p.3 #1I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Congrats Rodluvan. I really don't understand the people who claim this lens isn't great for anything beyond medium distance.
I used this lens a lot for landscapes and such. The deeper than usual DOF also helps when shooting scenes where you want to get everything in focus. It requires less stopping down.
For those who are interested, here's a full res example @ infitity: example
Maybe I'm not as critical, but I see nothing to complain about.
p.3 #4I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Jochenb wrote: I really don't understand the people who claim this lens isn't great for anything beyond medium distance.
Johenb, simply because it's easily out resolved at mid to infinity distances (WO and stopped down using a camera that is capable of resolving such differences, it is) by even older, half price lenses as I illustrated with provided samples.
Is MP50 usable at those distances and capable of producing satisfactory images? Yes it can be, standards dependent.
For Rodluvan this is a non-issue since he owns 50P already.
Cheers
p.3 #5I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
JaKo wrote:
Johenb, simply because it's easily out resolved at mid to infinity distances (WO and stopped down using a camera that is capable of resolving such differences, it is) by even older, half price lenses as I illustrated with provided samples.
Is MP50 usable at those distances and capable of producing satisfactory images? Yes it can be, standards dependent.
For Rodluvan this is a non-issue since he owns 50P already.
Cheers
I also own the 50P. It has a lovely look, but I never feel it outresolves the MP at any distance.
Seeing someone using the word "issue" is so strange when I go through my infinity shots from it. My 1,5 meter wide prints from it are also extremely detailed, not lacking at all.
IMHO the only issues of the 50MP are soft extreme corners wide open and field curvature.
But oh well... opinions. Let's see if Rodluvan will like it.
p.3 #6I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
^^^ I am positive he will love it.
And yes, forums are about sharing personal opinions, experiences and learning from others.
Opinions vary as they should otherwise FM would be a boring place.
p.3 #7I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Notions take hold and spread uncritically from person to person. These things happen from time to time. Now in the twitter/social media age it accelerates rapidly; 'trending' - forum goers often use the word 'meme' to describe the phenomenon:
Early on, the RX1 was thought to be poor at - you guessed right perhaps - long focal distances and infinity. I am assuming most here have pretty good eyes and pretty good displays, but you do wonder at times.
BTW, respected journal c't digital photography use the 50MP as the reference lens as they believe it to be what its (infinity) MTF indicate it to be - one of the strongest 50mm lenses made for DSLR.
p.3 #8I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Thank you Jochenb & philip_pj for you input. In the whole honesty I don't feel comfortable going forward with this, but I must state that I see what I see and others, who use decent monitors, should be able to conclude for themselves.
Shots below were taken for my own comparison and were conducted in a fairly controlled environment; no wind, MUP, remote release, ISO 100, Gitzo tripod and all that jazz. PP of both images was identical. Second image; Zeiss 50 MP on the left, Nikkor 50/1.2 AI-s on the right. I took shots at f/2, f/5.6 and f/8. Zeiss was closer to Nikkor at f/2; stopped down Nikkor was noticeably sharper.
I also have few test images comparing macro performance of 50MP to Nikkor 60/2.8 (lens used by Lloyd Chambers and Ming Thein for their products shots) and Zeiss 100MP and I can confirm that there is nothing wrong with my 50MP.
If one decides to use Zeiss MP 50 as their reference lens for infinity shots, great! For me Zeiss 50 MP will remain a solid performer and reference lens at close distances.
Cheers, gotta go for now.
p.3 #9I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Everytime I read one of these comparo's the lens being dissed always looks way worse than when it was being used to diss whatever was being dissed last time.
p.3 #10I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
JaKo wrote:
Shots below were taken for my own comparison and were conducted in a fairly controlled environment; no wind, MUP, remote release, ISO 100, Gitzo tripod and all that jazz. PP of both images was identical. Second image; Zeiss 50 MP on the left, Nikkor 50/1.2 AI-s on the right. I took shots at f/2, f/5.6 and f/8. Zeiss was closer to Nikkor at f/2; stopped down Nikkor was noticeably sharper.
What is the aperture that you picked for this second image? If it is not f/2, then why does only the Nikon crop display diffraction stars?
I also have few test images comparing macro performance of 50MP to Nikkor 60/2.8 (lens used by Lloyd Chambers and Ming Thein for their products shots) and Zeiss 100MP and I can confirm that there is nothing wrong with my 50MP.
It is always nice to have a good copy of a lens. As a minor note, Zeiss will tell you that the 50MP performs best at infinity.
p.3 #11I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
JaKo wrote:
Shots below were taken for my own comparison and were conducted in a fairly controlled environment; no wind, MUP, remote release, ISO 100, Gitzo tripod and all that jazz. PP of both images was identical. Second image; Zeiss 50 MP on the left, Nikkor 50/1.2 AI-s on the right. I took shots at f/2, f/5.6 and f/8. Zeiss was closer to Nikkor at f/2; stopped down Nikkor was noticeably sharper.
Something wrong with the comparison. The fact there are sunstars in one image, and not the other indicates aperture difference - sunstars come about on stopping down.
p.3 #12I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
There are subtle differences between the Makro-Planar and the Planar, but if you can't make images with absolutley top resolution at infinity at D800 sensor resolution with the Makro-Planar, you are doing something wrong.
Here is a comparison between my copies of the ZF.2 P and the ZE MP, taken with the Pentax Q (360 MP equivalent FF resolution). The sharpness obtained with both lenses at this pixel density, rules out focus error or lens problems that would affect the image at D800 resolution.
Take note that these are unscaled pixel crops from a tiny sensor, and we are looking at a very tiny part of an actual image.
Aperture f/4.
Both crops have beem sharpened equally. The sharpening makes the difference between the lenses more apparent than with unsharpened crops.
At the bottom, the same crops but resized to D800 equivalent pixel density.
p.3 #13I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
SKumar25 wrote:
Something wrong with the comparison. The fact there are sunstars in one image, and not the other indicates aperture difference - sunstars come about on stopping down.
Obviously the aperture is ƒ/2 for both lenses, hence the 1.2 lens is stopped down.
p.3 #15I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Rodluvan wrote: SKumar25 wroteSomething wrong with the comparison. The fact there are sunstars in one image, and not the other indicates aperture difference - sunstars come about on stopping down.Obviously the aperture is ƒ/2 for both lenses, hence the 1.2 lens is stopped down.
twoeye wrote:
...and Jako´s comparision shows that the MP50 has a only bit less resolution than the Nikkor 50/1.2, but much more coma.
alundeb´s shots also shows hints of coma around the brightest part of the image from the 50MP
Agree about coma with the MP50. If I were to stop down to f/5.6 to reduce LoCA, coma with the MP and residual SA and with the P, diffraction would take back most of that gain, and even the lenses out a bit.
p.3 #16I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Rodluvan wrote: SKumar25 wroteSomething wrong with the comparison. The fact there are sunstars in one image, and not the other indicates aperture difference - sunstars come about on stopping down.Obviously the aperture is ƒ/2 for both lenses, hence the 1.2 lens is stopped down.
Yes that is obvious!
f/2 is still relatively wide open though, and I don't think you can create sunstars at f/2.
If you have fast glass, then give it a try.
Could be wrong but I'm basing this on my experience.
An example I grabbed from the net to illustrate the effect:
Additionally, with the picture on the right the building is in focus, as are the lights in the far distance, huge DOF. With the picture on the left the lights in the far distance appear more diffuse as should be expected with a shallow f/2 type DOF.
p.3 #17I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
alundeb wrote: twoeye wrote...and Jako´s comparision shows that the MP50 has a only bit less resolution than the Nikkor 50/1.2, but much more coma.
alundeb´s shots also shows hints of coma around the brightest part of the image from the 50MPAgree about coma with the MP50. If I were to stop down to f/5.6 to reduce LoCA, coma with the MP and residual SA and with the P, diffraction would take back most of that gain, and even the lenses out a bit.
Do you see coma at f/4, in the central region of an image of a lens designed for full-frame sensors?
All I see is what looks like a trace of chromatic aberration with the MP.
p.3 #18I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
It´s possible that I am messing up on terminology here, but my point is that it is only the strong pointshaped lights that seem unsharp, the rest of the image is comparable when it comes to resolution.
p.3 #19I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Toothwalker wrote:
Do you see coma at f/4, in the central region of an image of a lens designed for full-frame sensors?
I admit that it sounds suspicious, and it might be something else. To me it looks to be an assymetrical aberration. Look at the lamp post. It doesn't have a green counterpart anywhere as far as I can see.
Some time ago, I started recording some point spread functions of these lenses with a point light source and using the Pentax Q, and the PSF is indeed assymetrical with my lenses, in the central region of the images. I didn't finish it because there was a lot of work involved. At these resolutions and enlargements, I guess we see effects of very small optical misaligments. I don't really have the authority to name it coma though
p.3 #20I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
I don't have a problem with 50MP resolution/sharpness at infinity. In fact it looks not bad as you can see below.
However, it's when comparing to other quality lenses that 50MP's infinity reference status is in question.