fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2011 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2011NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff

  
 
agnius
Offline
Details
p.12 #1NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
They do look terrible - totally out of focus. I think I get sharper images from my iPhone.

Did the model move after performing critical focus? And that is with $1000 Zeiss lens, at ISO of 160 with strobes? Terrible results.

I have been waiting for "7", but with these kind of results, I might just have to cancel the order. Or it is just a ruse to get us to cancel by people further on the list?
Oct 28, 2011 at 06:27 PM
michaelwatkins
Offline
Details
p.12 #2NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Henrik, by any chance did you see this series of 5N to GXR M mount comparisons:

http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/readflat.asp?forum=1013&thread=39677054
Oct 28, 2011 at 06:34 PM
ken.vs.ryu
Offline
Details
p.12 #3NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
agnius wrote:
They do look terrible - totally out of focus. I think I get sharper images from my iPhone.

Did the model move after performing critical focus? And that is with $1000 Zeiss lens, at ISO of 160 with strobes? Terrible results.

I have been waiting for "7", but with these kind of results, I might just have to cancel the order. Or it is just a ruse to get us to cancel by people further on the list?


I wasn't the only photog vying for the models attention - so she may have moved. Should've bumped up the shutter speed - it was at 1/60
Oct 28, 2011 at 06:57 PM
agnius
Offline
Details
p.12 #4NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Sometimes it is photographer, and sometimes it is equipment. With strobes shutter speed should not have mattered, so at the end I am not impressed by $1000 "Zeiss by Sony" lens. I guess Leica glass has spoiled me.
Oct 28, 2011 at 07:02 PM
bluetsunami
Offline
Details
p.12 #5NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
michaelwatkins wrote:
Henrik, by any chance did you see this series of 5N to GXR M mount comparisons:

http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/readflat.asp?forum=1013&thread=39677054


The more I see from the GXR the more I like. Great per pixel sharpness but there's also nice separation of tones and color versus the Sony (not sure if that's also due to the lack of AA filter?). The GXR colors globally look fantastic too but I've read that Standard mode can feel a bit anemic (setting to Vivid would help). I actually like that I have a native M-Mount to work with and I can adapt for DSLR lenses if I want (instead of the other way around).
Oct 28, 2011 at 07:29 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.12 #6NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
The GXR does look good, but you can't really compare an AA filterless cam with a camera that has an AA filter without using the proper sharpening technique for each. The right amount of deconvolution sharpening on the 5N should make up much of the sharpness difference against a GXR file that also has optimized sharpening.
Oct 28, 2011 at 07:36 PM
ken.vs.ryu
Offline
Details
p.12 #7NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
the 15mm is a bad lens

on the m9
http://www.flickr.com/photos/jhapeman/4150821459/in/set-72157622915915306

leica tried to correct the red edge with a fw update
Firmware update 1.162 features a revision of sensor homogeneity for wide-angle lenses. The additional color calibration noticeably reduces chromatic differences between the center and the corners of an image, especially in critical shooting situations. Additionally, the software processes of the Leica M9 have been optimized, significantly reducing the “red edges effect” and improving the menu’s Italian translation.

here's a recent photo with 15mm and the m9 - i'd guess that he has the fw update.
m9 with 15mm
Oct 28, 2011 at 09:51 PM
bluetsunami
Offline
Details
p.12 #8NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
I wouldn't call it a bad lens, maybe its just too wide to handle on Digital FF

Here's how it looks with the GXR...

http://www.flickr.com/photos/fratkin/6179249023/

I personally dig its size and focal length on something small like the 5N despite the heavy vignetting

Here's some more of the CV15 on the GXR...

http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1013&message=39611928

douglasf13 wrote:
The GXR does look good, but you can't really compare an AA filterless cam with a camera that has an AA filter without using the proper sharpening technique for each. The right amount of deconvolution sharpening on the 5N should make up much of the sharpness difference against a GXR file that also has optimized sharpening.


That's true and I'd definitely be interesting to see a downsized and sharpened sample from the 5N compared to the GXR. There's a nice sense of clarity from an AA less filter camera though that I like.
Oct 28, 2011 at 10:01 PM
ken.vs.ryu
Offline
Details
p.12 #9NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
bad should have been difficult.

gxr and the 15mm - red edge
http://www.flickr.com/photos/wogs/6195719995/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/zrahen/6216835671/

Oct 28, 2011 at 10:08 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.12 #10NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
The CV 15 is certainly NOT a bad lens, particularly on APS. Even when I used it on the older NEX-5, it was very sharp and Cornerfix did a pretty decent job of cleaning things up. On the 5n, and of course the GXR, I think it would perform superbly.

Here was an example I poste a while back taken with the CV15 on the NEX-5 and below are 100% crops.
http://www.gibranstudio.com/DickandJanes.jpg

Left top corner:
http://www.gibranstudio.com/leftopcorner.jpg

Left bottom corner:
http://www.gibranstudio.com/leftcorner.jpg

Center:
http://www.gibranstudio.com/centerv.jpg



Oct 28, 2011 at 10:10 PM
ken.vs.ryu
Offline
Details
p.12 #11NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
is there red tint on the aluminum sign?

on the nex-7 and the m9 - it looks bad.
Oct 28, 2011 at 10:16 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.12 #12NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
ken.vs.ryu wrote:
the aluminum sign has a red tint.

on the nex-7 and the m9 - it looks bad.



That was with the original NEX 5 and CornerFix was used. Any red tint you might see in the aluminum is due to color reflections in the scene. The magenta cast shows up in the org pre-cornerfix version in the corners, which I have shown crops of after the fix. On the 5n, the performance would only be better.

Clearly, the NEX-7 has issues, no doubt. The M9, being FF, would not surprise me it might have issues with this lens as well. The Ricoh GXR with A12 M module does not and the 5n is likely decent to good even without cornerfix. There would certainly be no smearing issues. Seems a bit out there to call the lens bad when it's actually a sensor issue in any case!
Oct 28, 2011 at 10:32 PM
denoir
Offline
Details
p.12 #13NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
ken.vs.ryu wrote:
the 15mm is a bad lens

on the m9
http://www.flickr.com/photos/jhapeman/4150821459/in/set-72157622915915306

leica tried to correct the red edge with a fw update
Earlier quoteFirmware update 1.162 features a revision of sensor homogeneity for wide-angle lenses. The additional color calibration noticeably reduces chromatic differences between the center and the corners of an image, especially in critical shooting situations. Additionally, the software processes of the Leica M9 have been optimized, significantly reducing the “red edges effect” and improving the menu’s Italian translation.
here's a recent photo with 15mm and the m9 - i'd guess that he has the fw update.
m9 with 15mm


The Leica firmware fixed the color casts on Leica lenses. When using third party lenses it gets more problematic - you have to code them as Leica lenses if you want the correction to be applied. This works well for I think all Zeiss ZM except the 21/4.5 C-Biogon. The CV 15 & 12 on the other hand show a cast regardless of which coding you choose for them and you must use CornerFix to get rid of the cast. While CF is a nice software package, it's still a major PITA to have that extra step - so my advice would be to avoid lens & camera combinations that produce a color cast.
Oct 28, 2011 at 10:32 PM
uhoh7
Offline
Details
p.12 #14NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
sebboh wrote:
it seems clear that the NEX-7 will be worse than the 5N for color shift and smearing, .


What ?
Correct me, but the M9 firmware is correcting for colorshift---at least that's what they say in Leica land, while the MLs are dealing with rez.

Does Steve have the final firmware? If not zero conclusions can be made from his tests.

Rock Huffwell strikes again--that's for sure.

Here's was my comment to his "review"

"Those of us who have using the nex system from the begining (like sebboh) with M and all sorts of RF glass understand colorshift is not the primary issue with retro wides, and your conclusions may be entirely misleading, since the mature firmware may address the issue. Even if it does not, colorshift is easliy addressed PP using cornerfix.

The primary issue is resolution in the corners and on the sides with retro focusing wides, which cannot be fixed. The best example of this might be the ZM 25 which did not perform well on the original nex-5, but it’s seen on many wides with the first gen sensor. Unfortuneatly your samples are not the best for checking this–though it does appear the GXR is out resolving the nex-7 with the CV 15 in the corners. What is suspicious is that it is also doing so in the center- at least to my eyes [I THINK HE HAS GONE PAST INFINITY IN THAT SHOT]. This makes no sense. I’ve shot alot with the cv 21 on my 5 (non-n) and while it shifts color like mad, it’s damn sharp in the centers.

Test shots with detail at equal distance accross the frame with the 15 and any other retro-focusing wides you have would be far more useful to serious shooters."

I simply cannot believe anyone here is drawing conclusions from a pleasant guy who has never owned a retro wide--and never touched one till last week. He then slaps it on his PROTOYPE and oula: the sky is falling !!!

Steve's test is worse than useless--it is more than likely misleading.

But like Dylan painting, Steve wins, because everyone is talking about him. Classic.

Edited on Oct 28, 2011 at 10:38 PM · View previous versions
Oct 28, 2011 at 10:32 PM
denoir
Offline
Details
p.12 #15NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
uhoh7 wrote:
sebboh wroteit seems clear that the NEX-7 will be worse than the 5N for color shift and smearing, .
What

Correct me, but the M9 firmware is correcting for colorshift---at least that's what they say in Leica land, while the MLs are dealing with rez.

Does Steve have the final firmware? If not zero conclusions can be made from his tests.


The problem is of course that the NEX has no idea which lens you've got mounted. The color cast corrections are entirely lens specific. So I think you can forget about any in-camera software fixes there. And it's actually worse than that - since you don't have any lens metadata, applying the correct cornefix profile may be problematic as you won't know which one you should choose (unless you remember exactly which lens you used for each shot that needs correction).

Leica has lens coding, so the camera knows which lens is mounted and thus knows which profile to apply.
Oct 28, 2011 at 10:36 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.12 #16NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
uhoh7 wrote:
sebboh wroteit seems clear that the NEX-7 will be worse than the 5N for color shift and smearing, .
What ?
Correct me, but the M9 firmware is correcting for colorshift---at least that's what they say in Leica land, while the MLs are dealing with rez.

Does Steve have the final firmware? If not zero conclusions can be made from his tests.

Rock Huffwell strikes again--that's for sure.

Here's was my comment to his "review"

"Those of us who have using the nex system from the begining (like sebboh) with M and all sorts of RF glass understand colorshift is not the primary issue with retro wides, and your conclusions may be entirely misleading, since the mature firmware may address the issue. Even if
...Show more →

Unfortunately, I think that ship has sunk with regard to the NEX-7 and the lenses in question.
Oct 28, 2011 at 10:38 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.12 #17NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
As I just mentioned in another forum, uhoh7, I get where you're coming from, but combine this with the other tests we've seen, and it's hard not to be suspicious of the NEX-7 not performing up to the NEX-5N in terms of wide M lenses.

link to other bad looking shots

I'm hoping that we just have incompetent testers on our hands, but I'm getting nervous.

edit* oh yeah, Steve Huff does apparently have production NEX-7, btw.

Edited on Oct 28, 2011 at 10:41 PM · View previous versions
Oct 28, 2011 at 10:38 PM
bluetsunami
Offline
Details
p.12 #18NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
uhoh7 wrote:
Does Steve have the final firmware? If not zero conclusions can be made from his tests.


Unfortunately the camera in Steve Huff's possession is the final in production NEX-7. There's could be firmware difference between what he has now and what the cameras have off the line but I think the color shift difference between the 5N and 7 is being dealt with at the hardware level. A week ago it would have fine to hold out for hope but I think Huff's white wall test conclusively shows that there is color shifting with the NEX-7 and with that usually comes smearing (which remains to be tested for).
Oct 28, 2011 at 10:40 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.12 #19NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
denoir wrote:
uhoh7 wrote
sebboh wroteit seems clear that the NEX-7 will be worse than the 5N for color shift and smearing, .
What

Correct me, but the M9 firmware is correcting for colorshift---at least that's what they say in Leica land, while the MLs are dealing with rez.

Does Steve have the final firmware? If not zero conclusions can be made from his tests.
The problem is of course that the NEX has no idea which lens you've got mounted. The color cast corrections are entirely lens specific. So I think you can forget about any in-camera software fixes there. And it's actually worse than that - since you don't have any lens metadata, applying the correct cornefix profile may be problematic as you won't know which one you should choose (unless you remember exactly which lens you used for each shot that needs correction).

Leica has lens coding, so the camera knows which lens is mounted and thus knows which profile to apply.
...Show more →

The GXR apparently allows you to adjust corner color correction in the camera menus. In fact, you can individually adjust each corner:

http://www.grblog.jp/2011/08/09/kyohda/CS02.JPG


Edited on Oct 28, 2011 at 10:44 PM · View previous versions
Oct 28, 2011 at 10:42 PM
uhoh7
Offline
Details
p.12 #20NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
denoir wrote:
The problem is of course that the NEX has no idea which lens you've got mounted. The color cast corrections are entirely lens specific. So I think you can forget about any in-camera software fixes there. And it's actually worse than that - since you don't have any lens metadata, applying the correct cornefix profile may be problematic as you won't know which one you should choose (unless you remember exactly which lens you used for each shot that needs correction).

Leica has lens coding, so the camera knows which lens is mounted and thus knows which profile to apply.
...Show more →

This implies the 5n is dealing with CS in a fundamentally different way than the m9. This is certainly not a forgone conclusion. You don't think it is possible for the camera to detect color shift and respond accordingly?

The m9 needs a profile, but the 5n does not--because of sensor design?
Oct 28, 2011 at 10:43 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister