p.2 #4NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
I thought that was a good idea tho. I know I wish for such with my current GH1. I never seemed to think any such thing with film cameras in the past but with these electronic things I sure do. I think it has something to do with being aware of the affects the humidity of my breath has on the exposed components (buttons, LCDs, cracks and crevices, etc.).
p.2 #5NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
That's funny, I had the same steadiness issues with viewfinders in the corner of the camera in my film rangefinder days. Especially with the Fuji GX645 folder that I had.
I find it much easier to hold a camera steady at slow shutter speeds when the viewfinder is in the middle of the camera body.
p.2 #6NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
>David R writes:
>I'm a really casual poster here,don't want to be rude but.........don't you think you're chucking this cam away too early?Bit pleb.
I've got a lot of cameras I love, and the NEX 7 has this ergonomic issue for me, so why keep it? What better time to sell it without a loss than (1) when mine is still in brand new condition (2) it's hard for people to get (3) two days before christmas!
>philber writes:
>However, your argument that you don't like the fact that the NEX shows up small deficiencies that the 5N doesn't is something I don't share with you. If you don't want to see areas that are OOF (your Rolleiflex series and comments), why don't you increase DOF rather than hop that the camera won't show the goods? Unless I misunderstand your point, in which case I apologise in advance.
Technically, you're absolutely right -- small flaws in the image that are revealed by the extra resolution are hidden by downrezzing, and the extra resolution offers at least the opportunity to take the picture more carefully -- perhaps on a tripod, shooting a bit more stopped down, using only the highest quality lenses, more careful focusing, etc and get a really amazing shot.
Practically speaking, I have my doubts. The two main purported advantages of the extra resolution are that you can (1) print bigger and (2) crop more aggressively. If you can't actually do that on most of your real-world shots because once you go past about 16 megapixels the limiting factor on how big you can print / how small you can crop isn't the resolution of the sensor but flaws in your handheld/available light/limited-time-to-focus technique - then what's the point?
>Tariq Gibran writes:
>I don't think you can underestimate the influence of time and experience spent using the NEX-5 with regards to how well you may have synchronized yourself with that camera. Anytime one makes a change in equipment, it often takes more than a few days to really get used to how everything works, particularly when it comes to holding a camera steadily. Anyway, I would bet every additional day spent with the NEX-7 ergonomics would result in better technique on your part
I would generally agree with you regarding getting used to a new grip shape, certainly getting used to the buttons/switches/user interface of a camera. However there are some things that I don't think one can get used to.
For example, my left-eye-shooter son once tried to use my wife's Olympus 43 DSLR. Every time the camera wrote a picture to the card, a bright red light was flashing right in the middle of his right eye!
Ironically, I think I could use the NEX 7 just fine if the eyecup material were more rubbery and had more friction against my glasses. But it's quite hard and smooth and slides around. Maybe one day an enterprising entrepreneur will start marketing the "no slip NEX 7 eyecup" -- if that day ever comes I can re-buy it.
>michael watkins asks:
> are you a right eye shooter then?
Yes
>Could you comment on the feel of the camera, the build quality?
The camera feels really really nice -- solid metal body, rubberized grip, small but purposeful.
And I was going to end this post with a link to the buy & sell listing, but while writing this post the camera sold!
p.2 #7NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
...and you sold it for MSRP. Great folks around here!
Regarding the dof and higher MP, it's interesting to see your examples because I never really run into this issue with my FF 24MP a900 and it would of course have even less dof per given angle of view. I never shoot beyond F8 as a rule and most often I'm at F4/5.6 but then again I'm usually shooting a 35 or 50mm lens. Your example with the Minolta 40 gives the equivalent fov of a 60mm lens and you are fairly close to your subject so I can see where dof would be limited at F4. Really not too surprising.
p.2 #8NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
ebrandon, your thought's mirror some of the thoughts that I've been considering with the NEX-7, and it's why I cancelled my preorder a couple of weeks ago (I ordered the kit, so I wouldn't be getting it soon, anyways.) I'm a left eyed shooter, so the EVF location, as well as the lack of a tilt, could be a problem for me. I'd love the extra resolution, although, as you mention, it takes solid technique and maybe a tripod to really reap the benefits, and I'd rather have the better edge performance of rangefinder wides from the 5N.
The NEX-7 is sexy and streamlined, and there are certainly things about it that I'd prefer, but the positives don't yet outweigh the negatives, so I'm sticking with the more pedestrian 5N, for now.
p.2 #9NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
I have some doubts also.
EVF on my 5N can be tilted and it's a really good thing.
As good as a tilted LCD. Imagine NEX-7 with a locked LCD, everybody would complain...
The comment about lack of support makes sense - it seems to be great not to touch
the camera with your nose, but it also might be true it's not as stable to shoot.
If the IQ is way better, I will still get one though
p.2 #10NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
ken.vs.ryu wrote:
who knew that leica m had it all wrong all this time.
Yes, I was surprised to read that the OP is right-eyed and has trouble keeping the camera steady and therefore gets a low proportion of keepers — when I started reeding his first thread I had the impression that he was left-eyed. As Henrik states above, one needs more than two days to get used to a camera, particularly one that has a different shape and design from what one has been using. I remember a posting somewhere where a guy was describing how his wife tried using a Ricoh GRIDx "for five minutes" because she wanted a camera that would give her more control over her photography but that could not get control of it in five minutes and therefore decided against it. I thought, "as long as five minutes?" and now, with this thread I'm thinking, "as long as two days?"
Guys, I'm not trying to offend anyone here but it's hard to take these two threads as anything else than rampant consumerism and the need to try the "camera of the month", which turns me off. On another board I just saw a posting by someone selling the Ricoh GXR-M, the Fuji X100, and the Sony NEX-5N because he just got the NEX-7. Great, but, for me, life is too short to be a camera tester.
My own view is that it takes time to master a camera: I bought the GXR-M a few months ago and still feel that it's the camera that's pushing me towards a type of shooting rather than my being able to make the camera transparent and having control of it, although I haven't had time too shoot enough with it.
For no particular reason, except to perhaps to get away from camera tests, here are a few of my favorite shots with the GXR-M. The first one is one of the test shots that I made at the Thai Ricoh Camera importer's office of the receptionist there using the DR Sumicron-50: shot in the worst possible mixture of fluorescent, tungsten and day light, I felt the GXR-M was transparent to the lens and produced the typical look of the DR Summicron the way tilm did, and the next day I went to a dealer and bought it. The rest of the pictures use the Leica Elmarit-21 ASPH lens.
p.2 #11NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
Mitch Alland wrote:
Guys, I'm not trying to offend anyone here but it's hard to take these two threads as anything else than rampant consumerism and the need to try the "camera of the month", which turns me off. ... My own view is that it takes time to master a camera
It's interesting how many people seem upset that I sold the NEX 7 off having just tried it for a couple of days.
Mitch, you're right that it takes time to master a camera, but it doesn't take much time to know when a camera isn't right for me because of some ergonomic quirk. Usually I can hold a camera in the store and tell in 5 seconds that it's not right for me -- Panasonic G3 (grip way too small) - any Canon Rebel (nose smushed hard against LCD) -- Olympus EP1/2/3 (fingertip goes way past shutter button). With the NEX 7 I didn't have that luxury to see it in a store, so I had to buy it / try it / sell it.
That doesn't make me a "rampant" consumer trying the "camera of the month". I'm still using & loving the Panasonic G1 that I've owned for years and I don't think the Olympus E-1, Olympus OM-4 or Mamiya 6 I use are the "camera of the month".
p.2 #12NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
I've said it before, but I think many of the ergonomic differences between the NEX-7 and 5N+EVF are akin to those between a rangefinder and a Hasselblad. Neither is necessarily better, just different.
p.2 #13NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
ebrandon wrote:
That doesn't make me a "rampant" consumer trying the "camera of the month". I'm still using & loving the Panasonic G1 that I've owned for years and I don't think the Olympus E-1, Olympus OM-4 or Mamiya 6 I use are the "camera of the month".
The Mamiya 6 is interesting as the finder is in about the same position as the NEX-7 I would think. Having owned one myself, I would guess the size as well as the superior grip make it more stable for you in use?
p.2 #14NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
Tariq Gibran wrote:
The Mamiya 6 is interesting as the finder is in about the same position as the NEX-7 I would think. Having owned one myself, I would guess the size as well as the superior grip make it more stable for you in use?
I've never spent so much time thinking about (let alone discussing in public) what's touching various parts of my face.
I just held the Mamiya 6, and while the VF is in the upper left corner, the eyecup is very shallow. Consequently, the whole camera is closer to my face and the top left corner of the camera body is pressed against my forehead. Also the left part of the camera body is pressing the side of my nose. All in all it feels extremely stable. In addition I'm shooting a ~45mm equivalent lens not up to 300mm equivalent like I tried with the NEX 7.
p.2 #15NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
ebrandon wrote:
It's interesting how many people seem upset that I sold the NEX 7 off having just tried it for a couple of days.
Mitch, you're right that it takes time to master a camera, but it doesn't take much time to know when a camera isn't right for me because of some ergonomic quirk. Usually I can hold a camera in the store and tell in 5 seconds that it's not right for me -- Panasonic G3 (grip way too small) - any Canon Rebel (nose smushed hard against LCD) -- Olympus EP1/2/3 (fingertip goes way past shutter button). With the NEX 7 I didn't have that luxury to see it in a store, so I had to buy it / try it / sell it.
That doesn't make me a "rampant" consumer trying the "camera of the month". I'm still using & loving the Panasonic G1 that I've owned for years and I don't think the Olympus E-1, Olympus OM-4 or Mamiya 6 I use are the "camera of the month".
Please don't take what I wrote that seriously: I'm not disputing that you find the NEX 5n better to use for a variety of reasons, among which the position of the viewfinder is a major factor. However, a lot lot of people have used Leica-M cameras, with the viewfinder in the same position and love that camera — and that's not a big deal.
Reading over my posting now, I see that I was too strong on the "camera of the month" thing because I applied it to your two threads — I apologize for that — when what set me off was the thought of the guy who bought, and is now selling the GXR-M, X100, and the NEX-5N to get the NEX-7. Indeed, I was very attracted to the NEX-7 when it was announced and was thinking of getting it. However, what I really was after was a camera to use with my six Leica-M lenses — and I found that the GXR-M suits that purpose well, having been disappointed with both the M8.2 and M9. Otherwise, I think most of us have been changing cameras too frequently, to the detriment of our photography.
p.2 #16NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
Tariq Gibran wrote:
...and you sold it for MSRP. Great folks around here!
Regarding the dof and higher MP, it's interesting to see your examples because I never really run into this issue with my FF 24MP a900 and it would of course have even less dof per given angle of view. I never shoot beyond F8 as a rule and most often I'm at F4/5.6 but then again I'm usually shooting a 35 or 50mm lens. Your example with the Minolta 40 gives the equivalent fov of a 60mm lens and you are fairly close to your subject so I can see where dof would be limited at F4. Really not too surprising....Show more →
I dont think the DOF is the thing. It's the resistance to handling variations in real world shooting. A 24MP APS-C sensor have so much higher pixel density than a 24MP FF so it will inevitably reveal the slightest mistake, shake, misaligned focus plane etc. The FF sensor have a much higher tolerance simply because its pixels are so much larger.
I personally ran into a wall with the Canon 7D (18MP APS-C). Add to that many of the lenses I used at that time also had IS. Moving to Canon 5DMkII (and lenses w/o IS) images came out much more resilient to minute handling deficiencies, lens issues and such.
The NEX 7 is for sure a great camera, but it takes effort to actually be able to fully harvest the extra resolution the camera is capable of. In casual shooting it's not that easy. Even the high pixel density of the 5N takes an extra effort compared to e.g. a Canon 5DMkII ("all things equal"). It's something like 5 million pixels per square cm compared to 1.5 for the FF sensor.
Apologize if I've misunderstood your point Tariq, in the above I try to elaborate what I think ebrandon referred to.
p.2 #17NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
kosmoskatten wrote:
PS
If anyone offers you $3K for it - sell it immediately!
Lotusm50 wrote:
Yes, indeed. If I had mine (lesson learned: don't pre-order from Amazon.com) I'd sell it for $3000 in a heartbeat and just order another one.
And then there's me who thinks no almost camera body is worth $1k and will wait for the Nex7 (or whatever) to become sub-$500 before I cough up the green.
p.2 #18NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
In my case, I find shooting from waist level such a bonus over shooting from eye level, that the 7 EVF, if I get the camera, will only be my plan B, for portrait for example, or in full sunlight.
p.2 #20NEX 7 vs NEX 5N - 5N wins by a nose (lots of samples)
Bif; NEX7 has tilt. I also agree that "toughing it out" until prices drop makes sense.
ebrandon: sometimes all you need is a gut feeling. If you felt it wasn't the camera for you, you made the right decision. At least you got to try it out with no financial loss.
I was in a similar situation with the NEX5n which I still think is a great camera, just not right for me. It also made me appreciate the GXR M mount even more. Neither are perfect but I found a better compromise in the GXR and I am happy I held on to it while I evaluated the NEX5n.
Mitch: I will be in BKK in two days, look forward to it. Will meet up with Ed there before heading down to Krabi for some climbing.