fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2013 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2013Sony A99 w/Zeiss autofocus glass?

  
 
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Sony A99 w/Zeiss autofocus glass?
wayne seltzer wrote:
Yeah, the 135 is one of my favorite portrait lenses along with Contax N85/1.4 which also has nice smooth bokeh along with Zeiss sharpness and colors.
50/2 APO looks great except for all Lloyd Chambers examples and complaints about its flare handling/control. Jury is still out on new Otus 55/1.4's bokeh as I need to see more examples but the contrast and sharpness wide open looks incredible and sets new standards for a 50'ish lens IMO, especially on a high MP camera like the D800.
Glad you are enjoying your A99 so far.
One question: Does the A99 EVF provide the
...Show more →


Actually, I sent my 50APO in to Leica for the flare issue. I was told the work would take a few days, and it's been a few weeks. They're really upsetting me with this fix, saying they're waiting on spare parts. Which I find to be rubbish, as they are making 50APO lenses, and can easily just stop making new lenses, and fix the ones that were sent to them!

I'll probably end up testing the Otus at some point, but for now, I'm happy with the ZA lenses.

Umm.. it's as far as I know a WYSIWYG scenario. For example, if I set my camera to say 1.4, it shows me DOF at 1.4, if I set it to 5.6, it shows me the DOF at 5.6.. Is that what you mean? Hope I explained it right.


Oct 29, 2013 at 12:10 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Sony A99 w/Zeiss autofocus glass?
edwardkaraa wrote:
wayne seltzer wrote
edwardkaraa wrote
wayne seltzer wrote
edwardkaraa wroteI certainly wouldn't say that the ZA have less micro contrast, in fact they may have more of that. I find them to have a medium format style subtle tonal gradations so if anything they may have less macro contrast. Tariq has once described them as a cross breed between Zeiss and Leica, and I fully agree with that description.
Before you sold your za and A900 I remember you even saying the ZA's did not have the pop of the ZF/ZE glass.
If you love traditional Contax and ZF/ZE rendering, something about the ZA lenses leaves me a little short.
My RX1 lens has more of it too than ZA imo.
Understand, the majority of A mount users will not agree with me.
The lack of a ZA 35 and for a long time a ZA 50 has been the problem with the Sony A mount line.
I think the high end Otus line of portrait primes 50, and rumored 85, will significantly up the ante against ZA and Sony and help Canikon.. I understand that is at the high end.
Indeed I did complain at the time that my ZA lenses didn't have the same pop as the ZS that I've used on the same camera. However that was not the reason why I sold them, but rather the non removable SLT mirror of the A99. However, while I agree that the ZS/ZE/ZF have more pop (and rather high macro contrast), I disagree about the Contax Zeiss lenses. They have a very subtle rendering not too different from the ZA. What's more interesting are my ZM lenses that I use on the Leica M9. I'm sure you won't like these ones either because they are much more subdued in rendering. My theory is that Zeiss designs each lens line with characteristics that it considers appropriate to the platform they're used on. The ZM have to compete with Leica M glass, in the same way that the ZA have to compete with and complement the Leica inspired Minolta glass.

This said, I still believe the ZA have an impressively high micro contrast that is well uniformly distributed across the frame. They also have a much more attractive bokeh than most of the ZE (latest models seem to have improved a lot in this respect like the 35/1.4 and 135/2).
Sorry Edward, did not mean to make it sound like you sold your A900 because of it. ZAs have always been slightly controversial since the Minolta camp feel they are not enough like the Minolta rendering and some of the Zeiss fans feel it is not enough Zeissy. I still love my ZA135/1.8 and realize a lot of this is just personal rendering likes as they are great lenses. I like them better than Sony G lenses. My old Rokkors, 58/1.2 and 28/2 have more Leica colors and rendering style. I do like the ZA135/1.8 much better than the new ZF/ZE 135/2.
ZMs are nice but different too like you mentioned.
Is Marc the wedding photog in the other Sony forum still shooting with his A900s?
No problem Wayne. Indeed the Minolta bunch never really liked the ZA rendering and I as a Zeiss Meister () would have preferred a more punchy rendering. But the fact is now that I have been shooting with the ZM for over 2 years, I really appreciate what Zeiss has done with the ZA, a sort of bastardized Zeiss/Leica look that is actually very charming.

Marc has moved to A99 by the way, still keeping his ZA lenses. He also has a couple of A7R on order



Who is this, I'd like to see his work. I'm curious, since I don't see many weddings on flickr and the likes, shot with a A99..
Oct 29, 2013 at 12:12 PM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Sony A99 w/Zeiss autofocus glass?


adamdewilde wrote:
edwardkaraa wrote
wayne seltzer wrote
edwardkaraa wrote
wayne seltzer wrote
edwardkaraa wroteI certainly wouldn't say that the ZA have less micro contrast, in fact they may have more of that. I find them to have a medium format style subtle tonal gradations so if anything they may have less macro contrast. Tariq has once described them as a cross breed between Zeiss and Leica, and I fully agree with that description.
Before you sold your za and A900 I remember you even saying the ZA's did not have the pop of the ZF/ZE glass.
If you love traditional Contax and ZF/ZE rendering, something about the ZA lenses leaves me a little short.
My RX1 lens has more of it too than ZA imo.
Understand, the majority of A mount users will not agree with me.
The lack of a ZA 35 and for a long time a ZA 50 has been the problem with the Sony A mount line.
I think the high end Otus line of portrait primes 50, and rumored 85, will significantly up the ante against ZA and Sony and help Canikon.. I understand that is at the high end.
Indeed I did complain at the time that my ZA lenses didn't have the same pop as the ZS that I've used on the same camera. However that was not the reason why I sold them, but rather the non removable SLT mirror of the A99. However, while I agree that the ZS/ZE/ZF have more pop (and rather high macro contrast), I disagree about the Contax Zeiss lenses. They have a very subtle rendering not too different from the ZA. What's more interesting are my ZM lenses that I use on the Leica M9. I'm sure you won't like these ones either because they are much more subdued in rendering. My theory is that Zeiss designs each lens line with characteristics that it considers appropriate to the platform they're used on. The ZM have to compete with Leica M glass, in the same way that the ZA have to compete with and complement the Leica inspired Minolta glass.

This said, I still believe the ZA have an impressively high micro contrast that is well uniformly distributed across the frame. They also have a much more attractive bokeh than most of the ZE (latest models seem to have improved a lot in this respect like the 35/1.4 and 135/2).
Sorry Edward, did not mean to make it sound like you sold your A900 because of it. ZAs have always been slightly controversial since the Minolta camp feel they are not enough like the Minolta rendering and some of the Zeiss fans feel it is not enough Zeissy. I still love my ZA135/1.8 and realize a lot of this is just personal rendering likes as they are great lenses. I like them better than Sony G lenses. My old Rokkors, 58/1.2 and 28/2 have more Leica colors and rendering style. I do like the ZA135/1.8 much better than the new ZF/ZE 135/2.
ZMs are nice but different too like you mentioned.
Is Marc the wedding photog in the other Sony forum still shooting with his A900s?
No problem Wayne. Indeed the Minolta bunch never really liked the ZA rendering and I as a Zeiss Meister () would have preferred a more punchy rendering. But the fact is now that I have been shooting with the ZM for over 2 years, I really appreciate what Zeiss has done with the ZA, a sort of bastardized Zeiss/Leica look that is actually very charming.

Marc has moved to A99 by the way, still keeping his ZA lenses. He also has a couple of A7R on order
Who is this, I'd like to see his work. I'm curious, since I don't see many weddings on flickr and the likes, shot with a A99..

He posts under the name fotografz on getdpi and Leica forum.
Oct 29, 2013 at 12:19 PM
briantho
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Sony A99 w/Zeiss autofocus glass?
Posted these shots in the NEX thread, they could be relevant to this discussion regarding character of the Sony Zeiss lenses.

Contax Zeiss Distagon 28mm f2 compared to Sony Zeiss Distagon 24mm f2 SSM, minimal PP.

Contax 28:

Contax 28/2 Sony 24/2 comparison #1 by briantho, on Flickr

Sony 24:

Contax 28/2 Sony 24/2 comparison #2 by briantho, on Flickr

Contax 28:

Contax 28/2 Sony 24/2 comparison #3 by briantho, on Flickr

Sony 24:

Contax 28/2 Sony 24/2 comparison #4 by briantho, on Flickr
Oct 29, 2013 at 12:27 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Sony A99 w/Zeiss autofocus glass?
edwardkaraa wrote:
adamdewilde wrote
edwardkaraa wrote
wayne seltzer wrote
edwardkaraa wrote
wayne seltzer wroteBefore you sold your za and A900 I remember you even saying the ZA's did not have the pop of the ZF/ZE glass.
If you love traditional Contax and ZF/ZE rendering, something about the ZA lenses leaves me a little short.
My RX1 lens has more of it too than ZA imo.
Understand, the majority of A mount users will not agree with me.
The lack of a ZA 35 and for a long time a ZA 50 has been the problem with the Sony A mount line.
I think the high end Otus line of portrait primes 50, and rumored 85, will significantly up the ante against ZA and Sony and help Canikon.. I understand that is at the high end.
Indeed I did complain at the time that my ZA lenses didn't have the same pop as the ZS that I've used on the same camera. However that was not the reason why I sold them, but rather the non removable SLT mirror of the A99. However, while I agree that the ZS/ZE/ZF have more pop (and rather high macro contrast), I disagree about the Contax Zeiss lenses. They have a very subtle rendering not too different from the ZA. What's more interesting are my ZM lenses that I use on the Leica M9. I'm sure you won't like these ones either because they are much more subdued in rendering. My theory is that Zeiss designs each lens line with characteristics that it considers appropriate to the platform they're used on. The ZM have to compete with Leica M glass, in the same way that the ZA have to compete with and complement the Leica inspired Minolta glass.

This said, I still believe the ZA have an impressively high micro contrast that is well uniformly distributed across the frame. They also have a much more attractive bokeh than most of the ZE (latest models seem to have improved a lot in this respect like the 35/1.4 and 135/2).
Sorry Edward, did not mean to make it sound like you sold your A900 because of it. ZAs have always been slightly controversial since the Minolta camp feel they are not enough like the Minolta rendering and some of the Zeiss fans feel it is not enough Zeissy. I still love my ZA135/1.8 and realize a lot of this is just personal rendering likes as they are great lenses. I like them better than Sony G lenses. My old Rokkors, 58/1.2 and 28/2 have more Leica colors and rendering style. I do like the ZA135/1.8 much better than the new ZF/ZE 135/2.
ZMs are nice but different too like you mentioned.
Is Marc the wedding photog in the other Sony forum still shooting with his A900s?
No problem Wayne. Indeed the Minolta bunch never really liked the ZA rendering and I as a Zeiss Meister () would have preferred a more punchy rendering. But the fact is now that I have been shooting with the ZM for over 2 years, I really appreciate what Zeiss has done with the ZA, a sort of bastardized Zeiss/Leica look that is actually very charming.

Marc has moved to A99 by the way, still keeping his ZA lenses. He also has a couple of A7R on order
Who is this, I'd like to see his work. I'm curious, since I don't see many weddings on flickr and the likes, shot with a A99..
He posts under the name fotografz on getdpi and Leica forum.



OH, I know Marc, I thought he switched to using MFD for weddings?!
Oct 29, 2013 at 07:55 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Sony A99 w/Zeiss autofocus glass?
briantho - Neat comparison. You did have very interesting light on that day, which helps a LOT. But can definitely see pop in all four samples.

I favor the second image over the first, but I favor the third image over the fourth.
Oct 29, 2013 at 07:59 PM
wayne seltzer
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Sony A99 w/Zeiss autofocus glass?
edwardkaraa wrote:
wayne seltzer wrote
edwardkaraa wrote
wayne seltzer wrote
edwardkaraa wroteI certainly wouldn't say that the ZA have less micro contrast, in fact they may have more of that. I find them to have a medium format style subtle tonal gradations so if anything they may have less macro contrast. Tariq has once described them as a cross breed between Zeiss and Leica, and I fully agree with that description.
Before you sold your za and A900 I remember you even saying the ZA's did not have the pop of the ZF/ZE glass.
If you love traditional Contax and ZF/ZE rendering, something about the ZA lenses leaves me a little short.
My RX1 lens has more of it too than ZA imo.
Understand, the majority of A mount users will not agree with me.
The lack of a ZA 35 and for a long time a ZA 50 has been the problem with the Sony A mount line.
I think the high end Otus line of portrait primes 50, and rumored 85, will significantly up the ante against ZA and Sony and help Canikon.. I understand that is at the high end.
Indeed I did complain at the time that my ZA lenses didn't have the same pop as the ZS that I've used on the same camera. However that was not the reason why I sold them, but rather the non removable SLT mirror of the A99. However, while I agree that the ZS/ZE/ZF have more pop (and rather high macro contrast), I disagree about the Contax Zeiss lenses. They have a very subtle rendering not too different from the ZA. What's more interesting are my ZM lenses that I use on the Leica M9. I'm sure you won't like these ones either because they are much more subdued in rendering. My theory is that Zeiss designs each lens line with characteristics that it considers appropriate to the platform they're used on. The ZM have to compete with Leica M glass, in the same way that the ZA have to compete with and complement the Leica inspired Minolta glass.

This said, I still believe the ZA have an impressively high micro contrast that is well uniformly distributed across the frame. They also have a much more attractive bokeh than most of the ZE (latest models seem to have improved a lot in this respect like the 35/1.4 and 135/2).
Sorry Edward, did not mean to make it sound like you sold your A900 because of it. ZAs have always been slightly controversial since the Minolta camp feel they are not enough like the Minolta rendering and some of the Zeiss fans feel it is not enough Zeissy. I still love my ZA135/1.8 and realize a lot of this is just personal rendering likes as they are great lenses. I like them better than Sony G lenses. My old Rokkors, 58/1.2 and 28/2 have more Leica colors and rendering style. I do like the ZA135/1.8 much better than the new ZF/ZE 135/2.
ZMs are nice but different too like you mentioned.
Is Marc the wedding photog in the other Sony forum still shooting with his A900s?
No problem Wayne. Indeed the Minolta bunch never really liked the ZA rendering and I as a Zeiss Meister () would have preferred a more punchy rendering. But the fact is now that I have been shooting with the ZM for over 2 years, I really appreciate what Zeiss has done with the ZA, a sort of bastardized Zeiss/Leica look that is actually very charming.

Marc has moved to A99 by the way, still keeping his ZA lenses. He also has a couple of A7R on order


Ah, Zeiss Meister! That reminds of Phillipe's old funny thread a few years back.
Makes sense he has A99 and is also getting A7r for his Leica M glass. I remember him and his other talented wedding photographer friend who only shot with Leica rangefinders both preferred the less obtrusive/imposing of the smaller sized Leicas for wedding reception and other social settings which I agree with my RX1 with silent leaf shutter. But A7r with built I EVF will allow flash at same time vs. RX1.
Oct 30, 2013 at 05:41 AM
wayne seltzer
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Sony A99 w/Zeiss autofocus glass?
adamdewilde wrote:
wayne seltzer wroteYeah, the 135 is one of my favorite portrait lenses along with Contax N85/1.4 which also has nice smooth bokeh along with Zeiss sharpness and colors.
50/2 APO looks great except for all Lloyd Chambers examples and complaints about its flare handling/control. Jury is still out on new Otus 55/1.4's bokeh as I need to see more examples but the contrast and sharpness wide open looks incredible and sets new standards for a 50'ish lens IMO, especially on a high MP camera like the D800.
Glad you are enjoying your A99 so far.
One question: Does the A99 EVF provide the user with an image of the scene at min aperture or the selected aperture like Nex line as Lloyd Chamber's complains about?
Actually, I sent my 50APO in to Leica for the flare issue. I was told the work would take a few days, and it's been a few weeks. They're really upsetting me with this fix, saying they're waiting on spare parts. Which I find to be rubbish, as they are making 50APO lenses, and can easily just stop making new lenses, and fix the ones that were sent to them!

I'll probably end up testing the Otus at some point, but for now, I'm happy with the ZA lenses.

Umm.. it's as far as I know a WYSIWYG scenario. For example, if
...Show more →
Sorry to hear about Leica is handling your 50APO flare repair. Hope you get it back soon. Considering the price of that lens it would be good for Leica to fix that fast for existing users.
I think Marc also had a 50MP MFDB 'blad which he also used for weddings and commercial work.
Oct 30, 2013 at 05:48 AM
wayne seltzer
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Sony A99 w/Zeiss autofocus glass?
Briantho, interesting comparison shots. Thanks for posting. I agree both these lenses show pop and render similarly except the Contax seems to have more macro contrast as Edward mentioned earlier. Would be interesting to see how the ZF 25/2 would compare to these two.
Oct 30, 2013 at 05:54 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Sony A99 w/Zeiss autofocus glass?
Wayne funny you mentioned that.. In the second photo (vs. the first) I tend to think that the 24ZA has the advantage in pop/rendering/contrast, in the 3rd (vs. the fourth) it definitely goes to the 28ZE.

I really don't know the technical difference between micro and macro contrast, I can NEVER remember.
Oct 30, 2013 at 10:01 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Sony A99 w/Zeiss autofocus glass?
I just did a shoot with the A99 n Zeiss lenses. I must say, the results were quite pleasing. The lenses are definitely sharp, and the camera hits focus very reliably.

I'm pretty convinced that this may just be the system for me.
Oct 31, 2013 at 12:55 PM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Sony A99 w/Zeiss autofocus glass?

OH, I know Marc, I thought he switched to using MFD for weddings?!


He was all over the place He had a DMR, then a Leica M, somewhere I think there was a medium format of some kind (Hy6?), an A900, and other bits and pieces.

He designed/faked the best-looking DSLR ever:

http://www.getdpi.com/gallery/files/9/4/3/leica_r10_fotografz_mockup.jpg
Oct 31, 2013 at 02:22 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Sony A99 w/Zeiss autofocus glass?
Then bought an S-system I'm guessing
Nov 01, 2013 at 05:59 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister