I had the 35G as well, and I find it has an old Leica/Minolta rendering. It is very sharp at infinity stopped down to f/8, and works nicely with people shots wide open or close to, but it has too much CA and SA. To be honest, I didn't hate this lens, but wasn't fond of it neither.
I have been using the new Sigma 35/1.4 on my Sony A900/A99 and I am pretty happy with the lens. The lens focuses well, both speed and accuracy, on both of my Sony bodies. The Sigma has become my go-to lens for night and low light use with my Sonys.
Interesting, I didn't realize they called the Sony 35 a G lens.. I looked at a lot of samples from all the lenses, I've spent the last few days doing that actually. Didn't seem to mind the sony 35, but I bought the A99 specifically for the Zeiss glass, so I'll be buying the 24/2 and 50/1.4 instead of the sony G lenses.. So I'm hoping that the 6 ZA lenses are going to give me some nice Zeiss love. But I do see now how/why a lot of people are buying the A99 for Alternative glass, as the viewfinder's pretty nifty, although it'll take a lot of getting use to before I bring it out to a wedding shoot.
I only got to test the camera and 85 1.4 ZA for a brief period of time (5 minutes), before my battery died
Charging the battery now.
I'm going to go take a look at the link from xbarcelo and RickPerry. Thanks guys!
Adam, you may have a more refine eye for rendering, but if you are shooting to make income, consider that most of your clients probably don't. From a business standpoint, I would speculate that it makes more sense to go Canon/Nikon:
1. You can easily rent either: backup bodies, extra/specialty lenses, etc.
2. You can buy/sell the equipment more easily, the used market for Canon/Nikon is much larger.
In the long run, it may be just outright cheaper and leave you with more $$$ for M glass.
Jabberwockt - Good points. And yeah I agree, most of my clients don't know any better, or care. It's just that I left Canon for a reason, and slowly I've realized that Nikon doesn't fill the void either. So I decided to explore my other options since manual focusing isn't one of them.
It's more for me, then anyone else. And honestly my business won't really suffer either way, just my wallet a little bit..
A lot of little things about the body bother me. No point in getting into it. Also a lot of stuff will take getting use to. One thing I cannot stand however is when you have it set to EVF only and u go to play an image and it plays in the EVF. Any way around this?
Also the 85 acts weird AF wise. The MF AF situation is strange.
However the 85 is pretty optically fantastic. I'm curious does Sony sharpen raws in camera. I mean, the lens is really sharp on 1.4. Almost to sharp. Even in Lightroom with sharpening on 0. Testing it fully today.
Guys, are you sure ZA's are real zeisses? I though the only thing from zeiss in them is a zeiss badge.
And from the IQ standpoint most of them (except ZA 135/1.8) gives nothing over canon/nikon competitors.
adam, Sony doesn't sharpen RAWs, I'm totally sure of this, so it is the lens. As for the review, why are you so bothered about being able to play an image on the EVF? It's actually very useful to check shot on a very bright day. But if you're adamant that you don't want this option, then some one else will have to answer your question, because I don't know if it's possible. When I get home, I'll check on my A65 and see if it can be done.
Adam, the planar is super sharp wide open, so much that it doesn't improve when you stop down to 2.8. You start to see mtf improvement from f/4 upwards. As for AF/MF problems, be careful not to touch the AF clutch button, and avoid holding the focusing ring when the lens is focusing.
Adam, the easiest way is to leave the EVF switch to auto and then flip the screen in when you aren't doing review. Then opening the screen to review shows you the images and you keep from getting nose grease on everything.
Sony doesn't sharpen raws but a stabilized 85mm is a thing of beauty at 80-150th. However sony DOES sharpen the preview with the jpg settings. This affects everything from the peaking to the zoomed in previews so It is very much worthwhile to dial in your desired amount of sharpening (I have mine set to -2 for MF) so that the preview is representative.
On the AF/MF switch: it has 2 normal modes, one where you press the switch and it releases the clutch, and the other mode called toggle in the menu where it turns off autofocus until you reset the camera or press the switch again. Horses for courses.
If you want to have an AF-ON button ala Nikon, I'm pretty sure you can turn off AF with half press and then press the center of the joystick and it should AF for you.
While I'm mentioning weird things, the AE-lock button has a few interesting modes. First is standard hold the current settings. Then there is a toggle mode, which will hold the settings after a single press. My favorite are the later two settings spot-on and spot-toggle, this will spot meter from the center 5% of the frame. It is very useful for getting faces properly exposed in the dark especially when they are back lit. You can do a spot toggle on a face and it will override whatever metering mode you are in and then you can shift the exposure up or down a bit with the EV comp.
It is possible to assign the rear wheel to be exposure compensation in S and A modes which is also pretty useful as you can see the first +/-2EV of exposure compensation in the viewfinder.
Zeiss ZA, ZA E and ZA FE lenses are designed by Zeiss with input from Sony, and they're built in Japan in a Sony factory (as opposed to being built by Cosina like the ZE/ZF.)
If I were to shoot SLR/SLT cameras again, the ZA lineup would definitely be my preference. That 85/1.4 is awesome, outside of LOCA at wider apertures.
Emacs wrote:
Guys, are you sure ZA's are real zeisses? I though the only thing from zeiss in them is a zeiss badge.
And from the IQ standpoint most of them (except ZA 135/1.8) gives nothing over canon/nikon competitors.
Three areas I actually prefer the Minolta 85/1.4 over the 85/1.4 ZA:
1) Flare control. If shooting into a light source, the Minolta actually has a far less distracting flare control. The ZA always leaves a huge blob, which can be worked around, but it's always there. The Minolta is more scattered and subtle IMO.
2) Colour. The ZA is more neutral, cleaner. As noted it's better corrected, and you notice this particularly at wide apertures. However, I do prefer the warmer, perhaps more vibrant colour of the Minolta.
3) Forgot to add the third here. The hood. The ZA does not lock in place like the Minolta. It clicks in fine but can easily slip round, like all the ZA hoods I've tried in fact. Never had the problem with the Minolta. There is a work around of course, I've actually taped all my ZA hoods to the lens with black tape. Might sound drastic to some but really saves the faff / time of fiddling and chasing after hoods like an old blind man
SoulNibbler wrote:
Adam, the easiest way is to leave the EVF switch to auto and then flip the screen in when you aren't doing review. Then opening the screen to review shows you the images and you keep from getting nose grease on everything.
Sony doesn't sharpen raws but a stabilized 85mm is a thing of beauty at 80-150th. However sony DOES sharpen the preview with the jpg settings. This affects everything from the peaking to the zoomed in previews so It is very much worthwhile to dial in your desired amount of sharpening (I have mine set to -2 for MF) so that the preview is representative.
On the AF/MF switch: it has 2 normal modes, one where you press the switch and it releases the clutch, and the other mode called toggle in the menu where it turns off autofocus until you reset the camera or press the switch again. Horses for courses.
If you want to have an AF-ON button ala Nikon, I'm pretty sure you can turn off AF with half press and then press the center of the joystick and it should AF for you.
While I'm mentioning weird things, the AE-lock button has a few interesting modes. First is standard hold the current settings. Then there is a toggle mode, which will hold the settings after a single press. My favorite are the later two settings spot-on and spot-toggle, this will spot meter from the center 5% of the frame. It is very useful for getting faces properly exposed in the dark especially when they are back lit. You can do a spot toggle on a face and it will override whatever metering mode you are in and then you can shift the exposure up or down a bit with the EV comp.
It is possible to assign the rear wheel to be exposure compensation in S and A modes which is also pretty useful as you can see the first +/-2EV of exposure compensation in the viewfinder....Show more →
Thanks for all the useful information.. I actually took the camera out for a spin today. Took some shots of my wife in a field.. Figured out a lot of the working before leaving, since I knew she wouldn't be a willing subject for very long.. I actually set my AF button to spot meter as well seems the most useful thing for it, since your right the joystick actually works as a focus button (previously I had the button on the front of the D4 doing the spot metering, but the front button is not as accessible on the A99).
I first tried to set the camera as close to Nikon as possible, as to make it more familiar, and it worked for the most part.. Well everything aside from needing to toggle MF mode before you can touch the lens and the viewfinder preview thing.. I'll try your screen flip suggestion, as I usually don't need to check the preview anyway. But just to confirm, you're telling me that when the screen is flipped into the body, it won't turn on, even if you don't have your eye to the EVF?
As for the +-EV, I shoot in manual mode mostly, simply because the ballrooms I shoot in are madness and I can never trust the camera to think for me.. I even have to set my camera's flash to manual, a bit of a pain, but necessary. Although I did notice that you can set the auto ISO in manual mode, and then also set the EV+- and the camera will do so with the ISO settings, which is cool, and exposure wise, works really well.
Maybe I'll check out the Minolta 85.. But I need to give the 85 and other ZA lenses a shot first.
Emacs, you may be onto something Sony may have a heavier influence on the lens design then I was hoping. It's not that I don't like the 85, I think it's amazing. It's just that I'm not 100% convinced it has the ZE/ZF Zeiss magic (that I love) from the brief period I've used it. My wife on the other hand..
I shoot around 60 shots (including about 20 just to check how it focuses while a subject walks erratically), my wife liked 21 of them, I edited all 21, and she tossed 5, to leave herself with 16 she liked.
We chatted about the system, and we compared it to older photos I shot of her (I reviewed older Canon 85L and Nikon 85 1.4G images).. Her response was that she felt that the ZA looked most like the Contax645 (odd since Edward said that yesterday), but she said that she felt it was more sharp at the focus point, and lacked the film like quality, she then mentioned that she suspects thats what a digital back for the Contax645 would look like, and then told me I should buy a digital back for the contax.
For reference her favorite camera/lens combo is the Contax645 w/80/2 and her second favorite is the 50/2 MPZE (which is my favorite Zeiss lens).
Keep in mind, I did tweak the photos to look like film, as that's what I seem to be doing these days. And I did crop it to 645 as I've been all about that crop lately (been using my 645 cameras a lot in my spare time, so kinda in that mind frame). Although I previously had tweaked the Nikon images to look like film... The Canon files look digital though, so it might have been a bit unfair for Canon (all shot wide open).
I think the lens may be growing on me, but it's going to take a few weeks of shooting to really decide it for me. And of course, I'm going to have to bring it as a "tester" camera to my next evening weeding, and see how it stacks up in troublesome lighting conditions (and I have just the one in mind, but it's two weddings away at the start of december).
Anyway, thanks again guys for the wonderful discussion, and for taking the time to help me out with tips and useful information.
I'm happy to keep this discussion going if anyone else wants to add anything to the conversation.
douglasf13 - 100% agree with you.. I see a lot of purple and green fringing, worse then what I was getting with my 100/2 MPZE, but in far less warranted situations. Hopefully this is something that'll be minimized in the conditions I intend to use this lens in..
adamdewilde wrote:
douglasf13 - 100% agree with you.. I see a lot of purple and green fringing, worse then what I was getting with my 100/2 MPZE, but in far less warranted situations. Hopefully this is something that'll be minimized in the conditions I intend to use this lens in..
Probably the most I've ever had in a lens. It's a given in contrasty, light on dark edges at wider apertures. Granted, there were't facilities in LR to correct for this back when I used the lens.
I actually got the A99 so that I could get the ZA 135/1.8. I also wanted it for my Leitaxed R lenses. Since getting it, I have added the ZA 24/2 and the ZA 50/1.4. All of them are excellent. The 50/1.4 is the quickest and most responsive in terms of AF and balances very well on the A99 in spite of being heavy. I probably wont get the 85 because i use my Summicron 90 in that range. I recently added the RX1R to my kit, which occupies the 35mm slot.
I used to shoot Hassy/Zeiss and am totally satisfied with this setup.
I actually got the A99 so that I could get the ZA 135/1.8. I also wanted it for my Leitaxed R lenses. Since getting it, I have added the ZA 24/2 and the ZA 50/1.4. All of them are excellent. The 50/1.4 is the quickest and most responsive in terms of AF and balances very well on the A99 in spite of being heavy. I probably wont get the 85 because i use my Summicron 90 in that range. I recently added the RX1R to my kit, which occupies the 35mm slot.
I used to shoot Hassy/Zeiss and am totally satisfied with this setup.