fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2013 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2013I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me

  
 
JaKo
Offline
Details
p.4 #1I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Also, no one mentioned possible hard stop at infinity issue with MP50. A while ago I checked all my Zeiss lenses at infinity hard stop and all are perfectly in focus.

At f/5.6: Leica on the left, Zeiss on the right:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/ufiles/84/751584.jpg
















May 26, 2013 at 08:40 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.4 #2I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
^ Definitely different focus in the comparison above. I would not take anything home about lens quality from those.

If the MP50 is at hard stop infinity, your copy does NOT reach infinity focus.
May 26, 2013 at 08:49 AM
Jochenb
Offline
Details
p.4 #3I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
JaKo wrote:
Also, no one mentioned possible hard stop at infinity issue with MP50. A while ago I checked all my Zeiss lenses at infinity hard stop and all are perfectly in focus.


Are you sure you're not going slightly past infinity?
All my Zeiss lenses do this at the hard stop. I have to pull the focus ring back a tiny bit (like about 1 millimeter) to get real infinity.
Have you tried this when shooting these scenes? The 50MP should perform better than what I see in your test shots.
May 26, 2013 at 09:03 AM
JaKo
Offline
Details
p.4 #4I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Well, focus was set identical for both images. You can actually see that the in first side-by-side screenshot that sharpness is nearly identical between both lenses. It's at further distance where 50MP gives up to Leica, but it could be expected from a macro lens.

Anyhow, we totally hijacked this thread and if anyone can contribute more to this topic perhaps Zeiss Discussion or Leica vs. Zeiss would be better places.
Thanks

Edited on May 26, 2013 at 09:11 AM · View previous versions
May 26, 2013 at 09:06 AM
JaKo
Offline
Details
p.4 #5I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Johenb wrote: Are you sure you're not going slightly past infinity?
All my Zeiss lenses do this at the hard stop. I have to pull the focus ring back a tiny bit (like about 1 millimeter) to get real infinity.
Have you tried this when shooting these scenes? The 50MP should perform better than what I see in your test shots.


I checked all my Zeiss lenses using LV and max zoom and all were right on the spot. The only one I would have to recheck was Distagon 2/35.
I will try to get more test shots in the next few days.
May 26, 2013 at 09:10 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.4 #6I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
JaKo wrote:
Well, focus was set identical for both images. You can actually see that the in first side-by-side screenshot that sharpness is nearly identical between both lenses. It's at further distance where 50MP gives up to Leica, but it could be expected from a macro lens.


Even without comparison, it is obvious that the distant part of the last image is out of focus.
May 26, 2013 at 09:23 AM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.4 #7I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Jack, There are might sweet point orientated to cross frame sharpness, especially with lens have FC. And might be the case even with Lens with minimal FC(MP50) at D800 level at corner/edge.

You might find if you focus at corner using LV, your result might be different. When I did sharpness at infinity test, I can easily see wave like sharpness zone in 50lux ASPH and 50cron rigid. And one is sharper than other at different zone. Though M9 doesn't have the capability to optimize it.

During my early evaluation of Leica 35cron on my "D700", I found at stop down, the optimized cross frame sharpness not happen at infinity, though my center compromised, DOF will help, but gain corner due to FC.

About Nikkon 1.2AIS, that shot looks like at around f5.6 or so

No matter what is result will be, I appreciate all your effort to show us the lens. I know it is a lot time involved. and benefit all the members here.

Zeiss lens is perceptional sharp due to its design. So we always feel Zeiss is very sharp, however, in photozone equivalent focal length test, it may not have advantage over Canikon at stop down. I am not that surprised for your results. However, I still fell at f2, f1.4, Zeiss indeed give a very different look to Canikon, which worth the prime to me.

No matter if MP is great or not, your result clear show 50cron is capable lens and why it used to be called best 50mm in the world.

May 26, 2013 at 10:52 AM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.4 #8I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
And, about that boat shot, looks like 50cron has more DOF than MP50. from center of image about the same sharp, but MP50 quickly roll off. and 50cron seems still sharp, are they at the same aperture?
May 26, 2013 at 10:58 AM
kiddik
Offline
Details
p.4 #9I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
After stumbling upon this thread I figured I had to test my copies of ZE 50P and ZE 50MP and see what the fuzz is about. Here's a 1:1 crop, f/8, center frame from outside my apartment, through an open balcony door (no window between lens and subject):



Out of all the Zeiss Z* lenses I have owned (6 ZE's) only one of them had an accurate hard stop infinity, and that was the 21ZE. On both my 50's I have to dial back just a little bit to reach infinity, but the 50MP goes further ahead of infinity than the 50P. From this particular example, I'd say the 50P wins by a tiny margin judging from the moire that's about to happen on the light-gray wall behind the lightpost (ca. center frame a little bit to the left). But I'm absolutely positive I could do another test where the 50MP wins by a similiar margin. They are incredibly difficult to focus identically on my 5D3's 10x live view. In my opinion and previous experience with both lenses, I'd say both the 50P and 50MP perform admirably and almost identically when stopped down, as will most 50mm lenses. I can't imagine selling either of them off - I love them both. I won't bother doing a wide open test as the 50MP will destroy the 50P in that regard. In the next 48hrs me and my spouse will be having our second baby (if all goes to plan) and I couldn't imagine bringing any other lens to the hospital, than the 50MP. It's the lens to bring when I can only take one.
May 26, 2013 at 11:36 AM
JaKo
Offline
Details
p.4 #10I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
zhangyue wrote: And, about that boat shot, looks like 50cron has more DOF than MP50. from center of image about the same sharp, but MP50 quickly roll off. and 50cron seems still sharp, are they at the same aperture?

Michael, I noticed that too on few occasions. Focus was set on a tree trunk, but compare DoF and details in the bridge on far right.

About Nikkon 1.2AIS, that shot looks like at around f5.6 or so.
I was definitely at f/2.0
See how it looks WO.

Current weather in Vancouver prevents taking any good infinity shots, but I will get back to it next week.

For now, here is a link to two RAW files of previously posted Cron-R 50 and MP50 images. Both shots were well controlled and I recall focussing on a 'Coast Hotels' logo using LV and one notch down from max magnification, but using a magnifying glass.

PS.
Thanks for your images, kiddik!
















May 26, 2013 at 11:50 AM
helimat
Offline
Details
p.4 #11I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
That's a great comparison Kristjan. Like you, none of my Zeiss ZE's nor my also Cosina-manufactured EF mount Voigt 125 have the hard stop right at infinity, I always have to bring it back a notch.

But it is worth noting that any variance in performance would be much more apparent at 100% on the 36-megapixel AA-less D800E.
May 26, 2013 at 11:58 AM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.4 #12I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
But kidik's comparison is at center, is it? Every 50mm at f5.6 should have that performance.
Jack, the sunstar looks beautiful at f2, I thought it only happen at small aperture. Now you reminde my biogin21 at f2.8 has sunstar as well.
Thanks for explanation.
May 26, 2013 at 12:29 PM
JaKo
Offline
Details
p.4 #13I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
helimat wrote: But it is worth noting that any variance in performance would be much more apparent at 100% on the 36-megapixel AA-less D800E.

Good point, but even on Nikon D700 differences between Zeiss 50P and Nikkor 50/12 AI-s become apparent.

Please see Martin Zimelka's comparison between these two lenses, especially infinity crops .


May 26, 2013 at 12:33 PM
Rodluvan
Offline
Details
p.4 #14I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
kiddik wrote:
In the next 48hrs me and my spouse will be having our second baby (if all goes to plan) and I couldn't imagine bringing any other lens to the hospital, than the 50MP. It's the lens to bring when I can only take one.



If that's not a seal of approval, I don't know what is. Good luck!
May 26, 2013 at 02:16 PM
SKumar25
Offline
Details
p.4 #15I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
JaKo wrote:
"About Nikkon 1.2AIS, that shot looks like at around f5.6 or so."
I was definitely at f/2.0
See how it looks WO.


JaKo, would you mind sharing the raw file please. Thanks.
May 26, 2013 at 06:28 PM
user222
Offline
Details
p.4 #16I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
The ZE 50MP was my first Zeiss. I was contemplating buying another Canon 50 1.2, to see if it would be better than the first one. When I searched for the Canon at bhphoto. I scrolled down a bit and saw the Zeiss, and thought "whoah...what's this?" Did a lil' research and then went for it. I would have to say the 50MP left an impression on me because now I have 5 Zeiss.

My experience with the lens is that it is extremely sharp at inifinity focus. If it has a drawback, it would be that it is too "contrasty" in certain light.

I recall reading John Shaw's "Nature Photography," and he wrote about the usefulness of a 50 macro lens. Have to agree...panos, landscape, macro, etc.


spring dream by craig_coonrad, on Flickr


hiding in the grass by craig_coonrad, on Flickr


night lights by craig_coonrad, on Flickr


Seattle skyline by craig_coonrad, on Flickr


desert light by craig_coonrad, on Flickr


Mt. Rainier from afar by craig_coonrad, on Flickr


May 26, 2013 at 09:22 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.4 #17I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
I kinda got the feeling JaKo's copy might not be all it should be, even where it should be strongest. Anyway the beat goes on...here is (somewhat cropped) image from a Leica 50mm Summicron-R E55, since we are posting images:




May 27, 2013 at 01:39 AM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.4 #18I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
zhangyue, CoF is definitely not an issue from IC to at least image height of 15mm as the transfer for 40 lpmm is too high, up to 70%, might be a bit at frame edge. The Summicron is the one with (likely) significant CoF, from 7-8mm from image centre. The above images don't show it and it is often buried under bokeh or partial focus fade.

Maybe a lot of 50MP users' unhappiness is down to focus error, they might unwittingly trust the inf. stop. The 50MP is a tough contrasty look, almost a traditional large format look, some Schneider lenses have it. With its MTF it is always going to be contrasty.
May 27, 2013 at 01:49 AM
kiddik
Offline
Details
p.4 #19I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Rodluvan: Thanks! :-)

I have a feeling too that all is not right with JaKo's 50MP. I believe the 50P to look like this at f/2 but definitely not the 50MP. My 50MP, like the 100MP - are pin sharp wide open at all distances.
May 27, 2013 at 03:33 AM
redisburning
Offline
Details
p.4 #20I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
I think it's important at this point to ask yourself if something is wrong with his copy and/or technique or if you want something to be wrong.
May 27, 2013 at 12:40 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister