fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2013 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2013I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me

  
 
JaKo
Offline
Details
p.2 #1I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Rodluvan wrote: If I did a lot of macro photography, maybe I would, but as it stands I'm not.

freaklikeme wrote: I'm not sure the Summicron 50 is what I would recommend to someone interested in the 50MP. They do share one trait in common- both have very subtle focus transitions. The bokeh is creamier. CA isn't as well controlled. It's a great portrait and event lens, and has a distinct character. It's not the sharpest lens wide open, but it improves steadily as you stop down. It's also one of the few bargains in the R lenses, and widely available used.
...Show more →

Summicron-R 50 is definatelly not a macro lens, but it performs well from 1 meter to infinity, where Zeiss 50MP, being a macro lens,givs up to Cron-r 50 at mid-infinity distances . Agree, for the price of Zeiss 50MP one can get Elmarit-R 60 and faster Cron-50.

http://www.kozera.ca/photos/images/_D8E2765_640.jpg
http://www.kozera.ca/photos/images/_D8E2768_640.jpg





May 24, 2013 at 08:42 AM
Dudewithoutape
Offline
Details
p.2 #2I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
The Summicron def has those Leica characteristics. Smoother, more painterly rendering.

The 50 MP pops more with it's quicker focus transition and high contrast.

Just my humble opinion.
May 24, 2013 at 09:02 AM
Rodluvan
Offline
Details
p.2 #3I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Looking at those photos, Zeiss seem to have booth the smoother bokeh and transition. Looking on the phone though, so maybe hard to tell. Thanks for the comparison, always fun.
May 24, 2013 at 09:42 AM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.2 #4I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
May 24, 2013 at 10:04 AM
JaKo
Offline
Details
p.2 #5I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Rodluvan wrote: Looking at those photos, Zeiss seem to have booth the smoother bokeh and transition. Looking on the phone though, so maybe hard to tell. Thanks for the comparison, always fun.


I can only comment and recommend lenses I own(ed) or had in my possession for a longer time. Said that, both Zeiss 50MP and Cron-R 50 are great and highly recommended. If one debates which one to get, I would suggest to obtain a clean copy of Summicron-R 50 E55 first before its price goes up even more. Cron-R 50 is 1/2 size and price of Zeiss 50MP, and you can always get Zeiss if needed.

http://www.kozera.ca/photos/images/D8E_2518_640.jpg
http://www.kozera.ca/photos/images/D8E_2517_640.jpg


Edited on May 24, 2013 at 06:43 PM · View previous versions
May 24, 2013 at 10:26 AM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.2 #6I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
290g vs 560g.

At f2 MP win for sharpness and POP. Actually, at short to medium distance, I feel it will win all the 50mm I have seen so far. Long distance, I never compare it to others, as I feel most of 50mm out solve my D700.

but I have to say focus transition is with Leica and it is more than enough sharp for most case. sharper than planar at f2 for sure. Bokeh doesn't look great for both at f2, both just average. (not Macro distance, there is no dog for that.)

at f5.6, 50cron reach to unbeatable level at most of the frame. so does MP50 and Leica 60.(I choose 50 over 60 is the speed and I never do macro.) However, I do notice it will further improve at f8 if you want cross frame sharpness but sacrifice a little on center.

I will pick a 50cron mint one any day of the week even at the same price. Just for its butter smooth focusing, proper focus throw and light weight design. Since it can give me anything I want it for a prime 50mm minus f1.4 and maybe Bokeh.

The lens is a Bargain at current price. It will sell $2500 level if Leica produce it now.

Both WO from 50cron

http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8231/8483957627_af22e6e7f9_b.jpg

http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8063/8263767185_3008479ba2_b.jpg

May 24, 2013 at 11:04 AM
Picture This!
Offline
Details
p.2 #7I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
I agree with JaKo. The cron 50 is also a great lens. Its not a bokeh machine but there's something about the way it renders skin tones (its slightly lower contrast helps). I have both the 50 cron and 60 macro elmarit and both are wonderful for different uses. I grab my 60 for close up work and intimate landscapes. The 50 for people shots and environmental stuff. The 50 cron has a soul to it that's hard to describe.

While I really liked the 50MP I sold it. It was super sharp close but a bit too clinical for my tastes and I found myself having to futz with the colors in post to get it to my liking. The leicas are a bit more subtle, have excellent color gradation and really grow on you. I assume both of Jako's shots above used the same settings, light etc but colors in the leica shot look much better on my screen. Especially the reds.
May 24, 2013 at 11:05 AM
Rodluvan
Offline
Details
p.2 #8I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Hm, must be me, but looking at the photos by JaKo to me it's apparent that ZF has a smoother bokeh and dof transition (at the two apertures). I will agree though, that the colours in the first set shows more punch in the Leica lens, but very so slightly.
May 24, 2013 at 03:02 PM
Rodluvan
Offline
Details
p.2 #9I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
anyway the ZF.2 will be here in a few days
May 24, 2013 at 03:06 PM
Picture This!
Offline
Details
p.2 #10I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
I agree with the 50MP showing a smoother bokeh. But the cron 50 to me has soul/character and both the cron 50 and macro 60 exhibit color fidelity that I haven't seen from the MP50... And the 60 despite its lower contrast puts out great detail and keeps up with the D800e's sensor without breaking a sweat... and is very very good at infinity too.
May 24, 2013 at 03:24 PM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.2 #11I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Congratulation! I assume this doesn't prevent you try a 50cron if you have the chance before it is too late

One big plus for Zeiss, is auto aperture( zero focus shift.) This is hard to neglect for practical usage.

However, whenever we are talking 50mm 'manual' lens, we should not forget Leica, no matter what age it is
May 24, 2013 at 03:32 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.2 #12I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Everyone should have a Summicron-R 50mm, ideally an E55! A great all round lens, perhas the best 50mm for portraits and environmental portraits, very easy to focus too, tiny and light and beautifully made, built-in hood. 50MP for what you see here - landscapes.
May 24, 2013 at 04:52 PM
JaKo
Offline
Details
p.2 #13I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
philip_pj wrote: Everyone should have a Summicron-R 50mm, ideally an E55! A great all round lens, perhas the best 50mm for portraits and environmental portraits, very easy to focus too, tiny and light and beautifully made, built-in hood.

I can see how you just contributed to yet another eBay price jump of Summicron-R

Personally, I will add this to 50 Cron vs. MP landscape take (I recall posting it already, but cannot find the link)






50 --> ∞

May 24, 2013 at 06:39 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.2 #14I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
JaKo wrote:
Summicron-R 50 is definatelly not a macro lens, but it performs well from 1 meter to infinity, where Zeiss 50MP, being a macro lens,givs up to Cron-r 50 at mid-infinity distances . Agree, for the price of Zeiss 50MP one can get Elmarit-R 60 and faster Cron-50.

http://www.kozera.ca/photos/images/_D8E2765_640.jpg
http://www.kozera.ca/photos/images/_D8E2768_640.jpg




To me, the Zeiss was the better choice for that shot. I don't see a lot of difference in the subject itself, but I do see a distracting difference in the Cron's nervous bokeh.
May 24, 2013 at 09:04 PM
Picture This!
Offline
Details
p.2 #15I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
The MP definitely has the better bokeh in that shot. Can't argue with that.

In the next shot though, the Leica does much better with the colors and gradation. Look at the flowers. The MP shows a red blob, whereas the Leica has better definition and much more pleasing colors. Between the bokeh and the color purity, I opted for the color purity. That's a personal choice of course.
May 24, 2013 at 09:31 PM
helimat
Offline
Details
p.2 #16I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Funny this discussion just came up, I own and love the ZE 50MP, but just added a Summicron-R 50/2 E55. (& ZS 50/1.4P too... ) The main difference I have noticed so far when using it is that after a few years of the MP being my go-to 50 & one of my main walk-around lenses, I miss having the close-focus abilities at my disposal. But I am liking what I am seeing in post.
May 24, 2013 at 09:44 PM
JaKo
Offline
Details
p.2 #17I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
carstenw posted a number of great illustrative images taken with Zeiss 50MP (here on FM and GetDPI forums) showing character of this lens. I would encourage you to check it out.
50MP excels at MFD to mid distances, it has fairly extended DoF (waaaay more than 100MP) and personally I find it damn sharp as a macro lens up to 1-2 meters. Its strengths end here and if these were the main reason you get this lens, it should fill your bill. Anything else this lens is not.

Many photographers have multiple 50mm lenses as I believe it’s hard to find one single 50mm lens that does it all. For me Cron-R 50 or even Nikkor 50/1.2 AI-s are better ‘all-arounders’ than 50MP, but still mine has its place in my set.
May 24, 2013 at 10:16 PM
JimUe
Offline
Details
p.2 #18I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
Picture This! wrote:
I agree with JaKo. The cron 50 is also a great lens. Its not a bokeh machine but there's something about the way it renders skin tones (its slightly lower contrast helps). I have both the 50 cron and 60 macro elmarit and both are wonderful for different uses. I grab my 60 for close up work and intimate landscapes. The 50 for people shots and environmental stuff. The 50 cron has a soul to it that's hard to describe.

While I really liked the 50MP I sold it. It was super sharp close but a bit too clinical
...Show more →

I've had the 50'cron and 50mp. I've since sold the Cron and picked up a 50'lux and found it more special. The 50mp is a lens I just don't love. Like you said, there's just something not right about the colour. I think I will trade it for a 60ME.
May 24, 2013 at 11:04 PM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.2 #19I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
JimUe wrote:
Picture This! wroteI agree with JaKo. The cron 50 is also a great lens. Its not a bokeh machine but there's something about the way it renders skin tones (its slightly lower contrast helps). I have both the 50 cron and 60 macro elmarit and both are wonderful for different uses. I grab my 60 for close up work and intimate landscapes. The 50 for people shots and environmental stuff. The 50 cron has a soul to it that's hard to describe.

While I really liked the 50MP I sold it. It was super sharp close but a bit too clinical for my tastes and I found myself having to futz with the colors in post to get it to my liking. The leicas are a bit more subtle, have excellent color gradation and really grow on you. I assume both of Jako's shots above used the same settings, light etc but colors in the leica shot look much better on my screen. Especially the reds.
I've had the 50'cron and 50mp. I've since sold the Cron and picked up a 50'lux and found it more special. The 50mp is a lens I just don't love. Like you said, there's just something not right about the colour. I think I will trade it for a 60ME.


Maybe we should change the thread title now we formally hijack the thread

I feel 50cron render differently than 50lux V1, but my 50lux can't replace it for rendering. There is something pleasing about 50cron I can't put word on. I will use it a lot more once my Canon body is in, I only have 3 leitax Nikon mount, so they go to 3 lux I have. But I plan to use 35&50cron a lot more often once my 6D is here, their size with 6D is dream setup for me

As for Bokeh, I said it is average, but I have to say it is very complicated thing to evaluating Bokeh. As shown in above two shots I posted, I feel their Bokeh is fine. We'd be careful claim one is better than other.

I also want to mention I don't see much Bokeh difference in the first set Jack posted. At least it is not obvious to my eyes that 50cron is worse. Are you guys refer the tree in background?


May 24, 2013 at 11:43 PM
Rodluvan
Offline
Details
p.2 #20I want to buy the 50MP, but can't find the photos to convince me
It seem to be a little nitpicking regarding bokeh and transition and color fidelity and nothing I suspect means much irl, but there also seem to be consesus that the 50MP isn't that great beyond medium distance. That is quite ok, I have the 50P for that and this is supposed to be used as a close focus lens.
I got, what I believe to be, a GREAT deal on a used MP (hasn't arrived yet, so I can't say for sure) including a few filters, which means I didn't pay a premium for the Zeiss and can certainly resell it for at least the same money.

Also, I like having the same color profile for all my lenses (the Zeiss' are by large color calibrated).
May 25, 2013 at 07:11 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister