Bif has presented some pro/con ... no love-struck fanboy with blinders on (not his style). My take on what he has brought to our attention is that he noticed the performance increase as notable improvement above previously seen levels. I noticed the addition of layers in a RAW converter as improvement above previously seen functionality.
Seeing an improvement in both performance and functionality that hasn't been seen elsewhere simply gives cause to go ... hmmmm. Whether that "hmmmm" bears out now, or more as "one to watch" is part of taking a peek at it. Other software producers have been NOTORIOUS for releasing buggy software and letting the consumer "Beta Test" after purchasing (gee, any names come to mind) and we have prolifically noted such in this forum. Well, if Corel/ASP follows this trend of sell it, then fix it like we've seen from others (now who could it be that has been doing that) ... then I think there is POTENTIAL to watch for.
Ultimately, I want a tool that works (as we all do) and if the tool doesn't perform ... you can't pay me to use it. Bif's point a "addressable bugs" is one of perspective. Some folks are ready to slay them, some are willing to try and help them. Will there be some growing pains from where they've come and where they might currently be ... maybe so. Are they lagging in some areas, I'd say yes. But seeing a commitment to multi-core performance (as presented by Bif) that others haven't harnessed, and seeing a commitment to layers (which LR fans have been asking for for a very, very long time) is something I see as half-full rather than half-empty.
Given that Adobe has as much as said that PS is not going to be further developed, maybe they can now turn their attention to LR @ performance for multi-core and layers. Despite the bugs, ASP is showing that it CAN be done. Now, even if ASP doesn't become the industry standard to replace LR (ain't gonna happen), maybe ASP can put a little pressure on LR in the next few years to help Adobe turn LR into the LR that everyone really wants it to be.
For my money (all $15 of it), giving a little support to ASP either as an option to LR or as a nudge to move Adobe (dreaming, I know) in a few years isn't a lost cause. As I mentioned, there are a few things I saw that warrant change, but it is just hard to dismiss the fact that they appear to be harnessing multi-core differently than others and have added layers functionality differently from others.
Rag on Corel's history if you like, but it would also seem as though they have presented something that no one else in history has done before. So, if history is your thing ... it is a double edged sword and multi-core/layers in RAW converter is cutting edge atm. Is it a "ragged" cut right now ... maybe, but if it has been retooled, then it will only need honing.
LR otoh will likely need retooling ... hmmm @ whether or not Adobe will ever retool to take advantage of muti-core. Without some pressure from competition, I don't ever see them doing so. So, if they are working on LR6 now (likely not retooling), and it takes a couple years for ASP to debug and pick up steam, LR7 will be in development. People start to make some noise (like we haven't already clamored for better multi-core/layers) @ Corel/ASP did it, why can't Adobe/LR ... well, maybe by LR9 or LR10 would be looking at retooling for multi-core. In that amount of time Corel/ASP has much opportunity to contend with addressable bugs, etc.
The future will show today as history. Will it show Corel/ASP as a retooling commitment that goes on to mature, or will it show another Corel bungled opportunity. Hard to say, but multi-core and layers in RAW Converter ... for me, those two are hinting at something to come.