I Googled the definition of "Magical". These are from the the 2nd use definition given on several sites:
"A mysterious quality of enchantment"
"Exhibiting an extraordinary quality"
"Unaccountably enchanting" (where "enchanting" is : casting a spell)
"Possessing distinctive qualities that produce unaccountable effects"
Most of the definitions included the terms, inexplicable or impossible to define.
So, perhaps there's a Catch22 situation here: If you manage to define the term "Magical", by definition it can't be Magical, because Magical can't be defined!
Looking over this thread so far, (I'm generalising massively here), two streams/types of lenses have emerged.
One stream I define for its special detail / information gathering properties, as exemplified by the Zeiss 21/2.8
the other for its special "smooth" bokeh properties, as exemplified by the Rokkor 58/1.2
Both of these "types" produce a spatial or 3D effect in different ways, one by high contrast in areas of high definition, (a characteristic of some Zeiss lenses), and the other by separating the subject from the background by out of focus effect, without necessarily having great resolution, like the Rokkor 58/1.2
However, some, rather than exemplifying or displaying something that's already present, add something of their own to the image, the Meyer Trioplan 100/2.8 with it's "crazy" bokeh comes to mind.
Having said that, I realise that, in their own way, they all "add" something of their own. So my thread starts to unravel.....
What do others think?
I throw this in to see what ripples develop!