fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2011 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2011Raw Photo Processor

  
 
Mitch Alland
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Raw Photo Processor
douglasf13 wrote:
For those that own LR3, I can highly recommend making a little donation to RPP, so that you can export out of LR3 (as well as getting multicore support.) I still use LR3 as my main database and printing module, but I send the raws out to RPP for conversion. Best of both worlds, IMO. I like both the Kodachrome and Portra color settings.


Douglas, I've been using RPP with Aperture for final touchups. However, yesterday I downloaded my free version of Lightroom that came from Leica when I bought the M9 (since sold). I had rejected using Lightroom because I found the interface too fussy, with the tiny and difficult to control curve facility, for example, and have been using Aperture. I tried Lightroom again last night — and still found the controls and interface. Now that I'm using RPP, I'll keep on using Aperture for final editing — since RPP produces such a good file I see no advantage to using Lightroom instead of Aperure for minor edit post-RPP, or for being the host for Viveza or Silver Efex.

I agree entirely with about the desirability of contributing $25 to RPP.

—Mitch/Chiang Mai
Days and Nights in the Forest
Nov 03, 2011 at 11:12 PM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Raw Photo Processor
Thank you Mitch.

Tariq PM:ed me a workflow on the RPP that he had worked out, albeit for his Fuji X100.
l simply relay the info here, I am sure Tariq won't mind:


"WB - As Shot
K64 set just under the preset tab.
Curve Type - Film-Like
Exp.-0 (default value)
Brightness 50 (default value)
Compressed Exposure (between 0.20 and maybe 1) This is the main place to make exposure adjustments as it will be less likely to clip your highlights compared to using the "Exposure" box.
gamma- 2.2 default
Contrast-0 default
Black Point-0 default
Cold/Warm- I like either 0.10 but sometimes in a night or twilight scene, 0 or even -0.1 work better.
Saturation - between 40-60 (60 sometimes is too much)
Sharpness- 5.0 and on unless you will be editing further in PS or LIghtroom
Local Contrast- between 10 and 30 depending on scene
Interp.- VCDMF. This is important as the default is "Half" which will only give you half resolution conversions!
Highlight Recovery- unchecked. IF you check this, it will often reduce your exposure dramatically in an attempt to preserve all detail in highlights. This would require a much higher Compressed Exp. amount above and possibly even an adj. to Brightness.
I usually use either Lab 16 or the Beta 16 bit color profile. With either one, I convert to my working profile in PS on import.

Also note that you can't get a 100% preview in RPP that I can find but unchecking the "Zoom to fit" box at the top will give you a 50% view).

Hope that helps.

Tariq"

RPP is the first RAW developer that gives me film like results easily. It really resembles properly scanned film and it will be exciting to start printing out some stuff with it. Some people may argue that film is nothing to strive towards but I find the look pleasing and does print well and if you can have the best of both worlds I am all for it.

/ Henrik
Nov 04, 2011 at 12:25 AM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Raw Photo Processor
Mitch Alland wrote:
douglasf13 wrote...All of this being said, if you accidentally blow highlights, LR3 does a much better job of reconstructing highlights with recovery. The makers of RPP admit as much, and they recommend that you "exposure for your converter," meaning that your exposure style should reflect the converter that you're using. With RPP, you don't want to blow highlights, but it does a better job in boosting underexposure, so error on that side, as opposed to ETTR with LR3.
Douglas, I hope you don't mind bringing this discussion over here to the RPP thread. I am not sure that I agree, as I have done some successful and major highlight recovery in RPP. Also, generally with my new GXR M-Module I have been exposing to the right and getting better gradation. It's only in the highest contrast or brightest light that I don't use ETTR but expose for the highlights, like transparency film. I'd be interested what others have found on this in using ETTR.

—Mitch/Chiang Mai
Bangkok Hysteria


I've spoken to the makers of RPP about this, and they recommend metering middle grey where you camera normally places it, rather than ettr, with RPP. They claim metering middle grey where it is supposed to be provides better color. They also say highlight recovery is better with LR3 if one of the channels is actually clipped.
Nov 04, 2011 at 12:32 AM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Raw Photo Processor
Philip_PJ;

The difference is perhaps not too relevant for web posting, but I can assure you that for printing the difference is quite substantial. I can see that some people would prefer the punchier and slightly shadow blocked conversions as it looks kind of snappy on glossy monitors.

Slungu:
An older Mac Mini would do fine, don't skip on the RAM though. RAM is thankfully not expensive for older Mac's, but make sure you keep within the RAM limits of that specific Mac and have equal sized RAM's in the slots.
Nov 04, 2011 at 12:36 AM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Raw Photo Processor
I take your word on the detail retention, Jae, now on my home monitor I see it also. I do think a good comparo is to see how images end up after 10 mins work or so, as I find ACR pretty good for getting close to what I want from all my images, even old NEFs, better than I got with Capture NX (written by Nik). You get the unwelcome feeling that some developers want to give you 'their' impression of the image...

Douglas, I'm on a PC so no RPP for me, I'd love to use it having heard you and Tariq discuss it. Agree that the ACR/LR3 engine does fine high tone recovery, quite surprising as it still looks 'natural'.

Mitch, your colours do look accurate yet rich, especially with different tones of greens. Colour excellence really helps the 3D look also I think, and fine lenses sure help.
Nov 04, 2011 at 12:41 AM
Mitch Alland
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Raw Photo Processor
douglasf13 wrote:
I've spoken to the makers of RPP about this, and they recommend metering middle grey where you camera normally places it, rather than ettr, with RPP. They claim metering middle grey where it is supposed to be provides better color. They also say highlight recovery is better with LR3 if one of the channels is actually clipped.


I've just done a Google search and found the following quote dating from August 2011 from Andrey, the developer of RPP:

"...I meant using camera light meter (or external one if you care), but don't push histogram to the right and use camera light meter as it's intended, i.e. expose most important part of a picture around camera midpoint. ETTR had some reasons for old cameras with low DR - noise was too close to the midpoint and we had to do this to minimize it. With late cameras which have over 9 stops of DR ETTR is very harmful for colors - midpoint is the most colorful place in A900 gamut and noise is not an issue there any more. In A900 gamut slowly narrowing down from midpoint to shadows and very quickly narrowing down from midpoint to highlights. This means that brightest stop of the camera range has most of colors gone forever and they cannot be restored with negative exposure compensation. I'd say all color critical parts should be below top 1.5 stops. Veiling glare from lens and sensor are the culprits here...Squeezing scene with high DR into sensor or film range is a totally valid approach when needed, same as exposing for shadows. ETTR however assumes that it's always better to shift histogram to the right, even when your scene is only 6 stops wide and sensor is 9.5 stops wide. You probably already noticed before that slightly underexposed shots can be amazingly colorful even after exposure correction and I definitely noticed that ETTR shots can be very dull after correction even if there was no clipping. So my point is that ETTR is not always better and shouldn't be used unconditionally. The whole approach that you need to pay attention only to highlights is very limiting - what's really important is were we place critical part of a picture on a sensor range. This critical part can be anywhere - in shadows, highlights or in the middle and we should understand that moving it closer to the middle gray will improve it's appearance and try our best...Gray point is the base point which light meter is calibrated to. There used to be an old film 18% gray standard (2.5 stops from saturation point at the top), than at some moment all vendors switched to 12.7% (about 3 stops). They all round up them differently, so there is some small variations, f.e. it can be 12.5%. Then they switched to even lower values. My A900 is about 10% gray (3.33 stops), but it looks like there is slight variations in different camera samples. This all is based on green channel only (not sure if they use same kind of green as on sensor though).

...Now recent crop of cameras like A900, D3X, 5D2 went even farther. A900 calibrated to 10% gray and picture exposed around this number will definitely look dark. Most likely vendors just optimized light meters to place gray point in the best spot of a sensor, which is a good thing - they can afford this because sensors are better and shadows are much cleaner now. Bad thing here is that pictures need to be compensated now. In RPP this means Compressed exposure correction about 0.7-0.8 for A900. It absolutely must be corrected! Other converters do this behind a curtain and apply some exposure corrections automatically, usually badly and based on their own (mis)understanding, tone curve is getting involved so that's were all this confusion comes from. I completely disagree with this approach and in RPP you'll actually see picture exactly as it was captured and you need to define your correction specifically and make it default."


—Mitch/Chiang Mai
Days and Nights in the Forest
Nov 04, 2011 at 02:39 AM
AhamB
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Raw Photo Processor
@Bif: Have you just installed and tried RPP, or read up a bit on the design philosophy of that program? I believe they deliberately didn't use sliders for most/all? controls because the program is meant to do RAW conversion with maximum precision, and sliders aren't very accurate controls. I first thought it was weird, but in Lightroom (which is very similar to ACR but with a bit nicer controls) I often use the arrow keys (up/down + shift to make bigger steps) to set and finetune the values of exposure/contrast/WB etc. I still like to have sliders though, to be able to quickly change the value of one of the controls to see how it looks.

The colors look off in your RPP sample btw (too much red) -- probably a poor camera profile.

Anyway, I probably won't ever try RPP since I'm on Windows.
Nov 04, 2011 at 02:47 AM
AhamB
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Raw Photo Processor
Looks like your GH1 is simply badly supported by RPP. In that case I wouldn't bother with the program either.
I don't really care about WB though (only use it very rarely). I just balance by eye and pick what looks natural for the lighting conditions.
Nov 04, 2011 at 04:52 AM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Raw Photo Processor
Yeah, I guess that could be the case. Although writing a proper profile is easier than coding a line or two of logic code - especially if he wrote any prior profiles. I don't often use Auto WB either. But I thought it was a pretty good indication of the overall quality of interaction one has with RPP. Still, I'm glad it exists... it may grow into some useful in the future - and donation-ware is always welcome.

Nov 04, 2011 at 05:02 AM
denoir
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Raw Photo Processor
Bifurcator wrote:
I don't like it. I think it's a waste of HD space. It does nothing unique or interesting. The only thing is that it opens images (by default) with stifled contrast and the saturation unnaturally turned down. To get the image back to normal: as shot, as displayed by the camera, as the scene actually looked like through the camera prior to pressing the shutter release button, you're faced with using extremely inadequate controls.


I sort of agree, although I would not put it quite as bluntly. My primary objection is the terrible user interface and as you mention, the work it requires to get the colors in order.

As for a resolution advantage, it depends on the camera. It does a decent job of partially counteracting the effect of the AA filter on 5DII files. For M9 files the deconvolution sharpening doesn't make much of a difference.


http://peltarion.eu/img/comp/raw/A_colors.jpg

100% Crops:
http://peltarion.eu/img/comp/raw/A_crops.jpg


http://peltarion.eu/img/comp/raw/A_crops2.jpg


http://peltarion.eu/img/comp/raw/A_crops3.jpg


Anyway, to me any potential advantage in slightly higher resolution isn't worth it. If I choose some shot that I want to print really big, then sure. However, on a day to day basis I have no need for that added resolution. The information is all there in the file should I need it in the future and basically any RAW converter will provide adequate resolution - even Aperture that frankly sucks as far as the actual processing goes. My choice is based on ease of use and other functions (highlight recovery, noise reduction etc) so I stick to lightroom.
Nov 04, 2011 at 06:11 AM
FlyPenFly
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Raw Photo Processor
I think my plan is to do batch processing in RPP then bring it over to Lightroom. Well this was my plan until i realized then each of my files becomes a 150mb tiff and i use an ssd. It looks like ill have to reserve its use only for my favorite shots.

However im shocked how much data acr discards for the a850/900 on a normal no frills import.
Nov 04, 2011 at 06:26 AM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Raw Photo Processor
denoir wrote:
Bifurcator wroteI don't like it. I think it's a waste of HD space. It does nothing unique or interesting. The only thing is that it opens images (by default) with stifled contrast and the saturation unnaturally turned down. To get the image back to normal: as shot, as displayed by the camera, as the scene actually looked like through the camera prior to pressing the shutter release button, you're faced with using extremely inadequate controls.
I sort of agree, although I would not put it quite as bluntly. My primary objection is the terrible user interface and as you mention, the work it requires to get the colors in order.

As for a resolution advantage, it depends on the camera. It does a decent job of partially counteracting the effect of the AA filter on 5DII files. For M9 files the deconvolution sharpening doesn't make much of a difference.

http://peltarion.eu/img/comp/raw/A_crops.jpg

_http://peltarion.eu/img/comp/raw/A_crops2.jpg

_http://peltarion.eu/img/comp/raw/A_crops3.jpg

Anyway]http://peltarion.eu/img/comp/raw/A_colors.jpg

100% Crops:
_http://peltarion.eu/img/comp/raw/A_crops.jpg

_http://peltarion.eu/img/comp/raw/A_crops2.jpg

_http://peltarion.eu/img/comp/raw/A_crops3.jpg

Anyway[/url], to me any potential advantage in slightly higher resolution isn't worth it. If I choose some shot that I want to print really big, then sure.
...Show more →

I can understand that. In the images above RPP is clearly the worst second only to Aperture (which I hate anyway!). It looks to me like LR (which is the same RAW converter engine as ACR) did the best job by far. So I guess we agree on all points... I love my bluntness tho! Hehehe...

Maybe the only place we differ is on the desire/importance of micro-contrast and sharpness. If I can get a little more detail without totally messing up my workflow speed I'll do it. But that's cuz I use a noisy-arse camera and the more detail I have to begin with the more I can apply NR if/when it's needed. But ACR and CaptureOne deliver the most detail so I'm already in the zone I guess.
Nov 04, 2011 at 07:11 AM
FlyPenFly
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Raw Photo Processor
Actually RPP is delivering the most detail with its floating point engine. What you're seeing is just higher contrast of the default Lightroom profile.
Nov 04, 2011 at 07:25 AM
denoir
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Raw Photo Processor
Floating point processing doesn't help with detail at all. What it does help with is the stuff that need intermediate calculations - such as highlight recovery, color processing etc In short, you don't lose information when everything is rounded to integers in the in-between steps of some calculation.

The reason why RPP often delivers more detailed results is because of it's deconvolution filtering which helps counteract the effect of an AA filter. In the example above it makes no difference as the camera it was shot with has no AA filter.

Nov 04, 2011 at 09:29 AM
FlyPenFly
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Raw Photo Processor
On my monitor, from your samples denior, the ACR conversion seems to discard shadow detail... That could be just the higher default contrast profile.

Some samples from their page on RPP vs ACR, not sure which versions of each they are though:



Nov 04, 2011 at 10:16 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Raw Photo Processor
Bif ... you mentioned ACR in top 3 ... what do you consider the other 2, maybe even round out your TOP 5.

I also have a preset in ACR that sets everything to zero, so I can go straight to PS with the RAW mostly in tact. Otherwise, the OEM DPP gets used at times as well.

BTW ... I dissent at you being the "Nay-Sayer".
You turn into the "Yeah-Sayer" whenever I'm being a "Nay-Sayer" ... which in turn sometimes makes you the "Nay-Nay-Sayer".

Edited on Nov 04, 2011 at 10:43 AM · View previous versions
Nov 04, 2011 at 10:37 AM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Raw Photo Processor
One of the issues in ACR vs RPP vs Any RAW Converter comparisons with "no sharpening" is that no such thing as "no sharpening" exists. From what I've read the RPP demosaic processing is not magic and like all demosaicing algorithms includes a sharpening process. These "no sharpening" comparisons are pretty worthless as all they really illustrate is the differences between the relative amounts of native sharpening within different demosacing algorithms. A more approriate comparison is "best detail" output after having gone through the appropriate post processing. Comparisons at "default" settings or "zero slider" settings are insidiously misleading in that people misinterpret them as being "equal" when in fact they are completely different and worse still completely arbitrary.

RPP has always intrigued me, but not being a Mac user I haven't experimented. Thanks for sharing all the samples, they help me check out RPP vicariously.

Ken
Nov 04, 2011 at 10:40 AM
FlyPenFly
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Raw Photo Processor
That is an interesting point Ken, I didn't consider there was no such thing as no sharpening. I agree with you about how the test should be changed.
Nov 04, 2011 at 10:53 AM
denoir
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Raw Photo Processor
kwalsh wrote:
A more approriate comparison is "best detail" output after having gone through the appropriate post processing.


That's the approach I took with the crops above. However, unfortunately it's not that simple. First you have the basic issue of being sure that an optimal configuration has been applied - something that can't be guaranteed.. Second there are various tradeoffs - you can press more detail out of an image at the expense of increased artifacts in some places and added noise.

So that approach is not much less problematic than the "zero" slider approach or using the default provided values.
Nov 04, 2011 at 11:26 AM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Raw Photo Processor
Denoir, I agree that once you introduce post processing you have problems with the skills and familiarity of the tester. Definitely not perfect. Problem is that in seeing default/zero comparisons for years that the arbitrary and often large differences between defaults are usually significantly greater than the small residual differences of a photographer targeting matched outputs.

It is a tricky problem but in my experience ignoring the problem by sticking to defaults is worse than attempting to match even if the match isn't perfect.

I noticed you did your comparison attempting matched output. It's a great example of that approach and its benefits and limitations. Thanks for the comparison. You always produce nice illustrative examples.

Ken
Nov 04, 2011 at 08:13 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister