p.5 #1Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
lowa2 wrote: Bones74 wroteThanks Andrew, really appreciate you bringing us these comparisons Looks like you have two great lenses there. I guess it really depends on the individual and their needs as to whether the Canon represents good value for money or not. It's a very exciting lens though Tht sigma is soon to be mine
... and we want samples; cats, dogs, rocks, walls, Pijuns anything
p.5 #3Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Bones74 wrote: lowa2 wroteBones74 wroteThanks Andrew, really appreciate you bringing us these comparisons Looks like you have two great lenses there. I guess it really depends on the individual and their needs as to whether the Canon represents good value for money or not. It's a very exciting lens though Tht sigma is soon to be mine ... and we want samples; cats, dogs, rocks, walls, Pijuns anything
The first thing ill do is go shoot birds with it or my cats
p.5 #4Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Nice images of the Sigma it looks much better than the earlier photos.
When comparing one thing to remember is he Canon can replace 6 lenses(200,300,400,500 and 600)the Sigma topping out at 300 so barely half he focal length.
Flexibility it seems has a big price tag..
Oh its 12300 in Australia..and i though our Canon was ripping us off.
Once again the rest of the world is subsidizing cheap Nth American prices..
All were with the 1DX, RAW, processed in LR4 with the default settings and some tone curve tweaks to taste, though also not very strong, as well as WB to taste. The battle scenes were shot from a monopod, the head shot and close up were hand held.
Download the full-rez files here. Also, these are for personal evaluation purposes only. Please be respectful of my copyright to these images.
My thoughts:
I'm still working out correct MFA settings for the wide and tele ends, as well as the TC setting. But, without any MFA, my combo is definitely front focusing. Many of my lenses do so with this 1DX, which I should have looked at by Canon before the warranty expires. Currently I've settled on +4 for 200mm and +7 for 400mm.
It's dangerous trying to evaluate this lens from the camera's LCD. Images look a bit soft. You really need to shoot RAW to get as much sharpness out of the files as possible (true for every Canon camera I've used). Jpegs, even with NR off, look a bit smeared.
I'm not sure if it was the day, but my WB tint was in the +15-20 magenta range, which is a bit higher than my other Canon lenses.
There seems to be more vignetting at 400 and even more with the 1.4x in place.
AF is fast enough so far (nothing today was fast moving or challenging), but I don't think it's as fast through the full focus range as my 400 IS v.1... still have to compare this.
Walking around for 8 hours shooting this lens hand held for much of that time is tiring. The zoom is workable, but the texture of the rubber grip feels a bit uncomfortable. Perhaps too grippy and therefore a bit on the abrasive side (or I have sensitive fingers). A power zoom feature might have been nice.
The lens also attracted too much attention at this event. Primarily because people weren't used to seeing this size lens. As a result, it was a bit difficult to be inconspicuous for candid portraits. It also felt like overkill shooting closeups with it. And its size was kind of cramping my style, taking some of the fun out of fluid shooting, especially with the Leica. As an aside, I was a bit surprised by how many of the participants who approached me were also photographers, either hobbyists or professionals.
p.5 #6Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
dehowie wrote:
Nice images of the Sigma it looks much better than the earlier photos.
When comparing one thing to remember is he Canon can replace 6 lenses(200,300,400,500 and 600)the Sigma topping out at 300 so barely half he focal length.
Flexibility it seems has a big price tag..
Oh its 12300 in Australia..and i though our Canon was ripping us off.
Once again the rest of the world is subsidizing cheap Nth American prices..
But the Sigma can replace lenses shorter than 200mm (which the Canon can't) so you can probably get 6 lenses with that also if you like that
And the Sigma can replace lenses like the Canon 200/2,8 or 300/2,8 much better than the Canon because it replace those lenses both in focal length and the f/2,8 aperture, which the Canon can't do.
So only for lenses that are 400mm or longer the Canon have the edge when it comes to replace prime lenses.
p.5 #7Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Great feedback again, Ron, containing astute and practical considerations.
I do like your pictures too, and if the weather was a bit more pleasant, I would have also been there, probably with my 70-200 f/2.8 IS MkII.
p.5 #9Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
dehowie wrote:
Nice images of the Sigma it looks much better than the earlier photos.
When comparing one thing to remember is he Canon can replace 6 lenses(200,300,400,500 and 600)the Sigma topping out at 300 so barely half he focal length. Flexibility it seems has a big price tag..
I like the Sigma's flexibility a lot more as I can shoot both indoors and outdoors with it. F4 is not going to cut it for indoor work in the venues I shoot. Given the sample of photos so far the Sigma looks terrific at least in terms of sharpness. If it's AF tracking performance is solid it's a no brainer.
p.5 #10Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Thanks guys!
Peter, normally the longest I bring is the 70-200/4 IS and sometimes use the 1.4x TC. This year I decided to concentrate a lot on the battle re-enactments with the 200-400, but usually I'm more interested in 'life in the camp' photos and actually shoot a lot of that at 50 and wider.
Weather was a bit dicey in the afternoon and it did spit rain briefly, but it was never as bad as was forecast, which I suspect had some influence on attendance. Considering this year was the battle's 200th anniversary and had been hyped accordingly, it didn't seem noticeably busier.
BTW, saw a few Sigma 120-300s there.
Here are a couple more, again shot on a monopod. Just web rez for these...
Point here is I could barely see anything other than the candles/lanterns. While of course a faster lens would have been useful, the zoom's IS was good enough that a majority of the images shot at this shutter speed are usable.
My feeling about this lens so far is 'pick your poison.' The newest generation of super-tele primes will probably offer the absolute best image quality at the tradeoff of flexibility. Other zooms, such as the 100-400 style, will be smaller but up to a stop slower and currently a notch below for sharpness. As I wrote earlier, it will be interesting to see how much Canon can improve the optics in a 100-400 upgrade.
p.5 #11Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
andrewsk wrote:
I took the TC off the SIGMA and shot them head to head at F4 @ 300mm. Here the SIGMA returns to much better image quality, I think tieing the CANON.
For me the comparison to evaluate the 200-400 with is the 100-400. The 120-300 is short 100mm and 300mm is a bit short for wildlife which is typcially what I would use this lens for and typically fully extended. So a good test but short on the focal range.
At 300mm (no 1.4x and f5.6 on sigma and 400/5.6), visually the sigma is a smidge better than 100-400.
With the 1.4x the sigma degrades significantly vs the 100-400, which makes sense given the 1.4x add.
So the above pictures comparing 200-400 vs sigma 120-300w1.4 are consistent with the 200-400 at 400 being significantly better, which is expected. If it were not true the lens would be a failure.
Which confirms that the sigma is better than the canon 100-400 at 300mm particulary at the centre and ca. But not dramatically. Which is what shows up in thedigitial picture.com marginally better at 300mm.
Assuming that your 200-400 or 120-300 were not mfa adjusted, your 1.4x tests (200-400 much better) at 400 (sigma would have 1.4xon) are consistent with expectations, which is comforting.
The fact that you conclude that sigma 120-300 are even at 300mm also suggests that the 200-400 is better than the 100-400 at 300mm but here the focusing technique is critical to evaluation. From looking them over, I cannot visually tell which is better and they seem focussed in different spots, so it is not conclusive for me.
Anyway, a long rambling way to say, thank you for your efforts, and as yet the 200-400 has not failed in being better than the sigma with a 1.4x on it. [still a low bar though]
I would like to see the 200-400 compared to 100-400 or 400 2.8 at 400mm with a test target. Maybe we can get together and compare in the next few days.
p.5 #13Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Ron, great night shots those are, although as we talk about gears, |I think they are more of an 1DX accomplishment (and obviously, owing to your skill) than the lens proper: an f/4 lens is an f/4 lens when it comes to low light AF, or exposure, be it a $1000 or a $10,000 lens.
However, obviously 4 stop IS should help.
p.5 #14Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Doctorbird wrote: Now if only it were about 5lbs or less ......
At that price Canon ought to be utilizing the latest nano technology to engineer it.
Db
That's what I have thought numerous times about that lens.
If there was only one key aspect of the lens I could hang my photography hat on, so to speak.
Well, yes, there is the variable FL feature, from 200mm to 560mm. That, objectively speaking ought to be a great feature for many photographers, just to me personally it is of limited utility and appeal.....at any rate, not worth $12,000 in itself.
If the lens was no heavier than 3 kg, or if its IQ rivals 70-200 f/2.8 IS MkII ( ? ,,,,still an open question), or if it was priced at no more than $8k, that would give me something to hang my hat on.
That is too bad because I like testing such nice new gears.
Here's a little analogy with 400 DO. I do not have much enthusiasm for the IQ my 400 DO gives me, but I can live with it, because the lens has some unique key strengths: very low weight/very compact, and very good AF servo tracking performance. To me that represents a net gain compromise, particularly when considering I paid $5,000 for it which doesn't seem that much any longer.
Would I pay $10,000 for 400 DO MkII ? I would, but only if its IQ was commensurate to its price.
p.5 #15Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Thanks Morrell and Peter. Of course there is more at play than just the lens and there would be more than one way (set of equipment) to get comparable results, which I'm sure we'll eventually see as others at the event post images to Flickr, Google+, FB, etc... TBH, I was on the verge of packing up at that point - it was so dark and I didn't bring a tripod due to the inconvenience of lugging it around and setting one up in a crowd.
If it was 2007 and I was using a 1DIII or 1DIIN, then I'd be using the 400/2.8 for that extra stop of light. What I haven't shown are the many images shot both of the nighttime candle scene and from the rest of the evening's event somewhere between 200 and 400 that would have been difficult to achieve with a fixed 400 prime. My enthusiasm for the 200-400 is very much due to how it fits into my system as a whole and how I anticipate it will meet my needs. And the 1DX certainly makes f/4 more feasible, though I already felt this way about the 1DIV. While I already abandoned 70-200/2.8 lenses for the f/4 version back in around 2008, there really wasn't a viable f/4 long-lens solution until now (from Canon).
The 200-400 is really a 200-560 f/4-5.6. The difference from a standard 2.8x variable f-stop zoom is the guaranteed f/4 at 400mm, I think. Probably also some optical considerations. It would be an interesting question to pose to Canon's lens designers what benefit the 1.4x TC offers vs. a standard zoom design....
Scott Stoness wrote:
I would like to see the 200-400 compared to 100-400 or 400 2.8 at 400mm with a test target.
I still plan to compare it against the 400 IS v.1. I don't have access to a 100-400, though as I mentioned, the few shots I did with the one at the store show the 200-400 to be sharper at 400, when the focus is correct.
p.5 #16Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
All the analysis and discussion is very useful and very much appreciated. I want to be comfortable dropping the cash on the right lens that gives me the IQ I want. It's come down to the 200-400 or the 400 II and from what I see so far, it very close but edging toward the 400 II.
p.5 #17Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
mogud wrote:
All the analysis and discussion is very useful and very much appreciated. I want to be comfortable dropping the cash on the right lens that gives me the IQ I want. It's come down to the 200-400 or the 400 II and from what I see so far, it very close but edging toward the 400 II.
These lens are quite different - i have the 500v1 and 600 v2 and often find with either of them for large animals, I am shifting between 5dii and 7d and 1.4 and not to get the right empty area around the animal. And zooming with my feet ito dangerous grizzly spots (away from my car). The 200-400-560 gives you the ability to compose for animals that are moving. I guess sports too. With the 400 or 500 or 600, you will have to either juggle between 100-400 and 400 or have to bodies going at the same time. I am thinking 200-400 and 600 w 1.4x would be a great combination for animals.
So if the 200-400 is better than the 100-400, and hopefully approaching the 400 2.8, it will be a fantastic lens. However if it is just marginally better than the 100-400, it will be expensive for what you get (1 stop for 10,000$)
But the choice of 400 vs 200-400 is the wrong discussion, its 100-400 vs 200-400. There is not a better zoom lens than the 100-400 in the long end, even though the 100-400 is 5.6 and a little weak in iq compared to 400/2.8.
p.5 #18Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
rscheffler wrote:
The 200-400 is really a 200-560 f/4-5.6. The difference from a standard 2.8x variable f-stop zoom is the guaranteed f/4 at 400mm, I think. Probably also some optical considerations. It would be an interesting question to pose to Canon's lens designers what benefit the 1.4x TC offers vs. a standard zoom design....
Yeah, the price probably doesn't make much sense before one can also appreciate the 560 f/5.6 part. If Canon just made at plain 200-560 f/4-5.6, you would have lost the 400mm @ f/4 option. It would probably be around f/4.8 or something at 400 mm, which would not have cut the mustard for your sport shooters. But it would have been less expensive.
p.5 #19Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Ron, thanks for all the images you've posted, and your analysis of the lens' operation. It's nice to see a lens in action in the real world.
I can see a great deal of versatility with this lens, but it is quite expensive. So much so that the 500/4 II is something that might be more to my liking at this point in time.
Now, if I win a big lottery, I don't think that price will be as much an issue as it is right now.
p.5 #20Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Scott Stoness wrote:
But the choice of 400 vs 200-400 is the wrong discussion, its 100-400 vs 200-400. There is not a better zoom lens than the 100-400 in the long end, even though the 100-400 is 5.6 and a little weak in iq compared to 400/2.8.
And you can have a 100-400L, 1.4x TC and a 500 f/4 mk II for less than a 200-400L. I'd prefer a two camera setup with the zoom and prime.