fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2013 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2013Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X

  
 
dehowie
Offline
Details
p.6 #1Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Pixel Perfect wrote:
Scott Stoness wroteBut the choice of 400 vs 200-400 is the wrong discussion, its 100-400 vs 200-400. There is not a better zoom lens than the 100-400 in the long end, even though the 100-400 is 5.6 and a little weak in iq compared to 400/2.8.
And you can have a 100-400L, 1.4x TC and a 500 f/4 mk II for less than a 200-400L. I'd prefer a two camera setup with the zoom and prime.


How do you figure that??
1Dx plus 200-400= 6800+12300=19200
2x1Dx+100-400+500II=13600+1800+10500=25900 oh plus 1.4+ another 500...26400.

Two camera setup equals missed shots plus slower zoom and 7000 bucks extra..
One camera...one lens...saves weight saves money and a thousand times more flexibility...well 7000 times!
Jun 02, 2013 at 05:22 PM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.6 #2Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
200-400L is more complex than I thought: the TC alone has 8 elements (coloured yellow in the block diagram below), plus 25 elements in the lens proper makes it a 33 element lens !
Such design complexity surely explains a significant lens weight, as well as the length of time that it has taken to develop the lens.

See this Canon writeup on 200-400L..

I can't help but wonder about the stability of such monstrous design: fabrication copy-to-copy variations on one hand, and performance resistance to diverse environmental influences which are encountered in lens use.

Edited on Jun 10, 2013 at 03:12 PM · View previous versions
Jun 02, 2013 at 08:30 PM
lowa2
Offline
Details
p.6 #3Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Jun 02, 2013 at 08:40 PM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.6 #4Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Different they are, but I also see similarities.
Canon would have been foolish not to test it as well as take apart the Nikon lens in the beginning of the 200-400L design process.

No doubt, Nikon must have done a similar thing with 800L when they embarked on their 800mm lens design.

Even if one wants to start designing from ground zero, it is very useful to see a similar finished product by competition.
Jun 02, 2013 at 08:59 PM
dehowie
Offline
Details
p.6 #5Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Well given that each super tele is hand assembled and individually tested id say as in the past the copy to copy variation will be small at worst.
Fully internal zoom with sealing should mean little to no enviro issues
Good write up by Canon to very interesting..
Jun 02, 2013 at 09:04 PM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.6 #6Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
There is a major concern I've had for some time, related to these top tier lenses and cameras, which may well be specific to Canada only, I can't tell.
A lens such as 200-400L may well be built "like a Mercedes-Benz" , and sure it is priced "like a Mercedes-Benz". Yet, based on my experience with them, Canon Canada support organisation is steeped in the attitude as well as the know-how of a Pontiac dealer.

What will happen if 200-400L starts to exibit softness, TC misalignment/slop, or anomalous IS operation, just to use a few examples ? How well are Canon regional service centres equipped to diagnose and remedy such deficiencies ?

Jun 02, 2013 at 09:23 PM
JohnBrose
Offline
Details
p.6 #7Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Very informative thread and the comparison shots are helpful. For myself, if I was in the market for this focal length, I would be leaning to getting a new Sigma 120-300 and a Canon 400 2.8 and maybe add a converter or two if I want to go up to 800. This would give more flexibility, but not quite the convenience-it would give some redundancy though which is also important. Just my two cents I guess.
Jun 02, 2013 at 09:38 PM
rscheffler
Online
Details
p.6 #8Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Peter, that's a good question and perhaps one to ask Nikon 200-400 owners? If you count the elements in each, excluding the built-in TC, they have the identical number: 25 (excluding the front flat glass in the Nikon design, but including the drop-in filter). Perhaps both brands are following the Zeiss 'lens relaxation' design philosophy of using more elements that each make a smaller contribution to the optical design, in contrast to Leica's philosophy of the least amount of glass that is as small as possible, which places a lot more expectation on each element of the design and also requires extreme precision.

Maybe we can convince Roger Cicala to do a strip down of each lens once he gets stock of the Canon 200-400? In his past strip-down blog posts, it would seem Canon has made better, more modular, design choices that should be more durable and easier to service.

That said, when I read the optical specs, I too wondered about longterm optical performance. FWIW, in the late 90s, one of the retaining rings for an internal element in my 400/2.8 II (non-IS) popped loose, with the result being, the element it held in place also popping out of place and rattling loose around the inside of the lens.. happened in the middle of a sports event too. Canon Canada did fix it...
Jun 02, 2013 at 09:45 PM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.6 #9Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Ron, I did not know that about Leica lens design philosophy.

That brings to mind 500 f/4.5L which I used to own. The lens had 8 optical elements in total.
Today's 500 f/4 IS MkII has 16 elements, and 3 of those are part of the IS unit. Yet, the old 500 f/4.5 had remarkably good IQ, not a heck of a lot different from 500 II.

Edited on Jun 02, 2013 at 09:59 PM · View previous versions
Jun 02, 2013 at 09:57 PM
rscheffler
Online
Details
p.6 #10Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Continuing with some tests. Today it's field of view at equivalent focusing distances as well as at minimum focusing distance. Lenses compared against the 200-400 are the 300/4 IS, 400/2.8 IS v.1 and 600/4 IS v.1. I believe in another thread Whayne brought up the focus breathing issue based on the maximum magnification factor. He's right. Please note these images are uncorrected, SOOC AWB and aperture priority. They're not intended to show optimum image quality or sharpness - just framing/angle of view.

200-400 at MFD (2m):
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0008.jpg


200-400 at ~3m (equivalent to 400/2.8 IS v.1 MFD):
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0003.jpg


400/2.8 IS v.1 at MFD (~3m):
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0001.jpg


200-400 at ~3m with 1.4x TC enabled:
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0014.jpg


As you can see, at the same distance of ~3m, the zoom has a much wider field of view . At its MFD, it's about the same as the prime. The same thing plays out at 560mm. Also, if the zoom is at 560mm and 3m, it's about the same area of coverage as the bare 400 at 3m (as pointed out by Whayne below).

Against the 300/4 IS:

200-400 at MFD:
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0009.jpg


300 at 2m:
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0010.jpg


300 at MFD (1.5m):
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0011.jpg


Against the 600/4 IS v.1:

200-400 w/1.4x TC at MFD:
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0017.jpg


600 at MFD (5.5m):
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0023.jpg


200-400 w/1.4x TC at 5.5m:
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0026.jpg


Edited on Jun 02, 2013 at 11:45 PM · View previous versions
Jun 02, 2013 at 09:58 PM
StillFingerz
Offline
Details
p.6 #11Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Might a delay in release/shipping have something to do with ample training of staff for those 'major' service centers; in each country...just a thought. Given this is still early in the game for the 200-400L, Canon could still be playing catch up training/skill wise, but IDK, seems this is a pretty high profile bit of gear, would they really want to get it wrong...even at the support level
Jun 02, 2013 at 10:07 PM
Pixel Perfect
Offline
Details
p.6 #12Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
dehowie wrote:
Pixel Perfect wrote
Scott Stoness wroteBut the choice of 400 vs 200-400 is the wrong discussion, its 100-400 vs 200-400. There is not a better zoom lens than the 100-400 in the long end, even though the 100-400 is 5.6 and a little weak in iq compared to 400/2.8.
And you can have a 100-400L, 1.4x TC and a 500 f/4 mk II for less than a 200-400L. I'd prefer a two camera setup with the zoom and prime.
How do you figure that??
1Dx plus 200-400= 6800+12300=19200
2x1Dx+100-400+500II=13600+1800+10500=25900 oh plus 1.4+ another 500...26400.

Two camera setup equals missed shots plus slower zoom and 7000 bucks extra..
One camera...one lens...saves weight saves money and a thousand times more flexibility...well 7000 times!


Where the hell did the 1DX's come from. Man I'm talking a 5D III and 7D or 1D IV. 2 1DX's is for powerball winners.
Jun 02, 2013 at 10:15 PM
Pixel Perfect
Offline
Details
p.6 #13Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
rscheffler wrote:
Continuing with some tests. Today it's field of view at equivalent focusing distances as well as at minimum focusing distance. Lenses compared against the 200-400 are the 300/4 IS, 400/2.8 IS v.1 and 600/4 IS v.1. I believe in another thread Whayne brought up the focus breathing issue based on the maximum magnification factor. He's right. Please note these images are uncorrected, SOOC AWB and aperture priority. They're not intended to show optimum image quality or sharpness - just framing/angle of view.



The 400 f/2.8L IS mk I has mfd of 3m and vII has mfd of 2.7m

At mfd the 200-400L has a FL of ~ 250mm max (probably less); the primes suffer much much smaller loss of FL at mfd

At mfd you need the 1.4x TC in place on the 200-400L to just match the 100-400L at mfd for magnification
Jun 02, 2013 at 10:20 PM
robbymack
Offline
Details
p.6 #14Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
wow one of the more informative FM threads in a while. Thanks to all the contributors. A 200-400L is certainly not on the $$$ horizon for me any time soon, but I am now totally intrigued by the Sigma.
Jun 02, 2013 at 10:41 PM
dehowie
Offline
Details
p.6 #15Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Pixel Perfect wrote:
dehowie wrote
Pixel Perfect wrote
Scott Stoness wroteBut the choice of 400 vs 200-400 is the wrong discussion, its 100-400 vs 200-400. There is not a better zoom lens than the 100-400 in the long end, even though the 100-400 is 5.6 and a little weak in iq compared to 400/2.8.
And you can have a 100-400L, 1.4x TC and a 500 f/4 mk II for less than a 200-400L. I'd prefer a two camera setup with the zoom and prime.
How do you figure that??
1Dx plus 200-400= 6800+12300=19200
2x1Dx+100-400+500II=13600+1800+10500=25900 oh plus 1.4+ another 500...26400.

Two camera setup equals missed shots plus slower zoom and 7000 bucks extra..
One camera...one lens...saves weight saves money and a thousand times more flexibility...well 7000 times!
Where the hell did the 1DX's come from. Man I'm talking a 5D III and 7D or 1D IV. 2 1DX's is for powerball winners.

Even a pair of Mk3's it comes in at 3300x2+1800+10500+500=19400
Still more expensive and less capable setup and still dependent on two bodies to get the same range of action the 200-560 gets.
In short as long as the IQ lives up to the hype at being near prime quality(which it appears to be)it offers ultimate flexibility and quality combination.
Two cameras equals lost shots..been there done that..
Jun 02, 2013 at 10:46 PM
rscheffler
Online
Details
p.6 #16Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Some other observations:

CA is generally very well controlled in the zoom.
Vignetting is quite strong and I suspect some will find it objectionable. There's a pretty significant difference compared to the 400/2.8 IS v.1 at f/4. The zoom needs to f/8 at all focal lengths to pretty much eliminate it, though it's already much better at f/5.6.

I did some distant scene shots with all the above lenses as well, but am reluctant to post them because of several factors: I don't have suitable quick release plates for any of these lenses to facilitate quick and easy lens changes on a tripod (my real-world use of these lenses is for sports on a monopod). It was very windy today buffeting the lenses while on the monopod, though IS compensated pretty well, but framing was not consistent. Even though I used live view and contrast detect AF for focus, it was difficult to visually confirm it was good because of the buffeting. Partial cloud cover meant the distant scenes were always unevenly illuminated, which influences the look of a given image compared to the others.

That said, what I can deduce from these images is that the 400 prime holds some edge in overall clarity/contrast at f/4. It's probably helped somewhat that it's already stopped down one stop, which has cleared up much of its vignetting. At near infinity, the zoom at 400 is very slightly wider in angle of view than the prime. And the zoom has a slightly warmer/richer color palette. Compared to the 600 IS v.1, the zoom with TC is very, very competitive. It would be splitting hairs. Add the external 1.4x II TC (I don't have the newest version) and I'd give a slight edge to the zoom (with its 1.4x TC in place). With the external TC both lenses show more CA, so I think much of this is due to the external TC. Compared to the 300/4 IS, the zoom is sharper with better contrast.

Here are vignetting samples with the lens focused at infinity. Unfortunately I completely forgot to do a series at 560mm!! Considering the degree of vignetting, I do wonder how accurate the lens's f/4 designation is. While LR 4.4 doesn't have a lens correction profile for the zoom, I found the 100-400's vignetting correction to be pretty good, especially for the 200-400 at 560mm.

http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0237.jpg
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0238.jpg
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0241.jpg
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0244.jpg


http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0247.jpg
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0248.jpg
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0251.jpg
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0253.jpg

http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0258.jpg
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0259.jpg
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0261.jpg
http://ronscheffler.com/samples/fmcanon/200-400/20130602_0263.jpg
Jun 02, 2013 at 11:29 PM
rscheffler
Online
Details
p.6 #17Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Pixel Perfect wrote:
rscheffler wroteContinuing with some tests. Today it's field of view at equivalent focusing distances as well as at minimum focusing distance. Lenses compared against the 200-400 are the 300/4 IS, 400/2.8 IS v.1 and 600/4 IS v.1. I believe in another thread Whayne brought up the focus breathing issue based on the maximum magnification factor. He's right. Please note these images are uncorrected, SOOC AWB and aperture priority. They're not intended to show optimum image quality or sharpness - just framing/angle of view.
The 400 f/2.8L IS mk I has mfd of 3m and vII has mfd of 2.7m

At mfd the 200-400L has a FL of ~ 250mm max (probably less); the primes suffer much much smaller loss of FL at mfd

At mfd you need the 1.4x TC in place on the 200-400L to just match the 100-400L at mfd for magnification


Thanks for pointing that out. I think I got the specs confused after visiting the Canon museum site. That said, my 400 IS v.1's focusing ring does move a fair amount past 3m. I guess I'd have to break out a tape measure to see how much closer than 3m that would be in reality... The zoom at 560mm and ~3m is interestingly also about the same area of coverage as the prime at ~3m.

Again, like the whole debate around the merits of this lens, it depends entirely on the context in which you will use it. For me at least, I have about zero inclination to chase small birds/animals with it and instead will be photographing field sports. At least at infinity, the angle of view of the zoom vs. the prime is very, very close.
Jun 02, 2013 at 11:40 PM
Pixel Perfect
Offline
Details
p.6 #18Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
dehowie wrote:
Pixel Perfect wrote
dehowie wrote
Pixel Perfect wrote
Scott Stoness wroteBut the choice of 400 vs 200-400 is the wrong discussion, its 100-400 vs 200-400. There is not a better zoom lens than the 100-400 in the long end, even though the 100-400 is 5.6 and a little weak in iq compared to 400/2.8.
And you can have a 100-400L, 1.4x TC and a 500 f/4 mk II for less than a 200-400L. I'd prefer a two camera setup with the zoom and prime.
How do you figure that??
1Dx plus 200-400= 6800+12300=19200
2x1Dx+100-400+500II=13600+1800+10500=25900 oh plus 1.4+ another 500...26400.

Two camera setup equals missed shots plus slower zoom and 7000 bucks extra..
One camera...one lens...saves weight saves money and a thousand times more flexibility...well 7000 times!
Where the hell did the 1DX's come from. Man I'm talking a 5D III and 7D or 1D IV. 2 1DX's is for powerball winners.
Even a pair of Mk3's it comes in at 3300x2+1800+10500+500=19400
Still more expensive and less capable setup and still dependent on two bodies to get the same range of action the 200-560 gets.
In short as long as the IQ lives up to the hype at being near prime quality(which it appears to be)it offers ultimate flexibility and quality combination.
Two cameras equals lost shots..been there done that..


Plenty of us already have two cameras so I was not factoring that in, just the cost of the glass. It's no stretch to say people that can afford this sort of glass already have more than one camera. Even if you factor in that extra body cost (why are you factoring in two bodies, as you will always have at least one camera if you actually want to take photos), you are well under your pessimistic pricing.

Ok 1D III's can be found for $1-1.5K so where on earth did the $3300 dollars come from? Unless you meant 1D IV's?
Jun 03, 2013 at 12:31 AM
Bones74
Offline
Details
p.6 #19Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
mogud wrote:
All the analysis and discussion is very useful and very much appreciated. I want to be comfortable dropping the cash on the right lens that gives me the IQ I want. It's come down to the 200-400 or the 400 II and from what I see so far, it very close but edging toward the 400 II.


I met up with a friend and his brand new 400 ii yesterday and shot a couple of hundred images on a 5D3. From what I can tell, optically the only Canon lenses that can match it are the other mk2 primes (Peter/Petkal should be able to confirm or deny ). Despite being very good, the 200-400L is a noticeable step down, from the RAW files and high res samples I've seen.

There is still the versatility vs outright IQ divide so I don't believe it's price point is warranted IMhO, despite the excellent versatility. If the zoom was priced slightly below the 500 ii I'd have no hesitation in placing an order, because I really want one, but here in the UK it's £4300 more expensive and £3700 more expensive than the 400 ii.
Jun 03, 2013 at 03:00 AM
MDJAK
Offline
Details
p.6 #20Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
As one of Canon's most highly anticipated and sought after lenses, I can certainly understand all the measurbating going on. To my old eyes, the sigma for what, one third the price, is damn close.

As to comparisons between the 400 prime, I think that misses the point. The sheer versatility of the zoom with 1.4 speaks for itself. But when I look at the fact it costs more than the new 500 prime, I'm a bit put off. More so when I see its five thousand more than the Nikon 200-400 sans TC. I mean really. Having owned the version I of the Nikon 200-400, however, and never being quite fond of it, I'm not sure I'd love this one. I got a hankering for the 500 which is increasingly seeming to be a better buy.
Jun 03, 2013 at 04:20 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister