Yeah, you were gonna toss me your "top 3" (iirc) for consideration in lieu of ACR, which I've never cared much for, but still use PS for its functionality. Seeing ASP with the ability to have layers/opacity adjustments ... sounds promising enough to put it in some effort toward the learning curve (old dog, new tricks, kinda slow @ change these days) to see how it goes @ harnessing what it has to offer.
Lot of folks rave @ LR (which I have and rarely use) in lieu of PS ... but without layers LR comes up short for me as a solution. Seeing ASP as LR type RAW converter + layers, yields promise (or at least some hope) in lieu of incurring large file sizes while working on RAW @ PS where I can get resource (RAM) constrained. Will have to see how it plays in Peoria as I give it a go.