There are definitely different things that can make people think "3D!". Subject/background separation is one, but it can be a fairly "cardboard-cutout" type of 3D look. Getting real depth into the parts that are in focus is harder, and depends on the subject, the lighting, etc I think. For the lens, having good "microcontrast" (another controversial term, but whatever) helps.
p.3 #43D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
I'll play with one shot each from some Contax lenses I use which often are accredited to be quite prone to produce 3D. While I agree to that I also see what I look for considering 3D in many other lenses. Some of the Canon L's are included there.
In the OP I see none, but e.g. jojomon's #1 (b/w tire) looks very 3D to me.
Short DOF is the thing here together with a certain amount pof "presence" so far in this thread. But the holy grail in 3D for me is the ones not employing that, shots of rather flat surfaces that yields a lot of presence. I have none but they appear every now and then including here at FM.
p.3 #73D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
wfrank, your Planar 85/1.4 (old car) example is particularly interesting. Even on a laptop screen I can easily detect separation between reflectors+front wheels, steering wheel, front seats and back seats and finally, the driver and the plane of back seats. This is a great example of 3D!
I recall once you posted an image of a kinked tree branch or a stick, or something like it. If my memory serves, it had fantastic 3D effect.
p.3 #83D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
Some examples. Zeiss is almost guaranteed to give 3D, but some other lenses as well. The Kodak SLR/c makes any lens much more "3D-able" probably due to no AA filter + some x-factor with the sensor/processing.
p.3 #93D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
wfrank wrote: mortyb wroteIs it 2 or 3 year intervals between every 3D thread? Yes, that tree does it for me too.
But the interval is more like 1.5-2 years :-)
i was thinking more like 6 months.
here's some that i think have some 3d to them and everything is in focus. i just took the first everything in focus shots i found in my photostream that were shot with the contax g 45 on a NEX camera so i could probably find shots that do a better job of it if i spent a little more time looking.
p.3 #113D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
I agree w/ Wilhelm about jojomon's B&W tire picture. Very 3D to me.
Meanwhile - Wilhelm, the EXIF in your 2/100 picture of the two guys says it was 1.4/50? I was wondering what aperture that one was shot at because the DOF is really great, not as super-thin as it would be at f/2 with the 100mm, but still shallow enough to give the subject isolation.
p.3 #203D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
snapsy wrote: SKumar25 wroteLots of people believe 3-d look only come about with shallow DOF. I am of the contrary opinion.
Sebboh shared some nice stopped down examples. Would love to see more.
I'll see if I can dig up some.To my eyes it's general the lighting/tonality that gives photos a 3-D look.
yes, sideways light helps a lot for making objects look more 3D and for photography in general. some lenses make the subtle nuances pop more and seem to bring out the look more easily. i actually think color transmission may play a roll too. i have some (non polarized) sunglasses with a warm coloration that make the real world appear more 3D somehow.
anyway, here's a few everything in focus shots with the g28 that i think have a 3D look to them:
this one i didn't bother to correct the color shift but i still get a strong sense of the shape and depth of the objects.
this shot has a veiling haze of fog making the flattest light possible