sebboh wrote: millsart wroteInteresting question for those that have a good number of current MF glass.
If (and I know it a big if) Fuji can introduce a line of lens that is optically good, of a compact size, and in the typical focal ranges/speeds that are popular, along with the ability to not only AF, but also with a direct MF ring (sort of like the Olympus 12mm f2.0) would you still prefer to mess with adapters ??
To some degree I guess this question applies to the NEX w/ Zeiss 24 as well. How many would prefer a $1200 ZM25, with the need for an adapter, and being MF only, compared to the E mount 24mm, assuming the E mount lenses delivers optically, which I don't think we've seen enough to really judge yet.
For me, legacy glass was always a means to an end. It was a way to get focal lengths not offered, but at least with m4/3, when native glass like the 45mm f1.8 came along, that was great optically, affordable, could AF, smaller/lighter and didn't require messing about with an adapter or having to zoom in to focus etc, I saw no reason to use to legacy glass on it.for me this depends on whether the OEM lenses offer something other than autofocus and exif info, specifically performance, size, speed, or character. i realize i'm in a tiny minority, but autofocus doesn't add anything for me (and in many cases increases the size) and adapters aren't an issue (just stick them on the lens and forget them) except for the contax g ones. in the case of the new zeiss, it offers speed and possibly performance compared to a bunch of lenses that aren't functionally much smaller (zm 25/2.8, OM 24/2.8, rokkor 24/2.8), so i'm very interested in it. even if it is sharper across the frame at all apertures than my current 24mm (the rokkor), i'll still use the rokkor from time to time as it's one of my favorite lenses. most of my lenses i'd be willing to replace though with something faster, sharper, and smaller....Show more →
millsart wrote:
If (and I know it a big if) Fuji can introduce a line of lens that is optically good, of a compact size, and in the typical focal ranges/speeds that are popular, along with the ability to not only AF, but also with a direct MF ring (sort of like the Olympus 12mm f2.0) would you still prefer to mess with adapters ??
As long as we're fantasizing about future offerings, I think it's more likely that the Ricoh/Pentax combination will present a compelling mirror less camera than Fuji.
I think Fuji has a very tough engineering problem if it tries to implement its hybrid viewfinder for multiple focal lengths.
Now, imagine a Ricoh/Pentax GXR II with an integrated EVF (like NEX 7) and a compliment of Pentax designed compact prime lenses. Hopefully, between Ricoh and Pentax engineers, they can come up with an improvement to Pentax's AF system.
In the meantime, I'm loving my NEX 5N and will love my NEX 7 even more when if shows up. We certainly have lots more really good options than several months ago.
For me personally, I bought the 5N for its size and to use it with small lenses - as I've learned now it means RF lenses to a large extent. The interface is by no means perfect. Better software (aimed towards us MF:ers) would improve it but that's not gonna happen.
The 7 is bigger (albeit with a better mechanical interface), has a doubtful resolution advantage whereas the 5N sensor is celebrated by all it virtues. Except perhaps color cast, but that is not changed with the 7.
Allthough 7 is an impressive camera, it walks away from what I like with the 5N. For now I'll stick with a 5D2 when I want any significant impovements over the 5N as I dont see them in the 7.
Jeff Kott wrote:
As long as we're fantasizing about future offerings, I think it's more likely that the Ricoh/Pentax combination will present a compelling mirror less camera than Fuji.
I think Fuji has a very tough engineering problem if it tries to implement its hybrid viewfinder for multiple focal lengths.
Now, imagine a Ricoh/Pentax GXR II with an integrated EVF (like NEX 7) and a compliment of Pentax designed compact prime lenses. Hopefully, between Ricoh and Pentax engineers, they can come up with an improvement to Pentax's AF system.
In the meantime, I'm loving my NEX 5N and will love my NEX 7 even more when if shows up. We certainly have lots more really good options than several months ago. ...Show more →
Ricoh also has a track record of taking chances and thinking outside the box so you never know what to expect from them.
When I look at the zoom optical finder of the x10, it makes me wonder what would happen if Fuji sized it up and increased coverage and accuracy. Perhaps this would be similar to the optical finder in the Contax G2? Now imagine that combined with on demand, instant EVF switching ala x100. That's sort of what I envision as a solution for Fuji.
Built in EVF's are always welcome, don't get me wrong, and certainly never a bad idea, but for me at least, the OVF, provided its a good one, ie; large and clear and able to show shooting info, still is preferred in probably 90% of the shooting I do.
I do think the hybrid OVF/EVF is a great way to go though as it can display things an OVF can't, and while as good as EVF's might get, it still feels like looking at a screen, and to me it gives the impression of being removed from the scene. While looking through an OVF, especially on a RF camera, I feel like I'm still there in the present, if that makes sense.
Certainly building a EVF into a camera is easier, but I think that doesn't mean its the best option.
Would the X100 be quite the camera it is if it only had an EVF ?? Or is the fact that its also a very nice optical finder (that does have its issues all optical finders do) really one of the things that sets it apart ?
Tariq Gibran wrote:
This route also gives you greater flexibility with future bodies/ systems (up to FF even) as your not locked only into the APS NEX system. This really didn't enter your decision process?
No, of course I did consider the inherited flexibility of investing in M mount glass. I also did consider build quality and performance and other factors.
What I wrestled with most in terms of functionality was wither AF or not for this focal length. I could make compelling arguments to first look at the E ZA 24mm AF lens, but in the end decided that I could go ahead and purchase the ZM25 without fear because disposing it on the used market should net me close to original purchase price - any difference would be a fee worth the price of admission for me, and I'm hoping that I'll decide I don't need AF for a prime in this particular focal length.
The bonus (that I alluded to earlier) was that the ZM was available first although that advantage will prove worthless if I'm not one of the pre-order clients that happens to get a NEX-7 out of the already built inventory.
Had the E ZA 24 been available first (and a camera to test it with) I do think early on that I'd have been able to dispose of it on the used market for purchase price, near it, or even a slight premium.
Maybe I'll still pick up the E ZA 24 so I can do a comparison on my own turf... but I'm going to hold off putting an order back in for that lens until more is known about the short and long term NEX-7 delivery situation, unless I hunt down a 5N for the interim period.
It seemed to me that from a risk perspective I couldn't go wrong so I ordered the lens which was available first - that was the basis of my prior comment. In my heart of hearts I'm hoping that my experience with a NEX OLED EVF and focus peaking satisfies my desire for and expectations of manual focus. In that case I'll be more likely to lean on M (or other manual focus) mount glass.
millsart wrote:
Would the X100 be quite the camera it is if it only had an EVF ?? Or is the fact that its also a very nice optical finder (that does have its issues all optical finders do) really one of the things that sets it apart ?
I wonder how many Fujifilm would have sold had it only had an electronic viewfinder? In my case I may have still bought it but can't be sure. After using it extensively for months I discovered that I was using the EVF far more than anticipated - more than 50% of the time, perhaps more than 80% of the time. This surprised me greatly. Hmm... is that info in EXIF? I should check that.
Now that Sony has raised the bar on EVFs, could Fujifilm release a camera of the same genre of the X100 with an EVF only provided it meets or exceeds that bar? While many would be sad to see that, I do believe it is a viable option for them and certainly it would reduce design and production costs if they went that route.
millsart wrote:
I do think the hybrid OVF/EVF is a great way to go though as it can display things an OVF can't, and while as good as EVF's might get, it still feels like looking at a screen, and to me it gives the impression of being removed from the scene. While looking through an OVF, especially on a RF camera, I feel like I'm still there in the present, if that makes sense.
Certainly building a EVF into a camera is easier, but I think that doesn't mean its the best option.
Would the X100 be quite the camera it is if it only had an EVF ?? Or is the fact that its also a very nice optical finder (that does have its issues all optical finders do) really one of the things that sets it apart ?...Show more →
+1 Great points!
I use the OVF in the x100 over 90 percent of the time. I only use the EVF to occasionally confirm focus. In a more versatile camera with interchangeable lenses, I see myself using EVF more mostly in professional studio situations where I need perfect 100 percent finder accuracy. Having the option of both would be the ideal.
millsart wrote:
For me, legacy glass was always a means to an end. It was a way to get focal lengths not offered, but at least with m4/3, when native glass like the 45mm f1.8 came along, that was great optically, affordable, could AF, smaller/lighter and didn't require messing about with an adapter or having to zoom in to focus etc, I saw no reason to use to legacy glass on it.
I completely disagree. A lens is what takes a picture, not a camera.
Your lenses are 10x more important for the final quality than the camera used.
NEX is a sensor, not much more. A versatile solution to use my best lenses.
You make it sound like it's the other way around.
Sigh..... your quite the amazing photographer and I do enjoy your images...but man when it comes to words and your attitude.....arrgghh
What does a lens do without a camera
Can you record an image with just a lens ? If the lens takes the pictures as you claim, why aren't we just carrying around a the lens ??
I don't know about you, or maybe some of the people here who view photography as more a pursuit of resolution and rendering rather than the creation of art of beauty, or recording a moment in time etc, but I don't care how good of lens I'm using, its the camera and the handling that produces the best pictures.
I'd rather have a crap lens on a camera thats fun to shoot, and that lets me capture my vision, although perhaps not in a manner than would impress the pixel peepers at 100% view, than the rarest, most exotic, high priced, hand made, ooooh and ahhh inducing on photo forums at the vary mention of its name lens if its not fun and enjoyable to shoot.
What good is 10x better technical quality to the image if one doesn't like the composition or missed the moment ?
Or just left the camera at home because while it may be fine for shooting random objects in the living room to post online, as far as something you actually want to carry with it and use when out its a PITA ?
A good lens is a nice thing to have, yes, but if its not implemented into the camera system in way that functions well for a persons giving shooting style its worthless IMHO
snowboarder wrote: millsart wroteFor me, legacy glass was always a means to an end. It was a way to get focal lengths not offered, but at least with m4/3, when native glass like the 45mm f1.8 came along, that was great optically, affordable, could AF, smaller/lighter and didn't require messing about with an adapter or having to zoom in to focus etc, I saw no reason to use to legacy glass on it.I completely disagree. A lens is what takes a picture, not a camera.
Your lenses are 10x more important for the final quality than the camera used.
NEX is a sensor, not much more. A versatile solution to use my best lenses.
You make it sound like it's the other way around.
I have both the GXR mount and 5n. I tested the voigtlander 12mm and voigtlander 28mm 3.5 and in both cases the m wides performed better on the gxr mount. The Gxr mount also showed better pixel sharpness and higher micro contrast with the same lens. In the 5n’s favor were slightly less noise and the shadows lifted cleaner.
kosmoskatten wrote:
mescalamba: the Ricoh GXR M mount does not perform as well as the NEX5N, not even with wide angle lenses. I know, I had both and shot them side by side with the same lenses. This was a bit sad for me as I love the GXR camera and think the camera itself is superior in handling to all other APS-C cameras. Maybe Ricoh will get it right with the next one. The idea is brilliant and the M module is quite good, it is just not great.
I have NEX5N as a stop gap until the NEX7 arrives - or something new from Fuji, Leica or whatever is the next decent platform for my RF glass. I have successfully managed to build up on lenses on the cheap (Zeiss ZM, Leica M and Contax G lenses) so all I know is that the next platform will at least have to (via adapter) manage M lenses and preferrably G lenses as well.
I sold my Leica M9 today, as I don't use it enough to justify it. With the NEX5N I can manage until something really good surfaces for my needs and whatever the outcome will be the NEX5N feels like chump change compared to the Leica M9.
Letting my gf take over it when I am done with it won't even hurt my wallet.
I have waited a few years already and the APS-C cameras have matured a bit. A new one from Fuji, Sony, Leica or some other might catch my attention but my hopes are still that a full frame mirrorless will become reality. When/if it does become reality I will make sure I have the lenses I need and some lenses I like.
I hope Fuji adds something to the market. Considering how good their lenses are I think they should. ...Show more →
there's no way you can get more accurate manual focus with an optical vs a zoomed in evf image.
luminous landscape mentioned that the Ricoh gxr needed stopped down metering since the evf was poor for smaller apertures. This introduces focus shift.
so the nex-7 isn't as good enough as an unknown Fuji x interchangeable? Lol
millsart wrote:
Built in EVF's are always welcome, don't get me wrong, and certainly never a bad idea, but for me at least, the OVF, provided its a good one, ie; large and clear and able to show shooting info, still is preferred in probably 90% of the shooting I do.
?
Hmmmm. I LIKE looking and framing through OVFs, but greatly prefer using MF lenses with EVFs.
I prefer taking photos with the OVF and AF with my Pentax K5 and Limited lenses until I look at the images and realize that only about 70-80% have critical focus. On the other hand, with the NEX 5N, EVF and MF glass, I am always amazed at how I seem to achieve critical focus with about 95% of my images.
I think part of it is stopping down and then focusing on the 5N, which eliminates focus shift as an issue.
ken.vs.ryu wrote:
there's no way you can get more accurate manual focus with an optical vs a zoomed in evf image.
luminous landscape mentioned that the Ricoh gxr needed stopped down metering since the evf was poor for smaller apertures. This introduces focus shift.
so the nex-7 isn't as good enough as an unknown Fuji x interchangeable? Lol
We must have been typing at the same time. If I had read your post first, I would have just gone:
Huff was the first well known guy to spend some time with the nex-5 before he posted a review a year ago or so. And it was a pretty decent one.
His reviews have a personal feel which is more pleasant to read than most. But it took him forever to try legacy glass on the nex platform. See that review where he takes his nex AND his M9 on a trip then compares images----BUt he never put his leica glass on the nex!!!
In this review he pleads poverty: no leica wides. I guess he never heard of CV?
Lets face it, the only people who have ever properly reviewed the nex system is all of us
Now we just need a site and a pretend personality: Steve Ruff.
"A lens is what takes a picture, not a camera.
Your lenses are 10x more important for the final quality than the camera used.
NEX is a sensor, not much more. A versatile solution to use my best lenses.
You make it sound like it's the other way around."
I agree with this statement, apart from changing 'takes' to 'makes'; and see none of what the Americans call 'attitude' in its expression. Cameras for many people come and go with dizzying, even alarming frequency, but the sensors in them simply impart the character of fine lenses (hopefully) faithfully.
It's just a different approach - find lenses from which you really like the output, learn to use them well, and use cameras which remain intermediary elements in the image production chain - a means to an end. Lens character is paramount to image rendition, but the same cannot be said for sensors contained within 'the box'. This is not beyond debate?
philip_pj wrote:
Lens character is paramount to image rendition, but the same cannot be said for sensors contained within 'the box'. This is not beyond debate?
Everything can be debated of course. In the film days, the choice of film had a profound affect on image rendering, often times just as much, or even more so, as lens choice. With digital sensors, there are still differences in rendering based on technology (AA filter or not, cmos, ccd, foveon, micro lens technology and so on) and software used within the camera - even when shooting raw. If I could shoot the same lens on Canon vs Sony vs Nikon vs Sigma vs Leica, these types of implementations would lead to a noticeable difference in image rendering. I do think overall that the differences have become more subtle in many cases vs film but often it is exactly the subtle things in the rendering of a specific lens which attracts one in the first place.
All of the above would assume similar handling which is never the case and is part of the point made by others.