"Better off" isn't the point. You may like to manually focus. And it may work fine for totally static subjects. These aren't static, and I'm foolish enough to believe if it worked on last generation's technology it SURE ought to work now.
I sent an email to Nikon detailing the problem. I KNOW this response will be a huge shock to everyone:
"Thanks for the email and sorry to hear about the problem. Unfortunately we're not going to be able to help since it's not a Nikon product. It sounds like there is some software issue with teh third-party Extension Tube. Have you asked Kenko about compatibility? Sorry we can't help more."
Yup, it's that Extension Tube SOFTWARE..... Apparently, the fact that the exact same extension tubes and lenses work perfectly on the D300 isn't relevant.
I have extensively used Kenko extension tubes with 70-300 VR Nikon with great ease and success. Then recently used them on 85 1.8 G and had experience like yours. I think it is due to shorter subject distance and relatively shorter focus range ( as apposed to 300mm ); with some experience I got used to it.
I went from the D7000 to the D800. The tubes worked perfectly with the D7000.
However, I am experiencing the same lack of autofocus on the D800. It is not all the lens that have the autofocus issues. My 60mm and 105mm micro lens, do not autofocus any longer with the tubes.
But, my 500mm will autofocus. I'm sure there is perfectly logical explanation, and it may just be the focusing distance.
I had the opposite experience with a 28-300 VRII lens. Jitters just like the 70-200.
I tried my 90mm macro, and it APPEARED to work ok, but since it's useless for what I use the 70-200/extension tube combination for, I didn't do extensive testing.
I DID try my Sigma 50-500 OS, and it jitters like crazy....
I haven't tried the 500/f4, but again, it's not a useful lens for butterflies or insects...
I'm disappointed but not surprised that Nikon support was totally dismissive and didn't even demonstrate a bit of curiosity to investigate a problem like this. But, I suspect they're more interested in NOT knowing there's a problem - kind of the GM ignition problem mindset...
Yep, I know how it works. Moving subjects. Tough subjects and I spend some good time working on getting the moment manually focusing with the extension Kenko extension tubes. Got nothing to do with if I like manual focusing or not, I'm talking about the accuracy of the AF in those circumstances. I kind of figured the AF stuff was a bit of gimmick now that I use them.
It's all hit and miss stuff.
I agree though, not Nikons problem really. Hit Kenko up and see what they say. Maybe they've got a new set coming out that fixes the issues you describe.
SO FAR, Kenko says ABSOLUTELY NOTHING... They haven't responded to my email. My suspicion is their response will be that Nikon has a problem and doesn't want to acknowledge it, and it's not their tubes.......