn't do for me, it honestly just panics me during those events. Street and portraits is different unless I'm being paid for the portrait. It won't replace my 50 1.2 as like a true shoot it and forget it all rounder, then again I don't think even the 50 Art replaces that, I'd need to shoot it some more.
GiovanniAprea wrote:
JadedWriter wroteI honestly think the lens is fine for street and posed portraits. Chaos photojournalism events is an entirely different story though.
GiovanniAprea wroteThe 58, to me, as an amateur, works/worked well on both the D850 and the Z6II through the FTZII, have no complains, anzi, I love it!

The few shots I published with the 58 here https://flic.kr/s/aHsmWjeTSE
If you refer to AF speed I can't really tell, either on the D8xx and the Z6II I can't tell it missed the focus and if it did it was my failure not the lens nor the camera; by the way it's not supposed to be a speed demon nor I guess the intention of the guy who designed it to be such so, probably, for a street use, which I am not fond of, where speed is crucial, not the right lens.



Sep 27, 2022 at 09:24 AM
Jack Flesher
Online
Details
p.346 #7The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
JadedWriter wrote:
I think my complaint is the softness and randomness of the whole thing for me. I basically want things sharp and to not worry about the output, which the lens doesn't do for me,


The design of this lens was specifically Mandler style for the look it rendered, and unfortunately that means it also exhibits focus shift with aperture and distance. This shift is most notable from wide open to about f4 or 4.5 and can only be AF fine tuned out reliably on a DSLR body at a chosen aperture AND subject distance in that range. (I used f1.8 and 6 feet as it gave me a decent central working performance point, but it still was only about 70% successful.) As such, I am in the camp it can't overcome that particular aperture/focus/distance shortfall *until you dedicate it to a mirrorless body*. Once you embrace it on mirrorless, it's in an entirely different league and IMHO, a total game changer. (FWIW, similar situation with the 105/1.4, though the issue isn't as pronounced as on the 58. And again, using the 105 on a mirrorless body is frankly Nirvana...)

Sep 27, 2022 at 09:54 AM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.346 #8The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Earlier in this thread I shot it on my Z9 once and I still found it to be a bit of a crap shoot. Either my copy is wonky or the lens all in all is straight wonky or I need to dial in some type of adjustment on that lens on my Z9. I have had like 0 issues with the 105 on mirrorless though.
gear-nut wrote:
JadedWriter wroteI think my complaint is the softness and randomness of the whole thing for me. I basically want things sharp and to not worry about the output, which the lens doesn't do for me,
The design of this lens was specifically Mandler style for the look it rendered, and unfortunately that means it also exhibits focus shift with aperture and distance. This shift is most notable from wide open to about f4 or 4.5 and can only be AF fine tuned out reliably on a DSLR body at a chosen aperture AND subject distance in that range. (I used f1.8 and 6 feet as it gave me a decent central working performance point, but it still was only about 70% successful.) As such, I am in the camp it can't overcome that particular aperture/focus/distance
...Show more →

Sep 27, 2022 at 09:59 AM
Jack Flesher
Online
Details
p.346 #9The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
JadedWriter wrote:
Earlier in this thread I shot it on my Z9 once and I still found it to be a bit of a crap shoot. Either my copy is wonky or the lens all in all is straight wonky or I need to dial in some type of adjustment on that lens on my Z9. I have had like 0 issues with the 105 on mirrorless though.


All I can tell you is both lenses are basically 100% deliverers on my Z7ii/FTZ with zero AF fine tune. I don't have a Z9 yet so can't comment.
Sep 27, 2022 at 10:13 AM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.346 #10The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Nikon must have sent me a wonky refurb then.
gear-nut wrote:
JadedWriter wroteEarlier in this thread I shot it on my Z9 once and I still found it to be a bit of a crap shoot. Either my copy is wonky or the lens all in all is straight wonky or I need to dial in some type of adjustment on that lens on my Z9. I have had like 0 issues with the 105 on mirrorless though.
All I can tell you is both lenses are basically 100% deliverers on my Z7ii/FTZ with zero AF fine tune. I don't have a Z9 yet so can't comment.


Sep 27, 2022 at 10:52 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

kriskunisch
Offline
Details
p.346 #11The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
If predictable outcomes are expected from opportune moments, the 58mm would not be the lens to grab.
- the 58mm needs to be stopped down to f/2-f/2.8 within MFD
- if you are on a DSLR, AF Fine Tune is a must
- Z system improves focus accuracy, but you will still not have as many keepers as a native Z lens
- it vignettes WAY less than the 50mm 1.8s
- it renders scenes beautifully with lovely, natural transitions between in focus and out of focus elements

It can be special. It is special. I will never part with mine. It's not a modern lens. I am glad it's not a modern lens.
Sep 27, 2022 at 05:44 PM
sanjayg
Offline
Details
p.346 #12The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
kriskunisch wrote:
If predictable outcomes are expected from opportune moments, the 58mm would not be the lens to grab.
- the 58mm needs to be stopped down to f/2-f/2.8 within MFD
- if you are on a DSLR, AF Fine Tune is a must
- Z system improves focus accuracy, but you will still not have as many keepers as a native Z lens
- it vignettes WAY less than the 50mm 1.8s
- it renders scenes beautifully with lovely, natural transitions between in focus and out of focus elements

It can be special. It is special. I will never part with mine. It's not a
...Show more →

Well summarized, @kriskunisch that is exactly how I feel about this lens. It is quirky but special
Sep 28, 2022 at 05:19 AM
akul
Offline
Details
p.346 #13The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Late summer image




  NIKON Z 6    Nikon AF-S Nikkor 58 mm 1.4G lens    58mm    f/1.4    1/4000s    100 ISO    0.0 EV  

Sep 29, 2022 at 05:01 AM
micke.vmix
Online
Details
p.346 #14The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Life at the soft end....


Sunrise by micke vmix, on Flickr
D500 at F1.4


Endless by micke vmix, on Flickr
D500 at F1.4


Muted by micke vmix, on Flickr
D500 at F1.4


Red by micke vmix, on Flickr
D500 at F1.4


Saturation by micke vmix, on Flickr
D500 at F1.4


Mystic Forest by micke vmix, on Flickr
D500 at F1.6


Apocalypse Now by micke vmix, on Flickr
D500 at F1.4


Mirrored by micke vmix, on Flickr
D500 at F1.4


Mushroom Universe by micke vmix, on Flickr
D500 at F1.4

...oops, got stuck wide open there for a long while.
Oct 01, 2022 at 12:51 AM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.346 #15The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Z09_5959 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Z09_5938 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Z09_5945 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Z09_6281 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Z09_6282 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Oct 07, 2022 at 07:10 PM
akul
Offline
Details
p.346 #16The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
These are awesome. Happy theme.

Luka
Oct 07, 2022 at 07:29 PM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.346 #17The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
The role of the 58 might just be for when I'm not in the mood to beat up my 50 1.2 and it's low stress shooting. Glad you like them.
akul wrote:
These are awesome. Happy theme.

Luka


Oct 07, 2022 at 07:47 PM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.346 #18The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Z09_6322 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Z09_6306 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Z09_6288 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Z09_6507 1 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Z09_6536 1 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Z09_6576 1 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Oct 09, 2022 at 02:28 PM
SiMuMe
Offline
Details
p.346 #19The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Glad you're are finding some use cases for your 58. I think this last set is showing both its strengths and weaknesses which are good to take note of. All the B&W and the bespectacled lady show its strengths, while the ones which are more close up show its weaknesses.

Oct 09, 2022 at 09:29 PM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.346 #20The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
This is why I gotta preference for the 50 1.2. The 58 has a bit too many special conditions for it to be good, but I'd probably rather just use this for stuff I have no emotional/financial investment in.
SiMuMe wrote:
Glad you're are finding some use cases for your 58. I think this last set is showing both its strengths and weaknesses which are good to take note of. All the B&W and the bespectacled lady show its strengths, while the ones which are more close up show its weaknesses.



Oct 09, 2022 at 09:38 PM


FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister