fredmiranda.com Login

Medium Format Digital Images Thread

  
 
Steve Spencer
Online
Details
p.84 #1Medium Format Digital Images Thread
Here are two shots from around the same time at the same location.Both are shot with the Fuji GFX. The first one uses the Contax 645 55 f/3.5 lens and the second one uses the Contax 645 35 f/3.5 with a slight crop. I am interested in which one people like better and why. They aren't the same light or the same composition obviously, but they were shot only minutes apart.









Sep 05, 2018 at 04:59 PM
ocean2059
Offline
Details
p.84 #2Medium Format Digital Images Thread
I like the second one better as it has more foreground details.
Sep 05, 2018 at 09:01 PM
sculptormic
Offline
Details
p.84 #3Medium Format Digital Images Thread
Second one, but I am a fan of wide angles.
Sep 06, 2018 at 06:43 AM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.84 #4Medium Format Digital Images Thread
The second one. Both suffer from lack of covering DOF (or a strong subject to use OOF areas to draw attention), but the first one's strong OOF foreground hits you as soon as you enter the frame.
Sep 06, 2018 at 07:01 AM
Steve Spencer
Online
Details
p.84 #5Medium Format Digital Images Thread
Gunzorro wrote:
The second one. Both suffer from lack of covering DOF (or a strong subject to use OOF areas to draw attention), but the first one's strong OOF foreground hits you as soon as you enter the frame.


Thanks Jim, I appreciate your honesty. I think sometimes we don't get enough feedback about what could be better about our images around here. I was going for the building and its reflection being a strong subject. I couldn't find anything in the foreground that I felt was worth focussing on so I was trying to draw attention away. I guess it just didn't work.
Sep 06, 2018 at 09:05 AM
Gary Clennan
Offline
Details
p.84 #6Medium Format Digital Images Thread
I prefer the second one. Have you considered a square or 4x5 vertical crop?
Sep 06, 2018 at 09:13 AM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.84 #7Medium Format Digital Images Thread
120 APO, stitched





Sep 06, 2018 at 11:38 AM
Steve Spencer
Online
Details
p.84 #8Medium Format Digital Images Thread
Gary Clennan wrote:
I prefer the second one. Have you considered a square or 4x5 vertical crop?


Thanks Gary. That is a very nice suggestion. Here is the second one with a 4 X 5 vertical crop. Perhaps still not all that great, but the crop I think does improve it quite a bit.




Sep 06, 2018 at 02:35 PM
lenticular11
Offline
Details
p.84 #9Medium Format Digital Images Thread
I prefer the second image too. Initially I liked the tones of the first one better, however Gunzorro's comments resonated with me and I realised that was the reason for my later preference.


I'm not going to be posting in this thread any more, simply because I have sold my P645D body. I'm sure I will learn to regret that sale, however I have sold a few things to get closer to affording a GFX or X1D. For now those plans are on hold at least.

I shall continue to enjoy this thread however, with perhaps some further personal posts if I re-visit old shots taken on the 645D.
Sep 06, 2018 at 06:29 PM
johnvanr
Offline
Details
p.84 #10Medium Format Digital Images Thread
Once in a while, I check out this thread and I can’t help feeling that a lot of images are just mediocre. They may be taken with a great camera, but they’re still mediocre. The camera doesn’t make the image, the light and composition do. And, granted, if those are great, your cameras will make better images than the others, but still...

(Btw, I have the same feeling about some other camera threads. Nothing personal...)
Sep 06, 2018 at 06:40 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.84 #11Medium Format Digital Images Thread
lenticular11 wrote:
I prefer the second image too. Initially I liked the tones of the first one better, however Gunzorro's comments resonated with me and I realised that was the reason for my later preference.

I'm not going to be posting in this thread any more, simply because I have sold my P645D body. I'm sure I will learn to regret that sale, however I have sold a few things to get closer to affording a GFX or X1D. For now those plans are on hold at least.

I shall continue to enjoy this thread however, with perhaps some further personal posts if
...Show more →

Look forward to see you come back with GFX or X1D

Steve, I think what Cary might have meant that crop the left side of 2nd image to make it either 1X1 or 5X4. I could be wrong but that is what I will try. thanks for sharing.

120S




Sep 06, 2018 at 07:02 PM
dwood
Offline
Details
p.84 #12Medium Format Digital Images Thread
boat shop in Maine - GFX / GF32-64





Sep 06, 2018 at 08:48 PM
Steve Spencer
Online
Details
p.84 #13Medium Format Digital Images Thread
johnvanr wrote:
Once in a while, I check out this thread and I can’t help feeling that a lot of images are just mediocre. They may be taken with a great camera, but they’re still mediocre. The camera doesn’t make the image, the light and composition do. And, granted, if those are great, your cameras will make better images than the others, but still...

(Btw, I have the same feeling about some other camera threads. Nothing personal...)


John, of course it is the photographer together with the subject matter that makes a great shot. Keep in mind there are really only about 20 or so people who ever post in this thread. That isn't a very large group, and I think there are several of us who would really like to keep the thread going and are therefore less picky about what they post to this thread than to other threads here on FM. I know that is true for me. Of course you will see a lot more fabulous images on a thread like the Sony FE thread in which several hundred people post, than on a thread in which 20 or so people post. So no doubt part of what we are seeing here with images is a result of just huge differences in the number of people shooting in each thread. That said even if my images are mediocre, which they often are, I do think there is some very strong shots too. Just not as many or as frequent as they are on other threads.
Sep 07, 2018 at 06:24 AM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.84 #14Medium Format Digital Images Thread
I find the thread inspiring and appreciate seeing how this larger format performs on various subjects. I certainly wouldn't use "mediocre" to describe the efforts of the posts. They show photographers pushing the envelope of better resolution and quality. Thanks for the efforts!

I hope more people get involved in the larger format, and as more used gear comes on the market, we'll probably see more people posting. Including me, I hope.
Sep 07, 2018 at 06:59 AM
johnvanr
Offline
Details
p.84 #15Medium Format Digital Images Thread
Steve Spencer wrote:
johnvanr wroteOnce in a while, I check out this thread and I can’t help feeling that a lot of images are just mediocre. They may be taken with a great camera, but they’re still mediocre. The camera doesn’t make the image, the light and composition do. And, granted, if those are great, your cameras will make better images than the others, but still...

(Btw, I have the same feeling about some other camera threads. Nothing personal...)
John, of course it is the photographer together with the subject matter that makes a great shot. Keep in mind there are really only about 20 or so people who ever post in this thread. That isn't a very large group, and I think there are several of us who would really like to keep the thread going and are therefore less picky about what they post to this thread than to other threads here on FM. I know that is true for me. Of course you will see a lot more fabulous images on a thread like the
...Show more →

Fair point. I also think the web isn't the best place to show off the amazing IQ and rendition that MF can bring. I know the few times I've shot with MF, the pictures were nothing to write home about, but seeing them on my monitor still wows me.
Sep 07, 2018 at 07:21 AM
retrofocus
Online
Details
p.84 #16Medium Format Digital Images Thread
Steve Spencer wrote:
Keep in mind there are really only about 20 or so people who ever post in this thread. That isn't a very large group, and I think there are several of us who would really like to keep the thread going and are therefore less picky about what they post to this thread than to other threads here on FM.


Main problem with this thread here is its limitation to digital only. In other forums outside of FM general medium format photo threads are well attended with many images posted - but the majority of photos are film-based even to this day. A pure digital medium format photo thread will only find more participation (including "better" photos posted as discussed earlier) if the price for digital medium format becomes more affordable. Also, let's not forget that the definition of digital medium format is very loose and most often just relates to sensors a big bigger than FF. Closest to one traditional 4.5x6 medium format is the just released (and very expensive) Phase One XF IQ4 camera. The sensor/film size plays IMO a big role when discussing medium format photos.

Currently on FM, some amazing medium-format photos can be found in the general film photo thread.
Sep 07, 2018 at 07:23 AM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.84 #17Medium Format Digital Images Thread
retrofocus wrote:
Steve Spencer wroteKeep in mind there are really only about 20 or so people who ever post in this thread. That isn't a very large group, and I think there are several of us who would really like to keep the thread going and are therefore less picky about what they post to this thread than to other threads here on FM.
Main problem with this thread here is its limitation to digital only. In other forums outside of FM general medium format photo threads are well attended with many images posted - but the majority of photos are film-based even to this day. A pure digital medium format photo thread will only find more participation (including "better" photos posted as discussed earlier) if the price for digital medium format becomes more affordable. Also, let's not forget that the definition of digital medium format is very loose and most often just relates to sensors a big bigger than FF. Closest to one
...Show more →

I'd like to see film MF images added to this thread. However, I am not the op and can't change the title. Maybe PM fred?

70mm Summarit Stitched






Sep 07, 2018 at 11:01 AM
retrofocus
Online
Details
p.84 #18Medium Format Digital Images Thread
zhangyue wrote:
retrofocus wrote
Steve Spencer wroteKeep in mind there are really only about 20 or so people who ever post in this thread. That isn't a very large group, and I think there are several of us who would really like to keep the thread going and are therefore less picky about what they post to this thread than to other threads here on FM.
Main problem with this thread here is its limitation to digital only. In other forums outside of FM general medium format photo threads are well attended with many images posted - but the majority of photos are film-based even to this day. A pure digital medium format photo thread will only find more participation (including "better" photos posted as discussed earlier) if the price for digital medium format becomes more affordable. Also, let's not forget that the definition of digital medium format is very loose and most often just relates to sensors a big bigger than FF. Closest to one traditional 4.5x6 medium format is the just released (and very expensive) Phase One XF IQ4 camera. The sensor/film size plays IMO a big role when discussing medium format photos.

Currently on FM, some amazing medium-format photos can be found in the general film photo thread.
I'd like to see film MF images added to this thread. However, I am not the op and can't change the title. Maybe PM fred?

70mm Summarit Stitched

https://farm2.staticflickr.com/1819/42150633480_ed08b04502_h.jpg


No worries, just to make it clear, I also like the majority of photos presented here in the digital thread - I am just not often active here since I don't have a digital MF camera. Didn't want to push it to have analog photos posted here, too. Maybe I should start a film-based medium-format thread which doesn't exist here yet to my knowledge....
Sep 07, 2018 at 11:08 AM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.84 #19Medium Format Digital Images Thread
zhangyue wrote:
I'd like to see film MF images added to this thread. However, I am not the op and can't change the title. Maybe PM fred?


if the image is on the internet it is "digital".

i gotta dust off my TLR.

Sep 08, 2018 at 02:40 PM
RickJames
Offline
Details
p.84 #20Medium Format Digital Images Thread
Pentax 645D & 45-85 F4.5

IMGP9320 by RickZPhoto, on Flickr
Sep 09, 2018 at 11:50 AM


FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister