Jeff Kott wrote:
I'm curious if any of the RPP proponents have compared the output to Capture One 6.
I'd wanted to try RPP for a long time, but unfortunately I'm Windows based and don't want to replace my computer and software just to try out a program that I may or may not prefer to Capture One.
Personally, I've never been a big fan of the conversions I get with ACR, but generally really like my Capture One conversions. I've found the Capture One 6 profiles and conversions for my NEX 5N to be fantastic.
I haven't used the most recent incarnation of C1, but I've used C1, Aperture and LR quite a bit in the past, and RPP kills anything that I've used in terms of raw demoisacing. It uses floating point, and takes a bit longer to process, but that results in positive IQ gains. I've made several attempts to dump it in order to streamline my workflow, but I keep coming back to it.
All of this being said, if you accidentally blow highlights, LR3 does a much better job of reconstructing highlights with recovery. The makers of RPP admit as much, and they recommend that you "exposure for your converter," meaning that your exposure style should reflect the converter that you're using. With RPP, you don't want to blow highlights, but it does a better job in boosting underexposure, so error on that side, as opposed to ETTR with LR3.