fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2011 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2011Most magical lenses?

  
 
dukeman1234
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Most magical lenses?
"Zuiko Auto-Macro 2/90 and 2/50 for the most magical sharpness + microcontrast "

+1

The 50 is my favorite lens ever!
Jun 14, 2011 at 05:33 PM
Jim Schemel
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Most magical lenses?
mMontag wrote:
Of the ones I've actually used:

Contax "N" 85/1.4 - hands down uniquely 'MAGICAL" - cannot take a bad image with that lens
Contax C/Y 35/1.4 - very close second - same as above
Contax "N" 17-35 & C/Y 35-70 - the most "MAGICAL" tools for landscape - leave everything else at home (except maybe the 24II TS-E)
Canon "L" 24II TS-E - add accessory TC 1.4III - most "MAGICALLY" versatile single prime - Architectural/landscape/nature/product/shift pano's/tilt close-ups - etc.

Haven't used but would like to:

Voigtlander 125/2.5 - never do macro - but "if" I did


was wondering if the Contax N 85 f1.4 is the same optically as the Zeiss ZE 85 f1.4, if so does it suffer from the same softness WO?
-Jim
Jun 14, 2011 at 06:32 PM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Most magical lenses?
Jim Schemel wrote:
was wondering if the Contax N 85 f1.4 is the same optically as the Zeiss ZE 85 f1.4, if so does it suffer from the same softness WO?
-Jim


They're quite different designs, the N is closer to the ZA in design than the ZE, but overall it's own unique variation of the Planar design. It's optimized as a portrait lens unlike the ZE or C/Y versions and has better near-distance performance.
Jun 14, 2011 at 06:34 PM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Most magical lenses?
Hmmm. . . magical?

Hmmmmm. . . I don't believe in magical for technical equipment. Although I have owned a few guns that could regularly hit the most distant and tiny targets with uncanny precision, seemingly without effort on my part (I called them "Robo-guns" -- having a mind of their own).

I believe in practical. I believe in repeatable. I believe in lenses that produce the result I want, and sometimes surprise me in a postive way. I believe in lenses that don't let me down and come through in tough situations. I believe in versatile.

Perhaps that is "magical"?

What lens(es) could I not live without? Which lenses have the imaging qualities I desire (including convenience and versatility)?

1) Canon 24/3.5L TSE II (if I owned the 17/4L TSE, it would probably be here too)
2) Canon 24-70/2.8L (I've taken more money-making pictures with this lens than any other)
3) Zeiss ZE 21/2.8 (still being examined, but amazing enough that I know it belongs here)
4) Canon 16-35/2.8L II (ultra-versatile and predictable with very good to excellent IQ, although bettered by primes)
5) Contax Zeiss 50/1.4 (impressive IQ and low aberrations)
6) Canon 100/2.8L macro (the best mild telephoto I've owned -- so far -- sold my 70-200/2.8L IS)

Not surprisingly, these are mostly my "Big Guns". Out of these, I'm having the most fun at the moment with the Contax 50/1.4!

Honorably mention goes to my uber-useful crop frame Canon 15-85/3.5-5.6, and full frame Contax Zeiss 80-200/4.

Jun 14, 2011 at 06:35 PM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Most magical lenses?
lewdoglewdog wrote:
What are the most magical lenses? Raw optical performance aside, which lenses just have something enchanting about them? I think the focus is so frequently on the sharpness or CA and, sometimes, the feel or drawing style of a lens is just so much more important.



I think I'm still trying to define what "drawing style" is. Do you have a clue? Does anyone have a clue? I have no clue. Well, maybe a clue... but yeah, mostly I'm clueless. What is the definition of a lens's "drawing style" if it's not Sharpness, CA, and Bokeh - which you segregate and exclude in your post?

This is a serious question. I don't know. So these lists of lenses aren't making any sense to me at all - except maybe they are lenses which are sharp, have nice bokeh, interesting CA (or lack thereof), or some combination therefrom that makes the photog feel good about the images it produces.

Shrug...
Jun 14, 2011 at 07:04 PM
dcjs
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Most magical lenses?
Bifurcator wrote:
I think I''m still trying to define what "drawing style" is. Do you have a clue? Does anyone have a clue? I have no clue. Well, maybe a clue... but yeah, mostly I''m clueless. What is the definition of a lens''s "drawing style" if it''s not Sharpness, CA, and Bokeh - which you segregate and exclude in your post?

This is a serious question. I don''t know. So these lists of lenses aren''t making any sense to me at all - except maybe they are lenses which are sharp, have nice bokeh, interesting CA (or lack thereof), or some combination
...Show more →

Bifurcator,

I think I remember that it has been established a long time ago that you don''t have a clue when it comes to the aesthetic preferences of some people here. Certain terminology is meaningful to some people because they have established a common ground by aesthetically judging many images in a similar way. I''ve tried to explain that some time ago and I still can''t think of a better way to put it:

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/860134/58#8520298

Your comments just highlight your inability to grasp the concept. Nothing wrong with that, but your way of demanding an explanation for the aesthetic preferences that some people here share seems slightly rude to me. If you still have to ask after such a long time on this board, you wouldn''t understand anyway.



Edited on Jun 14, 2011 at 07:35 PM · View previous versions
Jun 14, 2011 at 07:32 PM
Zaitz
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Most magical lenses?
Bifurcator wrote:
lewdoglewdog wroteWhat are the most magical lenses? Raw optical performance aside, which lenses just have something enchanting about them? I think the focus is so frequently on the sharpness or CA and, sometimes, the feel or drawing style of a lens is just so much more important.
I think I''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''m still trying to define what "drawing style" is. Do you have a clue? Does anyone have a clue? I have no clue. Well, maybe a clue... but yeah, mostly I''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''m clueless. What is the definition of a lens''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''s "drawing style" if it''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''s not Sharpness, CA, and Bokeh - which you segregate and exclude in your post?

This is a serious question. I don''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''t know. So these lists of lenses aren''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''t making any sense to me at all - except maybe they are lenses which are sharp, have nice bokeh, interesting CA (or lack thereof), or some combination
...Show more →

Sharpness can go into it to a certain extent. And bokeh, especially if you are talking general portrait type lenses, is a huge part of it. But I think what the OP is trying to get away from is the pixel peeping nonsense that most digital photography forums seem to be concerned with. Who cares if your 135mm isn''''''''t the absolute sharpest thing in the world. Who cares if it has a lot of CA, especially nowadays when it is easily fixed? How does it render the scene? Is it more satisfying than the alternatives? Lenses of a given focal length dont all draw a scene the same way.

Do you think an old Petzval would rate highly to pixel peepers who seem to only desire insanely sharp photos from corner to corner?
1
2

Do you think these lenses would?
http://tonopahpictures.0catch.com/4InchGundlachPetzval4X5Pics.html
http://www.apug.org/gallery1/files/4/8/8/7/virginia6.jpg

To some absolute sharpness and other technical details take a backseat to the other qualities a lens provides. Most people don''t seem to like the DC feature on the Nikon 135mm f/2. But I enjoy using it for the glow it can add to a photo and the softness it creates. Wide open it isnt very sharp but I couldnt care less.

Zeiss lenses are often spoken of for having a certain micro contrast that other lenses lack. Some Leica lenses seem to produce colors like no others can. Heliar lenses are said to be sharp as a tack and then have the dof drop off into oblivion.


Edited on Jun 14, 2011 at 07:38 PM · View previous versions
Jun 14, 2011 at 07:34 PM
nalahm
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Most magical lenses?
My magical lens is Carl Zeiss S-Planar 74/4.
Jun 14, 2011 at 07:37 PM
mpmendenhall
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Most magical lenses?
Bifurcator wrote:
I think I'm still trying to define what "drawing style" is. Do you have a clue? Does anyone have a clue? I have no clue. Well, maybe a clue... but yeah, mostly I'm clueless. What is the definition of a lens's "drawing style" if it's not Sharpness, CA, and Bokeh - which you segregate and exclude in your post?


"Drawing style" is the aggregate effect of a lens' optical properties that produce distinctive (subjectively assessed) qualities in images from the lens.

"Drawing style" is the result of measurable qualities of the lens (both those commonly measured, like MTFs, CA, and flare, but also all the other properties that, while measurable, are too complex to reduce to a single number or plot). However, when a person looks at a photo, their (subjective) impression is unlikely to be thoughts in terms of multispectral point-spread functions. Instead, what they will notice is things like whether the photo "looks realistic" or "3D" as if viewing through a window, or perhaps looks more like a flat painting; whether perceptually textures and colors are vividly presented or dulled; etc. Insofar as a lens will often impart the same (subjective) qualities to a wide variety of images, it is said to have a particular "drawing style."

The reason to separate the term "drawing style" from a direct discussion of MTFs, CA, and bokeh disc shapes is that simply knowing a few simplified technical measurements of a lens is not enough to determine how the complex, detailed interplay of many factors will actually "look" once everything is put together. For a complete technical description of a lens, you would need to describe things like the multispectral point-spread function at every radius for every subject distance, which would be a hopelessly huge amount of information that would likely mean very little to the reader (unless they are a very experienced lens designer with decades of experience in understanding the visual implications of such measurements). Instead, it's often nice to "cut to the chase" about what matters in the end for photographers: what kind of (subjective) impact the images will have. Afterwards, one can often identify specific objective factors that contribute significantly to the subjective look, but merely knowing these objective factors would not have told the full story.
Jun 14, 2011 at 07:51 PM
obik
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Most magical lenses?
Gunzorro wrote:
1) Canon 24/3.5L TSE II (if I owned the 17/4L TSE, it would probably be here too)
6) Canon 100/2.8L macro (the best mild telephoto I've owned -- so far -- sold my 70-200/2.8L IS)


These two are superb optics by any measure. I'm not one to get all emotional about lenses, but I really love my 100L. When I sent it in for repair I actually felt lonely without it and when it came back I was ecstatic. Sad, but true.
Jun 14, 2011 at 08:28 PM
shaunmlavery
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Most magical lenses?
I don't really know that I fully comprehend the term "drawing" but this is how I interpret it. I view the lens as a brush and this example, the lens draws very nice and smooth with great character.

Ok, ok...that sounds like an entry for a dictionary. The image is smooth, sharp and has nice unexpected soul.




Sorry about that broken link.

Lens: 50MM Noctilux Pre-ASPH E60 I don't think I ever type lens names right.

Edited on Jun 15, 2011 at 05:02 PM · View previous versions
Jun 14, 2011 at 08:50 PM
Ataboy
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Most magical lenses?
Undisputed (for me) leader: Contax Zeiss 85/1.2. It's like a great Italian espresso maker - tricky to use but when you get it right it will pull a heavenly shot.

Other: at least 15 lenses, with Helios-40 and Biotar 75/1.5 having the most memorable character of their own (and I don't mean just painterly bokeh)
Jun 14, 2011 at 10:04 PM
Sven Jeppesen
Offline
Details
p.3 #13Most magical lenses?
Zeiss ZE 21
Zeiss ZE 100
Canon EF 300/2,8 IS
Canon EF 400/2,8 IS
Jun 14, 2011 at 11:45 PM
denoir
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Most magical lenses?
Bifurcator wrote:
I think I'm still trying to define what "drawing style" is. Do you have a clue? Does anyone have a clue? I have no clue. Well, maybe a clue... but yeah, mostly I'm clueless. What is the definition of a lens's "drawing style" if it's not Sharpness, CA, and Bokeh - which you segregate and exclude in your post? This is a serious question. I don't know.


Oh dear, not you as well. How can you have over 4,000 posts - I'm guessing most of them in this forum - and not know the term by now? I'll copy-paste the answer I gave in the Canon forum recently:

"Drawing style" or "rendering style" or simply "look" is the encompassing term that includes all aspects of the optical signature of the lens. Colors, contrast at different resolutions, sharpness, bokeh etc all form the drawing style.

If you want an etymological guess, I'd say that the term is probably a translation of the German word "zeichnen". In Swedish you can say that a lens "tecknar" which is the same as the German word and means simply "draws".


So these lists of lenses aren't making any sense to me at all - except maybe they are lenses which are sharp, have nice bokeh, interesting CA (or lack thereof), or some combination therefrom that makes the photog feel good about the images it produces.

These lists of lenses are the ones the posters consider to be very special in some way.
Jun 14, 2011 at 11:49 PM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.3 #15Most magical lenses?
denoir wrote:
Bifurcator wrote:
I think I'm still trying to define what "drawing style" is. Do you have a clue? Does anyone have a clue? I have no clue. Well, maybe a clue... but yeah, mostly I'm clueless. What is the definition of a lens's "drawing style" if it's not Sharpness, CA, and Bokeh - which you segregate and exclude in your post? This is a serious question. I don't know.


Oh dear, not you as well. How can you have over 4,000 posts - I'm guessing most of them in this forum - and not know the term by now? I'll copy-paste the answer I gave in the Canon forum recently:

"Drawing style" or "rendering style" or simply "look" is the encompassing term that includes all aspects of the optical signature of the lens. Colors, contrast at different resolutions, sharpness, bokeh etc all form the drawing style.

If you want an etymological guess, I'd say that the term is probably a translation of the German word "zeichnen". In Swedish you can say that a lens "tecknar" which is the same as the German word and means simply "draws".


So these lists of lenses aren't making any sense to me at all - except maybe they are lenses which are sharp, have nice bokeh, interesting CA (or lack thereof), or some combination therefrom that makes the photog feel good about the images it produces.

These lists of lenses are the ones the posters consider to be very special in some way.[/quote]

Now, that's an outstanding definition of "magical" that I can embrace!

In that case, add my Zeiss ZE 35/2 to the list at #7!
Jun 15, 2011 at 12:00 AM
photosmart42
Offline
Details
p.3 #16Most magical lenses?
Tokina 90/2.5 FD macro
EL-Nikkor 63/2.8
Panasonic Lumix 20/1.7
Jun 15, 2011 at 12:44 AM
A.Erekhinski
Offline
Details
p.3 #17Most magical lenses?
Voigtlander 125mm F2.5 Macro APO-Lanthar
Jun 15, 2011 at 02:39 AM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.3 #18Most magical lenses?
mpmendenhall wrote:
Bifurcator wroteI think I'm still trying to define what "drawing style" is. Do you have a clue? Does anyone have a clue? I have no clue. Well, maybe a clue... but yeah, mostly I'm clueless. What is the definition of a lens's "drawing style" if it's not Sharpness, CA, and Bokeh - which you segregate and exclude in your post?
"Drawing style" is the aggregate effect of a lens' optical properties that produce distinctive (subjectively assessed) qualities in images from the lens.

"Drawing style" is the result of measurable qualities of the lens (both those commonly measured, like MTFs, CA, and flare, but also all the other properties that, while measurable, are too complex to reduce to a single number or plot). However, when a person looks at a photo, their (subjective) impression is unlikely to be thoughts in terms of multispectral point-spread functions. Instead, what they will notice is things like whether the photo "looks realistic" or "3D" as if
...Show more →


denoir wrote:
Oh dear, not you as well. How can you have over 4,000 posts - I'm guessing most of them in this forum - and not know the term by now? I'll copy-paste the answer I gave in the Canon forum recently:

"Drawing style" or "rendering style" or simply "look" is the encompassing term that includes all aspects of the optical signature of the lens. Colors, contrast at different resolutions, sharpness, bokeh etc all form the drawing style.

If you want an etymological guess, I'd say that the term is probably a translation of the German word "zeichnen". In Swedish you can say
...Show more →

These replies (the long and the short versions of the same thing) make sense to me. Thanks for that guys!!! That's kinda what I thought but I figured I'd challenge the cloud anyway. You know, something I could grab hold of, sink my teeth into or make sure I was on the same page with. (how's that for a triple metaphor? )

And this is also kinda why I was asking for more specific definitions. I don't think I have a favorite. I like'em all but a few. Many are so similar it's impossible to distinguish them apart. Others are very unique - but not "bad" - just different. For yet another metaphor and one I've used previously here, I think lenses are maybe a little like a painter's paint brushes. He chooses the one that's right for the job - for the desired effect or "look". I don't always like the same look every time. Just like if a painter always used the same brush I guess his portfolio would be pretty boring even if the individual works were each excellent.

What's "magic" to me is lenses or setups that take me by surprise. Riggings or lenses which produce a look (have a drawing style) that I wasn't expecting and was delightfully surprising. My camera sucks at revealing this during the shoot. I guess the GH1 embeds a low resolution thumbnail (scaled) of the shot and that's what's displayed during shot playback. So zooming into the image to see how things actually look is impossible and the image just turns to fuzz. Back on the computer however, the sparks fly, and the magic is revealed.

The most recent lenses that have surprised me in such a way (where I really dug their drawing style) were:

Tamron SP 28-80 adaptall (mostly at the wide end)
Canon FL 58/1.2
Canon nFD 300/2.8L + Extension Tubes,
Nikkor AF 35-70/2.8D

But I have to stop there because if I dig into ye'ol memory banks I can go on to list the majority of the lenses I've used in the past 6 to 8 months and that's about 300 lenses.

Here's some shots from those four:



http://tesselator.gpmod.com/Images/_Image_By_Lens/TamronSP_28-80mm_f3.5_Macro/Tamron_SP_28-80mm_F3.5_Macro_1190073.jpg

Tamron_SP_28-80mm_F3.5_Macro - from about a week ago


http://tesselator.gpmod.com/Images/_Image_By_Lens/TamronSP_28-80mm_f3.5_Macro/Tamron_SP_28-80mm_F3.5_Macro_1190147.jpg

Tamron_SP_28-80mm_F3.5_Macro - taken about a week ago


http://tesselator.gpmod.com/Images/_Image_By_Lens/TamronSP_28-80mm_f3.5_Macro/Tamron_SP_28-80mm_F3.5_Macro_1190265.jpg

Tamron_SP_28-80mm_F3.5_Macro - from about a week ago


http://tesselator.gpmod.com/Images/_Image_By_Lens/TamronSP_28-80mm_f3.5_Macro/Tamron_SP_28-80mm_F3.5_Macro_1190285.jpg

Tamron_SP_28-80mm_F3.5_Macro - from about a week ago











http://tesselator.gpmod.com/Images/_Image_By_Lens/Canon_FL_58mm_F1.2/Canon_FL_58mm_F1.2_1170494.jpg

Canon_FL_58mm_F1.2 - about 1 month ago


http://tesselator.gpmod.com/Images/_Image_By_Lens/Canon_FL_58mm_F1.2/Canon_FL_58mm_F1.2_1170215.jpg

Canon_FL_58mm_F1.2 - about 1 month ago











http://tesselator.gpmod.com/Images/_Image_By_Lens/Canon_FD_300mm_F2.8L/Canon_FD_300mm_f2.8L_1190444.jpg

Canon_FD_300mm_f2.8L + 2.5cm extension tube - Taken yesterday


http://tesselator.gpmod.com/Images/_Image_By_Lens/Canon_FD_300mm_F2.8L/Canon_FD_300mm_f2.8L_1190458.jpg

Canon_FD_300mm_f2.8L + 2.5cm extension tube - Taken yesterday











http://tesselator.gpmod.com/Images/_Image_By_Lens/Nikkor_35-70mm_f2.8D_Macro/Nikkor_35-70mm_f2.8-D_Macro_1180407.jpg

Nikkor_35-70mm_f2.8-D_Macro - about 2 weeks ago


http://tesselator.gpmod.com/Images/_Image_By_Lens/Nikkor_35-70mm_f2.8D_Macro/Nikkor_35-70mm_f2.8-D_Macro_1180480.jpg

Nikkor_35-70mm_f2.8-D_Macro - about 2 weeks ago








Part of the magic for me is also a lens's history, age, and design ambitions too BTW. I have an extra-majic feeling about the takumar line for this reason - besides of course their terrific drawing style.







.

Edited on Jun 15, 2011 at 06:00 AM · View previous versions
Jun 15, 2011 at 04:52 AM
pisq
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Most magical lenses?
Nikkor 35mm f1.4 AIS
Jun 15, 2011 at 05:28 AM
Anden
Offline
Details
p.3 #20Most magical lenses?
http://obj.fotosidan.se/obj/photo/a6/a60372ae830a2aa1340d0c1fbb2cf498.jpg

http://obj.fotosidan.se/obj/photo/22/2272c574b981713f1b5bcc28a052ade5.jpg

These two are my babies.
I also treasure the Contax 35/1.4 which is used on a daily basis.
The Rokkor 58/1.2 is another magical lens.

A
Jun 15, 2011 at 05:59 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister