Bifurcator wrote:
I think I'm still trying to define what "drawing style" is. Do you have a clue? Does anyone have a clue? I have no clue. Well, maybe a clue... but yeah, mostly I'm clueless. What is the definition of a lens's "drawing style" if it's not Sharpness, CA, and Bokeh - which you segregate and exclude in your post?
"Drawing style" is the aggregate effect of a lens' optical properties that produce distinctive (subjectively assessed) qualities in images from the lens.
"Drawing style" is the result of measurable qualities of the lens (both those commonly measured, like MTFs, CA, and flare, but also all the other properties that, while measurable, are too complex to reduce to a single number or plot). However, when a person looks at a photo, their (subjective) impression is unlikely to be thoughts in terms of multispectral point-spread functions. Instead, what they will notice is things like whether the photo "looks realistic" or "3D" as if viewing through a window, or perhaps looks more like a flat painting; whether perceptually textures and colors are vividly presented or dulled; etc. Insofar as a lens will often impart the same (subjective) qualities to a wide variety of images, it is said to have a particular "drawing style."
The reason to separate the term "drawing style" from a direct discussion of MTFs, CA, and bokeh disc shapes is that simply knowing a few simplified technical measurements of a lens is not enough to determine how the complex, detailed interplay of many factors will actually "look" once everything is put together. For a complete technical description of a lens, you would need to describe things like the multispectral point-spread function at every radius for every subject distance, which would be a hopelessly huge amount of information that would likely mean very little to the reader (unless they are a very experienced lens designer with decades of experience in understanding the visual implications of such measurements). Instead, it's often nice to "cut to the chase" about what matters in the end for photographers: what kind of (subjective) impact the images will have. Afterwards, one can often identify specific objective factors that contribute significantly to the subjective look, but merely knowing these objective factors would not have told the full story.