p.7 #1Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Stu, both 400 II and 300 II are very special, in the long tradition of 300 & 400 f/2.8 lenses.
However, 500 II and 600 II are success stories as well.
I believe that intrinsic resolving power alone is not the best differentiating factor amongst those four lenses. I think one has to look beyond it, at issues such as weight/handling, AF performance and TC performance.
p.7 #4Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Bones74 wrote: MDJAK wroteAs one of Canon's most highly anticipated and sought after lenses, I can certainly understand all the measurbating going on. To my old eyes, the sigma for what, one third the price, is damn close.
As to comparisons between the 400 prime, I think that misses the point. The sheer versatility of the zoom with 1.4 speaks for itself. But when I look at the fact it costs more than the new 500 prime, I'm a bit put off. More so when I see its five thousand more than the Nikon 200-400 sans TC. I mean really. Having owned the version I of the Nikon 200-400, however, and never being quite fond of it, I'm not sure I'd love this one. I got a hankering for the 500 which is increasingly seeming to be a better buy.I think the point (my point) really is that because the 200-400L is priced so much higher than the already high priced 400ii (and 500 ii) it needs to be closer optically, not just brilliantly versatile. I don't expect it to perform miracles and match the 400 ii, but FWIW I also don't think the price is warranted. If I were going to drop this amount on a lens I'd have to be happy with it 100% and based on what I've seen I might be left a little disappointed.
I think we all had very high expectations from reviews (Andy Rouse for one) that the 200-400L is as good as the new primes, but a whole lot more versatile. The 500 ii certainly looks like the best buy ...Show more →
Instead of the 200-400L lens, I could buy the 100-400L + 500 II L IS for the same price
p.7 #7Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
This morning I stumbled upon a small flock of Common terns fishing frantically in a relative proximity of the shore. Some of them were too far for 400 f/2.8 IS MkII which I had on me, some of them were too close, as that often happens.
I guess 200-400mm zoom might have helped with proximity shots, if I could zoom out in time, which is not a given with those erratically flying/diving birds.
However, what I needed much more than a zoom, was a real light lens, something like 300 f/2.8 IS MkII or 400 DO, because I had to quit shooting after about 1/2 hour, as my arms, shoulders and back began to ache real bad due to high repetition rate of shots.
(Handheld 400 f/2.8 IS MkII is a great action lens, however, once such action becomes a bit intense and extended in duration, then the fatigue sets in quickly.)
This is obviously my own specific need (and limitations.) If one is using a pod, then the weight is not much of a consideration. However, if one is using a pod, then the keeper rate on Common terns and such is not likely to be very good.
p.7 #8Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
PetKal wrote:
This morning I stumbled upon a small flock of Common terns fishing frantically in a relative proximity of the shore. Some of them were too far for 400 f/2.8 IS MkII which I had on me, some of them were too close, as that often happens.
I guess 200-400mm zoom might have helped with proximity shots, if I could zoom out in time, which is not a given with those erratically flying/diving birds.
However, what I needed much more than a zoom, was a real light lens, something like 300 f/2.8 IS MkII or 400 DO, because I had to quit shooting after about 1/2 hour, as my arms, shoulders and back began to ache real bad due to high repetition rate of shots.
(Handheld 400 f/2.8 IS MkII is a great action lens, however, once such action becomes a bit intense and extended in duration, then the fatigue sets in quickly.)
This is obviously my own specific need (and limitations.) If one is using a pod, then the weight is not much of a consideration. However, if one is using a pod, then the keeper rate on Common terns and such is not likely to be very good. ...Show more →
Ah Peter, the secret to your success is bared:
"Early to bed, early to rise makes a man healthy, wealthy and wise"
p.7 #11Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
PhotoMaximum wrote:
I would try using a CF monopod and and a quality compact video fluid head for support and fluid movement when shooting fast moving birds like this...
You can try.......if it works OK for you, I might try too.
p.7 #12Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
With all the new kids using these cameras for video there is now a huge market for all kinds of stabilization systems. Fluid heads for video have gotten a lot smaller and better recently. If you are shooting sports then its easy to use your own body to move a 400 from side to side. Shooting birds in flight adds a lot of up and down movement which is more difficult when using a monopod. If this is a favorite subject then I would check out some of the new DSLR film making sites to see what kind of fluid heads are available. Sachtler and Miller make nice systems...
p.7 #13Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
PetKal: If one is using a pod, then the weight is not much of a consideration. However, if one is using a pod, then the keeper rate on Common terns and such is not likely to be very good.
Peter, have you considered or tried using a light carbon fiber monopod, with RRS MH-01 monopod head: resting on the monopod, say 80% of the time, and then lifting the whole rig and shooting hand held? I tried this using a 500 f4 version 1 at an airshow, and it worked exceedingly well! For me, it made the weight of the older 500 a non-issue.
p.7 #14Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Peter, that sounds like it would have been a very challenging workout for both photographer and equipment. The question of the zooming ability here is a good one because I find the throw of the zoom ring quite long, as earlier reported. This is great for precise framing, but coupled with the somewhat high resistance of the ring's action and the somewhat aggressive grippy and abrasive feeling of the rubber material, may pose some challenges. My impression is the lens designers probably optimized the zoom ring's feel for pod use where one's left hand will be able to apply more leverage to the ring than if also supporting the lens at the same time when hand held. And indeed, when shooting from a monopod it is less of an issue for me.
As for the debate about the value of the lens... it would seem one's geographic area is nearly as relevant as the intended uses for the lens. It's unfortunate that in the UK, for example, Canon has decided to set a price that commands such a considerable premium over the 400 II, whereas here in NA, it's about on par.
MDJAK wrote:
As one of Canon's most highly anticipated and sought after lenses, I can certainly understand all the measurbating going on. To my old eyes, the sigma for what, one third the price, is damn close.
As to comparisons between the 400 prime, I think that misses the point. The sheer versatility of the zoom with 1.4 speaks for itself. But when I look at the fact it costs more than the new 500 prime, I'm a bit put off. More so when I see its five thousand more than the Nikon 200-400 sans TC. I mean really. Having owned the version I of the Nikon 200-400, however, and never being quite fond of it, I'm not sure I'd love this one. I got a hankering for the 500 which is increasingly seeming to be a better buy. ...Show more →
This then is a perfectly reasonable line of thought for *your* needs. For me at least, and I assume also for many field-sports photographers, the comparison against the 400 is extremely logical because it's the defacto standard lens used for many of these sports. Gone are the days, except perhaps for SI's photographers, of showing up to games with an assistant and a barrage of prime tele lenses; 300, 400 and 600. As a result, the 400 was the 'compromise' of reach vs. speed. Now the zoom adds versatility, but with tradeoffs, some of which are compensated by current camera and sensor technology. My interest in this lens against the 400 v.I in particular is because that lens already delivers image quality acceptable to my clients. Therefore the zoom doesn't need to beat it, and the improved IQ of the V.2 super-teles is not necessarily desired or beneficial because my existing gear already provides for excellent image quality - better than merely good enough. Therefore, I'm looking for other benefits, primarily the flexibility of the zoom and the convenience of the built-in TC. The fact the zoom weighs around 1.5kg less than the 400 IS v.1 and is smaller in diameter (therefore easier to pack for travel) is an added bonus. As you can see, for me at least, the appeal of the v.2 super-teles was already tempered. I contemplated upgrading to the 400 II last year because the 200-400 was taking so long, but instead opted to try the 1DX, which for me at least was the right decision and resulted in a considerable (30-50%) increase in production per event. That said, the measurbating is warranted because it would be foolish to blindly accept a new piece of gear as replacement to a 'gold standard' without determining its strengths and weaknesses prior to using it for client work.
I hope I don't come across as defending this lens simply to justify my purchase, because it 'has to be good for this price.' Indeed the lens has some technical shortcomings that were carefully skirted by the few preproduction reviewers. Should we be surprised?
Hopefully the information presented here will be useful for others in making decision relevant to their needs, while also realizing others will have different, yet valid, expectations and requirements.
p.7 #16Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
PetKal wrote:
Ron, I did not know that about Leica lens design philosophy.
That brings to mind 500 f/4.5L which I used to own. The lens had 8 optical elements in total.
Today's 500 f/4 IS MkII has 16 elements, and 3 of those are part of the IS unit. Yet, the old 500 f/4.5 had remarkably good IQ, not a heck of a lot different from 500 II.
Yes, I've used the 500/4.5, particularly for motor sports and it was a really nice lens. It made an excellent pairing with the 300/2.8 because they complemented each other and both were about the same weight and easy to carry around all day.
Here's an extreme example of telephoto simplicity: the Leica 400/6.8 with a 2/1 optical design, and some nice sample images in this review.
I think the biggest contrast in the Zeiss vs. Leica lens design philosophy is at 50mm, where Zeiss will release a massive 12- element ~$4000 55mm/1.4 (a nice video here) vs. the ~$7000 50/2 Summicron APO, weighing in at 300g, 39mm filters and an 8/5 optical construction. Of course there are differences too because one is for SLRs while the other is for a rangefinder mount...
And if you think the price of the 200-400 is crazy, the per gram price for the Leica is well beyond the Canon.
p.7 #18Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Don Clary wrote: Earlier quotePetKal: If one is using a pod, then the weight is not much of a consideration. However, if one is using a pod, then the keeper rate on Common terns and such is not likely to be very good.Peter, have you considered or tried using a light carbon fiber monopod, with RRS MH-01 monopod head: resting on the monopod, say 80% of the time, and then lifting the whole rig and shooting hand held? I tried this using a 500 f4 version 1 at an airshow, and it worked exceedingly well! For me, it made the weight of the older 500 a non-issue.
Thank you, Don, I have thought of that, and might some day put in motion, for the right set of conditions.
Unfortunately my 5 series Gitzo + Wimberley II head weighs a ton, and I need to get something lighter.
p.7 #19Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Peter,
I have a Wimberley 1 (even heavier), but I don't use it on the monopod. I use the featherweight RRS MH-01. But come to think of it (lifting the whole rig), you don't need ANY head, since you are not shooting from the monopod. Just screw the monopod into the telephoto foot (even lighter). The monopod just allows you to rest your arm muscles in between shooting, and the one pound weight of my Induro carbon fiber monopod is barely noticed.
p.7 #20Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Peter, I hang my 500/4 is on a blackrapid sport strap and the Acra Swift clamp. I then clamp my monopod to the lens using an acratech long lens head on the monopod. The rrs plate for the 500 is long enough to hold both quick release clamps (monopod and swift clamp).
I then use a measuring tape leather pouch on my belt, and set the monopod into that. I can walk for hours and not even feel the weight. It's at shooting position and stabilized all the time!