fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2011 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2011NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)

  
 
philber
Offline
Details
p.3 #1NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
I believe so, yes, since one of the happy few early adopters commented that it hinged slightly better than the 5N.
For reference, Bif, since you discuss that elsewhere on FM, shooting from the waist gives me much greater stabilty than at eye-level. I can achieve decent sharpness at 1/3 the conventional speed, and another member can get results at 1/5... So this is worth doing even with an EVF-equipped cam IMHO.
Dec 24, 2011 at 05:07 AM
Mitch Alland
Offline
Details
p.3 #2NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
kosmoskatten wrote:
...Mitch: I will be in BKK in two days, look forward to it. Will meet up with Ed there before heading down to Krabi for some climbing.


Henrik, have sent you a PM. Who is Ed?

—Mitch/Bangkok
Dec 24, 2011 at 06:22 AM
AhamB
Offline
Details
p.3 #3NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
Mitch Alland wrote:
kosmoskatten wrote...Mitch: I will be in BKK in two days, look forward to it. Will meet up with Ed there before heading down to Krabi for some climbing.
Henrik, have sent you a PM. Who is Ed?

—Mitch/Bangkok

Ed = Edward Karaa, member of this forum.
Dec 24, 2011 at 06:34 AM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.3 #4NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
philber wrote:
I believe so, yes, since one of the happy few early adopters commented that it hinged slightly better than the 5N.


Thanks!


For reference, Bif, since you discuss that elsewhere on FM, shooting from the waist gives me much greater stabilty than at eye-level. I can achieve decent sharpness at 1/3 the conventional speed, and another member can get results at 1/5... So this is worth doing even with an EVF-equipped cam IMHO.

I still wouldn't be able to. I can't see the LCD with my eyesight. I get the general image of course but I couldn't tell if anything was in focus, I couldn't read the text to achieve AE-Lock with spot metering or know the settings in a dynamically lit environment, and the concentration+squinting needed to ensure proper framing and level horizons would be torture. Lastly I've not found an LCD that's actually visible in even slightly bright light - not even the Nex. I know: Poor-poor-pityful-me!

For low angle shots I squat with my elbows on my knees. This gives me motionless 1s shots with 35mm to 85mm lenses (70-170mm equiv.). If I can kneel, sit, or lay on the ground it gets even better.


Dec 24, 2011 at 06:40 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.3 #5NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
wfrank wrote:
Tariq Gibran wrote...and you sold it for MSRP. Great folks around here!

Regarding the dof and higher MP, it's interesting to see your examples because I never really run into this issue with my FF 24MP a900 and it would of course have even less dof per given angle of view. I never shoot beyond F8 as a rule and most often I'm at F4/5.6 but then again I'm usually shooting a 35 or 50mm lens. Your example with the Minolta 40 gives the equivalent fov of a 60mm lens and you are fairly close to your subject so I can see where dof would be limited at F4. Really not too surprising.
I dont think the DOF is the thing. It's the resistance to handling variations in real world shooting. A 24MP APS-C sensor have so much higher pixel density than a 24MP FF so it will inevitably reveal the slightest mistake, shake, misaligned focus plane etc. The FF sensor have a much higher tolerance simply because its pixels are so much larger.

I personally ran into a wall with the Canon 7D (18MP APS-C). Add to that many of the lenses I used at that time also had IS. Moving to Canon 5DMkII (and lenses w/o IS) images came out much
...Show more →

That very well could be it as I have never used an extremely high MP APS camera. If the high density is the issue, I suppose the upcoming 36+MP FF cameras could suffer the same issue.
Dec 24, 2011 at 06:54 AM
philber
Offline
Details
p.3 #6NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
wfrank wrote:
I dont think the DOF is the thing. It's the resistance to handling variations in real world shooting. A 24MP APS-C sensor have so much higher pixel density than a 24MP FF so it will inevitably reveal the slightest mistake, shake, misaligned focus plane etc. The FF sensor have a much higher tolerance simply because its pixels are so much larger.

I personally ran into a wall with the Canon 7D (18MP APS-C). Add to that many of the lenses I used at that time also had IS. Moving to Canon 5DMkII (and lenses w/o IS) images came out much
...Show more →

Very interesting point, wfrank! I also found out that 5N can be more demanding in terms of stability (and other parameters) than my 5N. But it is IMHO also more rewarding. Does it mean that a very small pixel is more "sensitive" or "reactive" than a larger one?
This prepares me to the 7 being even more demanding than the 5N. I hope it is also more rewarding when all is well...
Dec 24, 2011 at 07:30 AM
you2
Offline
Details
p.3 #7NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
Is the 24MP more demanding or is it that you can zoom in further (given the higher pixel density). I.e, if you zoom in the same amount as the 5n; is dof/shakes still more readily apparent ?

philber wrote:
wfrank wroteI dont think the DOF is the thing. It's the resistance to handling variations in real world shooting. A 24MP APS-C sensor have so much higher pixel density than a 24MP FF so it will inevitably reveal the slightest mistake, shake, misaligned focus plane etc. The FF sensor have a much higher tolerance simply because its pixels are so much larger.

I personally ran into a wall with the Canon 7D (18MP APS-C). Add to that many of the lenses I used at that time also had IS. Moving to Canon 5DMkII (and lenses w/o IS) images came out much more resilient to minute handling deficiencies, lens issues and such.

The NEX 7 is for sure a great camera, but it takes effort to actually be able to fully harvest the extra resolution the camera is capable of. In casual shooting it's not that easy. Even the high pixel density of the 5N takes an extra effort compared to e.g. a Canon 5DMkII ("all things equal"). It's something like 5 million pixels per square cm compared to 1.5 for the FF sensor.
Very interesting point, wfrank! I also found out that 5N can be more demanding in terms of stability (and other parameters) than my 5N. But it is IMHO also more rewarding. Does it mean that a very small pixel is more "sensitive" or "reactive" than a larger one?
This prepares me to the 7 being even more demanding than the 5N. I hope it is also more rewarding when all is well...

Dec 24, 2011 at 11:12 AM
AhamB
Offline
Details
p.3 #8NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
@Philippe: Could you please read your posts before you submit them? First you talk about flipping up the 5N's mirror (where you meant screen) and now the 5N is more demanding than the 5N. No offense intended.
Dec 24, 2011 at 12:27 PM
philber
Offline
Details
p.3 #9NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
You are right, Aham! Apologies to all, and merry Christmas!
Dec 24, 2011 at 02:22 PM
wfrank
Offline
Details
p.3 #10NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
Tariq Gibran wrote:
That very well could be it as I have never used an extremely high MP APS camera. If the high density is the issue, I suppose the upcoming 36+MP FF cameras could suffer the same issue.


Yes, it's been heading that direction but slow. Now perhaps even reversed temporarily. Canons latest FF (1Dx) reduced MP (!) in preference for speed. But about your comment, an FF sensor with 36MP would still have lower pixeldensity than the 16MP NEX - and of course far less than the NEX 7.

philber wrote:
Very interesting point, wfrank! I also found out that 5N can be more demanding in terms of stability (and other parameters) than my 5N. But it is IMHO also more rewarding. Does it mean that a very small pixel is more "sensitive" or "reactive" than a larger one? This prepares me to the 7 being even more demanding than the 5N. I hope it is also more rewarding when all is well...


We all know that as technology moves forward it allows for gradual improvements of DR and SNR while at the same time allowing some increase of pixeldensity. The FF sensor of the 5D2 is 3 years old while the 5N's APS-C is new. Sonys APS-C sensors have gone further than Canons APS-C's. Sony is clearly ahead of Canon there, particularly in DR. And also the new phenomenon "ISO-less photography". Pressing a Canon APS-C sensor in the same manor produces banding - a unusually terrible form of noise. This has to do with differencies in read-out technology where Sony are doing well. A 5N will allow you to lift shadows more than a 5DMkII. Great achievement! Maybe parts of this is where you find your 5N more rewarding than the 5D2 (?). There's should be no extra reward to find in the NEX 7 though.

But there's one point where sensor tech does not help.

Higher pixeldensity works as a magnification glass on e.g. micro shakes and lens limiations. But this is only valid when pixelpeeping in 100%. A equal sized print there are no negatives at all - just potential upsides if the prints get huge or you want to crop. The higher pixel density of the NEX 7 houses the capability of outresolving the 5N in every shot. What I am saying is that it wont be the case in everyday shooting. But on a tripod, good light, lots of time - it can be a 100% advantage as long as you have a lens and handling that copes with it. But then again, if the sensor outresolves the lens (or parts of it) the pixeladvantage means nothing.






Dec 25, 2011 at 12:28 PM
philber
Offline
Details
p.3 #11NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
Thanks for your interesting comment, wfrank. What I meant, and maybe did not express very clearly, is that higher density sensors step up the requirements not only on lenses, but on all components of the picture, including those which are photographer-based (proper focus, stability, etc.) Hence, the 7 will show these "smaller deficiencies" which the 5N might not have shown. But, in case of a shot free of such "smaller deficiencies", the 7 will be even more rewarding than the 5N. Hence it raises the bar on us 'togs to "do things really right". I am excited at the thought, even though I might end up with both a 5N and a 7 for just that reason. A 5N for lower noise, better handling of WAs, less demanding performance, and a 7 for hyperperformance with hyperlenses.... One advantage of light systems anyway is the possibility of having two of them ready with their mounted prime, which saves a lot of hassle...
Dec 25, 2011 at 12:54 PM
wfrank
Offline
Details
p.3 #12NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
Aha, I think I get your point better now Philippe. Yes, the NEX 7 should be furthermore demanding regarding handling to be able to to foster its virtues. Just as the Canon 7D craved for more precise handling than e.g. a 40D. And the NEX 7 have gone one step further in challenging the glass as well as the photographer. So in that sense it will sure be more rewarding when one succeeds.

As a personal wish, I'd say that for me the 5N is demanding enough, being a sloppy photographer staying away from tripods and so forth. For my next FF, I wish no more pixels, just more DR.

Merry Christmas :-)
Dec 25, 2011 at 02:56 PM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.3 #13NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
It is becoming clearer that the NEX-5N is better with wide angle rangefinder lenses in the corners.

Does anyone have any samples of how wide angle DSLR lens, like the ZF lenses do in the corners on the NEX-7? I presume that it would be better than with the rangerfinder lenses, but it would be nice to see some sample to to see, if anyone has any.

Jan 12, 2012 at 11:00 AM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.3 #14NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
Hi, it seems like there are more users with Nex-7s in their hands over on the get dpi Sony forums. You may want to check there. The 7 shouldn't really have issues with SLR lenses, as it would affectively perform like any other dslr.
Jan 12, 2012 at 12:06 PM
Mescalamba
Offline
Details
p.3 #15NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
Lotusm50 wrote:
It is becoming clearer that the NEX-5N is better with wide angle rangefinder lenses in the corners.

Does anyone have any samples of how wide angle DSLR lens, like the ZF lenses do in the corners on the NEX-7? I presume that it would be better than with the rangerfinder lenses, but it would be nice to see some sample to to see, if anyone has any.



It will perform same as on SLT-A77. Minus light lost by mirror.. Tho you will negate size advantage a bit.
Jan 12, 2012 at 12:09 PM
michaelwatkins
Offline
Details
p.3 #16NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
Lotusm50 wrote:
Does anyone have any samples of how wide angle DSLR lens, like the ZF lenses do in the corners on the NEX-7? I presume that it would be better than with the rangerfinder lenses, but it would be nice to see some sample to to see, if anyone has any.


Way back before any cameras were in user hands Rob Skeoch posted a series of photos shot on the NEX-7 with different Zeiss ZM lenses and he included also the ZF.2 35mm f/1.4 lens, maybe other ZF's, I can't recall.

http://thepicturedesk.blogspot.com/2011/10/sony-nex7-with-zeiss-f-mount-35mm-zf2.html

Here's the ZF at f/8, full sized file available too:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/sportsphotorob/6231985291/in/photostream/
Jan 12, 2012 at 12:18 PM
mirkoc
Offline
Details
p.3 #17NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
The resolution at f8 looks very impressive. It would be interesting to see the comparison with Sony A850/900 and 50mm Zeiss. There is nothing to complain about picture quality alone, no matter the ergonomics or camera type. If the price drops a bit after some time (it wasn't the case with top Sony cameras, as far as I know), it is a remarkable bargain for a landscape shooter.
Jan 12, 2012 at 12:48 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister