fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2013 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2013Corel AfterShot Pro

  
 
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Corel AfterShot Pro
Fluid is always a challenge on resource constrained gear/OS.

I'm in the market for a new laptop to be certain, but am torn between something lightweight and something I can load 16GB RAM into. That and I haven't found a 14" IPS, anti-glare display yet (in a quad machine). I've been chasing 95% gamut, but I might have to give up that parameter in favor of IPS. Lenovo rep told me today that they make no 14" IPS, so I'm @ for others vs. 15.6". If I do go with something lighter @ less resource, the efficiency of the software to utilize those resources could help offset things a bit.
Sep 12, 2013 at 01:24 PM
keithreeder
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Corel AfterShot Pro
Despite the gushing fanboyism for ASP here, it has, without question the worst IQ of any commercially-available converter out there, especially if you shoot Canon.

In particular, the profiles for Canon cameras (even those that have been supported since way back when, like my 7D) are awful - they're not even close to accurate, especially in the blues (I've had some of the most bizarre skies I've ever seen from ASP conversions); and this problem is made a hundred times worse by ASP's execrable highlight recovery, which to be blunt isn't even good enough to qualify as crap - all you get with ASP's "recovery" is grey "whites" across the image which kill contrast and which even bugger up the midtones; and - as often than not - magenta/pink highlights.

Add to this the continued existence of bugs which I first reported (way back in 2005!) as a Bibble 3 user, like the show-stopping "edge pixel bug" (where conversions randomly lose pixel-wide sections from the edges of the image - it was still there in ASP conversions I did last night!) and utterly broken white balance, and you'll realise that ASP is a joke compared to converters like Lr and Photo Ninja.

Oh, and speed? on my decently-specced machine, Photo Ninja converts a 7D file to a 1300 px 16-bit tiff in just over a second; ASP takes up to ten seconds. (And yes, PN is faster with full-sized exports too, albeit not by as much - I use the reduced-size example simply to make the point).

If your experience of Lr can be characterised as involving "constant lags with just about everything you try to do", you might want to learn to use it properly - it ain't like that for me.

Some of us have been around Bibble/ASP long enough to know just how flawed it really is. It's literally not in the same game as Photo Ninja or Lr, and God help you if you find an ASP bug or need support for a (not necessarily very new) camera before you retire...

Edited on Sep 12, 2013 at 03:07 PM · View previous versions
Sep 12, 2013 at 02:53 PM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Corel AfterShot Pro
To challenge LR and other RAW converters they have to keep up with camera support. 1DX was released over a year ago and still no support for it. Other people in reviews were pointing out other camera's not supported as well. That's going to kill the potential of this product.
Sep 12, 2013 at 03:03 PM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Corel AfterShot Pro
Well at least we have some specific claims now. That's better. The flying testosterone covered butt-monkeys aren't useful tho.


  1. I'm not sure I believe you about the Canon Camera profiles being off. How many have you actually tried? It looks like the one for the 7D might be a little wonky at times tho. See below.
  2. You're right about the highlight recovery feature being too broad and gouging into the midtones. And using the one in the Exposure tool which has a clamp range associated with it isn't any better. The clamp operates on the opposite of the end of the range needed to fix the problem. It's fill Light has similar issues too. This is some pretty big trouble IMO. They need to address these ASAP!
  3. The Noise Ninja Edge Pixel Bug only affects like, one out of a hundred people and is hardly a show stopper when Wavelet Denoiser exists as a work-around (maybe even to a better end results). Still you're right it should be fixed. I bet they don't tho, usually developers don't fix stuff that's no longer supported and Noise Ninja is no longer a part of AfterShot by their reckoning.
  4. I think you're right about the White Balance too. If the image is about right to begin with it's no problem but something is definitely fishy. This is another point that's pretty serious.
  5. I call BS on your Tiff times. Or, your HDD was erring. I did a group of fifty 7D CR2 files to Tiff 16bit 1300px and the operation took 30s (again on my ancient MP1,1 x5355 xeon). So I tried one at a time both with versioning and overwriting and both ways were about a half a second.
  6. About my experience with constant lags being incompetence I could say the same for you with your tiff times. But the fact remains there are 100's of people on every photo-forum with nice machines who complain about LR's lagginess. Just as there are (so far) a very high percentage of AfterShot users who claim the speed is incredible. In both cases I seem to be in the majority. I haven't recently gone back over all the newest versions of everything but about 12 or 18 months ago I spent considerable effort in a second round (second to the one I did 3 or 4 years back) of timing apps - both across a proficient user's pro level workflow and also benchmark type times like the 50 CR2 files I did here (but more extensively of course). Of the 15 or so apps tested LR was the slowest when projects were of a size a pro might typically process. With under a hundred files LR was kinda average however. So for weekenders LR is probably fine. The thing is, I don't want to use, support, or recommend an app that bogs down on people when they try and get serious with it.
  7. I did actually get a few 7D files that initially read in with a weird magenta cast. However selecting either "Apply Initial Setting" or "Apply Default Settings" cleared that right up. So I'm not sure what's going on there. Apparently it's confused by the 7D's EXIF on initial import or read - but in a way which gets straightened out when the values are reapplied.
  8. Yes, God help us all in all of our endeavors! Not sure he's too concerned about image processing applications tho.
  9. Also it's true that there are currently some holes in the camera support Corel offers with AfterShot. There are like 8 or ten popular cameras (a Nex, some Fuji's, and so on - plus it looks to me like no MFDB are currently supported), which are MIA. Corel says they're aggressively working on this tho.


In conclusion so far it looks like AfterShot is standing with a firm potential with it's more than excellent core but needs a few fixes here and there before a professional can commit to it as a main pipeline tool.




Edited on Sep 13, 2013 at 05:43 AM · View previous versions
Sep 12, 2013 at 08:28 PM
dcains
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Corel AfterShot Pro
^^^^Bibble 4 had many of those same issues, and of course, so did Bibble 5 - Long before there was a 7D. How patient should Corel's customers be while waiting for fixes? AFS sells for $15 because that's what the market will bear for such a low-end product, and guys paying $15 very likely don't know the difference. Guys paying $150, or more, for software, probably do. Bibble died for good reason, and so will AFS. Having said that, if the program works for you, enjoy it.
Sep 12, 2013 at 10:08 PM
Lasse Eriksson
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Corel AfterShot Pro
dcains wrote:
^^^^Bibble 4 had many of those same issues, and of course, so did Bibble 5 - Long before there was a 7D. How patient should Corel's customers be while waiting for fixes? AFS sells for $15 because that's what the market will bear for such a low-end product, and guys paying $15 very likely don't know the difference. Guys paying $150, or more, for software, probably do. Bibble died for good reason, and so will AFS. Having said that, if the program works for you, enjoy it.


+1

I prefer paying a bit more for a software like the LR. It's still a rather low price. And it's way better
Sep 13, 2013 at 12:42 AM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Corel AfterShot Pro
On the other hand there were a bunch of negative nannies just EXACTLY like this for LightWave3D who started in with the negative generalizations just exactly like this, at version 6. It reached a fever pitch by version 8 two or three years later. And they were right, there were some bugs and some tools were incompetent compared to industry standards. They also said the software would die. OMG, you should have seen it. On every CG forum - just exactly like this thread but hundreds of pages long. They were eating their words by version 9.5 after I and several others designed or redesigned some of it's critical components. Now at version 11.6 and really by version 10 it's probably the single most important CG application in the CG boutique industry once again. I wonder if history isn't repeating itself...

So you can all claim it'll die and plus-one each other if you like but all you're doing is making yourselves look silly and assuming you also believe what your saying, limiting your own options. The fact is ASP's core is one of the strongest if not thee strongest in the industry. There's not another application I know of that's this fast without throwing tens of thousands of dollars in fast hardware at it. Does it have a few misconfigured tools and a wonky camera profile or two? It would seem so, yes. But that doesn't spell it's demise. It's $15 at amazon ONLY and everywhere else it's $79 to $99 with sales up from what I can gather, after it's July release of version 1.2 - So give the little guy a break. The company seems serious about raising the tool and feature set to higher standards. I say we wait and see. If what they say is true then in just another couple of months we ought to have another 10 or 20 camera profiles and some needed bug-fixes.

With a core engine this fast it would be pretty self-destructive of us to shine it on completely because of a few very addressable bugs. My hunch is that the folks who take advantage of the $15 price will be really glad they did! And given they don't have the one or two affected Canons and aren't shooting landscapes can be pretty happy right now. Let's see.
Sep 13, 2013 at 03:17 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Corel AfterShot Pro
Bif has presented some pro/con ... no love-struck fanboy with blinders on (not his style). My take on what he has brought to our attention is that he noticed the performance increase as notable improvement above previously seen levels. I noticed the addition of layers in a RAW converter as improvement above previously seen functionality.

Seeing an improvement in both performance and functionality that hasn't been seen elsewhere simply gives cause to go ... hmmmm. Whether that "hmmmm" bears out now, or more as "one to watch" is part of taking a peek at it. Other software producers have been NOTORIOUS for releasing buggy software and letting the consumer "Beta Test" after purchasing (gee, any names come to mind) and we have prolifically noted such in this forum. Well, if Corel/ASP follows this trend of sell it, then fix it like we've seen from others (now who could it be that has been doing that) ... then I think there is POTENTIAL to watch for.

Ultimately, I want a tool that works (as we all do) and if the tool doesn't perform ... you can't pay me to use it. Bif's point a "addressable bugs" is one of perspective. Some folks are ready to slay them, some are willing to try and help them. Will there be some growing pains from where they've come and where they might currently be ... maybe so. Are they lagging in some areas, I'd say yes. But seeing a commitment to multi-core performance (as presented by Bif) that others haven't harnessed, and seeing a commitment to layers (which LR fans have been asking for for a very, very long time) is something I see as half-full rather than half-empty.

Given that Adobe has as much as said that PS is not going to be further developed, maybe they can now turn their attention to LR @ performance for multi-core and layers. Despite the bugs, ASP is showing that it CAN be done. Now, even if ASP doesn't become the industry standard to replace LR (ain't gonna happen), maybe ASP can put a little pressure on LR in the next few years to help Adobe turn LR into the LR that everyone really wants it to be.

For my money (all $15 of it), giving a little support to ASP either as an option to LR or as a nudge to move Adobe (dreaming, I know) in a few years isn't a lost cause. As I mentioned, there are a few things I saw that warrant change, but it is just hard to dismiss the fact that they appear to be harnessing multi-core differently than others and have added layers functionality differently from others.

Rag on Corel's history if you like, but it would also seem as though they have presented something that no one else in history has done before. So, if history is your thing ... it is a double edged sword and multi-core/layers in RAW converter is cutting edge atm. Is it a "ragged" cut right now ... maybe, but if it has been retooled, then it will only need honing.

LR otoh will likely need retooling ... hmmm @ whether or not Adobe will ever retool to take advantage of muti-core. Without some pressure from competition, I don't ever see them doing so. So, if they are working on LR6 now (likely not retooling), and it takes a couple years for ASP to debug and pick up steam, LR7 will be in development. People start to make some noise (like we haven't already clamored for better multi-core/layers) @ Corel/ASP did it, why can't Adobe/LR ... well, maybe by LR9 or LR10 would be looking at retooling for multi-core. In that amount of time Corel/ASP has much opportunity to contend with addressable bugs, etc.

The future will show today as history. Will it show Corel/ASP as a retooling commitment that goes on to mature, or will it show another Corel bungled opportunity. Hard to say, but multi-core and layers in RAW Converter ... for me, those two are hinting at something to come.

Sep 13, 2013 at 07:50 AM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Corel AfterShot Pro
Good post Rusty!

I think I may have figured out what is going on with this magenta thing. Either that or I discovered a new bug.

When you double-click (or slide) on any color balance setting anywhere to change or reset its value it changes the White Balance preset from "As Shot" to "Custom Kelvin" - even if the slider value was already on it's default (as loaded) position.

So let's say you load an image and immediately move the Tint or Temp (as so many of us normally might do) but the changes are not satisfactory for whatever reasons. You double-click on it to reset the value to what you think is the loaded state and navigate to the next (nearly identical) image to see if that's easier to get right. You get the second one right (let's say), process it, and quit ASP. When you load ASP the next time and cursor over or to that first image you gave up on and reset - it's still assigned to "Custom Kelvin". This would be fine if "Custom Kelvin" didn't have different ideas about the magenta channel than whatever "As Shot" produces given identical values for Tint and Temp.

To demonstrate this here's a gif anim of ASP with an image loaded were no other values are being changed. Only the mouse is rolling over the two profiles: "As Shot" and "Custom Kelvin". Nothing else is being modified and all displayed numerical values remain the same throughout the GUI. You might notice that the histogram is also changing here.



If "Custom Kelvin" in ASP is supposed to act like "Custom" in ACR where any changes set the white balance profile name to "Custom" which I assume it is, then "Custom Kelvin" given the same numerical values, should display identically to "As Shot" - yet here it adds a ton of magenta. Yup, Bug. Tho probably nothing to do with camera profiles?
Sep 13, 2013 at 01:15 PM
Hulot
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Corel AfterShot Pro
I like afp because it works well with snow leopard, it is easy to learn and makes use of the mac file system. on the downside it seems not to read dng files. I see it as an alternative to ps bridge.

IMO raw conversations are as good as it gets, there is no real difference to adobe converters
Sep 13, 2013 at 05:04 PM
keithreeder
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Corel AfterShot Pro
RustyBug wrote:
Bif has presented some pro/con ... no love-struck fanboy with blinders on (not his style).


And yet that's precisely what this thread is - uninformed gushing praise based on no worthwhile experience of this miserable product.

He's learning, though (Bifurcator = Tesselator):

http://forum.corel.com/EN/viewtopic.php?f=94&t=51151
http://forum.corel.com/EN/viewtopic.php?f=94&t=51582
http://forum.corel.com/EN/viewtopic.php?f=94&t=51588 (This one is particularly amusing - the tone of his posting actually suggests that the highlights issues inherent in ASP were an unknown before he posted. I was banging on about broken highlight recovery way back in the Bibble days (as were others), and "hyper critical" or not, it has been roundly ignored as an issue for years and years. That's what you get for your $15).

So. Pretty much exactly the issues I mention up the page. Jumped into your ASP love-fest a bit too quickly, eh, Bifurcator?

And - "Bif" - I don't appreciate your arrogant dismissal of the edge pixel bug as trivial because it doesn't matter to you. There are lots of folk out there who find ASP unusable because of it - imagine what it means to people who stitch panoramas.

Besides, the very idea of having to scrutinise the edges of every single image from a 2000+ image shoot in case the artefact shows up, is more than enough of a basis to rule ASP as a non-starter for many of us.

Oh - and Wavelet Denoise as a replacement for NN? Please! And it doesn't fix the bug anyway!

As to the processing times - call "BS" 'til you're blue in the face. They're accurate, and I used to see the exact same thing with Bibble 5 on an entirely different machine, in comparison with Capture One. They're directly impacted on by the need to rely on umpteen user-written plug-ins necessary to make up (or not) for the many and wide-ranging functional shortfalls in ASP/Bibble.

I'll say it again - some of us know all about ASP. It's crap.
Sep 14, 2013 at 05:31 AM
Ho1972
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Corel AfterShot Pro
keithreeder wrote:
I'll say it again - some of us know all about ASP. It's crap.


Too bad, really, but it is Corel after all. They can buy (they don't seem to be capable of development) a perfectly good piece of software and destroy it in short order (see: Knockout). It's unlikely that they can take a piece of flawed software, such as Bibble, and sort out the bugs that eluded the original developers for years. If past experience is any indicator, they *will* add several bugs of their own.
Sep 14, 2013 at 06:52 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.3 #13Corel AfterShot Pro
Unfortunately the marketplace is just not that competitive with Adobe. Sure there are alternatives out there but they all have issues in some form or other. Given the momentum that Adobe has and people wanting to have the "industry standard" there is just not anyone willing to spend the resources to compete with them on a level feature set.
Sep 14, 2013 at 05:25 PM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Corel AfterShot Pro

Using ASP with LR.

An overview of ASP.


BTW, the Amazon $15 deal is now gone but a $30 deal has replaced it.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0073LIDE4 and that's still a 70% discount.
Oct 25, 2013 at 10:20 AM
FM ForumsPost-processing & PrintingJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister