fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2011 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2011Raw Photo Processor

  
 
FlyPenFly
Offline

p.1 #1Raw Photo Processor
Started playing around with this app, its pretty good. Sure the UI sucks and it'll probably take me a weekend to figure out what all the settings do but this is nice!

Both are unsharpened, it seems the Adobe camera profiles are still influencing color even though I set both to the same white balance setting and the default adobe camera profile on my A850. This was taken with the CY 35-70 at infinity at 1/750 at I believe F5.6 or F8.

I raised exposure to try to match on the RPP file because of the initial import.

Exported to TIFF on both programs then did the comparison in Photoshop then exported as a very high quality JPG file.

To me, there is definitely more detail on 1:1 crops in RPP. I'm not sure if it's worth it to interrupt my workflow but perhaps for the handful of images where I want to maximize every detail.

Nov 03, 2011 at 02:13 PM
FlyPenFly
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Raw Photo Processor
I will say it appears in the default import, ACR applies its own NR and contrast which wipes out some of the detail. Doesn't appear you can turn this feature off.

Reading the FAQ for RPP, it makes me think if I should just always have +.8 or so EV on.
Nov 03, 2011 at 02:31 PM
slungu
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Raw Photo Processor
A little question somehow off topic but does anybody know what the minimum requirements for RPP are ? Thinking about getting some older mini.

Regards Stefan
Nov 03, 2011 at 02:39 PM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Raw Photo Processor
After a very short time with the RPP I can only say, wow, what a difference it makes for the better. I have read some articles by the people behind it and when I saw that they were involved in RPP I knew that it would probably very good.

User interface is... ...not the greatest. But I will take that if that is what it takes.

RPP has given a new life to my Ricoh A12/28mm lens/unit, a lensor that left me a bit cold as it was a lot softer than what I had hoped it would be. With RPP I have seen what it can and will do. As a former commercial printer/lab rat (1989 to 2005) I can immediately recognize the potential and the film settings are quite accurate too. I know the files will print well - something I wasn't always sure with when using ACR, as I had to dabble too much with the files at times.

This post could be seen as a shameless plug for RPP, but hey, there is no money involved as it is a free software. I will donate, for sure. No more ACR for me. I have been lazy with investigating the development on the RAW format arena, as there are simply too many to choose from and I can't go through a buy and try on each and everyone.

Since I am well used to CS3 (that old dog) I find that RPP does really well in preparing the files for further processing.

/ Henrik
Nov 03, 2011 at 02:44 PM
AhamB
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Raw Photo Processor
FlyPenFly wrote:
it seems the Adobe camera profiles are still influencing color even though I set both to the same white balance setting and the default adobe camera profile on my A850.


The camera profiles have a huge impact on colors and contrast. Do you have different profiles for Sony cameras in ACR? For Canon there's 5 different ones, besides the Adobe Standard profile and ACR 4.4 and 4.2. I usually use the Camera Standard profile for my 5D files.
Nov 03, 2011 at 02:46 PM
FlyPenFly
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Raw Photo Processor
Nope they just have something they call adobe default.
Nov 03, 2011 at 02:51 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Raw Photo Processor
AhamB wrote:
Do you have different profiles for Sony cameras in ACR? For Canon there's 5 different ones, besides the Adobe Standard profile and ACR 4.4 and 4.2. I usually use the Camera Standard profile for my 5D files.


only canikon get that level of support from adobe. the rest of us our lucky ACR supports our cameras at all.
Nov 03, 2011 at 02:52 PM
FlyPenFly
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Raw Photo Processor
I wonder if it would be smarter to import the raw via rpp batch proccessing then bring the images into lightroom for tagging, uploading, cropping, straightening, and adjusting black levels as well as clarity, vibrandy, saturation, sharpening, and noise. Rpp strength seems to be the initial processing.
Nov 03, 2011 at 02:55 PM
Joseph Marney
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Raw Photo Processor
There are some user made profile sets that work well with the A900/A850.

RPP does a great job a detail retention. I just wish I could plug that engine into the Lightroom interface/workflow.
Nov 03, 2011 at 02:59 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Raw Photo Processor
Joseph Marney wrote:
There are some user made profile sets that work well with the A900/A850.

RPP does a great job a detail retention. I just wish I could plug that engine into the Lightroom interface/workflow.


You can by following these steps:

1) make a small donation to RPP to unlock LR3 compatibility and multicore support.

2) import raws into LR3 as normal.

3) cull, tag, etc. photos

4) right click on photo and select EXPORT--> Open photo in RPP

5) Make necessary raw adjustments in RPP (I turn sharpening off btw,) and select "open in Adobe Lightroom 3" and hit save

6) This reimports a TIFF in LR3 that you can do further adjustments to, like sharpening, NR, etc.

7) Export or print TIFF out of LR3 as needed.


Nov 03, 2011 at 04:19 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Raw Photo Processor
It sounds like the real RPP strength is the initial file translation, does it not do tone and detail/nr controls well?

I find ACR6 defaults very workable WRT contrast (its actually quite flat with good tonal spread) also for this lens/camera combination - colour NR is the default 25 setting upon open, with lum noise 'indicating' off and the files certainly not overly cleaned of detail.

Detail is every bit as good as Raw Therapee in my lengthy examinations (even using RT's deconvolve feature) and WB is read much more accurately. And ACR's controls give plenty of grip at a macro level on the histo.

Looking at the crops here, detail is not a night and day difference - and the contrast/WB/sat issue is swamping any meaningful conclusion re detail rendition. An adjunct test would be to do the best you can with each app in 5-10 minutes and then compare - this seems to me to be a better real world comparison of the ability of each application's toolset. Thanks for sharing.
Nov 03, 2011 at 05:16 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Raw Photo Processor
Sorry, just saw your comments in the NEX7 thread, Douglas, re RPP controls.
Adobe apparently rewrote the NR/sharpening controls in ACR for CS5 and included deconvolve 'by the back door 'more accurate' in Smart Sharpen within CS5.
Nov 03, 2011 at 05:21 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Raw Photo Processor
Phillip, RPP does tone and other things well. Most of the time, I do everything in RPP except NR/Sharpening. I do use LR3's sharpening (detail at 100 means deconvolution) with RPP's files after the fact, just as RPP was meant to be used. I'm surprised you don't notice a detail difference between RPP and LR3. Either way, outside of the extra detail, the tonal transitions, color and overall look of RPP are so good that it is still worth it to me to use RPP in cooperation with LR3.
Nov 03, 2011 at 05:29 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.1 #14Raw Photo Processor
douglasf13 wrote:
Either way, outside of the extra detail, the tonal transitions, color and overall look of RPP are so good that it is still worth it to me to use RPP in cooperation with LR3.



Dare I say RPP offers the most film-like conversions of any raw program I have tried thus far. Images can often take on a certain depth that you would have to work really hard to get out of some of the other programs.
Nov 03, 2011 at 05:37 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Raw Photo Processor
Tariq Gibran wrote:
douglasf13 wroteEither way, outside of the extra detail, the tonal transitions, color and overall look of RPP are so good that it is still worth it to me to use RPP in cooperation with LR3.
Dare I say RPP offers the most film-like conversions of any raw program I have tried thus far. Images can often take on a certain depth that you would have to work really hard to get out of some of the other programs.


Yeah, while I can't say I'm PS expert per se, I've been using the heck out of LR since it was originally released, and every time I think that I've maybe nailed a process that allows me to eliminate RPP from my work flow, I end up comparing things and retreating back to RPP with my tail between my legs. I give up! lol.
Nov 03, 2011 at 06:31 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.1 #16Raw Photo Processor
Tariq Gibran wrote:
douglasf13 wroteEither way, outside of the extra detail, the tonal transitions, color and overall look of RPP are so good that it is still worth it to me to use RPP in cooperation with LR3.
Dare I say RPP offers the most film-like conversions of any raw program I have tried thus far. Images can often take on a certain depth that you would have to work really hard to get out of some of the other programs.


yeah, i don't use rpp much just because of the slow down in workflow, but whenever i want the portra look i open up the files in it (also if i need maximum detail). i should spend more time investigating the other film settings.
Nov 03, 2011 at 06:40 PM
FlyPenFly
Offline
Details
p.1 #17Raw Photo Processor
What I like, and I think what my crops demonstrate is:

RPP doesn't discard data and does its own processing before I do my own. This is how ACR processes my RAW files before I even do anything. I definitely see a loss of fine detail in the ACR files if you look at the grass and some of the horse hairs.

That really bothers me, it looks like a JPG engine went in and hit the files before I was able to do my own processing.
Nov 03, 2011 at 06:55 PM
FlyPenFly
Offline
Details
p.1 #18Raw Photo Processor
Hmm I don't see an option for "Open in Adobe Lightroom 3" I've donated, installed the unlock code and installed the plugin and exported from LR3 to RPP.
Nov 03, 2011 at 07:34 PM
Mitch Alland
Offline
Details
p.1 #19Raw Photo Processor
The above posts deal with the increased resolution of RPP, which I think, compared to Aperture, ACR, Capture One, Irident, and Lightzone — the taw developers that I've tried to date — is compelling. What no one has mentioned is the fact that RPP also has substantially better color rendition than these other raw developers. Forgive me for re-posting below the Ricoh GXR M-Module pictures taken with the Elmarit-21 ASPH (except for the B&W one, which is with the Tele-Elmarit-90), which illustrate the colors that I'm getting with RPP.







































As RPP has a steep learning curve because it works so differently from Aperture and Lightroom, I;m listing the steps I take in RPP:

1. Set the B&W balance if there is neutral gray in the picture (Command-click on the neutral area);
2. Select a color film curve — I mostly use KR64;
3. Set the exposure using Compressed Exposure;
4. Set the Black Point (try 0.3 or 0.6); and
5. Set the Saturation (try 30-50) — if your camera has a profile in RPP, you'll need much less than this.

I'm not sure, but maybe step 3 should come before step 2. Step if is not always necessary, but in some cases is essential.

Remember, RPP is only a raw develop and you may want or need to do colot correction or contrast changes in Aperture, Lghtroom or Photoshop. There is an option in the File Menu called "Optimize for post-procesing on Save", which saves a files with slightly less contrast to give 5% headroom for further processing in image editing software. BTW, I found the following list for the meaning of the film presets:

A25 B&W = Agfa APX 25
P50 B&W = Kodak Vision2 50D
Duo = Technicolor 2-Strip
P160NC = Kodak Portra 160NC
A100F = Fujichrome Astia 100F
K64 = Kodachrome 64
V50 = Fujichrome Velvia 50
TC4 = Technicolor System4 Dye Transfer (Technicolor 3-Strip)
LF = Kodak Ektar 25

I've only been using RPP for some ten day, and therefore think it would be useful if we exchanged our experience with it in this thread.

NOTE: Henrik (kosmoskatten) thought the the color picture were a bit soft. Although they look sharper and have more bite as full-sized tiffs, they could probably benefit from some more mid tone contrast, using Definition in Aperture or Structure in Viveza.

—Mitch/Chiang Mai
Days and Nights in the Forest
Nov 03, 2011 at 10:05 PM
Mitch Alland
Offline
Details
p.1 #20Raw Photo Processor
douglasf13 wrote:
...All of this being said, if you accidentally blow highlights, LR3 does a much better job of reconstructing highlights with recovery. The makers of RPP admit as much, and they recommend that you "exposure for your converter," meaning that your exposure style should reflect the converter that you're using. With RPP, you don't want to blow highlights, but it does a better job in boosting underexposure, so error on that side, as opposed to ETTR with LR3.


Douglas, I hope you don't mind bringing this discussion over here to the RPP thread. I am not sure that I agree, as I have done some successful and major highlight recovery in RPP. Also, generally with my new GXR M-Module I have been exposing to the right and getting better gradation. It's only in the highest contrast or brightest light that I don't use ETTR but expose for the highlights, like transparency film. I'd be interested what others have found on this in using ETTR.

—Mitch/Chiang Mai
Bangkok Hysteria
Nov 03, 2011 at 10:51 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister