fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2012 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2012AFing with Extension Tubes

  
 
Hrow
Offline

p.1 #1AFing with Extension Tubes
I have a D800 and bought a set of Kenko extension tubes. When I try to AF with one or more on the camera the AF goes spastic and moves in and out with a almost a thumping motion. Never locks. Is this normal with Nikons or do I have a connection problem with the tubes? The lenses being used are an 85 G 1.8 and a 70-20 VRII.

Note... before anyone tells me I should be MFing with tubes please be aware that I have been using them for years and know their limitations. I also know that the Kenkos AFed fine about 80% of the time when I was using Canon. I do a lot of near macro work with flowers and butterflies and the D800's viewfinder is really marginal for MFing in these situations.
Jun 24, 2012 at 03:57 PM
MikeW
Offline
Details
p.1 #2AFing with Extension Tubes
that is normal, MF is the way to go. I think it does it because you are not within the focus range with that tube...either too close or too far away. That is what I found anyways.
Jun 24, 2012 at 04:11 PM
Kerry Pierce
Offline
Details
p.1 #3AFing with Extension Tubes
It's been quite a while since I used my Kenko Pro tubes, but I believe that mine would AF fine on my d70's and d200's. I don't recall whether I've used them on the d300/d700 or not, but I don't think so.

Do you have access to another late model Nikon body that you can test the tubes on?

If not, I'd suggest cleaning all of the contacts, including the lenses and body. I generally use electrical contact cleaner for that job.

hope that helps
Kerry
Jun 24, 2012 at 04:19 PM
nikt
Offline
Details
p.1 #4AFing with Extension Tubes
Mine AS, but I'd generally don't use them in AF because I can sometimes have the same issue. And AF accuracy as those DOF levels is not as accurate as I'd like.

Live view should be used in MF and zoomed in on the Nikons.
There's also some external viewing devices that help immensely with macro work.
Jun 24, 2012 at 05:06 PM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.1 #5AFing with Extension Tubes
Contacts are clean. I am within the focus range. It is obviously trying to AF but doing a miserable job. I rely heavily on MFing but there are times when AFing is very useful, especially with butterflies as I am using the tubes to shorten the MFD but I am still several feet away. I often used my 70-200 with a 1.4x and tubes for both flowers and butterflies and Live View often isn't an option. Add to that the reality that Nikon has crapped up the Live View on the D800 big time and it is not a pretty picture.
Jun 24, 2012 at 05:47 PM
CGrindahl
Offline
Details
p.1 #6AFing with Extension Tubes
Nik makes the salient point. Tubes diminish the focal plane to the point where it is difficult for the camera to find focus. Furthermore as Mike noted finding the right relationship to the subject so you can actually obtain focus is important. You can't infinity focus with tubes so you need to be within a specific range from the object. You may do better by investing in a true macro lens that will give you a greatly reduced MFD AND infinity focus. My guess is you'd AF without difficulty with such a lens. I say that as a person who loves to shoot with tubes but also loves to use Nikon's great MF lenses. Nothing is finer than an 80-200 f/4.5 AI with a 36 or 20mm tube... push-pull works beautifully for macro work. I paid $76 for mine...
Jun 24, 2012 at 05:59 PM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.1 #7AFing with Extension Tubes
With due respect, I have a pretty good idea of how to work in the near macro world. I know when and how to use a macro lens and I also know when a macro won't give me the particular look I want (which is most of the time). In the two galleries below, 90% of the images were taken with extension tubes on 85L, 70-200, or 300mm. The other 10% were taken with a 180L macro. Many are MFed but many are AFed.

http://hrowan.photoshelter.com/gallery/Flowers/G0000FmYweNUV_mg/C0000u36PX6WWVsk

http://hrowan.photoshelter.com/gallery/Butterflies/G0000XJoCO8hUMvc/C0000u36PX6WWVsk

The question is why is it that my Canon's could AF (multiple bodies, multiple lenses, multiple tube combos) and my Nikon can't? Is there a technical reason for this or is something not working properly?
Jun 24, 2012 at 08:54 PM
CGrindahl
Offline
Details
p.1 #8AFing with Extension Tubes
My apologies if you felt I was denigrating either your understanding or abilities. The images you link to are lovely. I don't own the D800, though I'll have one for about nine days beginning early next week. Perhaps when I've experimented myself I can speak more directly to your concerns. Of course when I shoot with tubes I'm not using a tripod so my experience would likely under any circumstance be different than yours. The D700 is rather brilliant both with MF lenses and with tubes. I'll get back next week with observations about the D800. I'm sorry that your Nikon adventure has disappointed you after you're wonderful experience with Canon...
Jun 24, 2012 at 09:11 PM
lisy78
Offline
Details
p.1 #9AFing with Extension Tubes
if you're saying that lens continues to rack as if it's not convinced it has achieved perfect focus than mine does that though it usually will lock but boy do I have to stay perfectly still. It will lock every time in AF-S thoguh it may rack a little before it does. Again by rack though I don't mean the crazy hunt that can sometime happen with the lens has no clue what is going on... I'm talking that the lens basically locks focus and then starts saying "a qarter millimeter forward, quarter millimeter back, no forward, no back..."

And yes that's with the 70-200 VR2 and the 85 1.8G with 12mm kenko tube.

I use macros for details at weddings... they're not moving so everything is good. my guess would be that if you were trying to lock focus on a butterfly that might move 'cause you know... it's alive... you might just rip your hair out ... I think the camera is truly trying to AF so that the image would be sharp wide open (which is where it's focusing)... which is insane

In your shoes I would try:

1. AFS vs AFC
2. change the AF settings pertaining to how the camera reacts to changes in focus distance

I woldn't be suprised if you find a combination that works much better for you for your macro work, and then you can store it as a custom setting called "Kickass Macro" or whatever.
Jun 24, 2012 at 09:54 PM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.1 #10AFing with Extension Tubes
lisy78 wrote:
if you're saying that lens continues to rack as if it's not convinced it has achieved perfect focus than mine does that though it usually will lock but boy do I have to stay perfectly still. It will lock every time in AF-S thoguh it may rack a little before it does. Again by rack though I don't mean the crazy hunt that can sometime happen with the lens has no clue what is going on... I'm talking that the lens basically locks focus and then starts saying "a qarter millimeter forward, quarter millimeter back, no forward, no back..."

And yes
...Show more →

Racking is a good description of what seems to be going on, though in a micro movement sense rather than a 3' to infinity sense. I suspect that because the adjustments are small that they are more rapid and thus more numerous - sounds like it is broken rather than just "normal" racking - which sounds smooth. Will have to try it on a tripod to today. It may be that the Nikon's AF system of what constitutes an acceptable in focus range is smaller than Canon's.

I'll try changing the focus speed and see what happens - excellent suggestion.
Jun 25, 2012 at 06:28 AM
pr4photos
Offline
Details
p.1 #11AFing with Extension Tubes
sounds normal. mine does it
Jun 25, 2012 at 07:30 AM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.1 #12AFing with Extension Tubes
Changing Focus Tracking with Lock-On to OFF while using AF-S works. Kinda - sorta OK. Still a bit fidgety but regardless, it is a big improvement and with some field experience to learn its limitations, it will be alright.

Thanks lisy78, that was a great idea. I hadn't thought about the Focus Tracking as being a potential source of the issue.

Edited on Jun 25, 2012 at 10:27 AM · View previous versions
Jun 25, 2012 at 10:11 AM
Betacamman
Offline
Details
p.1 #13AFing with Extension Tubes
I've had this happen with my Kenko tubes and Canon 50D. I was even warned when I bought them that "you probably won't be able to AF if you use all three at once." I did have occasional failures with two, but much less often than with three.
Jun 25, 2012 at 10:18 AM
Mark_L
Offline
Details
p.1 #14AFing with Extension Tubes
Mine does it too. Wish I gone for cheaper non af tubes.
Jun 25, 2012 at 10:46 AM
pr4photos
Offline
Details
p.1 #15AFing with Extension Tubes
I bought cheapy AF tubes from Ebay. Really not a lot more than non AF tubes. Using one tube with my 80-200mm lens works brilliantly and am really pleased with the results.
For studio work I will still use my 105mm Macro, but for outdoor work the tube on the zoom works a treat
Jun 25, 2012 at 10:58 AM
dkperez
Offline
Details
p.1 #16AFing with Extension Tubes
I noticed that this topic has been sitting here for almost two years, and there still doesn't appear to be a solution...

I recently purchased a D800 body. I do some close-up work - flowers, insects butterflies.

I've been using Kenko extension tubes that fully couple on the Nikon for SEVERAL years. I have ALWAYS used my Nikon 70-200 VRII with my old D300, and it has worked regardless of whether I'm using a 12mm, 20mm, or 36mm extension tube. I've also used this combination on my even older D2X with no problem. I'll repeat that - the Nikon 70-200 AFS VRII with the Kenko extension tubes has always, and CONTINUTES to autofocus PERFECTLY with a D300 that costs half as much as the D800.

I don't stack tubes. I DON'T have an issue with the zoom range OR the focus range.

On the D800, the camera will not lock autofocus. It does NOT hunt from end to end of the range, it jitters very rapidly across a small range of autofocus. For example, if the accurate focus point was in the middle of the "10" foot mark, it would likely jitter from just past the 1 to the outer edge of the 0. It does this consistently. It does it at ALL zoom points I've tried. It does it with EVERY tube from the TWO sets I've tried. It does it with MY 70-200. It does it with a Nikon 28-300. It does it with a Nikon 24-70.

Yes, a 200mm macro would probably be a suitable substitute, but I see no good reason to buy a SECOND macro lens. And the "regular" 100mm macro I have is not suitable for butterflies and insects because of the very short working distance. The 70-200 with an extension provides a working distance of at least 2 feet, which doesn't annoy the subject.

And while manually focusing all the time may work for some, in less than perfect conditions, trying to manually focus on a butterfly's head/eye, and KEEP it perfectly in focus when the butterfly moves is unnecessarily difficult. Especially since the ancient technology of the D300 (or D2X) has NO problem continuously autofocusing to keep things sharp.......

So, in the intervening 2 years since this topic was started, has ANYONE gotten a D800 with a reasonable zoom lens and any fully-coupling extension tube, to accurately, quickly, and consistently to autofocus as well as previous generations of bodies? And if not, has there been any admission or acknowledgement from Nikon that there is a problem with the autofocus or some other adjustment on the D800 that needs to be made?
Apr 03, 2014 at 10:52 AM
BlueBomberTurbo
Offline
Details
p.1 #17AFing with Extension Tubes
Hmm, I have the Kenko 2.0x teleconverter. Worked fine on my D90 and D7000, but does the same thing (jittery AF in a certain range) on my D7100. I'm thinking it's just an incompatibility with the newer Nikons and Kenko's older stuff. Kinda like how some Sigma lenses tend to have compatibility issues with the newest Nikon bodies.
Apr 03, 2014 at 07:10 PM
dkperez
Offline
Details
p.1 #18AFing with Extension Tubes
Bizarre... I can see Nikon doing things to improve their equipment that could cause 3rd party equipment to have problems, but it's odd to me that there wouldn't be more noise about it... Frankly, had I KNOWN the D800 had this problem with extension tubes, I likely wouldn't have bought it.

I also keep waiting in the forums where there are finally discussions, for the flood of "I'm not having any problem with <xxx> zoom and <yyy> extension tubes on my D800. Haven't seen it yet.

Yesterday, I put an extension tube on my Sigma 50-500 OS, and it did EXACTLY the same thing. I've also talked to another person that tried a Nikon 24-70 f2.8 and SHE also has the same problem. So, it appears that at least THREE Nikon zooms and one Sigma zoom have the problem. Which, to me, says it's not the lens(es), and since the combinations work find on the D300, it's not the extension tube. Seems like it's something to do with the design and/or the auto focus on the D800...

I've sent an email to Nikon support asking for information, but my expectation is very low.
Apr 04, 2014 at 06:38 AM
trenchmonkey
Offline
Details
p.1 #19AFing with Extension Tubes
GL. I'd venture to say it's not gonna be a high priority for them
Doubt more than 5% of D800 shooters employ tubes and those
that do, are probably stacking static shots. With a shallow DOF to
begin with, a DX body seems much more appropriate in that regard.
Apr 04, 2014 at 08:00 AM
nikt
Offline
Details
p.1 #20AFing with Extension Tubes
And to add, you're just simple better off manually focusing in this environment.
You can also get external monitors that will allow tremendous accuracy with live view if you really need that.
Apr 04, 2014 at 08:04 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister