fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2011 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2011NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff

  
 
Jeff Kott
Offline
Details
p.11 #1NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
douglasf13 wrote:
If the GXR had built-in EVF and tilt LCD, I'd probably bite. That NEX-7 body looks about perfect. The other thing that I like about NEX is the Hawk's helicoid adapter allows me to focus closer than the GXR can.


Let's assume that the IQ of the NEX 7 isn't satisfactory with WA lenses (I'm not assuming that, my NEX 7 is still on order). Why would someone buy the GXR over the 5N?

We know:

1. WA lenses seem to work on the NEX 5N,
2. The 5N and GXR both have attachable EVFs, but the NEX 5N has a better EVF, magnified view and focus peaking.
3. As Douglas points out, with the Hawk's adapter you can focus closer with the same lenses on the 5N.
4. 5N has tiltable LCD.
Oct 28, 2011 at 12:26 PM
bluetsunami
Offline
Details
p.11 #2NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
The GXR looks interesting now that I've seen it compared against the 7. I really like its colors and the lack of AA filter but I agree that the 5N competes with it in regards to alt usage. I may forgo the 7 in place of the GXR or 5N. I really want to use the 12/5.6 Super-Wide Heliar as one of my main lenses.

Of course I could live with the NEX-7 if I bought into the system surrendering to the fact that I'll be using large DSLR lenses when I go really wide. I really, really like the control rich body of the 7.
Oct 28, 2011 at 12:30 PM
millsart
Offline
Details
p.11 #3NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
bluetsunami wrote:
The GXR looks interesting now that I've seen it compared against the 7. I really like its colors and the lack of AA filter but I agree that the 5N competes with it in regards to alt usage. I may forgo the 7 in place of the GXR or 5N. I really want to use the 12/5.6 Super-Wide Heliar as one of my main lenses.

Of course I could live with the NEX-7 if I bought into the system surrendering to the fact that I'll be using large DSLR lenses when I go really wide. I really, really like the control
...Show more →


By the the time you put the Alpha adapter on though, and factor in the DSLR lens size, seems to me that the A65 or A77 almost makes more sense, and cost the same or in the case of the A65, less money.

I'll admit I'm pretty tempted by the A65 just for its flip out display and fast AF paired with a wide angle. I've tried the Nikon D5100 for example and while I like the flip out display, the AF is just so slow its useless for anything but static scenes.
Oct 28, 2011 at 12:41 PM
slungu
Offline
Details
p.11 #4NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Jeff Kott wrote:
douglasf13 wroteIf the GXR had built-in EVF and tilt LCD, I'd probably bite. That NEX-7 body looks about perfect. The other thing that I like about NEX is the Hawk's helicoid adapter allows me to focus closer than the GXR can.
Let's assume that the IQ of the NEX 7 isn't satisfactory with WA lenses (I'm not assuming that, my NEX 7 is still on order). Why would someone buy the GXR over the 5N?

We know:

1. WA lenses seem to work on the NEX 5N,
2. The 5N and GXR both have attachable EVFs, but the NEX 5N has a better EVF, magnified view and focus peaking.
3. As Douglas points out, with the Hawk's adapter you can focus closer with the same lenses on the 5N.
4. 5N has tiltable LCD.


You forget one thing : the Ricoh M module does not need the most vulnerable piece of the NEX setup : the adapter.
Oct 28, 2011 at 12:42 PM
Jeff Kott
Offline
Details
p.11 #5NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff

You forget one thing : the Ricoh M module does not need the most vulnerable piece of the NEX setup : the adapter.


I guess you could view that as a positive or a negative since as pointed out above and as we've seen in a lot of images in the NEX image thread, if you use the Hawk's adapter you get better close focus performance with your M mount lenses.

I have a Voigtlander NEX to M adapter on my 5N. It's a solid, well machined piece of metal, I haven't taken it off since the first time I put it on and it just doesn't seem very vulnerable to me.
Oct 28, 2011 at 12:48 PM
michaelwatkins
Offline
Details
p.11 #6NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
I don't look at the requirement for an adapter as a negative and if I had to pay 180 or 300 dollars for a Voigtlander or Novoflex or Hawk adapter (my Hawk is in the mail) - a piece of metal with no glass - in order to get a solution that performs properly, all the time, I would without hesitation. Factored across a few lenses the cost is reasonable if not actually insignificant.

Adapters on the NEX to me are not icing on the cake but are the cake or are at least the flour in the cake. I'm not stuck using only the mount Ricoh wants me to use or the lenses it produces itself, I can use almost any lens within reason. That to me is such an overwhelming advantage I have a hard time considering going the GXR route even if it does on paper look like a camera I'd rather handle and use than the NEX-5N (assuming I can't abide by the NEX-7).
Oct 28, 2011 at 12:59 PM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.11 #7NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Well, since I have owned both the Ricoh GXR M and the NEX 5N at the same time I could chime in a little.

I love my GXR, I had high hopes for the M mount which was one of the reasons I got the GXR in the first place, and a long wait ensued. Now that the wait is over and I have had it I can say it does well, but not great and I found the images from the NEX5N more pleasing to my eye.

I found that the NEX5N would hold small detail better with the wide angle lenses. I was hoping the opposite to be true but when comparing ZM18 pictures on both cameras the NEX5N had an advantage in pulling out micro detail. I know some think the GXR M has better output and detail but I could not see it. On same shots, same lens, direct comparisons the NEX5N did better. For handling and build quality the GXR is much better. For image quality and versatility the NEX5N is better. Despite the lack of AA filter I found the images from the GXR M mount quite soft and flat and the images a flashback from the old Canon 5D, the images needed a lot of tweaking to sing. And they would not always carry a tune. Compared to the Leica M9 the GXR M files were really flat, shot at the same time and place with the same lenses.

The NEX5N does better for me, but I see it as a temporary stablemate as I don't find the handling and build quality good enough to keep it indefinitely. The buttons and scroll wheel are a bit flimsy but I think the touch screen works well for MF lenses with the magnification.

I chose not to keep the GXR M mount, even though it is not too expensive for what it is considering I already have the GXR. But I find having a few totally different cameras can be confusing and detracts from the shooting pleasure so I decided to roll with the NEX5N until something more suitable appears.

EDIT: the comparison has been between NEX5N Jpegs and GXR M mount RAW/DNG files so I think the NEX5N will do even better when I have sourced up a RAW converter for it. Hence my slight disappointment with the GXR M. I haven't bothered with the supplied Sony RAW software yet. Have been busy at work so all I do in the evenings when my mind is blank is write ill informed postings in relevant threads.

Since my printer broke down - for good - I haven't had the opportunity to print out samples from the different cameras. I think the GXR files will print nicely all things considered. I usually reserve my comments until I have seen comparisons in print. As an example the ZM18/4 did slightly better on the M mount than the A12 28/2.5 unit does which goes to show it isn't bad at all.


Oct 28, 2011 at 02:01 PM
michaelwatkins
Offline
Details
p.11 #8NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Despite Huff's posting, I still have a 7 on order and a check with Sony Canada yesterday suggested to me that it is in fact likely that they'll ship one to me in middle November. While I'll believe it when I see it, I'm considering three scenarios right now and trying to decide if I should keep it on order or cancel it in favour of a stop gap solution with the 5N:

1) NEX-7 proves to be very workable with ZM glass even the 18/4 with maybe minor vignetting correction and not a lot need to fuss about with cornerfix or other colour shift remedies. This is, unfortunately, a scenario which looks less and less likely.

2) With the NEX-7 and ZM glass selection, colour shift is pronounced enough even on the 25/2.8 or 35/2 that fussing about ends up being the default rather than exception for handling keeper images. It is still workable but annoying over the long run, but image quality is still high in the end result.

3) With the NEX-7 and ZM glass selection images need correcting so often that it isn't fun or workable and image quality suffers enough of the time to be unworkable.

The GXR simply isn't on my radar.

If the first situation plays out, the action is simple: buy and keep the NEX-7. If it performs, it'll serve my needs for some years. That is in fact my ideal scenario - I like to keep cameras a long time if possible and focus on photography, not buying cameras. That was easier in the film days but I'd hoped this juncture in time would allow me to buy for the long haul.

If the second situation plays out, does it make more sense to suffer the hassle of occasional or frequent image correction but enjoy the NEX-7 for the tilt LCD and built in EVF and presumably sturdier build quality benefits? Or go with the 5N on a temporary basis. In either case the camera is probably not a long term keeper but maybe one or the other will hold its resale value higher, longer.

If the third situation plays out, buy the NEX-5N and an EVF and hang on to it until Sony comes out with a NEX-7N or equivalent that solves the problem, if ever. Despite good image quality, the camera is not a long term keeper because, one day, Sony or someone will get it right enough.

After typing all this I've realized I'm no closer to a decision. ugh.
Oct 28, 2011 at 02:40 PM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.11 #9NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Michael; I am shadowing you on the forum it seems.

I know they are just web samples but I was kind of surprised at how good the GXR M mount images looked. I had a very early M module and I need to have another look at the files I have with the ZM18 on it. I am not saying there is anything wrong with the one I had, just that I expected more from it. But then again, down sized and on the web pretty much everything looks fine. I still think they M mount could have done with 18MP or so but you have got to hand it to the Ricoh techies, they sure made a sensor that can swing them wides.

GXR improvement list:

Tiltable LCD
Better LCD viewfinder
around 18MP
and, not likely to happen, but still: full frame.
Oct 28, 2011 at 02:57 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.11 #10NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
I don't think there is any chance after seeing Steve's examples with wide angle rangefinder lenses, as well as the other controversial tests posted elsewhere, that the NEX-7 will be found to perform well when tested by others. The color vignetting (remember you will also get softness/ smearing of detail as well) is so bad, it goes beyond any influence of a cheap adapter or user error. The sensor is just not as good as that in the 5n for use with small, wide angle rangefinder lenses. Even the older NEX-5 I used with the CV 15 performed noticeably better than the NEX-7. It's just too bad but that's the case.

Edited on Oct 28, 2011 at 03:04 PM · View previous versions
Oct 28, 2011 at 03:02 PM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.11 #11NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
MW: for what it's worth, keep cool.

The 5N works fine, it is good enough to be pleased with, despite being a tad light on metal.
I will keep it until the a better working solution comes out. The NEX7 is just a faint blip on my radar but I decided to continue the waiting game and see how it pans out.

/ Henrik

EDIT FOR BEING TO SLOW:

Tariq, yes, let's call it as we see it; a flagship that might sink on it's maiden voyage.
We had that in Stockholm in 1628 with the Wasa, so I know all about it.
Oct 28, 2011 at 03:03 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.11 #12NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
it seems clear that the NEX-7 will be worse than the 5N for color shift and smearing, but the question is by how much. the cv 15/4.5 is one of the worst lenses around for color shift from all i've seen (much worse than the zm 18mm or cv 12mm on the original NEX). the shots from the leica 24 and 21 don't look to bad though, which gives me hope that the zm 18mm and 25mm might actually be passable with regard to color shift. i wish steve had shown corner crops at infinity with the various lenses to judge smearing though...
Oct 28, 2011 at 04:41 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.11 #13NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Like Tariq mentioned, I'm concerned about not only color shift, but corner resolution. I've seen a few comparisons between the new 16mp sensor and the NEX-5, and not only was there less color shift, but there was also a tangible improvement in resolution in the corners.

I'm not going to jump the gun, but, for the first time, I'm seriously looking at the NEX-5n + EVF...which is bumming me out a bit, because the NEX-7 body looks ideal to me.
Oct 28, 2011 at 04:52 PM
pdmphoto
Offline
Details
p.11 #14NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
Don't look at this:
http://sonyalphanex.blogspot.com/2011/10/sony-nex-7-with-rokkor-m-konica-and.html

And take a look at the 12mm sample at the bottom of the page (click to make it bigger). Too bad.
Oct 28, 2011 at 04:58 PM
michaelwatkins
Offline
Details
p.11 #15NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
douglasf13 wrote:
I'm not going to jump the gun, but, for the first time, I'm seriously looking at the NEX-5n + EVF...which is bumming me out a bit, because the NEX-7 body looks ideal to me.


I'm slightly farsighted and find it difficult to shoot using the rear panel display without my glasses, and I only have glasses on hand in my office / home or when I know I'm going to be shooting with a tripod. So that means a NEX-5N + EVF for me too, which is about the same cost as a NEX-7 and possibly about as available (the EVF) soon if every alt-glass user deserts the 7 in favour of the 5N.

My head hurts, it is time for a nice glass of wine me thinks.
Oct 28, 2011 at 05:00 PM
ken.vs.ryu
Offline
Details
p.11 #16NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
I'm selling all my sony stock due to a single image posted.
Oct 28, 2011 at 05:07 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.11 #17NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
ken.vs.ryu wrote:
I'm selling all my sony stock due to a single image posted.


I thought that when we saw all of those ZM on NEX-7 shots recently, but Steve's pics toady are definitely causing me concerns, since we're 0 for 2 when it comes to guys using M lenses on NEX-7.
Oct 28, 2011 at 05:37 PM
michael49
Offline
Details
p.11 #18NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
pdmphoto wrote:
Don't look at this:
http://sonyalphanex.blogspot.com/2011/10/sony-nex-7-with-rokkor-m-konica-and.html

And take a look at the 12mm sample at the bottom of the page (click to make it bigger). Too bad.


What's up with those samples? They all look terrible; they are so bad I wonder if they are mis-focused. I'm getting tack sharp images using old Canon FD glass.
Oct 28, 2011 at 05:45 PM
ken.vs.ryu
Offline
Details
p.11 #19NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
michael49 wrote:
pdmphoto wroteDon't look at this:
http://sonyalphanex.blogspot.com/2011/10/sony-nex-7-with-rokkor-m-konica-and.html

And take a look at the 12mm sample at the bottom of the page (click to make it bigger). Too bad.
What's up with those samples? They all look terrible; they are so bad I wonder if they are mis-focused. I'm getting tack sharp images using old Canon FD glass.


yep could be. they were all shot wide open.
Oct 28, 2011 at 06:03 PM
michaelwatkins
Offline
Details
p.11 #20NEX-7 Review by Steve Huff
I've been concerned about M glass performance on the NEX-7 for awhile now although that didn't stop me from buying some M glass recently for use on a NEX, figuring the 5N was a fall back camera. Rob Skeoch's series of photos shot with the 7 and various ZM lenses showed vignetting and colour shift on the edges on all the wide angle glass; what puzzled me in the building series was the colour change in the brick work but perhaps that's the camera adapting to the increased magenta coming in from the fringes. That was a pre-production camera but can't have been far off - least not physically - from those which consumers will be receiving (if any) in November.

Huff had a production camera and firmware - same problem, cheap adapter or not.

I'm afraid the maiden voyage sinking with all hands analogy is looking rather apt.

Oct 28, 2011 at 06:25 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister